THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER (SOME METHODS OF HYPODERMIC MEDICATION IN THE TREATMENT OF INOPERABLE CANCER) BY JOHN A. SHAW-MACKENZIE, M.D. Lond. THIRD EDITXON^-RJEJO^J^^JQ^MXABGED .NEW TORK william' 'wood cmny MDCCCCVI IN GRATEFUL APPRECIATION OF THE HELP AND OPPORTUNITIES AFFORDED ME IN FIRST TESTING THESE METHODS OF TREATMENT IN CASES OF INOPERABLE CANCER, AND OF CONTINUED HELP AND ENCOURAGEMENT I DEDICATE THIS SMALL WORK TO MY OLD AND VALUED FRIEND, COLONEL T. LIGERTWOOD, C.B., M.D. PREFACE TO THE THIRD EDITION The rapid exhaustion of the second edition of this work has enabled me, in preparing a new one, to add several cases to my list, in which the trypsin treatment, alone or aided by other substances which increase its action has again proved satisfactory. It is interesting to note that clinical evidence is accumulating in favour of the glycogenic theory of cancer and the relationship between this disease and diabetes. With reference to the proteolytic and glycolitic fer- ments, I have drawn atteniion in the text to the ferments of the intestinal glands, and noted additional treatment, by preparations of the same, in carcinomatous growths and in cases of diabetes. Furthermore, the natural and comparative immunity of the duodenum and small intes- tine from cancer, and the slower rate of growth of the disease in the large intestine, would appear to give support to medicinal treatment by means of preparations of the pancreas, intestinal glands, and the bile-salts, alone V VI PREFACE or combined. Apart from these additions, save in respect to certain revisions in the text, the present edition re- sembles the last. While naturally encouraged at the reception by the profession of my views on the nature and treatment of cancer, I am nevertheless of the opinion that the best results of the treatment would be obtained by resorting to it in the early stages of the disease. Hitherto only far advanced and impossible operative cases have had the opportunity of deriving benefit from this treatment, in the majority of which it was impossible to expect much, in view of the extensive dissemination of the disease. I desire again to thank my friend Mr. Percy Dunn, F.R.C.S., for many kind suggestions in correcting and revising the proof-sheets. J. A. SHAW-MACKENZIE. 42, Green Street, Park Lane, London, W. April, 1906. PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION This volume is a new edition of my former work published under the title of ' Some Methods of Hypo- dermic Medication in the Treatment of Inoperable Cancer.' Finding that a more extended experience of the subject had led me into paths of inquiry which I had not anticipated when my first work was written, I came to the conclusion that it would be better to employ a more comprehensive title for the purposes of the new edition. I have done so the more willingly inasmuch as the indication of pancreatic treatment, now added, rests upon the independent work and scientific researches of different observers, and upon conclusions reached by different routes. I desire to thank my friend Mr. Percy Dunn, F.R.C.S., for many kind suggestions in correcting and revising the proof-sheets. J. A. SHAW-MACKENZIE. 42, Green Street, Park Lane, W. August, 1905. VII CONTENTS INTRODUCTION I'AGE HYPODERMIC MEDICATION, GENERALLY, IN INOPERABLE CANCER ------- i CHAPTER I HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF CHIAN TURPENTINE (IN ASSOCIA- TION WITH COLONEL T. LIGERTWOOD, C.B., M.D.) Technique-Dosage-Cases-Action of chian turpentine- Suggested use in other directions 5 CHAPTER II HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE (SOAP) SOLUTION (IN ASSOCIATION WITH COLONEL T. LIGERTWOOD, C.B., M.D.) Technique-Cases-Notes on iodipin injections in a case of carcinoma and enlarged prostate ; on pain and septic joint trouble simulating rheumatism in carcinoma- Mr. J. H. Webb's (Melbourne) method of treatment by soap injections and purified ox-gall (abstracts)-Theory of the disease-Cholesterin-Cases-Remarks-Palliative effects of ox-gall-Cases (Clay)-Further observations on cholesterin and diet (F. W. Beneke)-Relation between gall-stones and cancer-Systemic origin of cancer deter- mined locally by irritation-Views of older authorities (Astley Cooper) ------ 13 IX X CONTENTS CHAPTER III THE RELATION OF DIABETES TO CANCER-GLYCOGEN- NATURE OF CANCER CELLS PAGE Action of soap and other substances on cholesterin-Acetone -Simultaneous occurrence in same patient; substitution of one disease for the other in same patient; alternation of disease in members of same family-Diabetes and carcinoma referred to defective glycolitic action of the pancreas-Action of trypsin on glycogen and glucose- Reversion to embryonic distribution of glycogen- Glycogen in blastoderm and in embryonic tissues (C. Bernard, M. Hartog, M. Foster, and C. Murchison)- Glycogen in malignant growths (C. Murchison, J. de Nittis, Brault, K. W. Monsarrat, De Backer, H. Manders, and Roger Williams)-Nature of cancer cells (embryonic, somatic) Cohnheim's theory ; Researches of Roger Williams ; G. Beatson ; Messrs. Farmer, J. Moore, and Walker ; - (pre-embryonic, asexual or ' trophoblastic ') pancreatic factor in degeneration and treatment (trypsin), J. Beard-(somatic) F. Blumenthal ; solvent action of pancreatin ------- 40 CHAPTER IV THE ACTION OF TRYPSIN ON GLYCOGEN, GLUCOSE, AND STARCH -HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF TRYPSIN-AIDS AND OTHER FERMENTS, SECRETIN, EREPSIN, ENTEROKINASE Plant and vegetable glycogen and ferments (trypsin, erepsin) -Hypodermic injections of pancreatic trypsin-Tech- nique-Solution and dosage-Internal administration of pancreatic and intestinal preparations-B. Moore on absence of acid from gastric contents-Aids to treatment (E. H. Starling, J. P. Pawlow)-Inhibition-Enterokinase -Spleen as aid to trypsin, Herzen, H. F. Bellamy- -Erepsin (intestinal), Cohnheim-Universal presence of erepsin in animal tissues, and in all classes of animals ; erepsin (pancreatic) ; H. M. Vernon-Immunity of small intestine, F. F. Carroll-Notes on diet-Spontaneous CONTENTS XI PAGE cure-Age incidence-Suggested use of trypsin, erepsin, and enterokinase in other diseases-Diabetes (Lepine, C. A. Herter, J. Tyson, A. C. Crofton, T. Ligertwood, L. Brunton, J. H. Abram)-Bacterial diseases-Phthisis -Relation of venereal disease and cancer - - 51 CHAPTER V CASES AND COMMENTS Cases and comments-Action of trypsin on the living cells of Jensen's mouse-tumour; (J. Beard)-Action of trypsin on the living cells of recurrent carcinoma of breast; (G. Fraisse)-Action of glycolitic ferments on the living cells of cancerous growths (animals); (R. Odier) - - 66 CHAPTER VI SUMMARY Chian turpentine-Soap and ox-gall-Trypsin-Suggested treatment in association with operative procedure- Prolonged nature of treatment-Natural and compara- tive immunity of duodenum and small intestine-Com- bined treatment-The hopeful aspect of treatment - 83 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER INTRODUCTION HYPODERMIC MEDICATION, GENERALLY In the year 1902 I was first led to adopt the method of hypodermic medication in the treatment of disease, though previously to this I had had some experience in the administration of the cacodylate preparations by this method. I had long taken an interest in the medicinal treatment of uterine fibroids, and for some years I had been desirous of finding a substitutive method of administering, among other drugs, iodide of potassium and iodine. When, therefore, Messrs. Merck, of Darmstadt, introduced iodipin-a combination of iodine and sesame oil-as an efficient substitute for iodide of potassium generally, and administered subcu- taneously, without producing iodism, it occurred to me to apply this method to the treatment of uterine fibroids and menorrhagia. The opportunity for treating cases in this way was shortly after kindly afforded me by Dr. John Shaw in out-patients under his care at the North West London Hospital. He undertook the first injections, and general improvement with complete relief of symptoms, in some 1 2 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER cases with more or less shrinkage of the tumour, have been obtained. No particular local or general incon- venience follows the injections, which are given well into the connective tissue of the buttock, in doses of 3 to 10 c.c. of the 25 per cent, strength. The treatment is a continuation of the older iodine one, only, as it seems to me, by a more convenient, rapid, and direct method of administration, the drug itself, in the form of the tincture administered by the mouth, having been originally advo- cated and successfully employed by Dr. Samuel Ashwell in the treatment of fibroid tumours of the uterus, so long ago as the year 1845. The injections do not confine the patient to bed or the house, nor is there apparently any disagreeable after- effect. In one case under my care rapid shrinkage at first, and later almost complete disappearance of a large and undoubted uterine fibroid, for which hysterectomy had been a few days before independently recommended, took place under this treatment.1 This patient at the time mentioned to me that a friend of hers had obtained great benefit while abroad from hypodermic injections of iron, after large quantities of iron mixture had been taken without apparent benefit. The preparation in this case was one of arsenic and iron-both this and various preparations being readily obtained here and abroad. That of Dr. Zambeletti, of Milan, a ferrous salt of iron and arsenic, is extensively used in Italy. Many trials of these preparations, with or without strychnine, have since been made by Dr. Shaw and myself, and have proved to be beneficial in certain cases of anaemia, neurasthenia, and malaria. Again, we made trial of 1 ' On the Use of lodipin in Cases of Uterine Fibroid,' the Lancet, April 4, 1903 ; British Medical Association, Section of Surgery, the British Medical Journal, October 22, 1904. INTRODUCTION 3 various preparations of mercury, and a solution of the benzoate which I obtained from Messrs. Merck has proved satisfactory. Both the iron and arsenic, and also mercury, are injected into the muscular tissue of the gluteus. It is impossible here to enumerate the many cases in which the above hypodermic preparations, as well as others-as, for example, strychnine and spermin- have been singly or alternately employed, but encouraging results have been obtained in some cases of endometritis, chronic pelvic inflammation in women, rheumatoid and septic arthritis, sciatica, locomotor ataxy, and improve- ment, in one case, of disseminated sclerosis. HYPODERMIC MEDICATION IN INOPERABLE CANCER Encouraged by the results of hypodermic medication in the foregoing cases, and by the work of others in the treatment of cancer by hypodermic medication, I was led to adopt this method in cases of inoperable cancer. Towards the end of the year 1903 and commencement of 1904, decided relief-removal of pain and fetor-with apparent arrest of disease, were obtained in two cases of inoperable cancer under the care of Colonel T. Ligertwood, C.B., M.D., in the Infirmary of the Royal Hospital, Chelsea, as already recorded by Colonel Ligertwood and myself in the July number, 1904, of the Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps.1 The first case was one of carcinoma of the tongue in an old soldier, which was treated by hypodermic injections of sodium oleate (soap) solution originally recommended by Mr. John Holden Webb, Melbourne. The second case was that of carci- noma of the neck, treated by hypodermic injections of chian turpentine-a new method of treatment so far as 1 Vide also additional cases, Medical Press and Circular, October xg, 1904. I-2 4 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER we know-a rapid and direct method of administration- the drug itself, administered by the mouth, having been originally introduced by the late Professor Clay, of Birmingham, in the treatment of cancer. In January, 1905, I commenced trial of hypodermic injections of trypsin, an additional method of treatment and new therapeutic agent, so far as I am aware. CHAPTER I HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF CHIAN TURPENTINE Despite the disappointments with chian turpentine recorded in the past, its employment in the above case was nevertheless suggested by the recollection of the complete recovery in 1891 of a case of presumed and advanced cancer of the uterus, in which Colonel Ligert- wood and I had recommended its internal administration, subsequently to the opinion at the time of an eminent authority (since deceased) of the hopeless nature of the case; while the combination of iodine and sesame oil in iodipin suggested a similar combination of chian turpen- tine for hypodermic purposes. It may be recollected that twenty-five years ago the late Professor Clay strongly recommended chian turpentine by the mouth in the treatment of cancer, and ' if permanent cure was not obtained, an amount of relief secured to patients which had not been afforded by any other plan.'1 The treatment was condemned by others and fell into disuse, and yet the results reported by Professor Clay in certain cases cannot be doubted. Since the publication of the method of hypodermic administration by Colonel Ligert- wood and myself, Mr. Augustus Clay, the son of the late Professor Clay, has informed me that he had never heard 1 The Lancet, 1880-1887 5 6 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER of chian turpentine being injected subcutaneously, but at the same time he remarks that he can quite understand how very much more trustworthy the treatment may become under this method. Accounting for the difference in the results which followed the internal administration of the drug by his father and others, he suggests that in all probability the explanation was to be found in the fact that the drug was unassimilated, inasmuch as large masses were passed ' undigested ' by the rectum. This was noticeable in the pill form of administration, the emulsion giving far better and quicker results. Mr. Clay states that he is using the injections in a case of cancer of the rectum. The patient had previously been taking large doses of morphia, but had had none since the commence- ment of this treatment on July 30th, 1904, and, as noted September 16th, 1904, relief from pain had been obtained. June, 1905 : Colotomy has not been required, but the growth has extended. Mr. Clay finds that chian turpen- tine seems to act better in cases of epithelioma than in scirrhus. Technique.-The injections of chian turpentine are administered deeply into the subcutaneous tissue. Ex- perience has shown that the buttock is a suitable place. Given deeply into the connective tissue they cause some smarting, but little or no inconvenience or pain. The muscular tissue itself must be avoided, as injections into it cause pain and a sense of tension. I prefer the ' all glass' syringe, made by Messrs. Burroughs, Wellcome and Co. The special features of this appliance are that it is separable into parts which, with the needle, can be sterilized by boiling first, before use. The method I adopt is to keep a separate needle for each patient. A somewhat stout needle is necessary. An irido-platinum needle is preferable, being not liable to break in the HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF CHIAN TURPENTINE 7 deeper injections into the gluteal region. The same applies to the intramuscular injections of iron, arsenic, and mercury. The site of injection is first sterilized with some antiseptic solution, after which a piece of block ice is placed upon the surface, by which local anaesthesia is induced. The latter is a simple means of abolishing all pain of insertion of the needle; it may be followed by eucaine, as will be described under Mr. Webb's method of soap injections; and though these may seem minor details, upon them depend, in many cases, a continuance of hypodermic medication. Dosage.-Colonel Ligertwood and I found by experience that 5 minims of a 20 per cent, combination of chian turpentine with olive oil, obtained from Messrs. Southall Bros, and Barclay (Birmingham), is the quantity to begin with, increasing by 5 minims on alternate days up to 60 minims. In our first case there was considerable rise of temperature following the third and fourth injections of 15 minims and 20 minims respectively. Some doubt existed as to the cause of this, inasmuch as in other cases the same has not been noticed when gradually pushed to the full. Messrs. Southall now supply the injections of chian turpentine in small stopper phials ready for use, as well as the emulsion for internal administration. Case I.-Carcinoma of the neck in an old soldier, aged seventy-three, in the Infirmary of the Royal Hospital, Chelsea, under the care of Colonel Ligertwood. There was a large, hard, fixed mass, ulcerating in places, and bleeding readily, over the middle of the right sterno- mastoid, extending up towards the mastoid process, under the ramus of the jaw and over the trachea in front. The head was forced over to the opposite side, great pain was complained of, and swallowing was becoming difficult. Weight, 9 stone 7 pounds. It had 8 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER commenced primarily as a pimple in November, 1903, attributed to rubbing of the coat-collar, and was evidently growing. ' Medical history sheet clean.' Malaria in India forty years ago. Microscopic examination of a small piece taken from the edge of the ulceration proved it to be epithelioma. On January 25, 1904, 5 minims of a 20 per cent, combination of chian turpentine in olive oil (sterilized) were injected subcutaneously into the arm, the dose being increased by 5 minims on alternate days till 20 minims were given. The third injection of 15 minims was followed by a rise of temperature to 102° F., return- ing to normal in the morning; while after 20 minims it rose to 103'6° F., necessitating reduction of the dose to 5 and 10 minims in future, once or twice a week, followed by a rise of temperature to ioo° F. or thereabouts. Briefly, in this case all pain went from almost the first injection ; the extensive redness of the surrounding surface, which reached to above the mastoid in one direction and on to the upper chest in the other, rapidly subsided, leaving a faint purple discoloration, limited to the immediate neighbourhood of the growth; the ulceration decreased, and the discharge assumed a purulent character, free from all smell; the head was no longer tilted, and could be moved freely in all directions; the difficulty in swallowing passed away ; and at the end of a month the growth had diminished astonishingly in all directions. February 16: Weight, 9 stone 10 pounds. On May 30 the tumour was about the size of a hen's egg, remain- ing stationary, but occasioning no inconvenience ; slight further shrinkage had continued from week to week, with purulent but inoffensive discharge from the ulcerated surface. The patient was in the convalescent ward, and going out of doors regularly. Weight, 9 stone 11 pounds. As I subsequently heard, he began to fail in August, HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF CHIAN TURPENTINE 9 took to his bed, and died; but though there had been some slight haemorrhage-i.e., oozing at times-there was no pain, fetor, or extension of growth. Case IL-On August 10, 1904, Mr. consulted me. He had been under several eminent surgeons and physicians in town. He was suffering from a rapidly growing pelvic and inoperable tumour, which was first noticed in January-probably a sarcoma, but whether it was this or carcinoma it was not possible to say. I found a hard, solid tumour, filling the abdomen almost up to the ensiform cartilage, and the right thigh and leg were enormously cedematous. There had been already some haemorrhage from the bladder on several occasions. He was unable to retain solid food. His wife was carrying out X-ray treatment for him in the country ; but his appetite had failed, his weakness was great, and the surgeons in town had expressed the opinion that the X-rays had not arrested the growth. I wrote to his medical man in the country, suggesting, in addition to the same, trial of chian turpentine injections and also of the emulsion by the mouth, which he kindly agreed to carry out. August 22 : I heard from Mrs. that, so far, the injections had worked a wonderful im- provement, that his leg was softer, his appetite better, and that he could retain solids. September 9 : I again heard that he was very much better, that the tumour had receded from the stomach in a really wonderful manner, and that he could eat solids as well as ever and enjoy them. September 10: His medical man wrote to me corroborating the above, and noted it later, elsewhere.1 September 17 : Mr. came up to town to-day to see me, and the general improvement is very marked. The abdomen is no longer distended, but soft. The 1 Medical Press and Circular, November 16, 1904, p. 531. 