issue brief CONTRACEPTIVE ACCESS, CHOICE, & UTILIZATION A Survey of Mississippi Women PUBLISHED JULY 2019 Mississippi women have historically reported high rates of unintended pregnancy. The Affordable Care Act and state-level health policies have broadened access to reproductive health services and contraception in recent years benefitting Mississippians of all incomes. Access to contraception including the most effective reversible forms of birth control is wider than ever. However, despite improved access, evidence suggests that utilization of the most effective methods of birth control is low. To understand how Mississippians access birth control generally, the Center for Mississippi Health Policy commissioned a survey of Mississippi women of reproductive age to understand what factors influence women’s choice of birth control methods and what barriers, if any, limit them in obtaining the method of their choice. Survey respondents were recruited from a geographically diverse sampling that included women who had enrolled children in licensed day care facilities across Women who have given birth to at least one child are described as parous, while women the state. These mothers also recruited women who had not given birth to a child who have not given birth are described as (nulliparous). The final sample included parous (women who have given birth) and nulliparous. nulliparous respondents of reproductive age (15-44). Providers and Coverage Are Key to Contraceptive Access Both groups of women surveyed reported largely similar experiences of reproductive healthcare. Ob-gyns were most often reported as the provider type last seen for birth control, but parous respondents were much more likely to see an ob-gyn. Over one third of nulliparous women relied on a family practice physician or nurse practitioner for birth control. Parous women report far higher rates of use of the most effective methods (Figure 1), and are less likely to be uninsured. Both nulliparous and parous women in this study reported high rates of insurance coverage. Approximately one quarter of respondents reported that if they did not BIRTH CONTROL METHOD EFFECTIVENESS have insurance they would not be able to use birth control. Effectiveness of preventing pregnancy varies across birth control methods. The most effective FIGURE 1. BIRTH CONTROL EFFECTIVENESS FOR PAROUS AND NULLIPAROUS WOMEN BY PROVIDER TYPE permanent methods are male and female PAROUS NULLIPAROUS sterilization, while the most effective reversible methods are Intrauterine Devices (IUDs) and 100% 100% 2.6% 14.8% 9.4% 7% 9.9% hormonal implants often referred to as long- acting reversible contraceptives (LARCs). 80% 31.6% 80% 60% 60% 62.5% 72.8% 79.5% Many types of birth control are available without 83.9% 83.1% having to access the healthcare system; these 40% 40% 63.4% types of birth control are generally the least effective methods that have significantly higher 20% 20% rates of failure (i.e. unintended pregnancy). 22.7% 17.8% 17.9% Moderately effective methods and the most 0% 5% 0% 9% 7% effective methods (both permanent and Ob-gyn Family Nurse Ob-gyn Family Nurse reversible) are provider-dependent, meaning Practice Practitioner Practice Practitioner users must access the healthcare system to obtain them. Most Effective Methods Most Effective Methods Moderately Effective Methods Moderately Effective Methods Least Effective Methods Least Effective Methods Note: Statistically significant (p<0.004) Note: Statistically significant (p<0.009) Columns may not total to 100% due to rounding. 1 of 4 Source: Kolbo, J., et al. (2018) Center for Mississippi Health Policy � Issue Brief: Contraceptive Access: A Survey of Mississippi Women � JULY 2019 Decision-Making About Birth Control Women’s Perceptions, Beliefs, and Knowledge The vast majority of respondents report a belief in personal responsibility to prevent unintended pregnancy, as well as a sense of being in control of their reproductive health. However, factors outside a woman’s immediate sphere of control, including a lack of information about all methods, may impact her ability to access the best means for her to prevent pregnancy. Responses indicate many women have common perceptions that may influence their choice or even whether they seek information from their provider: COMPARISON OF BIRTH CONTROL METHODS EVER USED BY METHODS % Agree With Statement RESPONDENTS KNOW ENOUGH ABOUT Parous Nulliparous TO MAKE A CHOICE If an IUD or implant was right for me my healthcare provider 70% 57% PAROUS would have recommended it to me. Birth Control Pills IUDs and implants are too expensive. 