op mre ree enemy aetna ott ee 1 Madison Avenue | ly dear Doctor Du gent ig@ that they are too long (310-312 fest Mon ment Street , / / , Baltimore, Md. 2 = ola De 19 22,4. A American Publie Health Association, New York City. . bli n: : : : i have your letter of Mareh 30th, and have just ‘finished going over the summary reports Which accompanied it. The first criticiem 1 would make of the reports . g and that eighty cities abstracted in this manner will make tee great a bulk of material. | in reading the reports over I have wondered whether er not. it is advisable to comment either favorably or unfavorably by over the material you sent me and am upon the situation as it exists in the individual city. 1 feel that Doctor imerson's comments, while in the main sound and justified, are in @ sense a violation of our promise to keep individual and specific information confidential, The implied eriticiem of the I am sure, cause an unfavorable reaction. — While I agree whh you thet it is diffienlt to avoid a “dull uniformity" of statement, we must remember that the function of the Committee is to study present practice in health administra» tion and not te give gratuitous advice to individusl eities. I present health comuissioner of New York and similer stetements will, hesitate to speak so unfavorably of vhat impresses me as really a very valuable and delightful set of swumeries. Yor my own reading I should enjoy very much secing the complete set but for the purposes of the Comittee I think a more direat statement of faets in regard to each city is essential, o es ae I am devoting practi cally all of my time now to working L you much interested in it. I foree see only one difficulty and that is that each subject offers such inviting opportunities for study that it is going to be difficult to s bring them whhin any reasonable compass, | very truly yours, (Signed) A. Ww. Vreaman, MeDe, sea