10 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER tumour has diminished astonishingly, and can be made out at the level of the umbilicus, while the leg is obviously reduced in size. October 8: The improve- ment is fully maintained. The swelling of the leg has gone down very much, and permits him to get about freely. The tumour is further diminished, and on deep palpation the main mass extends to the level of the umbilicus on the right, and to the left a separate lobe about the size of a small Tangerine orange. So far there can be no doubt of the direct benefit-in fact, it is difficult to persuade him to go on with treatment regularly. October 29 : There has been no apparent growth-in fact, the mass appears smaller and more separate. The patient is, however, again suffering from loss of appetite, and the bladder is irritable at nights. His bowels are acting freely and disproportionately to the amount of food he is taking. While pressure, therefore, on the bowel appears to have been relieved, the mass appears to be pressing on the bladder from weight alone, the symptoms being relieved by upward support. Since commence- ment of the treatment no further haemorrhage from the bladder has been noticed. The leg is again more swollen, but he is able to get about. He looks very well, and has put on several pounds in weight, though this may be explained by the cedema of the leg. The injections have been reduced to 25 minims, as on two occasions there was some rise of temperature of undetermined origin. He went home and was laid up with phlebitis, from which he had previously suffered, but again recovered. He was anxious to go abroad for a change, and I saw him on his way through town on December 15. It was difficult to make out more than an oval painless tumour about the size of a small melon in the right inguinal region. I regret that accurate measurements were not HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF CHIAN TURPENTINE 11 taken by me from the first, but as evidence of the great reduction in size of the tumonr, it may be mentioned that the question about this time arose as to the possi- bility of its surgical removal. The girth of the leg had again very much diminished, but he had lost flesh con- siderably. The bowels were acting freely under ox-gall pills and soap injections, which had been substituted, and there was no apparent reason to prevent him going abroad and continuing treatment while away. January 17, 1905 : There had been some return of phlebitis, and death occurred suddenly from cardiac embolism. The points which may be noticed in this case are : (a) The obvious reduction in size of the growth under chian turpentine injections ; (b) removal of pressure symptoms from the bladder and bowel; (c) maintenance of the action of the bowels, contributed to largely by ox-gall, despite the fact that colotomy had been suggested by others ; (^) prolongation of life without pain and in comparative enjoyment; (e) the indirect but fatal issue. It is not possible to assert what the precise action of chian turpentine is. The direct removal of associated inflammation with marked leucocytosis, apart from any special or phagocytosic action of the latter on the cancer cell, is, however, suggestive that the arrest of growth is in part due to the cutting off of its nutrient supply, as obtains in certain cases of uterine fibroid under iodine treatment. Chian turpentine is probably also a general antiseptic. Shrewd observers of old knew the value at least of pre- venting as far as possible exposure of these ulcerations and growths to atmospheric influence ; in other words, the value of limiting sepsis as far as possible in these cases. 12 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER SUGGESTED USE OF CHIAN TURPENTINE IN OTHER DIRECTIONS. If, as has been asserted by others in the past, the results Dr. Clay obtained were in cases of inflammatory disease, and not in true cancer, the indication for chian turpentine is obvious in chronic pelvic inflammatory affections, specific or doubtful, of the uterus and ovaries in women ; and that so far is my experience. Tuberculosis.-The undoubted removal of inflammation with leucocytosis following injections of chian turpentine suggested trial of the same in a man-a case of tuberculosis of the larynx involving the base of the epiglottis, with some affection of the base of the right lung and marked presence of tubercle bacilli in the sputa. Frequent local applications and curetting had previously been employed by distinguished laryngologists, and cacodylate and iodi- pin injections had been carried out by myself. In the summer of 1904 chian turpentine injections were sub- stituted. Subsequently iodipin and cacodylate injections were continued abroad with electro-cauterization of the larynx. The patient is at the present time (July, 1905) in robust health, the larynx has almost recovered, and the lung has cleared up, while careful examination of the sputa has shown no tubercle bacilli except on the last occasion in small numbers. While the electro-cauterization has been attended with the happiest results, it is independently acknowledged that the various injections have con- tributed to the general good result which did not follow previous wintering abroad. CHAPTER II HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE (SOAP) SOLUTION For some years Mr. J. H. Webb, Melbourne, has been successfully treating cases of inoperable cancer by hypo- dermic injections of soap solution.1 The first difficulty I had, however, to encounter was that of determining the requisite strength of the solution and dosage. Un- able to ascertain that the treatment had been tried by others, I communicated with Mr. Webb. Meanwhile, Colonel Ligertwood and I agreed to commence with 5 minims of a 1 per cent, solution obtained from Messrs. Allen and Hanbury, increasing by 5 minims on alternate days to full doses of 60 minims every fourth day. Technique.-The injections are given into the sub- cutaneous tissue-in these cases chiefly into the outer surface of the upper part of either arm alternately or of the chest in the neighbourhood of the growth. They are not altogether free' from some smarting or pain, which, however, soon passes off, or is obviated by previous injection of eucaine. They appear to be more painful in the leg and in certain situations which vary individually, and I have noticed the same with 1 'Cancer: Its Nature and its Treatment,' by John Holden Webb, M.R.C.S. Eng., L.R.C.P. Lond., the Lancet, October 12, 1901. 13 14 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER ' other injections. Locally, the effect seems to vary from some tenderness to painful inflammatory areolae and to lumps without suppuration. The soap solution readily passes through an ordinary fine steel needle, and the same details of syringe antisepsis and local anaesthesia before insertion of needle are followed, as previously noted in chian turpentine injections. For convenience, Messrs. Allen and Hanbury have put up for me i-drachm doses of the sterilized soap solution in small stopper bottles. These only require to be warmed before use, and the solution poured into the barrel of the syringe. Case I.-Carcinoma of the tongue, of apparently seven months' duration, in an old soldier, aged seventy- three. In May, 1903, before admission to the Infirmary of the Royal Hospital, Chelsea, under the care of Colonel Ligertwood, he had been recommended operation in hospital, but refused. About the end of November, when first seen, there was great difficulty in opening the mouth, with inability to protrude the tongue, which was much swollen. Ulceration existed over a hard lump of the size of a walnut, projecting from and in- volving the right posterior third of the tongue. An enlarged gland could be felt under the ramus of the jaw. He complained of severe pain locally and radiating up the right side of the neck and head. Thin liquid nourishment could only be taken with difficulty. Saliva constantly escaped from the angles of the mouth, and the fetor was marked. He was too feeble to leave his bed. Opium and an antiseptic mouth-wash were pre- scribed December 4, 1903. Five minims of a 1 per cent, solution of soap were injected subcutaneously into the outer and upper part of the right arm, and increased by 5 minims on alternate days to full dose of 60 minims every four days, and later once in ten. Thyroid extract HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 15 was also commenced, but was shortly omitted on account of severe cardiac disease. December n : The patient expresses himself as always easier after the injections. For a few days iodide of potassium was given, but it only served to increase the distressing local condition and flow of saliva, and it was left off, there being no apparent indication for it. December 28 : The pain has gone from the neck and head, and he is able to take a little minced chicken. All fetor has gone. January 25, 1904: No pain. Able to fairly open the mouth, and protrude the tongue. Takes a little minced beef, and has insisted on being allowed to resume his pipe. Ulcera- tion exists over a projection, now the size of half a filbert, on the side of the tongue, the base of which is posteriorly thickened. February 1: Has been up and able to be weighed. Weight, 10 stone 6 pounds. Normal weight stated to be 15 stone. February 8 : No pain, but the ulcer is sensitive to the touch. All opium has been omitted. February 16: Is up and dressed every day, and has been out for a short walk. Takes fish, minced chicken and beef, diet sparingly, but bread-and- butter pudding freely. Weight, 10 stone 8 pounds. March 4: The gland under the jaw, which till now seemed to be smaller and giving no trouble, is again somewhat painful and swollen. March 7: The gland is again reduced. He takes his food well. Weight, 10 stone 11 pounds. He looks better, and there is no pain or fetor. March 21 : A small patch of ulceration still exists, but no enlargement or thickening of the tongue is appreciable, and the local condition in marked contrast to the usual termination of tongue cancer. Un- fortunately, as stated, he was suffering from advanced cardiac and arterial degeneration, which throughout treatment had been a cause of great anxiety, and on 16 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER this day some cedema of the extremities was noticed. It passed into black gangrene of the left leg and foot, and he rapidly sank without suffering on March 24. Post-mortem inspection of the tongue showed but little difference from the normal; on the other hand, micro- scopic examination of sections through the small patch of ulceration demonstrated epithelioma. Case II.-Mrs. , aged fifty. Left breast removed in hospital in July, 1903, for rapidly growing scirrhus. Her father died of cancer of the tongue, and two of his sisters died of cancer of the breast. On February 16, 1904, she came to me with a diffused, hard, raised, irregular recurrence above the cicatrix ; enlarged gland of the size of a walnut in the posterior triangle; much pain, and the arm somewhat swollen. She was unwilling to undergo any further operation. Injections of soap solution as employed in Case I. were commenced, Colonel Ligertwood kindly assisting me with these. March 3 : The pain has ceased, and both the enlarged gland and growth seem smaller. March 10 : The gland is now the size of a pea, the growth softer, and split up into separate nodules. March 17 : No pain, and the gland can barely be made out. March 24 : There is some return of pain in the growth, and the gland is a little more evident. The menstrual period has appeared after two months' interval, and is profuse. March 31 : The gland again can only be made out with difficulty, and no pain is complained of. April 7 : Several of the nodules have disappeared, leaving an apparently quiescent adherent surface. In the tem- porary difficulty of obtaining fresh purified ox-gall, which in the meantime Mr. Webb had recommended, as I shall subsequently refer to, 5-grain tabloids of the same were added to the treatment. She continued to be doing well, and the injections were omitted for a fortnight. When HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 17 on June 2 the period again appeared, the tissues became thickened and hard and two small fresh nodules appeared, which increased to the size of peas, bled a little, and threatened to break down. A fresh small cervical gland could also be felt. On continuation of the injections every other day the sores scabbed over, and the patient was apparently again progressing satisfactorily. In April and July Dr. A. W. Higgs, of Chelsea, her medical attendant, wrote to me, fully testifying as to her condition and improvement. July 16 : Patient complained of pain in the right breast, and I was disappointed to find a movable, rather large lump, which before had not been present. Injections were commenced in its immediate neighbourhood on the chest-front every other day, and ^-drachm doses of fresh purified ox-gall prescribed. July 23: The growth was very much reduced in size, and there was no complaint of pain. The injections have been continued, but the ox-gall has been obliged to be reduced on account of the diarrhoea caused. September 15: Injections into the breast-tissue itself surrounding the growth have been followed by pain and tender swellings. They have been resumed again into the pectoral region and upper arm, since which all pain has ceased, and the tumour is apparently reduced and quiescent. The left chest remains sound, the scabs having fallen off. October 3 : The patient remains the same. There is some fulness and pain at times in the left supraclavicular region, but her condition is giving no cause for anxiety. Keratin coated pills have been substituted for the mixture or tabloids. Her condition remained satisfactory till November 10, when severe pain in the left shoulder confined her to the house, and she was unable to attend and continue treatment. December 3 : I visited her, and found fresh superficial nodules in the left breast, which 18 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER had hitherto remained sound, and the liver was also found to be nodulated. December io: She seemed to be holding her own, but on December 16 she passed away. I was away at the time, and I am indebted to Dr. Higgs for the following notes. December 14: ' I was called to her for pleurodynia and lumbago, and I found the heart failing. December 15 : The pains had gone, but her heart was still failing, and she died the next day. Her temperature at first was about 1010, and next day one degree higher. I cannot state the cause of her death other than a general septic condition, usually observed in such cases, and sufficient to enable me to say that the end was approaching. With regard to the treatment, I agree with you that the disappearance of the left supra- clavicular gland was due to the soap injections, that for some time afterwards the disease appeared to be arrested and a general improvement under the ox-gall apparent.' Note.-The temporary reactivity of the disease noticed at the two menstrual periods, with intervening subsidence, is noteworthy, and the removal of ovarian irritation may possibly be a contributing factor in the improvement effected by oophorectomy (Beatson) in certain cases of recurrent cancer of the breast. The growth in the right breast coincident with retrocession of the process in the other is also noteworthy, the disease being held in check locally by the injections, but the general process uninfluenced. In this case ox-gall could not be pushed, owing to the diarrhoea occasioned by small doses. I have employed soap injections in two other cases, one that of carcinoma of the rectum in a patient of advanced years, with cardiac disease and hemiplegia. Colotomy had been performed nine months previously. As a result of the injections, rectal pain was removed, discharge checked, and fetor kept down, but death occurred, the HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 19 digestive powers having been almost lost. In this case an enlarged prostate necessitated constant catheterism, and complete ability to pass water followed previous injections of iodipin. This latter point, in considera- tion of the shrinkage following iodipin injections in similar fibroid enlargements of the uterus, is, I venture to think, deserving of attention in the treatment of enlarged prostate. Let me mention that in the case of this patient constant pain was complained of in the left hip. It dated from a slight previous fall, but a skiagram revealed no injury. The pain and joint trouble in this case, as also in Case II., may be instances of joint trouble, probably septic, noted by Heberden, which I have since become acquainted with in Sigmond's remarks on the palliation of cancer. ' In the last sad stage of cancer,' he states, ' hemlock, if it has not been so in- judiciously employed as to have no longer any efficacy, becomes the chief support and the best friend of the sufferer ; it is preferable to opium. Heberden first told us that in the last stage, besides the usual distress of fever, the hectic patient is often harassed with pains like those of rheumatism, which wander throughout the whole body or remain constant and fixed in one part, and what is rather strange, often at a great distance from the primary malady, and in appearance unconnected with it; he observes that these pains have been so great as to make no small part of the patient's sufferings, and not to be tolerable without the assistance of opium. These pains, at a very distant part of the body from the seat of cancer, are found principally where the ulceration exists in parts that are exposed to the action of the air.'1 In the other case-carcinoma of the mouth-soap injections 1 ' Lectures on Materia Medica and Therapeutics,' by George G. Sigmond, M.D., the Lancet, July 29, 1837. 