22% 33% Male Condoms Withdrawal IUDs and implants cause medical problems like pelvic inflammatory Shots/Injections 45% 47% Emergency Contraception disease, etc. Not Having Sex at Certain Times Contraceptive Ring Female Condoms Responses indicate gaps in knowledge about the most effective methods of Contraceptive Patch contraception. *Hormonal IUD *Contraceptive Implant % Don’t Know + Incorrect Answers Foam, Jelly, Film, Cream Parous Nulliparous *Copper IUD Diaphragm, Cervical Cap, or Sponge Women of all ages can use an IUD. 69% 63% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% Know Enough About to Make a Choice You must have a child to use an IUD. 43% 80% Ever Used Source: Kolbo, J., et al. (2018) IUDs and implants are a type of birth control that can be 29% 42% Note: Statistically significant relationship (p<.000) reversed at any time. * Indicates LARC Method NULLIPAROUS As seen in the charts in the sidebar, respondents are more likely to use methods Birth Control Pills they feel they know enough about to make a choice. Male Condoms Withdrawal Shots/Injections Provider Clinical Guidance Emergency Contraception Not Having Sex at Certain Times Providers play a critical role beyond just facilitating access to birth control; they Contraceptive Ring Female Condoms may often be the primary factor influencing a woman’s choice of methods. Survey Contraceptive Patch respondents overwhelmingly indicated reliance on providers as a key source for *Hormonal IUD decision-making, for help in choosing a method, and for medically appropriate *Contraceptive Implant Foam, Jelly, Film, or Cream guidance. A 2018 survey of Mississippi providers documented significant *Copper IUD differences in education by provider type; fewer than half of family practice doctors Diaphragm, Cervical Cap, or Sponge and nurse practitioners reporting formal training in LARC counseling compared to 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 86 percent of ob-gyns. Know Enough About to Make a Choice Ever Used Comprehensive counseling has been linked to higher utilization of LARC methods, Source: Kolbo, J., et al. (2018) Note: Statistically significant relationship (p<.001) as shown by the Missouri CHOICE Project which saw 72 percent of participants * Indicates LARC Method choose a LARC method after counseling on the effectiveness, risks, benefits, and common side effects of all non-permanent options for birth control. 2 of 4 Center for Mississippi Health Policy � Issue Brief: Contraceptive Access: A Survey of Mississippi Women � JULY 2019 Additional Barriers to Obtaining Birth Control Low-income women Engaging with the health system is necessary for women who want highly effective birth control, and for most women in Mississippi, health insurance Approximately one quarter of coverage is a crucial first step. Previous research has shown that respondents reported that if they publicly insured women in the state are less likely than privately did not have insurance they would insured women to use the most effective methods. not be able to use birth control. Nulliparous women who paid for birth control out of pocket or by public insurance were more likely to report that their most recent visit to a provider was longer than a year ago. This can be a consequential length of time for users of moderately effective and most effective reversible birth control as these methods are provider-dependent and require a renewed prescription, administration of a drug, or a physical check annually to continue use. Unsurprisingly, none of the parous women who paid for their birth control out of PERCENTAGE OF RESPONDENTS USING pocket reported currently using a LARC method, which have high upfront costs THE MOST EFFECTIVE METHODS OF BIRTH CONTROL BY PARITY AND PAYOR ($300-$1000) but are also the most cost-effective methods due to the long life of the device (up to 12 years depending on the exact method). PAROUS PUBLIC Women under 25 4.2% 24.4% INSURANCE PRIVATE Young women in Mississippi are at a disadvantage due to socioeconomic realities 7.6% 32.8% INSURANCE that are associated with age, such as lack of employer-based insurance or financial SELF-PAY 0% means of paying for health services. Women under 20 in this sample were much more likely to rely on public insurance for birth control, and women under ALL 6.2% 28.2% 25 had relatively high rates of paying out of pocket (21 percent). Most women 15-19 with and without children are publicly insured (82 percent and 68 percent, 0% 10% 20% 30% respectively). Nulliparous women 15-19 reported the highest rates of seeing family Percent of Respondents practice doctors for birth control (27 percent), and the 2018 survey of Mississippi providers indicated 70 percent of family practice physician respondents