2-2 20 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER were pushed to a 2 per cent, strength, which, however, produced painful lumps, lasting several days, and this contributed to the cessation of this method of treatment. Chian turpentine injections were also tried, and, as others thought at the time, with some improvement and reduction of fetor; but I lost sight of the patient, and though the injections were continued, I believe later they, too, were abandoned. MR. J. H. WEBB'S METHOD OF TREATMENT AND THEORY (abstracts). As a result of a long correspondence with Mr. Webb, of Melbourne, I was furnished with full details of the technique of his method of treatment, together with the notes of many cases in which he had obtained good results, notably in recurrent breast cancer after opera- tion. He thinks he has effected much improvement in his method, and states that while the soap injections seem to succeed very well alone in certain cases, he now recommends in others the internal administration of fresh purified ox-gall in preference to his original recommenda- tion of the same hypodermically. His letters seem to me to be of so much interest and importance that I have arranged the following abstracts thereof, and I would direct attention to them in accordance with his kind permission and sole wish that due trial may be made of his treatment. ' Soap Solution.-The superfatted soap of Messrs. Allen and Hanbury, or, for that matter, common yellow bar soap. A 1 per cent, solution is a trifle too thick, but will suffice. The standardized solution corresponds to 0'8 per cent. Inject drachm doses anywhere, but as near to the tumour in sound tissue as possible, every four days at first or thereabouts. Subsequently daily doses in smaller HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 21 amount can be used with caution in the continuance of the treatment. 1 Syringe. - A Parke-Davis, aseptic. The cylinder should hold just a drachm, and a fine needle is necessary. ' Eucaine Solution.-Three per cent. Insert the needle first, then inject £ drachm or less of eucaine. Do not withdraw the needle, but wait a couple of minutes, and then throw in the soap solution. Massage the part a little after withdrawing the needle, so as to disperse the fluid.' 1 Animal Gum': Sodium Tauro- or Glycocholate - Purified Ox-Gall. ' Preparation.-Evaporate a gallon or less of bovine bile to dryness over charcoal (granulated animal charcoal). Throw into methylated spirit. Boil for twenty minutes, then filter; boil again in fresh charcoal. If all the colouring has disappeared, filter again and concentrate till it is as thick as Devonshire cream. This made into a mixture with some tragacanth and a little orange syrup is not very disagreeable to take. Begin with ^-drachm doses three times a day, and increase till it causes diar- rhoea or looseness of the bowels.' Subsequently once or twice a day is sufficient dosage. ' The term " gum " is short, and expresses its chief physical peculiarity. It does not matter what it is called. One thing is positive-that it has a powerful influence on cancer when it can be taken in sufficient doses. But here is a difficulty: it does not answer alone, neither does the soap after a time. The latter seems to succeed very well by itself at first, and in primary cancer injections of it alone may be enough, but in chronic or recurrent carci- noma it seems to me that its effects wear off after a time, 22 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER but they can be revived by the gum. If you wish to see the action of soap, take a smallish rodent or epithelioma, and inject a few drops under the ulcer. It is very painful, and eucaine or a general anaesthetic is necessary. The scab will at once fix and remain on ten or fifteen days, and sometimes fall off dry, leaving a perfectly healed surface. It may return, and you will then have to use the gum also. A word more as regards the soap. I do not care how large or how offensive a cancerous ulcer may be, I assert that the soap solution alone in a few days-sometimes as little as two-will remove all un- pleasantness and nearly all discharge. I have done this in old people and advanced cases over and over again. In old people with extensive ulceration life itself cannot be much prolonged, but if all the horrors of cancer-pain, discharge, fetor-are removed, very much is effected, and this I affirm it will always do. ' If you wish to see the effects of soap on cancer as an external application, make a paste by boiling down some preparation, such as Maclinton's or Allen and Hanbury's toilet soap, and lard it over a large foul epithelioma, and you will be surprised at its action-how it will clean the sore, leaving an apparently healthy surface, but the disease will continue.' ' Nature of the Disease.-I hold the first lesion in carcinoma is crystallization of cholesterine from the living cell, and that may be brought about in two ways : (i) By local injury or by a local chemical change in cholesterine, as is effected by soot or paraffin cancer. In rodent and in non-infiltrating epithelioma, this is all. The process ends here, and these cases will recover completely, and remain well, with the soap solution. But when you come to the infiltrating carcinoma, behind the local crystallization there lies another process. HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 23 (2) Some change in the liver secretion, one which is probably a loss or mechanical separation of the soap, and that to my mind constitutes the difference between the two forms of malignancy, and in a measure accounts for the variability and capriciousness of cancer. A person receives a blow : this separates the cholesterine from the cell; inject with soap alone and it will recover, at least for a time, sometimes for always. A change-not a loss, or patients with chronic biliary fistulae would at once become cancerous-takes place ; a diminution of soap in the bile-product allows the same process-viz., crystal- lization-to take place, separation from the cell occurs, and cell proliferation starts. Here soap alone is in- effectual ; the fault is in the liver secretion. Take, for instance, a case of breast cancer with fetor. Inject with a saturated solution of cholesterine dissolved in soap, and it will have no more effect on the disease than so much water. It will turn the urine red, that is all. Now inject soap solution alone, and the fetor will at once disappear. Therefore soap injections do very well in local cancers, like some operations ; but, on the other hand, when the disease is a general one, due to loss of soap or change in the biliary secretion, you must employ gum, and opera- tion is useless. I do not know how you can distinguish between the two at first. ' It is curious to watch cancer healing. It is not the cell element which gives the trouble, but that fibrous induration which imparts the strong hardness to the tumour. In many cases this never disappears, but indurated glands seem to yield. I have recovered eight breast cases in all. I lost one recurrent of the breast, but I never could induce her to take the gum by the mouth. Nevertheless, I relieved her enormously, for I entirely got rid of all smell and discharge. Nothing 24 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER short of saving her life could have been more satisfactory. And I lost another in which I think the administration of thyroid played a prominent part. Another case I cannot get to take the gum, and in consequence I am not very hopeful about her. She says it makes her back ache and prevents her from sleeping, and I cannot get her to persevere. Gum has a peculiar action on soap. Make a soap solution, and stand it aside. Now make another ; add a little gum to it, and let it rest for a few days. The soap solution remains soap solution, but the mixture has separated out with something else, which I have not determined. I do not wish to infer that the doses I have given are correct. There is some proportion, a balance between the gum and soap, which I have not exactly made out. The action of these two substances is like the disease itself-surpassingly capricious. The last case of epithelioma I treated I kept in check for two years, at times very nearly healing it up. It never quite went away, though I thought it had. I subsequently gave gum by the mouth, and the healing process commenced at once, and now it has gone (yide Case IX.). ' In severe cases soap will not do alone, neither will the gum. Whether it is that the gum loses its soap in passing through the stomach or not, I cannot say. In milder cases the soap injections by themselves seem to answer very well, but when the disease has advanced, it appears to me that the gum is essential. It requires a little management, but the treatment to my mind is very effectual when the disease is uncomplicated. I am strongly of opinion, when these substances can be used as I have suggested, uncomplicated cancer is a treatable affection ; but there must be no albuminuria, diabetes, jaundice, or broken-down metastasis ; and in intestinal HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 25 cancer involving the lumen, operation should precede treatment, for I am afraid cicatricial contraction results, and healing must increase rather than remove the con- striction. If the lesion is only mesenteric, it does not signify so much. Where fibrous hyperplasia is great, I use a little (io grains at the outside) of thyroid extract, as I hold that the only influence that gland has is on the fibrous tissue, and its use is passing away very much.' The following brief notes of some cases forwarded by Mr. Webb illustrate the results of his treatment: ' Case I.-Mrs. S . I mentioned this case in the Lancet,1 but notice the sequel. There was a tumour of the breast of the size of an orange. It was of two years' growth, was firmly attached, and the nipple was deeply retracted. I injected soap alone. In less than six weeks the whole tumour had disappeared, leaving a firm cicatrix, and in three months after the commence- ment of treatment one would hardly have known there had been any disease at all. Naturally everybody re- marked, Was it cancer ? For fifteen months the breast remained perfectly sound, when one day she returned with a suspicious skin-spot. I injected it, and in a few days a slough came away, leaving a malignant foul ulcer of the size of half a crown, with a very dense base- proof, if anything was wanted, to confirm my diagnosis. Under soap and thyroid this breast completely healed for the second time. Eighteen months later epithelioma appeared in the tongue, but the breast remained clear. A third time I nearly recovered this patient, when she refused treatment any longer, and yet it was reduced to a mere nothing. If I had given her gum on the first occasion, I think she would not have had the recurrence. 1 'Cancer: Its Nature and its Treatment,'J. H. Webb, the Lancet, October 12, 1901. 26 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER ' Case II.-Recurrent breast cancer; quite recovered. This isa woman, aged thirty-five. First seen December 23, 1901. I removed the primary tumour, February 23, 1902, so that at present date, December 25, 1903, over two years have elapsed since the first appearance of the disease. I had the nodule examined by the leading pathologist here, who pronounced it at once to be malig- nant. It recurred in the shape of a skin-nodule-one of those circular-cupped deposits. I did not give it time to break down, and from that time till within three months ago I kept the woman in excellent health ; still I felt that I was not administering sufficient animal gum. I used to use the ethereal preparation. I then changed to the alcoholic {yide Preparation), and gave it by the mouth with manifest effects. ' Case III.-Cancer of the tongue. Soap solution. The patient had a metastasis which had invaded and opened the oesophagus, so that from mechanical causes alone recovery was impossible, but the action of the remedy was again marked. All throat irritation and expectora- tion went away in a few days, and when death came it was in comparative comfort. ' Case IV.-Cancer of breast. Sent to me February 23, 1901. Breast removed five months previously and every- thing cleared away. Recurrence well marked. Scar adherent and raised. Ulceration above cicatrix. Scattered nodules. Losing 2 or 3 pounds in weight a fortnight. There was no doubt here about the rapid recurrence and cancerous nature of this woman's breast. She is to-day alive, fat, and as well as can be. Not a sign to be seen ; not a nodule in her chest. ' Case V.-Woman, aged forty-five, consulted me with large adherent breast, involving all the gland ; nodules all over the front of the chest, some on the point of breaking HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 27 down, or, rather, flattening and ulcerating. Patient weak and emaciated. August 25, 1901,1 removed a large part of the breast. Under the soap treatment, as in the above, she completely recovered, and now, August, 1904, is without a sign of cancer and in perfect health. Unfortu- nately, in these two cases the breast was not examined microscopically. In my own case it was surely not necessary, and in the hurry of the moment I omitted to bring away the part removed. ' Case VI.-Woman, aged fifty. A tumour had been detected in the breast about Christmas, 1901. Four months later a portion of breast was removed in hospital. The pathologist to the University pronounced it to be undoubtedly malignant. At the end of June she came to me with a tumour, the size of a mandarin orange, in the breast. Soap injections were administered, and to-day, eighteen months after, her health is perfect, but there is a cicatrix in her breast as large as a walnut. ' Case VII.-Cancer, " cuirass." Right breast. Thick ichthyotic scab. Arm much swollen, so much so that blisters, or, rather, blebs, formed. Albuminuria two years. Axillary and supraclavicular glands much swollen. This woman with injections of soap and gum completely recovered from the cancer, save for a little swelling of the arm. Up to this, I thought when once the vein was occluded the thrombosis would prevent the circulation ever being re-established, but this is not correct. She all but regained the use of her arm, and could raise it and touch the back of her head. The breast entirely healed and the glands disappeared completely, as far as I could feel, and she became a useful member in her family. Then the albuminuria increased. I never could find any cancer cells, but plenty of casts in her urine. Dropsy set in, and she died one day in a convulsion. 28 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER ' Case VI11.-Abdominal carcinoma. This woman was really almost in extremis; at all events, I did not think when I first saw her that she could live more than a few days; and yet some six months afterwards she walked into my room as healthy-looking a woman as one could wish to see. The disease returned, and, I think, must by now have proved fatal; but her recovery for the time was simply marvellous, and this with soap alone. ' Case IX.-Epithelioma of nose. Typical sore about the size of an elongated shilling. Examined microscopi- cally, and pronounced to be undoubtedly malignant. March, 1902: Soap injections. Healed rapidly, and remained well till August. Injected again, and healed, remaining well till January, 1903. Recurred again, and gum injections given. I have kept it under, or, rather, his own doctor did up to about a month ago. At one time it was healed for five months, when it recurred faintly. It never quite went away; there was always some itching left, and then it would scale again. " But you cannot continue this kind of thing always," as he said the last time I saw him ; " I have had ninety-two injections." December 12, 1903: The local soap and gum injec- tions were omitted, and " gum " given by the mouth. December 25, 1903, the patient writes: " Continual disappointment has made me rather sceptical, but I cannot shut my eyes to the immense improvement that has taken place since I began taking the gum by the mouth. The part is assuming a healthier aspect. The scab is steadily shrinking ; the inflammation practically gone, the edge of the scab looking healthy, and the swelling has all but disappeared. If the improvement continues, I see no reason for doubting an ultimate cure." March 9, 1904, again he writes: "I think I can safely assume that the epithelioma which has worried me for HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 29 the last twenty-seven months is gone for good. I would have written before, but my unhappy experience has made me very sceptical of an absolute cure. But the conditions now are so distinctly different from any previous conditions of apparent cure that I have now little fear of a recurrence. True, more than half of the cartilage of my right nostril has disappeared, but what is left looks absolutely sound and healthy, with the excep- tion of a slight scar tissue, which is becoming smaller and beautifully less every day. I have had no local injection of soap and animal gum for eighty-nine days. I have taken no gum by the mouth for fourteen days. The improvement was marked and continuous from the first dose of gum by the mouth, on December 12 last, until the present moment of writing, a period of ninety days. I am still watching developments very carefully, and although I am inclined to think that I need not take any more gum, I shall resume taking it again in a day or two for precaution." March 15, 1904 : I saw the patient to-day. The ulceration has made a little half- moon on the ala of the nose, and there is a scar, but otherwise this epithelioma has completely disappeared. September n, 1904 : Patient has been to town on business, and made a friendly call. He continues per- fectly well. February, 1906: Remains perfectly well. 'Case X.-In July, 1902, a woman, aged sixty-eight, came into my room showing an enormous cancer of breast en cuirass, which had broken down in several places -in fact, the nipple had gone, leaving a hole large enough to hold a small tomato. The whole mass covered a surface larger than the crown of my hat. I treated it with soap and gum injections for about twelve months, when it all but healed, the patient continuing all the time in excellent health. When I first saw her she 30 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER weighed io stone 4 pounds; maximum weight, 15 stone. February 16, 1904: Weight, 14 stone 10 pounds. She then went back a bit. A suspicious nodule appeared, which, to my intense disappointment, broke down into a nasty ulcer, the size of half a crown, and her arm swelled a great deal. Accordingly, I gave gum by the mouth, which for three months acted fairly well, the ulceration not spreading. The arm commenced to swell, and I recognised the fact that the latter drug was not holding the case as it should. I used injections of soap again in the manner I have described, but without much improvement. I next reverted to daily injections of soap, administered by a Parke-Davis aseptic syringe. April 25, 1904 : This has answered perfectly. I could not wish for anything better. Everything has absolutely healed, and she is in most robust health and so stout as to be unwieldy. I found that I had been giving too much gum, and that twice a day was quite enough. By the Parke-Davis syringe the injections are almost painless, the needle is so fine and strong ; and it does not require such a large dose at a time if you inject daily, while in this way the soap solution does not leave those painful nodules you write about. The swelling has practically gone from the arm in this way. If the limb is raised for half an hour or so, all the oedema goes ; but if it is left to hang down, some swelling returns, so I presume the oedema is solely due to loss of elasticity on the part of the tissues, and not to venous obstruction. July 27 : In Case XII., as will be detailed, all the nodules have gone; but, as a rule, these fibrous deposits occasion great trouble, for they will not disappear, nor will they ulcerate, and are too large to remove with the knife. In this patient, save for her age, she would be in very good health but for one of these masses. The annoying HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 31 thing is that it will not heal, and yet is so soft that I could scrape it away with my thumb-nail, and I should do so, but I am afraid of the haemorrhage that might occur, as it is extremely vascular. August 29 : Is doing well. Really, if you could see her you would never doubt that there is virtue in soap. The arm goes down sometimes almost entirely, and then it swells up again in a very curious way. I dare not touch her fibrous knobs, they bleed so readily, or otherwise I would scrape them all off. They are quite soft. September 11 : The swelling has gone from the arm; it went in three or four days. One limb is now no larger than the other. She cannot yet use her hand, for, naturally, the fingers are stiff. I can make no impression on the soft fibrosity that covers the whole of the left breast, but on firm pressure on a nodule a quantity of gelatinous matter wells up. There is no discharge, but occasionally the lumps exude an odourless serum. Really, it is curious to see an immense carcinomatous mass, as this is, or rather was, entirely free from smell or pain. Her health is perfect. She has had this disease now over four years, but has been only under my treatment for two. I am sure when she first came to me no one would have given her three months to live, if a third of that time. November 7, 1904 : She took to her bed, with intense vomiting, refused food, and sank from cardiac failure. She retained her obesity to the last. Though consider- able nodulation was left, there was no swelling of the arm or ulceration. 'Case XI. - Woman, aged thirty-five, whose right breast had been removed for carcinoma. The operation, performed at a very early stage, had been a complete one. At the time there were no glands or any dissemina- tion, but the underlying fascia and part of the pectoral 32 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER muscle were removed. Nine months afterwards a recur- rence took place in the scar. She then came under my charge. I injected her with soap, and the nodule dis- appeared, and all then remained well for four months, when a further recurrence took place. I then used gum and soap mixed, and for a second time was successful in removing all traces of the disease as far as I could see. Six months ago the malady appeared again, and spread rather rapidly. I found that neither the soap injections nor gum injections were of much avail. Then three months ago I treated her in the same way as in the previous case. Toward the end of last January I recognised that the gum was making her very ill, so much so that she took to her bed complaining of severe pain in her back and limbs, sleeplessness, and occasional nose-bleeding. I reduced the dose to once a day, and injected soap daily, using eucaine also. April 25, 1904 : The breast has now healed except one spot, the size of a threepenny-piece, and there is some healthy scabbing left. There is one supraclavicular gland and a small chain of nodules by the side, which seem to me to be disappearing. She is regaining her health, is able to be up, though not walking about. Her appetite is very good, and on the whole I think she is in fair way to recovery. June 14: Progressing, as far as the cancer is concerned, wonderfully well, but the other day, having been caught in the rain, developed pneumonia. This is most unfortunate. The glands in the neck have entirely gone except one, and even that is barely perceptible. July 18: The ulceration has entirely healed, but the fibrosities seem to be irritable ; they stand out in raised plaques. She recovered from the pneumonia, but has fallen into a neurasthenic condition, and is very thin. July 27 : The disease has left some warty patches, which HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 33 have a tendency to exude like an eczema. August 29 : Not doing very well. A few years ago she had phthisis, but seemed to have recovered, though the apex on the right side is depressed, and her pneumonia does not quite clear up. The carcinoma, so far as the active disease is concerned, is satisfactory. There are some fibrous nodules left, and there were a few warty plaques. Two or three I touched with nitric acid, and as soon as the superficial eschar disappeared, they quickly healed. ' Case XII.-Recurrent carcinoma of the breast, with hepatic metastasis. Previously operated upon by Mr. Henry O'Hara, Senior Surgeon to the Alfred Hospital, Melbourne. She returned last January, and passed again under the care of Mr. O'Hara. At this time her chest was most extensively nodulated, and her abdomen dis- tended with ascites, for which Mr. O'Hara tapped her, and also removed one of the lumps for re-examination. She then came under my care at the beginning of February, 1904, with far-advanced recurrence. I suppose there were quite a hundred nodules visible. The glands in and below the axilla and above the clavicle stood out like small currant grapes ; besides which the abdomen, though she had only been tapped a week, was fairly distended. She was so weak as to be hardly able to sit up, and very pallid. She managed to return home, and I taught her sister how to inject her. Three weeks later her husband wrote to me that he thought she was a little stronger, but that the ascites had become almost insupportable. I travelled to the country to see her, and tapped her, and, finding that the injections were not being managed very well, I succeeded in getting her to town again, and have since been treating her. I have had to draw off the abdominal fluid altogether some 34 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER six times. The last time the water was somewhat less, but the abdomen swelled again for about a week, and then the ascites commenced to go away of its own accord. July 18, 1904: To-day every nodule has disappeared, and the stitch marks, every one of which had been plainly visible, can now no longer be seen. She is thin, but not so much as to attract attention, and she walks about, to all appearance as if there was nothing the matter with her. I must confess I have never before seen an ascites disappear of its own accord. I have known it not to return after tapping in one cirrhotic case, but the man died three months afterwards. But in the above case the abdomen emptied itself apparently by the kidneys, as the patient passed enormous quantities of ■water. In any case, not a vestige of any tumour or hardness can be detected. 'July 19, 1904. Note by Mr. O'Hara : "I have just seen Mrs. , and must congratulate you upon your success. Twelve months ago she came to me with a far-advanced carcinoma of the right breast, with secondary involvement of her axillary glands. I advised the removal of the breast according to Watson Cheyne's method, and thoroughly cleared out all the involved tissue. Just within twelve months she came back to me with multiple carcinomata in the stitch-holes and hepatic metastasis, which had caused ascites as extensive as it could be. I tapped the abdomen, and removed one of the glands for bacteriological examination. As there was no doubt as to the recurrence, I advised her to return home and prepare for the worst. I saw her again about a week ago. She informed me that Mr. Webb had been treating her for six months. Her improvement is marvellous. The nodules have all disappeared, and she has made an excellent recovery. The bacteriological HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 35 examinations were made for me by the hospital patholo- gist, Dr. J. F. Mackiddie." ' August 16: I discharged Mrs. yesterday, and she has gone home, as far as I can see, perfectly well. She had been away for a fortnight to a farm-house some miles from Melbourne, and returned wonderfully improved. In this case I used the Parke-Davis syringe, injecting never more than | drachm at a time, generally only 15 minims, and she took by the mouth 20 to 30 minims of the purified ox-gall three times a day. August 29 and November 7: Reported satisfactory. Whether she will be able to maintain her present condition is one thing ; what is certain is that the treatment I suggest has had a most beneficial effect on her. This is incontestable, and there was not a shadow of a doubt as to the nature of her malady. January 17, 1905 : Patient succumbed at home, out of reach of medical attendance, to an attack of diarrhoea during the hot weather. ' This is not the best case I have had, for I think the one whose breast I removed myself was perhaps further advanced. It will be now three years this month since I operated on and treated her, and so far there is no return or anything approaching to it, and she is quite a strong and robust woman (yide Case V.). 'Case XIII.-Rodent ulcer of forehead in a young woman aged twenty six. It was of eleven years' duration, and had been twice removed and once grafted. This patient completely recovered in six weeks under the soap injections and thyroid. This is the case I mentioned in the Lancet.1 She has never had the slightest return ; she is married, and the scarring is trifling. This was a sore larger than half a crown, almost baring the bone, and there has been no return now for four years. 1 The Lancet, October 12, 1901. 36 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER 'Case XIV. Rodent Ulcer, September n, 1904.-The patient was an old man and tabetic. The ulcer was situated at the inner canthus, about the size of a florin. It had been excised, then grafted, excised again, X-rayed, subjected to radium and electricity, and yet the sore was virulent and spreading. I injected him every other day for three weeks, when the scab fell off, leaving a perfectly healthy surface. ' To recapitulate, in small rodents inject a few drops of soap solution under the base of the sore. It is very painful, and a general anaesthetic or eucaine is necessary. ' In epitheliomata and general cancer it is necessary to do more : (1) " Gum," by the mouth, 20 drops three times a day. Continue till diarrhoea occurs, or pains in the limbs are complained of. (2) Inject-anywhere, but as near to the tumour in sound tissue as possible-daily not more than 30 minims of a o-8 per cent, solution of soap at one time. Rub the part slightly afterwards to disperse the injection. A nurse can give the injection, as it gives no trouble, and it is not so painful as morphia injections. (3) Lather the ulceration with soap and let it remain on. Do not apply any antiseptic. Cover with cotton- wool. ' Whether the theory on which this treatment is based is exactly right is a matter of opinion, but there is no question that the remedies suggested have an enormous influence for good in carcinoma. By all means use my letters, or anything I have written, in any way you like, and, if there is any question, I shall be only too pleased to answer it. There is nothing private, or anything I desire to keep to myself. My sole wish is that the treat- ment should have a fair trial. Personally, I have not a shadow of doubt as to its efficacy; I have done it so often.' HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF SODIUM OLEATE 37 Remarks. - My experience so far with Mr. Webb's treatment has been attended with similar results, and the apparent arrest of growth, undoubtedly, locally and for a time, together with the removal of some of the worst features-pain and fetor-confirm the results claimed by him for his method of treatment. Further- more (June 4, 1905), Dr. McNab of Chicago wrote to me : ' I have had under observation some six cases of carcinoma of the breast. I have used the 1 per cent, soap solution hypodermically, and the ox-gall per mouth. Two of the cases show marked improvement ; the other four I cannot speak so well of.' The value of Mr. Webb's independent work and improved methods is, in my opinion, enhanced by the fact that the palliative effects of ox-gall in cases of cancer have been known from early times. Not long ago I came across a paper by Dr. Clay of Manchester,1 on the internal administration and use of inspissated ox-gall generally, with notes of three cases of cancer in which palliative effects resulted. This observer is, I find, no relation to the late Dr. Clay of Birmingham, and it is curious that the name should thus be doubly associated with the treatment of cancer. The cases are as follows : ' Case I.-Cancerous ulcer of the nose, accompanied by excruciating pain, which, although not cured by the ox- gall-nor was it given with such hopes-yet it received a considerable check, and what was of infinite importance, great relief in respect of the agonizing pain under the inspissated gall used to the extent of about 30 grains in the day. ' Case II.-Male, scirrhus of breast of long standing with extensive fungoid excrescences; the pain was ex- 1 MedicalTimes, 1846, vol. xiii. 38 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER cessive, and the discharge considerable and offensive. After taking the gall for a little time the pain was in a great measure relieved ; the discharge became less offensive, the sore healthier and disposed to heel; the general health improved ; the sore was nearly healed, although at first not less than 3 inches in diameter, and great hopes of succeeding to an entire cure were entertained. Some time after he received a blow on the part; the disease returned with great violence, and, with the exception of the pain which the gall at all times considerably abated, he sank some months after. 'Case III.-Extensive cancerous destruction of the whole of the left labium pudendi, extending to the mons veneris and to the glands of the groin. In this case everything that experience would suggest, or the materia medica supply, had been tried, not so much to cure as to give some ease to the torment the patient endured. Nothing procured her sleep for more than an hour at a time, and that of a restless character. After four 10-grain doses of the gall she enjoyed more real rest than had visited her for many weeks before; but though she experienced more relief from this than any other remedy, and it always controlled the pain more or less, still, the work of destruction progressed, and she finally sank-not, however, without expressing her satisfaction at the relief it had from time to time afforded her.' The cholesterin theory, moreover, derives support from the work of Dr. F. W. Beneke. This observer believes the cells of carcinoma are relatively rich in cholesterin and in lecithin ; he concludes that the growth of the tumours in question may be checked by the use of a diet in which nitrogenous food is reduced to a minimum, and recommends those vegetable substances CHOLESTERIN AND CANCER-SYSTEMIC ORIGIN 39 in which the carbohydrates largely predominate, as well as sugar.1 Furthermore, at the present time the opinion seems to prevail that a relation exists between gall-stones and cancer. Now that the parasitic origin of cancer has come to be generally regarded as an impossible theory- though the ' uncontrolled ' cell may in a sense be regarded as ' parasitic '-it may not be without interest to recollect that the older authorities considered the systemic origin of cancer as being necessary to its local evolution. ' Although the disease operates on some particular part of the body, it is always preceded by a state of constitu- tion which has excited it. He who looks at this disease in the light merely of a local affection takes but a narrow view of it ' (Astley Cooper). In this connection the conclusions arrived at by Mr. J. H. Webb are most suggestive-viz., that it can only be a secretion which regulates cell proliferation,2 and that cancer is uncontrolled cell proliferation due to the deposition of cholesterin, from the cell, either locally from injury, or dependent on some chemical change in the liver secretion, associated with deficiency of the bile- salts which normally hold cholesterin in solution. 1 'Food in Health and Disease,' by I. Burney Yeo, M.D., F.R.C.P. - The Lancet, October 12, 1901. CHAPTER III THE RELATION OF DIABETES TO CANCER-GLYCOGEN -NATURE OF CANCER CELLS Soap is, as Mr. Webb holds, a solvent of cholesterin. So are oil of turpentine, olive oil, and neutral fats; so also is acetone. The latter fact, I submit at once, suggests the further questions, viz.: (i) Are diabetics resistant to cancer, and is there any connection between the two diseases ? (2) Are the alleged results claimed for molasses treatment in cancer consequent on the artificial production of glycosuria or acetonuria, and suggestive of a sugar diet or similar lines of treatment P1 The simultaneous occurrence in the same patient of carcinoma and diabetes is not unknown, and acetonuria is found in association with certain forms of cancer (Osler).2 But cases are not only known in which, on the one hand, diabetes has followed carcinoma, and on the other, car- cinoma has followed diabetes. As an instance of the former, Mr. J. Langton3 referred to a case of cancer which had been operated on twice, and in which death occurred nineteen years later from diabetes. Dr. C. O. 1 ' Some Methods of Hypodermic Medication in the Treatment of Inoperable Cancer,' by John A. Shaw-Mackenzie, 1904. - * The Principles and Practice of Medicine,' Professor W. Osler, M.D., F.R.C.P. 3 Medical Society, British Medical Journal, March 18, 1905. 