would not NULLIPAROUS recommend LARC for someone in this age group. PUBLIC INSURANCE 4.2% Black women PRIVATE 7.6% Access to birth control services is significantly different for both parous and INSURANCE nulliparous black women compared to white women. Black women are SELF-PAY 2.9% significantly more likely to report the following: ALL 6.2% relying on publicly funded clinics; 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% relying on public insurance for birth control; Percent of Respondents seeing a family practice physician for birth control; and Source: Kolbo, J., et al. (2018) using a least effective method of birth control. Nulliparous women Nulliparous women are more likely to see family practice physicians or nurse practitioners for birth control and are less likely to use the most effective birth control methods. The fact that fewer nulliparous women than parous women see ob-gyn’s is consistent with their pregnancy and childbirth status; however, it may reveal an additional barrier to receiving the most effective birth control methods prior to a first pregnancy. 3 of 4 Center for Mississippi Health Policy � Issue Brief: Contraceptive Access: A Survey of Mississippi Women � JULY 2019 Discussion While efforts to improve contraceptive access for Mississippi women should not focus 84 and 65 percent of parous and solely on increasing utilization of specific methods, they should ensure that women have nulliparous respondents, respectively, reported that their ob-gyn was a top been informed of all of their options when choosing what is best for them. New insights 3 source for information about birth gained from this survey highlight the critical role of providers in decision-making about control. birth control, as well as misperceptions and a lack of information about LARCs and other methods among respondents. Demonstrated gaps in knowledge and differences in utilization of the most effective methods point to hurdles for Mississippi women beyond initial access barriers. A prior review of unintended pregnancy and a subsequent survey of Mississippi healthcare providers revealed several potential barriers to contraceptive access: Mississippi has very low usage rates for the most effective reversible methods; Many women seek care from providers who have not been trained to provide all methods of birth control; and Some providers hold beliefs and attitudes about the appropriateness of LARCs for certain patients that are inconsistent with national guidelines. This survey provides additional insight on how women make decisions about birth control: Women use methods they feel they know enough about to make a decision; They rely heavily on their providers for information and guidance about birth control; and Few women indicate a comprehensive knowledge of birth control methods. These findings corroborate the experience of other states: efforts to improve access to the most effective contraceptive methods must include both clinician training and patient education. Because many women in Mississippi use primary care clinicians for reproductive health and access to birth control, these providers should be trained in counseling women on all methods of contraception. More information about this sample’s responses to questions of satisfaction, personal beliefs and attitudes, as well as an exploration by race and parity can be found in a complementary chartbook An Analysis of a Contraceptive Survey of Women in Mississippi. See also Preventing Unintended Pregnancy in Mississippi and Long-Acting Reversible Contraceptives: A Survey of Mississippi Healthcare Providers. Sources Center for Mississippi Health Policy. (2018). Preventing Unintended Pregnancy in Mississippi. https://mshealthpolicy. com/preventing-unintended-pregnancies/ Center for Mississippi Health Policy. (2018). Long-Acting Reversible Contraceptives: A Survey of Mississippi Healthcare Providers. https://mshealthpolicy.com/larc-provider-survey/ Kolbo, J., Ismail, O., Mcleod, S., and Zhang, L. (2018). Women’s Health Care and Contraceptive Practices Survey. Plaza Building, Suite 700 Pellegrine, I. & Southward, L. (2018). Long-Acting Reversible Contraceptives: Survey Results from Mississippi Health 120 N. Congress Street Care Providers. Social Science Research Center. Mississippi State University. Prepared for the Center for Mississippi Jackson, MS 39201 Health Policy. Birgisson, N.E., Zhao, Q., Secura, G.M., Madden, T., and Peipert, J. (2015). Preventing unintended pregnancy: The con- traceptive CHOICE project in review. Journal of Women’s Health, 24(5), 349–353. http://doi.org/10.1089/jwh.2015.519 Phone 601.709.2133 Fax 601.709.2134 www.mshealthpolicy.com @mshealthpolicy