40 THE RELATION OF DIABETES TO CANCER 41 Hawthorne kindly informed me of a case of the latter which had come under his observation. My friend Dr. Gerald Harper has recently furnished me with notes of a case, in which the following sug- gestive sequence obtains-1891 : Male, aged sixty-one. Diabetes, after three to four years of great trouble, worry, and stress. At first the symptoms were severe, but gradually declined under diet, and were almost absent. In 1902 malignant disease of right lower jaw. Operation. Ten months later the glands became affected, and were removed. The diabetes returned in a marked degree after each operation, but slowly declined. 1906: There is no sugar in the urine, and the general health is good; a cataract, considered to be of diabetic origin, has been observed during the last six months. Mr. Roger Williams, on inquiry, kindly referred me to his remarks on this subject in the ' Twentieth Century Practice of Medicine,' vol. xxi., Supplement,1 which only recently I have had an opportunity of 'seeing : ' It is interesting to note that of late many instances of the association of malignant tumours with diabetes have been reported (Kappler, Kreutzmann, Tuffier, and others); and most of those who have specially studied this subject maintain that the diabetic state favours the development of malignant disease.' It is of interest to note that only recently Dr. de Lint, of Scheveningen, independently expressed this Opinion to me. Dr. Hawthorne further directed my attention to the observations of J. Boas on the subject. Amongst 366 cases of intestinal carcinoma, the coincidence was present in twelve cases, and in seven of these the diabetes was not ascertainable later. Moreover, the course of the carcinoma, according to this observer, appears to be 1 ' Cancer : Theories of the Parasitic Origin.' 42 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER affected by the presence of diabetes in the active stages, and patients succumbed in a comparatively short time; while when the diabetes is more or less latent, the car- cinoma appears to be rendered less rapid and malignant than usual.1 In a case recently seen of recurrent cancer of the inguinal glands after previous removal of primary epithelioma of vulva, and subsequently of glands, sugar was found to be present in the urine some weeks ago, but not now. In two cases of malignant disease which have come under my own notice one or other parent died of diabetes. I learned this by chance in Case II., p. 9, who, on my recommendation of the addition of sugar to his diet, informed me that he had always avoided sugar, as his father died of diabetes. The other was a case of carci- noma of the breast, which ran a very rapid course in a patient whose mother had been for a long time under my observation suffering from diabetes. Conversely, I have recently seen a case of carcinoma in the father of a son who died of diabetes. In two family histories to my own knowledge a brother has died of diabetes and a sister of carcinoma. In another-two sisters-one died of cancer and the other of diabetes, while recently I have seen a case of carcinoma in a man whose brother died of diabetes. My attention has further been directed to the work of Dr. James Oliver, in which he states : ' I believe malignant disease and diabetes are, from an inheritance point of view, co-related to each other. My clinical notes lead me to express this opinion. At the present time I have two sisters under my care, the one suffering from advanced malignant disease of the uterus, the other from pruritus vulvae dependent on diabetes.'2 1 ' Carcinoma and Diabetes,' J. Boas, Berl. Klin. Woch., March 16, 1903 ; Epitome, British Medical Journal, November 7, 1903. 2 ' Notes on Diseases of Women,' by James Oliver, M.D., 1888. THE GLYCOGENIC THEORY OF CANCER 43 While further inquiry may well be directed to these clinical points, the above references are sufficient to indicate that (a) the simultaneous presence of the two diseases, carcinoma and diabetes, in the same patient is comparatively rare ; (ty substitution of the one disease for the other in the same patient; (c) that there is some alternation between the two diseases in different members of the same family. The latter consideration directly led to the inference that (i) whereas at the present day there is an admitted relation between diabetes and functional derangement or disease of the pancreas, so also in car- cinoma the pancreas may be at fault; (2) that whereas in diabetes there is (fl) overproduction, defective storage in liver, or (b) imperfect destruction of glycogen and formation of glucose, directly or indirectly dependent on failure of the glycolitic or sugar-splitting function of the pancreas, so in carcinoma there may be (fl) overproduc- tion or (6) non-conversion of glycogen ; (3) that, as an additional or alternative theory to cholesterin, in the same way the presence of glycogen in new growths may be due either to undue deposition or formation in the tissues locally or dependent on some nutritional disturbance in the liver or pancreas, associated with failure of the glycolitic function of the latter. Chiefly, therefore, the underlying theory here put forward is that cell proliferation or alteration of type of division rather than inflammation may be dependent on some systemic condition, and local irritation determine the site of growth.1 In the same way the above considerations directly led to investigations into the solvent action of various fer- ments, including those of the pancreas on glycogen. As 1 'Local Irritation and Cancer,' by John A. Shaw-Mackenzie, the Lancet, January 14, 1905, p. 120; British Medical Journal, January 7, 1905, p. 48. 44 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER will be subsequently seen (Chapter IV.), they led to the discovery that the proteolytic ferment of the pancreas -trypsin-broke up glycogen and glucose, and imme- diately to the preparation of a solution of trypsin for hypodermic and therapeutic use. Moreover, a similarity seems to exist between (i) the presence and excess of glycogen in embryonic tissues, and (2) the excess of glycogen in malignant growths, suggestive that in malignant disease there is reversion to embryonic dis- tribution of glycogen. 1. Glycogen seems to be present wherever active growth is going on, being found in most of the tissues of the young foetus, but, curiously, not in the liver. Dareste and Bernard have both described its formation in the developing hen's egg, and state that it exists there in the form of granules, much like those of vegetable starch.1 According to Professor M. Hartog,2 'the inference is, that a saccharoid substance is present in the blastoderm of the hen's egg, and an inverting ferment effects the change.' According to Michael Foster, ' all the embryonic tissues for a long time are protoplasmic in character, and the foetal tissues at a very early period, before the liver has become functionally active, are loaded with glycogen. By the fifth month it is deposited in the liver. By this time histological differentiation has advanced largely, and the use of the glycogen to the economy has become that to which it is put in the ordinary life of the animal ; hence we find it deposited in the usual place. Besides being present in the foetal, glycogen is found also in the placental structures; but here, probably, it is of use, not 1 'Dictionary of Chemistry,' by Henry Watts, B.A., F.R.S., F.C.S., 1875. 2 ' Some Problems of Reproduction,' Marcus Hartog, Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science, 1903-1904. GLYCOGEN 45 for the foetus, but for the nutrition and growth of the placental structures themselves.' Again, in association with milk secretion and the direct formation locally of the representatives of the three great classes of food-stuffs-proteids, fats, and carbohydrates- ' what we see taking place in the mammary cell is probably a picture of what is going on in all protoplasmic bodies. If by a slight change the milk-sugar were accumulated rather than the fat or proteid, we should have a result which by an easy step would bring us to glycogenic tissue.'1 According to Murchison, there are good grounds for believing that glycogen assists in cell growth, for just as in plants the presence of sugar seems to be necessary for the most rapid development of cells, so in animals glycogen can be found wherever cell growth is actively going on.2 2. According to the same observer, glycogen is present in new growths whenever cell formation is active. According to J. de Nittis, the percentage of glycogen in the blood, which is always small, and then only com- bined with the white corpuscles, everywhere else appear- ing in the form of glucose, is diminished amongst the tuberculous, the cancerous, and the cachectic. On the other hand, it has been shown that it accumulates in the periphery of tuberculous granulomata by Loeper and Esmonet, and of new growths by Brault.3 Moreover, the latter has further drawn attention to the fact that rapidity of growths in tumours varies in direct proportion 1 ' A Text-book of Physiology,' by Sir M. Foster, K.C.B., M.A., M.D., F.R.S. 2 ' Lectures on the Diseases of the Liver,' by Charles Murchison, M.D., LL.D., F.R.S. 3 J. de Nittis (Arch. Gen. de Med.), May 19, 1903 ; Epitome, British Medical Journal, June 20, 1903. 46 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER to the amount of glycogen present in them, and that the proliferation and luxurious growth of the cancer cells is due to the increased supply of this nutriment. Dr. de Backer had for some time advocated injections of pure cultures of yeast in the treatment of phthisis on the ground of its leucocytosic and phagocytosic action. He concluded, further, that this ferment reduced the natural glycogen of the body, and, in view of Brault's observations, was led to apply this treatment in cancer, as brought forward and advocated by Dr. H. Manders in this country.1 VIEWS REGARDING THE NATURE OF CANCER CELLS. At this point it is interesting to epitomize some of the views held in respect of this question. (a) Cohnheim referred the origin of carcinoma to the proliferation of ' embryonic ' cells-cells which in process of development have been very early shut off and remained dormant till aroused into activity by some cause or other. (b) On the other hand, in 1888, Mr. Roger Williams pointed out that ' the various pathological formations originate by reversion of the cells, which are usually engaged in maintaining the normal structures, to an embryonic state of activity, and that these unspecialized cells then manifest their potential reproductive qualities.' He attributes ' the genesis of all neoplasms to excessive activity of certain lowly-organized cells of the part, deter- mined by local excess of nutrition, with probable perver- 1 Keith W. Monsarrat, F.R.C.S.E., the Medical Annual, 1899; ' The Method of Dr. de Backer in the Cure of Tubercle and Cancer,' by Horace Manders, F.R.C.S., British Medical Journal, September 25, 1899; 'Ferment Treatment of Cancer and Tuberculosis,' 1898; * Cancer : Theories of the Parasitic Origin,' by W. Roger Williams, F.R.C.S., 'Twentieth Century Practice,' vol. xxi. (Supplement). THE NATURE OF CANCER CELLS 47 sion of the secretion of the affected part, while there are good reasons,' he thinks, ' for believing that the constitu- tional condition has ceased to be normal. The agency of micro-organisms,' he states, ' is no more necessary to account for the phenomena of cancer and tumour forma- tion than it is to account for the development of a tooth or hair. As long as the tissue cells are subject to the normal restraining influence of the organism, they develop normally; but when this influence is weakened or with- drawn, their potential reproductive power may become actual. The only cells of the body thus set free are the reproductive cells ; but any cells abnormally emancipated may then grow and multiply more or less independently, regardless of the requirements of the adjoining tissues and of the organism as a whole.'1 Briefly, therefore, there is reversion to embryonic cell activity and repro- ductive properties ; and, above all, local nutritional and systemic conditions favour and determine growth. (c) It is usually taught that the reproductive organs arise from the pleuro-peritoneal cells of the germinal ridge, and therefore are somatic in origin. For some time Dr. Beatson has held that in malignant disease the epithelial cells of the body have taken on the power of ' active proliferation, which is the marked characteristic of the germinal epithelium.'2 (d) In 1903 Messrs. Farmer, Moore, and Walker demonstrated the similarity existing between the cells of malignant tissue (gametoid) with those of reproductive (gametogenic)-i.e., heterotypical and other mitoses, with reduced number of chromosomes; differing in character 1 'The Principles of Cancer and Tumour Formation,' by W. Roger Williams, F.R.C.S., 1888 ; ' Cancer Genesis,' the Lancet, November 12, 1904, and December 3, 1904. 2 ' Cancer and its Origin,' by George Thomas Beatson, C.B., M.D., May, 1896, British Medical Journal, January 2, 1904 ; April 29, 1905. 48 THE NATURE AND TREATMEMT OF CANCER from embryonic cells which have the full number of chromosomes. These observers considered that the remote causes which change the course of somatic cell development into that characteristic of gametogenic tissue ' must be sought among those various physiological stimuli occasioned, e.g., by continual irritation, known to favour their development.'1 In the same way, it seems to me that the remote causes may still further be sought in the bio-chemical conditions and stimuli of disordered metabolism. («) According to the conclusions of Dr. J. Beard, founded on embryological researches, the cells of cancer are not embryonic or somatic, but the products of ' germ cells ' of pre-embryonic origin. According to him, in the normal life cycle of development there are two genera- tions-an asexual one, the ' larva,' phorozoon or tropho- blast, and a sexual one, the ' embryo '-and that in every normal development the embryo or sexual form is able in some way or other to suppress the asexual foundation upon which it arose. As a rule the victory of the former over the latter is complete. * Only in ordinary chorio-epithelioma is the malignant neoplasm a persisting portion and derivative of the trophoblast of the imme- diately previous gestation. Any ordinary cancer or sarcoma is a new development of trophoblast, due to the attempt of a germ cell to start the cycle anew.' The factor or factors which bring about degeneration of the trophoblast in normal development are based on nutritional changes at the ' critical period.' ' The change in nutrition initiated at the critical period in vertebrate animals, from fishes to man, is based on the commencing 1 ' The Resemblance between the Cells of Malignant Growths in Man and those of Normal Reproductive Tissues,' by J. B. Farmer, F.R.S. ; J. E. S. Moore, F.L.S. ; and C. E. Walker, Royal Society, December io, the Lancet, December 26, 1903. PANCREATIC (TRYPTIC) FACTOR 49 functional activities of the pancreas. This introduces an alkaline digestion by means of the pancreatic juice with its various ferments. . . This cancer research along the lines of embryology led him to hope, and independently suggest, that the same factors ' might also be potent when directed against an irresponsible trophoblast or cancer.'1 ' The solution of the problem of the functional relation of embryo and trophoblast-how the latter nourishes itself by an (intracellular) acid peptic digestion, and degenerates slowly by a pancreatic digestion-becomes at the same time the embryological, if not the medical, resolution of the problems of malignant neoplasms as well as of chorio-epithelioma.' (For further details the reader is referred to ' Embryo- logical Aspects and Etiology of Carcinoma,' the Lanett, June 21, 1902; 'The Problem of Cancer,' the Lancet, October 29, 1904; 'The Cancer Problem,' the Lancet, February 4, 1905, by J. Beard, D.Sc. Victoria, University Lecturer in Comparative Embryology, Edinburgh.) (/) According to Dr. Blumenthal, the cancer cell shows a chemical composition different from that of the somatic cell. Amongst other properties, an autolytic ferment is present, which possesses the power of not only destroying the cancer albumin (Petry), but with perfect ease the albumin of other tissues and organs. He considers that the cancer cell has assumed properties different to the epithelial cell, its mother cell, and under- gone a chemical transformation ; while liberation of the cancer ferment not only effects a considerable destruction 1 Dr. Beard has recently directed my attention to a lecture delivered by him on January 20, 1905, to the members of the Anatomical Society, the Medical Institution, and the Biological Society, in Liverpool, and published on January 21, 1905, in which he stated that ' at the critical period the embryo, complete in all its parts, began to nourish itself by an alkaline pancreatic digestion and with a ferment known as trypsin . . . which clearly, then .... ought to possess potency when directed against the cells of a malignant tumour. ' 50 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER of somatic albumen, but produces arid explains the cachexia. He further notes the important fact that ' all carcinomata are always very easily digested by pancreatin (Bergell), while, on the contrary, all other tissues of the organism are fairly resistant to its action.'1 1 'The Chemistry of Cancer,' by Professor F. Blumenthal, of the Cancer Research Institute, Berlin, translated by J. Beard, the Medical Press and Circular, April 12, 1905. CHAPTER IV THE ACTION OF TRYPSIN ON GLYCOGEN, GLUCOSE, AND STARCH ; HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF TRYP- SIN-AIDS AND OTHER FERMENTS, SECRETIN, EREPSIN, ENTEROKINASE As previously noted, many experiments were commenced early in December, 1904, and undertaken for me by Mr. F. W. Gamble, pharmaceutical chemist, upon the solvent action of various ferments, including those of the pancreas on glycogen. As a result, it was found that while pepsin and diastase had little or no action, the proteolytic ferment of the pancreas-trypsin-effectually and immediately broke up glycogen, and led me to begin, on January 19, 1905, trial of hypodermic injections of trypsin, together with the internal administration and local applications of pancreatic preparations, in cases of inoperable cancer. It was further found that trypsin reduced glucose itself, and that the addition of the bile-salts considerably aided the reducing action of trypsin. Not only did clinical considerations especially lead to chemical experiments with the ferments of the pancreas, but the known physiological action of the pancreatic juice on starch, attributed to its diastatic action, suggested similar inquiry into its action on glycogen. In percentage composition glycogen is the same as starch-C6H10O5; it 51 52 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER came, therefore, as a surprise to find that it was the proteolytic ferment of the pancreas, and not the diastatic, which acted on glycogen. On the other hand, as subse- quently ascertained, M'Donnell1 regarded glycogen as a nitrogenous starch. According to him and others, the fibrin and much of the albumen of the portal blood vanishes in the liver. While the liver destroys these azotized compounds forming its own non-azotized amyloid substance (glycogen), it excretes bile, containing so little nitrogen that it need hardly be taken into account. ' The conclusion seems obvious, therefore, that the nitrogen which leaves the liver by no other outlet may go forth in the hepatic blood in union with the glycogen, thus changed into a new azotized principle.' Glycogen, therefore, in the living tissues of the body- in the blastoderm as well as in cancer-probably exists in nitrogenous combination, and thus the action of the proteolytic ferment of the pancreas, rather than its diastatic, is readily understood. According, also, to Bernard, glycogen is converted into sugar by acids, diastase, and the ferments contained in the blood, saliva, liver, and pancreas ; but according to the same authority, glycogen which has not previously been treated with saliva does not ferment with yeast. Michael Foster2 also notesthat ' the result of the action of diastase, salivary or pancreatic ferment, upon glycogen, is, according to Musculus and V. Mering, a mixture of achroodextrin and maltose.' But none of these observers suggested that it is due to the proteolytic ferment. The results of further interesting experiments kindly made by Mr. Gamble show that (i) glycogen is not broken up by yeast; (2) trypsin appears to exert little or no action upon unheated starch. If the starch granules, however, 1 ' Dictionary of Chemistry,' by Henry Watts, B.A., F.C.S., 1864. 2 Ibid., Appendix, fourth edition, 1883. THE ACTION OF TRYPSIN AND EREPSIN 53 be broken up by heat, the resulting mucilage of starch is completely altered by commercial trypsin. This action may be due to the presence of a small proportion of amylopsin. The nature of the products of the digestion of starch by trypsin is doubtful. Sugars are apparently not formed. PLANT AND VEGETABLE GLYCOGEN AND FERMENTS (TRYPSIN AND erepsin). According to Dr. W. Pfeffer glycogen is a reserve carbohydrate allied to dextrin and present in many fungi. In large fungi it is consumed during growth (Clautrian). Vegetable trypsin occurs in many, but not in all plants, and trypsin is produced by many bacteria, and pepsin by many fungi. The enzymes of most bacteria are, like trypsin, active only in an alkaline or neutral solution. On the other hand, the enzymes of some act only in the presence of acid. The liquefaction of gelatine by many bacteria and certain fungi show that they also can excrete a proteolytic ferment. Experiments are required to show whether vegetable pepsins produce peptone with albu- moses as intermediate products, and whether vegetable trypsins carry the digestion as far as the formation of leucin and tyrosin.1 It is not impossible that the asserted action of plants and sera in the treatment of cancer may be due to vegetable trypsin and erepsin. 'As regards the vegetable kingdom, it has recently been shown by Vines (Ann. Bot., xvii., pp. 237 and 597, and xviii., p. 289), that extracts of practically all parts of all plants contain a peptolyzing ferment, whilst certain plants contain a fibrin-digesting ferment in addition ... it seems not improbable that they might show a much closer resemblance to the erepsins of the lowest members of the animal kingdom.'2 1 ' Physiology of Plants,' by Dr. W. Pfeffer, Professor of Botany, University of Leipzig, translated by A. J. Ewart, D.Sc. 2 ' The Universal Presence of Erepsin in Animal Tissues,' by H. M. Vernon, M.A, (Oxon.), M.D., the Journal of Physiology, 1905. 54 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER Of obvious use in plant metabolism and on plant glycogen, it is hardly to be expected that vegetable ferments will compare with animal ferments on animal glycogen. Yeast, for example, contains a proteolytic ferment, but, according to Pfeffer, is apparently unable to ferment glycogen. It is possible that an enzyme may be obtained from saccharomyces capable of decomposing sugar. HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF TRYPSIN. Technique.-The injections are administered deeply into the subcutaneous tissue, anywhere, but as near to the growth in sound tissue as possible. In growths of the stomach and recurrent abdominal disease the injections may be made in the subcutaneous tissue of the abdominal wall. In disease of the uterus and rectum the sub- cutaneous tissues of the upper gluteal region seem a suitable place. As regards syringe, needles, antiseptic pre- cautions, ice, and eucaine, I have nothing to add to the technique previously described under chian turpentine and soap injections. If details are carefully followed I have rarely witnessed or heard of any pain, local or general trouble. In two cases severe pain was reported to me, but in these cases the injections were being made into muscle, and ceased when this was pointed out. In another case I heard the treatment had been abandoned on account of local pain, and in another on account of intermittent pulse, conse- quent on some cardiac and renal complications. In one case witnessed by myself the injections appeared to set up local swelling and erythema, and could not be pushed in consequence. It seemed in this case to be an idio- syncrasy which I am unable to explain. Solution and Dosage.-Having arrived at the fact that HYPODERMIC INJECTIONS OF TRYPSIN 55 trypsin broke up glycogen, the next point was to determine a solution suitable for hypodermic injection and dosage. A i per cent, solution of trypsin in sterile normal solution, with a trace of phenol and glycerine, was furnished by Mr. F. W. Gamble, to whom I am again indebted, and I decided to commence with 5 minims, which was in- creased by 5 minims on alternate days up to 30 minims. In the same way a 2, 3, and 4 per cent, solution was pro- ceeded with. I now usually begin with 15 minims of a 2 per cent, strength, and increase by 5 minims every other day. I do not wish to infer that this dosage is finally correct. Details of this treatment require to be worked out, and no doubt the proper dosage will be arrived at. The preparation and tentative therapeutic use of these injections have been the subject of much anxious consideration, both on the part of Mr. Gamble and myself. Phenol was soon given up, as mere traces of it in the injections seemed to cause pain. The actual chemical composition of trypsin is not known. Its proteolytic activity varies. Time and exposure to air decrease its activity, while heat, excess of water, carbonate of soda (Vernon), and various combinations destroy it. A 5 per cent, solution keeps better than a 2 per cent., and solutions of the latter soon become cloudy. A word of caution may not be out of place. Till we know more of this toxic agent, it should be used with care. The injections are better used fresh, and the proteolytic activity in all cases tested.1 With regard to dosage, I am at present inclined to think the indication is to give larger doses of a 2 per cent, strength, with a view, if possible, to irrigate and reach the site of disease, rather than proceed to smaller doses of a higher strength. 1 These hypodermic injections of trypsin (sterile) may be ob- tained of Messrs. Allen and Hanburys. 56 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER Internal Administration.-Two grains of trypsin, or 5 grains of pancreatin, in combination with purified ox- gall, may be given three times a day. The liq. trypsin (Allen and Hanburys), in i to 2 drachm doses, may be given three times a day in a little water immediately before meals, or glycerole pancreatin (Armour and Co.). In addition, I have latterly been using in 4-drachm doses preparations of intestinal glands, containing, as I under- stand, 'secretin;'1 'erepsin;' and 'enterokinase' (Allen and Hanburys); alternately with the trypsin. Preparations of the pancreas are not all equally active in the proteolytic ferment, and become weakened by keeping. It has been objected that pancreatic prepara- tions must get destroyed in the stomach, but in the first place it has recently been shown by Professor Moore2 that the presence of free hydrochloric acid in the gastric contents is diminished or absent in cases of carcinoma other than the stomach, and in the second place the simultaneous administration of ox-gall in pill form acts as a protective to the trypsin. Keratin-coated pills have not proved satisfactory, as in one case the pills passed un- dissolved-a fact which I did not discover for some time. Local Applications.-Much relief has followed pancreatic solution and pigments to sclerosed and ulcerated surfaces. The further use of douches, suppositories, and oint- ments of the same is obvious. Aids to Trypsin; other Ferments; Erepsin.-(a) I have already noted the therapeutic effect of purified ox-gall 1 'Trypsin in Cancer,' by John A. Shaw-Mackenzie, the British Medical Journal, January 27, 1906, p. 240. 2 ' On the Absence or Marked Diminution of Free Hydrochloric Acid in the Gastric Contents in Malignant Disease of Organs other than the Stomach,' by Benjamin Moore, M. A., D.Sc., Royal Society, March 16, 1905, in collaboration with Messrs. W. Alexander, M.D., M.Ch., F.R.C.S. ; R. E. Kelly, M.B., B.Ch.,B.Sc. ; and H. E. Roaf, M.B. THE ACTION OF TRYPSIN AND EREPSIN 57 alone, and chemically its aid to the reducing action of trypsin; (i) Professor Starling1 has pointed out the direct action of ' secretin ' on the secretory activity of the pancreas. J. P. Pawlow has shown how the succus entericus is capable of aiding the proteolytic ferment of the pancreas, and, according to him, the pancreatic secre- tion is through nerve reflex, (c) In either case, inhibition of the pancreatic and intestinal functions follow from the important fact of the absence of acid in the gastric contents noted by Professor B. Moore. Whatever the nature of the internal secretion of the pancreas may be, the pancreatic juice, as generally taught, does not contain trypsin, but a zymogen or tryp- sinogen, which, after entering the intestine, is converted into trypsin by the ferment ' enterokinase ' contained in the succus entericus. According to Herzen and Bellamy,2 the spleen also is an aid to the pancreas, in the formation of trypsin. It is obvious, therefore, that in any deficiency of the trypsin ferment the pancreas itself may not be primarily at fault. Erepsin.-The researches of Dr. H. M. Vernon demon- strate the universal presence of erepsin in animal tissues, a peptone-splitting ferment discovered by Cohnheim in the intestinal mucous membrane. ' An ereptic ferment ... is common to all animal tissues; it is present in the tissues of all classes of animals, cold-blooded as well as warm-blooded, invertebrata as well as vertebrata.'3 Furthermore, ' it has always been assumed that the whole 1 'Elements of Human Physiology,' by E. H. Starling, M.D., F.R.S. 2 ' On the Agents concerned in the Production of the Tryptic Ferment from its Zymogen,' by H. F. Bellamy, M.D., Journal of Physiology, 1901-1902. 3 ' The Universal Presence of Erepsin in Animal Tissues,' ' The Peptone-splitting Ferments of the Pancreas and Intestine,' by H. M. Vernon, M.A. (Oxon.), M.D., Journal of Physiology, 1904-1905. 58 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER of the proteolytic changes brought about by the action of pancreatic juice or extracts are due to a single ferment.' In this respect, according to Dr. Vernon, ' pancreatic extracts contain two independent ferments-viz., pan- creatic erepsin, which does not exist in the form of a soluble zymogen, and trypsin, which does; and of the peptone-splitting effected by pancreatic extracts, the larger part is due to pancreatic erepsin, a ferment entirely distinct from trypsin . . . and different to intestinal erep- sin.' With regard to erepsin, according to the same observer, in order of activity the kidney heads the list, then intestinal mucous membrane, pancreas, lung, spleen, liver, and blood, and serum last. While, therefore, the importance of the pancreas is self-evident in the production of proteolytic or glycolitic ferments, it is obviously significant to note the additional role which the intestinal glands assume in discharging a similar function. In this connexion, Captain F. F. Carroll, R.A.M.C., who is especially interested in the conservative and operative work on the stomach and intestines, has sig- nificantly drawn my attention to the facts-viz., that cancer of the stomach stops abruptly and sharply at the pylorus (Bergmann);1 that the small intestine is rarely the site of cancer; and that cancer of the large intestine and rectum increases in frequency, for the most part, the further the distance from the duodenum (Hiemann's statistics).2 Dr. Vernon has kindly informed me that while he has never heard of erepsin being obtainable for therapeutic use, preparations of the intestinal glands and of other 1 'A System of Practical Surgery,' by Von Bergmann, vol. iv„ p. 372, 1904. 3 Ibid., p. 391. ' Trypsin and Erepsin in Cancer,' by John A. Shaw- Mackenzie, the British Medical Journal, March 24, 1906, p. 715. NOTES ON DIET 59 organs, if properly prepared, contain it, but too strong acid destroys it, and the crude juice contains other fer- ments and proteids. The selection of fresh and healthy gall-bladders, and details of the preparation of pure ox-gall itself, are not simple matters. In this connection I desire to acknow- ledge the services Mr. H. Horne, pharmaceutical chemist, has afforded me. He informs me that a large number of the gall-bladders obtainable are unfit for use, and the selection of them is of the first importance. I have also to thank Mr. T. Burgess, pharmaceutical chemist, for similar valued assistance he has rendered me. NOTES ON DIET. As long ago as 1845 Macilwain maintained it to be a pure assumption that cancer is incurable by the powers of Nature. This observer referred the causes to errors in diet or non-assimilation of food, sedentary habits, the free use of alcohol, and of greasy, fatty, and saccharine matter. He rigidly dieted his patients, excluding sugar, as some authorities at the present day also do. On the other hand, I have already referred to Beneke's recom- mendation of sugar on the cholesterin theory, and I suggest it also on the glycogenic. It is at least possible, not to say probable, that the source of the fcetal glycogen, as also in diabetes and carcinoma, arises in part from a splitting up of proteids, while, probably, this may be re- duced, on the ground that carbohydrate food and sugar decreases the waste of cell proteids (Herter). On clinical grounds, as already noted, a carbohydrate diet and sugar suggests itself. I have already noted on p. 42 that Case IL, p. 9, had always avoided sugar, as his father died of diabetes. It is curious that in several cases of cancer lately inquiry 60 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER has elicited the same avoidance of sugar. In two cases it had been given up to avoid a tendency to stoutness ; in other cases, rheumatic and gouty, on the recommenda- tion of the medical attendant. In other cases sugar had not been absolutely avoided, but there was no particular wish for it. In another case the taste for sugar was coincident with the onset of cancer. These may only be coincidences. It is, however, impossible to avoid the reflection that the general recommendation to avoid sugar and sw'eet wines by the gouty and rheumatic may have been carried too far ; and that the prevalence of cancer now is in contrast with the port and gout of former days. Most enzymes are destroyed by heat, so that cooked ' sweetbreads ' are not available. In several cases recently seen, inquiry has elicited the fact that salt has been taken in excess, as also there has been a craving for acids. In one case the patient in- formed me he had long thought he was taking too much salt, and that it must be deleterious. This popular belief has an element of truth in it. If cancer cells take from the blood for their own purposes those substances from which the organism usually forms hydrochloric acid in aid of its gastric digestion (J. Beard), it is probable that salt and chlorides are contra-indicated. In two carcino- matous patients their condition appeared to be aggravated by change to the seaside. Further inquiry is desirable into the incidence and progress of carcinomatous cases at such resorts. In one country district where carcinoma is prevalent, a medical man kindly informed me in his opinion it was associated with the introduction of a new water-supply, as opposed to the previous use of well- water. SPONTANEOUS CURE-AGE INCIDENCE 61 SPONTANEOUS CURE. With reference to recorded cases of spontaneous cure, no adequate explanation has hitherto been advanced to account for their occurrence. On the other hand, in view of the considerations advanced in these pages, it is not improbable that in these cases the temporary failure of the function of the pancreas or intestinal glands has been directly or indirectly restored-that is to say, that these spontaneous cures of cancer may be attributed to the removal of inhibitory-e.g., mental, nervous-or of chemical causes, temporarily interfering either with the formation or local supply of the proteolytic ferments. AGE INCIDENCE. Together with local and systemic influences, the factor of the life cycle itself may be considered. Turning once more to physiology and the phases of life, according to Michael Foster, we know that 'the life of such an organ as the thymus is far shorter than that of its possessor. What is true, also, of the teeth is probably true of many other organs. It is obvious that though the phenomena of old age are primarily the result of the individual decline of the several tissues, they owe many of their features to the disarrangement of the whole organism produced by the premature decay or dis- appearance of one or other of the constituent bodily factors. Everywhere we see a disposition on the part of the protoplasm to fall back upon the easier task of forming fat rather than to carry on the more arduous duty of manufacturing new material like itself; every- where almost we see a tendency to the replacement of a structural matrix by a deposit of amorphous material.'1 1 Michael Foster, ' A Text-book of Physiology.' 62 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER What is true for the thymus and teeth, it may be sug- gested, is true also for the pancreas and intestinal glands, and the phenomena of old age primarily the result of their individual and gradual decline. Furthermore, in view of the fact that diabetes and cancer are in the main diseases of advancing and advanced years, it is not unreasonable to suggest that primarily they are the result of diminution or disappearance of the proteolytic ferments, produced by the premature decay of these organs. We have seen that up to the fifth month in foetal life, the tissues are loaded with glycogen. Its storage in the liver is coincident with the presence of trypsin in the pancreas-according to Michael Foster-somewhat later than the fourth month, though this appears to differ in different animals. As already noted (p. 44), glycogen is found in the developing hen's egg (Bernard); and the blastoderm of the three to four days chick itself contains a saccharoid substance (M. Hartog).1 According to the same observer, a peptonizing ferment, active only in presence of dilute acids, is present, and Millon's re- agent stains the extravascular blastoderm more than the embryo. So, later, with advancing years, coincident with a failing pancreas or intestinal glands, a reversion to embryonic distribution of glycogen takes place. Deprived of its proteolytic ferments, a biological change in chemical properties occurs in the epithelial cell; it reverts, as it seems to me, to its blastodermic condition; its saccharoid peptone is no longer split up ; and its reproduction uncon- trolled. What is true for the cancerous growth itself is probably true for the cells elsewhere. According to Michael Foster, it is 'doubtful whether a truly peptic 1 ' Some Problems of Reproduction,'by Marcus Hartog, Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science, vol. xlvii., 1904. A GE INCIDENCE 63 gastric juice is secreted during intra-uterine life, and, ac- cording to Professor Benjamin Moore, the absence of acid gastric secretion persists after removal of a cancerous growth itself, suggestive not only of the risk of recurrence, but of the general condition underlying its manifestation. In the same way, this hypothesis suggests that cancer in the young and the so-called hereditary origin of cancer may be due to developmental imperfections in the same organs. Similarly, in the unlimited growth of trans- planted cancer in mice, the pancreatic or other ferment, sufficient to deal with natural processes, may not be equal to controlling the growth or neutralizing the ' cancer ferment.' SUGGESTED USE OF TRYPSIN, EREPSIN, AND ENTERO- KINASE IN OTHER DISEASES. Diabetes.-I have already noted the reducing action of trypsin on glucose. Lepine was the first to suggest a glycolitic ferment in the pancreas finding its way into the lymph and blood, and its defect in diabetes. Accord- ing to Herter,. this hypothetical ferment has not been isolated.1 Recently, according to Tyson, Dr. Alfred C. Crofton holds that trypsin, the proteolytic ferment of the pan- creatic juice, is the glycolitic ferment in question, requiring, however, the presence of haemoglobin to effect its function.2 It has also been pointed out by Tyson that subcu- taneous injections and injections into the peritoneum of animals of pancreatic extract is followed by glycosuria -a further indication, it seems to me, of the use of subcutaneous injections of trypsin in cancer. 1 ' Lectures on Chemical Pathology,' by C. A. Herter, M.D. a ' Bright's Disease and Diabetes,' by James Tyson, M.D., 1904. 64 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER In like manner adrenalin has the power to cause glycosuria. According to Crofton, the suprarenal capsule contains a substance which either induces the formation of sugar or inhibits its normal destruction. While the administration of pancreatic preparations by the mouth in diabetes has on the whole proved disappointing, it may nevertheless be hoped that injections of trypsin hypodermically may prove more satisfactory, and that neutralization of the acid products of diabetes may, furthermore, be directly effected by this means. Colonel T. Ligertwood, M.D., has recently reported to me a case of diabetes which has seemed to, and still appears to, improve under the administration of trypsin. Sir Lauder Brunton has kindly drawn my attention to his researches on ferments in the pancreas and in muscle; the difficulties of distinctly isolating the ferments; and on a probable glycolitic ferment in muscle, with raw meat in the treatment of diabetes.1 It is interesting to note that recently Dr. J. H. Abram2 has drawn attention to much benefit obtained in cases of diabetes under the internal administration of the acid extract of the duodenal mucous membrane, presumably attributable to the ' secretin ' contained. As a further explanation, I would suggest the presence, or use, of erepsin and enterokinase. Bacterial Diseases.-Most of the parasitic diseases are due to the action of ferments, and it may be that the proteolytic ferments or sera are indicated in some of these. I have witnessed myself very marked improvement locally and generally in a case of chronic phthisis under the 1 ' On Disorders of Assimilation, Digestion, etc.,' by Sir Lauder Brunton, M.D., D.Sc., LL.D. (Edin, and Aberd.), F.R.S. 2 ' The Acid Extract of the Duodenal Mucous Membrane as a Remedy in Diabetes Mellitus,' by John Hill Abram, M.D. (Lond.), the Lancet, January 27, 1906, p. 220. TRYPSIN AND EREPSIN IN OTHER DISEASES 65 administration of trypsin in the previous failure of fresh air and cod-liver-oil treatment. Venereal Disease.-There is probably more connection between syphilis and cancer than is generally admitted. Many undoubted cases of this association have come under my own observation. E. Lancereaux believes that syphilis attacks the pancreas more frequently than is generally supposed-views which have not been fully appreciated by me till now in the incidence of cancer. CHAPTER V CASES AND COMMENTS Subjoined are cases which have been under my care, or which I have seen, illustrating so far the effects of the treatment. Case I.-This was a poor woman, aged fifty, from the East End, with inoperable recurrent carcinoma of the right chest, after thorough operation and removal of the breast five months previously in hospital. The stitch scars were the seat of multiple carcinomata, and the tissues of the front of the chest were adherent and studded with multiple carcinomata of the size and shape of small buttons, some of which were breaking down, with one growth about the size of a walnut over the sternum. She first came to me on October 3, 1904, and attended regularly for three months on alternate days for soap injections and ox-gall treatment. Under this she obtained great relief. The arms became less swollen, the tight- ness across the chest became less, the sores less angry, her appetite improved, and she suffered no pain, but there was no real improvement; the main mass increased slightly, and fresh button-like deposits appeared, and her weakness was extreme. She was averse to going into the Infirmary, and continued to attend with a neighbour who used to accompany her. On January 19, 1905, I 66 CASES AND COMMENTS 67 commenced hypodermic injections of trypsin, 5 minims of a 1 per cent, solution, increasing by 5 minims on alternate days up to 30 minims. I further gave her 1-drachm doses of liq. pancreatici three times a day in a little water, and recommended the local application of the same to the ulcerated places. She continued also the ox-gall, which produced diarrhoea after 30 grains daily. January 25 : She expresses herself as not having felt so well for a long time. January 30 : The scab has fallen off one patch, leaving a sound surface. She thinks the local applications soothe and help her, and especially asks for them. February 6: The main growth seems smaller. February 13: Locally, the main growth has perceptibly shrunk and is puckered in, but generally she is very feeble. February 20: She came by herself and expressed herself better. There is no breaking down of the main growth, and the few ulcerated surfaces have scabbed over. February 23: Her husband came to tell me that she had died suddenly this morning. Since her visit to me on the 20th she had been in good spirits and visiting friends. On the 22nd, feeling so well, she did not think she would come as usual on the morrow, as the weather was so bad. On this morning, the 23rd, her husband left her sitting up in bed taking her tea as usual, feeling well and speaking of all she hoped to do. On his return shortly after, she was still in the same position, but death had peacefully come. Remarks.-The freedom from pain, ulceration, and fetor was remarkable in this case, but owing to the circum- stances and extreme feebleness of this patient it was impossible to push the treatment as I could have wished. Had the surroundings of this patient been more favour- able, I cannot but think the result would have been different. As it was, from the commencement of the 68 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER soap injections she suffered no pain, while distinct im- provement seemed to follow the trypsin treatment. Case IL-This is the case of a man aged sixty-nine, who had been attending hospital for about a year with carcinoma of the rectum, which had been diagnosed to be ' permanently fixed ' and inoperable. Colotomy had been advised, but refused. High up an undefined growth of the rectum exists with hard infiltration, and which does not allow the passage of the finger. January, 1905 : The weight of the patient is 9 stone 10 pounds. Soap and trypsin injections alternately were com- menced, but living in the country, he could only occasionally attend. The internal administration of ox- gall and trypsin with liq. pancreatici has therefore been chiefly relied on. March 23 : There is considerable local irritation about the anus, which disturbs his night's rest. His appetite has improved, and his weight is 9 stone 9^ pounds. He was now laid up at home with symptoms of threatening obstruction, which were effectually relieved by aperients prescribed by Dr. Rudyard of Watford. The patient continued the ox-gall and pancreatic treat- ment, and on June 7 was able to come and see me again. The bowels are acting well. The motions are solid and no longer flattened. Pain is only experienced on passage of the motion, and at times there is a tinge of blood. He states his appetite is ' capital.' Weight, with lighter clothing, 9 stone 8 pounds. On rectal examination the finger passes easily through the stricture, and the infiltra- tion is softer and much diminished. June 16: Weight, 9 stone 6 pounds. He does not appear so well; 1 per cent, trypsin injections were commenced again and con- tinued every other day. June 23: Large bulky motions can now be passed. June 28: Much better. Weight, 9 stone 8 pounds. Two per cent, injections commenced. CASES AND COMMENTS 69 July 4: Weight, 9 stone 8| pounds. Local and general condition occasioning no anxiety. July 25 : The general improvement is fully confirmed by Colonel Ligertwood, who saw him previously on June 16. August 14: Reported the same. October 29: Dr. Rudyard kindly wrote, ' I must say that the result of the treatment so far is extremely gratifying; he has certainly held his own, and, in my opinion, is better than when I first saw him.' Decem- ber 27 : Examination per rectum shows no extension, and the finger passes through a soft and dilatable constriction. February 17, 1906 : Weight, 9 stone 10 pounds-that is to say, during the last twelve months no weight has been lost; the patient has been kept comfortable and free from pain, and the present condition is occasioning no anxiety. Case III.-March 10, 1905: Miss . Rather more than a year ago health began to fail, and a small sarcoma was removed from left infra-orbital region in September, 1904. Shortly after symptoms of obstruction and pressure on the right side of the nose appeared, with increasing deafness. It was considered to be probably a similar growth affecting the right superior maxillary bone and its neighbourhood-pronounced to be in- operable. Extending to the mid-line of the hard palate is a raised flat swelling. Hearing, taste, and smell are much diminished, if not altogether lost. There is much purulent foetid and blood-stained discharge from the right nostril, and the right side of the face is much swollen. There is slight albuminuria, and the pulse is intermittent. The patient had enjoyed good health all her life, except for chronic constipation. A maternal aunt is stated to have died of carcinoma, and a maternal uncle of diabetes. March 15 : Weight, 6 stone 10 pounds. Briefly, soap injections, 30 minims, were commenced and continued 70 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER every fourth day up to 60 minims. Trypsin injections 5 minims of a 2 per cent, solution, were given on alternate days, increasing by 5 minims up to 30 minims. Capsules of ox-gall and trypsin, together with liq. pancreatici, were prescribed t.d.s. per mouth. March 18 : Colonel Ligert- wood kindly saw the patient from week to week, and undertook the treatment with me. March 22 : The nasal discharge is diminished and less fetid. The growth seems flatter and less congested. There is some return of the power of smell. March 29: Hearing, taste, and smell much improved. The swelling of the face has dis- appeared. Appetite good, and the patient is able to go out and about freely. March 31: Colonel Ligertwood confirmed the improvement locally and generally. April 1 : The temperature rose to ioo° F. after 25-minim injections. April 4 : The nurse having been taught how to administer the injections, the patient was allowed to go home. April 12 : Reported to be ' very much better ; the swelling externally of the face is now hardly percep- tible ; general health is much improved; enjoys her food. Weight, 6 stone 12^ pounds. April 17: Reported that patient has been doing well this week both in appetite and walks, etc. Patient writes: ' I think I may say I am feeling nicely, and can do a good deal more than before I went to London. We are thinking of going away before very long for a change.' May 2 : Patient came to see me, and looks well. Locally there is little to note, but the dis- charge continues slightly. It is probable that there is pus in the antrum. Weight, 7 stone 1 pound. Injections of a 3 per cent, solution of trypsin were commenced. May 30 : The face was again slightly swollen, but the swelling subsided in a few days. Weight, 7 stone 5 pounds. A 4 per cent, solution of trypsin was commenced. June 6: The injections have been followed by local CASES AND COMMENTS 71 swelling and redness. The temperature rose to ioi° F. after an injection of 15 minims, necessitating the return to the 3 per cent, strength, 30 minims of which have been continued since without any trouble. July 5 : Patient came up from the country to see me. Weight, 7 stone 7 pounds. General condition excellent. Locally, the nasal discharge is slight. The right side of the face is again slightly swollen. The previous swelling and subsidence, together with the steady increase in weight, seem to suggest pus in the antrum. July 23 : Is reported to be suffering from rise of temperature to ioo° F., lasting four days, with increased nasal discharge. July 24: Her medical attendant fears the growth is extending, but is continuing the injections. August 14: Reported to be again better. I heard subsequently that the injections were dis- continued on account of the intermittency of pulse, and later that the disease had extended. Note.-Mr. J. H. Webb is of opinion that cases of bone cancer are not satisfactory cases for treatment with the injections of sodium oleate introduced by him. He con- siders that uncomplicated cancer is a treatable affection, but there must be no albuminuria, etc. (see p. 24). These objections hold good apparently in the case of trypsin. Case IV.-Male, aged fifty-eight. Consulted me August 12, 1904. Two years ago a small growth was removed from the base of the mouth, and pronounced to be malignant. There is now apparently a recurrent ulcer involving the fraenum. The weight of the patient is 8 stone 12 pounds. Iodides were prescribed. March 17, 1905: There is a large mass in the right posterior triangle, and the growth in the mouth is raised and bleeds readily. Ox-gall and pancreatin pills were commenced with drachm doses of liq. pancreatici, t.d.s. He is unable to 72 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER come for injection treatment. April 7: Weight, 8 stone 13 pounds. July 28 : Weight, 8 stone 11 pounds. There has been no extension of growth in the neck or the mouth. The small growth at fraenum does not bleed. He looks well, and is able to attend to his usual work. There is some pain and throbbing occasionally, but I believe the disease has been kept in check. For a few weeks he took the emulsion of chian turpentine, but the ox-gall and pancreatin have been steadily persevered with. February, 1906: I have not seen the patient again. I understand he is under other treatment. Case V.-Epithelioma of the upper part and rim of the right auricle. Excision in January, 1903. In May, 1904, some cervical carcinomatous glands were removed. In December, 1904, another gland in same situation was removed. It showed nothing. Shortly after I advised him to take emulsion of chian turpentine. In March, 1905, I substituted trypsin and ox-gall by the mouth. He has taken this continuously ever since. He was in robust health when I saw him last on February 13, 1906. Note.-This case, while it may very well be put down to successful operation, may equally illustrate the effect of treatment in the prevention of recurrence. We know that cases of epithelioma when excised early may not recur. On the other hand, it may be suggested that other glands in the cervical chain have been suppressed in this case by the pancreatic treatment pursued. Case VI.-On July 31, 1905, this patient came to see me. Eighteen months previously he had been operated upon by a distinguished surgeon for gastric tumour. ' It was so hard and nodular, and the glands so extensively involved, that it was impossible to remove it. Gastro-enterostomy was therefore performed. The CASES AND COMMENTS 73 relief was so marked, and the restoration to apparently complete health so good, that it was thought it might be possible that the growth may have been dependent on chronic ulcer and not on cancer.' In July, 1905, he wras again losing weight rapidly, and it was thought now the original diagnosis was correct, and that nothing more could be done. Under these circumstances he came to see me. He weighed 12 stone 8 pounds, as compared with 14 stone previously, and was obviously extremely ill. He was under the care of a distinguished physician, w;ho gave his consent to a trial of treatment by me. The internal administration of ox-gall and pancreatin was therefore commenced. August 15: Weight, 12 stone 12 pounds. At this time, in my absence from town, further treatment by subcutaneous injections of trypsin was commenced and kindly carried out by my friend, Dr. John Shaw. October 16 : On my return to town the patient weighed 13 stone io| pounds, and was in the best of spirits and apparently of health. A tumour could still be felt to the right of the umbilicus, of the size of a big plum, painless and movable, and very different from the diffused hard mass which previously existed. November 28: Weight 14 stone 2 pounds. There is no evidence of tumour, and the patient is apparently perfectly well. January 17, 1906: Patient remains very well, and all treatment is now given up. Remains perfectly well. Case VIL-This patient was kindly sent to me by Dr. W. Minchin, of Kells, co. Meath, on October 4, 1905. Gastro-enterostomy had been performed in Dublin in the previous July for large malignant tumour about the pylorus. Relief was obtained, but nausea, vomiting, and wasting had returned. Vomiting was constant, and a large mass existed in the epigastrium. The internal 74 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER administration of ox-gall and pancreatin with trypsin was commenced. He returned home at the end of a week, and Dr. Minchin most kindly and devotedly carried out the subsequent treatment. I am indebted to him for the following notes. November 25 : ' On examination 1 was surprised to find the tumour was only half the size it was. I had here some hopes; yet the symptoms of vomiting and nausea could be no worse. The ox-gall was omitted, but the pancreatin continued ; trypsin injec- tions were given daily, and nutrient enemata resorted to. December 3 : Practically no vomiting. December 9 : The injections appear to cause no disturbance of any kind, yet I decided to give them every second day, as the vomiting was decidedly improved. The tumour is cer- tainly diminishing in size, and is not so hard. I did not palpate the tumour for some time, in order that I would be the better able to detect a shrinkage in it. I am quite satisfied the tumour is much smaller. December 10: The vomiting commenced again, and persistently continued till December 17, on which date the patient died exhausted. The vomiting all through was of a bilious nature, and I think such vomiting is often met with after operations of gastro-enterostomy.' Note.-The shrinkage here, in an undoubted case of carcinoma of the stomach, is independently noted. It is impossible to say how much this shrinkage contri- buted in this case to the disturbance of the original gastro-enterostomy. Case VIII.-Recurrent carcinoma of rectum. Male. In January, 1903, the rectum was excised. Six months subsequently a small growth and the coccyx were re- moved. Recurrence now, and the condition was pro- nounced to be inoperable. I saw him on November 28, 1905, previously to his return home to Canada, and CASES AND COMMENTS 75 suggested treatment should be undertaken there. On February 27, 1906, Lieutenant-Colonel W. Nattress, M.D., kindly wrote as follows from Toronto: ' I have carefully and consistently carried out your treatment, and am now giving on alternate days 30 minims of trypsin hypodermically. He is also taking the ox-gall, etc., as recommended. Locally, I have made no examination, but I am more than surprised with the general progress shown in his face, his strength, and buoyancy. It seems to me that the treatment is certainly keeping the disease in abeyance, and it would be marvellous should it hold this case after two operations. I have never seen any unfavourable symptoms regarding the injections of the trypsin, and have been giving 30 minims regularly for the past month on alternate days. His appetite is good, he walks out every day, and is distinctly stronger, and can go further, and enjoys his exercise and rests tolerably well. I have not had to give him any morphia. ... I assure you that I am quite pleased.' I note also the following : 1. Carcinoma of rectum. Female. Colotomy, three years previously. Severe paroxysmal and tenesmal pain, or from pressure of mass on sacral nerves. The reports in this case have not been encouraging. The trypsin injections apparently set up local pain and swelling, and the pain generally appears to have been increased. Treatment was, therefore, abandoned. The preparation of intestinal glands (Allen and Hanburys) was substituted for the liq. trypsin, with, I understand, some relief, but opiates had to be continued. In another similar case recently seen (January 31, 1906), in which colotomy was performed some eighteen months ago, the same increase of pain has been noted. In this case there is a large mass in the rectum and in 76 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER the abdomen. In both cases the gut is probably con- stricted, and any increased peristaltic action consequent on the administration of trypsin and ox-gall, increases the pain. In such cases, in view of possible shrinkage of growth under trypsin, if continued, it becomes a question whether further operative procedure may not still be usefully employed to relieve obstruction. As already noted, Mr. J. H. Webb has pointed out that in intestinal cancer involving the lumen, operation should precede his method of treatment; for cicatricial contraction results, and healing must increase rather than remove pain and constriction. Something may also be done in the way of irrigating solutions of trypsin by the rectum and colotomy entrance. The usual glycerine extracts are not avail- able, as in the first case I saw this tried, diarrhoea and tenesmus followed, which I should have recollected from the glycerine contained. Simple solutions of trypsin seem to be tolerated, but they soon deteriorate without glycerine. 2. Carcinoma of the rectum. Female. Large mass in the liver. Violet-leaf treatment had been pursued with X-rays for some months for the rectal disease, and apparently with some benefit, but involvement of the liver became manifest. Trypsin treatment was com- menced, and for a few weeks great hopes were entertained; but from reports, the injections were attended with irri- tation, redness, and swelling, and had to be given up. A weaker solution of trypsin has been suggested, or in- jections of sodium oleate, together with the internal administration of the preparation of intestinal glands. In another case of carcinoma of the liver, an enormous mass existed. She was admitted into a Nursing Home (January I, 1906) in almost moribund condition, from severe haemorrhage from the bowels. Under trypsin, CASES AND COMMENTS 77 she seemed to pick up a little; the haemorrhage entirely ceased; the appetite even improved, but ascites and cedema increased, and she passed away in six weeks, having suffered no pain, from the commencement of the treatment. 3. Advanced carcinoma of the uterus and sepsis. The fetor was intense. Both trypsin and sodium oleate injec- tions were commenced and pushed, chiefly with a view to palliating the fetor and pain. Death took place a month later, and though the fetor was in no way mitigated, her medical man kindly informed me, ' the freedom from pain after using your treatment was most wonderful.' 4. Advanced diabetes with carcinoma of bowel. Female. The diabetes was of long duration, and a strict diet had been followed. Within the last three months some masses have been found on deep palpation in the left iliac region and in the right abdomen, pronounced to be carcinomatous. Enemata have not removed them, and scybala are not probable. The internal administra- tion of trypsin was suggested, but with what result I have not so far heard. 5. Recurrent carcinoma of base of mouth and sub- lingual region. Male; aged seventy-three. Primary operation twelve months ago. Recurrence six months later. Violet treatment for some months had apparently checked pain and growth. Trypsin and ox-gall treatment added. The reports of this case have not been satisfac- tory. The difficulties in swallowing and of nourishment in these cases is well known. Capsules and pills of ox- gall are impossible, and moreover it is a difficult place for the injections to be carried out with any prospect of reaching the site of disease. The same difficultyun way of nourishment has been witnessed in another case. It 78 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER is almost impossible to treat these cases satisfactorily except in hospital or a nursing home. 6. In February, 1905, the late Dr. E. Blake came to see me with a view to commencing trypsin injections in a case of recurrent carcinoma of the breast under his care (the third case in which this treatment was commenced). Recently, to my great interest and surprise, a letter was put into my hands from this patient to another patient, kindly recommended to me by Dr. A. J. Chalmers (Colombo, Ceylon) and Dr. Arthur Giles, in which it is stated: ' The treatment that I have tried, and am still undergoing, has so far prevented the cancer increasing, but it has not diminished, though the pain is much less, and I am certainly better in general health than I was before I began it. It consists of hypodermic injections of a solution of trypsin; these I have now twice a week. My London doctor saw an account in the Lancet, of February 11, 1905, and he considered it the most hopeful thing he had read, and wanted me to try it, and I com- menced doing so the same month, with the result I give you. Unfortunately, my London doctor died last July. I know that there are several doctors using this remedy, and I believe with success. I should certainly advise your friend to try it. I have often said to my doctor that I wish it could be more known. I hope this may be of some use to your friend. I am so glad if my case will in any way help another sufferer.' Dr. Chalmers, who was at home at the time, was good enough to express to me his interest in the question, more especially in view of his own work on ' Pancreatitis in Ceylon,' and on ' The Incidence of Cancer in Ceylon.' As a former resident at the Cancer Hospital he was able to corroborate the incidence of excessive salt taking in cases of carcinoma, and borne out in the case he kindly recommended to me. CASES AND COMMENTS 79 Case IX.-Carcinoma of rectum. Male. In Septem- ber, 1905, abdominal section was performed, and the condition found to be inoperable. January 9, 1906: The motions are difficult and flattened, and he is losing flesh. No history of diabetes in the family was ascer- tainable. For many years he has avoided sugar in order to prevent a tendency to stoutness. His weight now is 10 stone i2| pounds. A sugar and carbohydrate diet was recommended, and the administration of trypsin and ox-gall commenced. February 14: Weight, 11 stone 2 pounds. Formed and bulky motions are passed at times, and no pain is complained of. The local and general improvement so far is fully and independently confirmed. March 14: Weight, n stone 8| pounds. Condition excellent. I am indebted to Mr. Aslett Baldwin, F.R.C.S., for the following and, so far, encouraging notes of a case of carcinoma of the rectum, under his care in the West London Hospital. Case X.-'Male, aged sixty. First noticed "diarrhoea" with discharge of mucus on July 1, 1905. Had no pain, but has been getting weaker in himself, and has a weak- ness at the bottom of his back, and has lately been subject to fainting attacks. Bowels moved eight to ten times in the twenty-four hours; what is passed is entirely liquid and contains mucus and blood. Admitted into the West London Hospital February 1, 1906. Condition on admission : There is a fixed ulcerated crateriform growth in the anterior wall of the rectum, about the size of a five-shilling piece; no obstruction. February 6: Weight, 10 stone 2J pounds. On this date, trypsin treatment commenced; 15 minims of the 2 per cent, solution were injected into the arm on alternate days for the first day or two; then into the buttock region. February 12: Daily injections of 20 minims into the buttock ; on two 80 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER occasions 30 minims were injected. Drachm doses of liq. trypsin were given by the mouth t.d.s. before meals up to February 22 ; then drachms, and on February 25 2 drachms t.d.s. He also has a drachm of the rectal solution without glycerine by the rectum twice daily, while he takes 5 grains of purified ox-gall in capsule twice a day after meals. February 27: The bowels act two to four times in the twenty-four hours ; a little mucus and blood occasionally; the motions are more formed. The growth in the rectum feels softer to the examining finger. The patient feels very much better in himself, and has not had any fainting fits since being in the hospital. His weight on February 26 was n stone, a gain of n| pounds since February 6. March 16: I do not think I have anything to add; he had lost some weight, but he seems now to be gaining it again.' Dr. J. Beard has recently reported the action of trypsin upon the living cells of Jensen's mouse-tumour.1 The following is a preliminary note on the action of trypsin upon the living cells of recurrent carcinoma of the breast. Case XI.-Recurrent carcinoma of the breast. On February 7, 1906, Dr. G. Fraisse (Paris) kindly brought this patient. In December, 1904, the breast and axillary glands were removed by Halsted's method. Recurrence six months later, and removed. Two months ago re- currence. It was agreed to commence treatment by trypsin, to then remove the nodules and enlarged axillary glands, and to subsequently continue treatment in the hope of preventing recurrence. On February 19 Dr. Fraisse wrote to me that after eight injections (exclusive 1 * Are the Problems of Cancer Insoluble ?' the Medical Press and Circular, December 20, 1905 ; ' The Action of Trypsin upon the Living Cells of Jensen's Mouse-Tumour,' the British Medical Journal, January 20, 1906, by J. Beard, D.Sc. ACTION OF TRYPSIN ON LIVING CELLS 81 of two previously-ten in all) he had successfully removed a large quantity of diseased tissues, the operation proving long and difficult. ' Already at the sixth injection the nodules appeared to be diminished and retracted. At the operation I observed a very curious phenomenon, of which you cite an analogous case in your book. The nodules and indurated plaques in the neighbourhood of the first two injections were hard, retracted, and presented a blackish exterior. The interior had fallen in and was transformed into a milky liquid, like phlegmonic pus. This transformation had taken place without febrile reaction. This process is very interesting to observe. It is due doubtless to thrombosis of the vessels which were nourishing the neoplastic tissues. Perhaps that is the mode of action of trypsin-an elective action over the diseased tissues-for all round the fibres of the small pectoral muscle appeared absolutely untouched. This purulent aseptic condition of the doubtful tissues gives me great hope, and consequently I shall be inclined to recommence the injections as soon as the state of the wound will permit. Since trypsin has no injurious effect on the organism, it is good to impregnate all the parts as a preventive.' It is gratifying to note this independent testimony in favour of local degeneration of cancerous tissues in the living subject following trypsin injections. While simple atrophy may be a result in small nodules when directly injected, and which I have witnessed myself, Dr. Fraisse's observation in respect to fluid degeneration is of impor- tance. I have witnessed the same in a large recurrent mass of post-cervical glands, in a case at present under my care, and apparently the result of injections in the immediate neighbourhood of the growth. In this case there has been no febrile reaction. The fluid is thin and 82 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER yellow. In two other cases it has been reported to me that the growth has become tense with sense of fluctuation. Discharge also from ulcerated surfaces seems to increase with the apparent softening up of the tissues. Local atrophy and degeneration, however, are far from the successful treatment of the general conditions under- lying the manifestation, and in a large number of cases the growth itself is inaccessible to local injections. It is interesting to note that Dr. R. Odier1 (Geneva) has recently and independently suggested the treatment of malignant tumours and of diabetes by injections of a mixture of the extracts of the pancreas, liver, and muscle. ' In the case of animals afflicted with tumours,' he affirms that ' injections of the mixture in question act on the neoplasm itself by attacking the glycogen accumulated there. . . . The consequence is a rapid arrest of cell division, so that the tumour seems to become simply an inactive foreign body. Histological examinations of sarcomata, carcinomata, and of adenomata, made after treatment, have shown that the tumours were deprived of glycogen.' 1 ' Le Traitement des Tumeurs malignes et des Tumeurs en voie de Developpement par 1'Injection de Ferment Glycolytique,' La Semaine Medicale, February 28, 1906. CHAPTER VI SUMMARY It is well to bear in mind that the results attributable to any treatment may in reality depend upon other influences. Amongst these maybe mentioned: (1) That cancer does not always progress evenly, but by periods of activity as well as of quiescence. (2) That age has a very con- siderable influence. This was pointed out long ago by Dr. George G. Sigmond in the following words: ' Car- cinomata will run with much greater quickness through their sad career in a female at the age of forty-five than they will when they attack a woman who is sixty years of age; they will at that or at a later period of life remain for years stationary without any advance, con- tinuing perfectly stationary to the last hour.'1 His con- clusions are still in accord with the experience of the present day. (3) That any change of treatment and surroundings may be followed by a temporary improve- ment in the disease. (4) Occasionally cancer has been known to undergo spontaneous cure. While, however, freely admitting all the above-recognised data, neverthe- less, I am satisfied that my results are directly due to the influence of treatment. Let me now discuss more fully the remedies seriatim. 1 ' Lectures on Materia Medica and Therapeutics,' by George G. Sigmond, M.D., the Lancet, July 29, 1837. 83 84 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER Chian Turpentine.-In my own experience so far the effects observed are (a) marked diminution and apparent arrest of growth ; (b) alleviation of pain, arrest of fetor, and removal of pressure symptoms, followed by some restoration to normal nutrition as evidenced in the improvement in the general health of the patient; (c) subsidence of the inflammatory symptoms, especially indicating its initial use in epithelioma, sarcoma, and in cases in which pain or inflammation are actively manifest. Soap and Ox-gall.-The results obtained here are (a) apparent arrest of growth, (b) relief of pain, and (c) arrest of fetor, notably in recurrent breast cancer after operation. Only recently, amongst other cases, Mr. Webb kindly forwarded me particulars of a large and extensive cancerous ulceration in the axilla, in which not only was shrinkage taking place, but all fetor had gone under his method of treatment. It is not improbable the liver may be primarily at fault in many cases. I have the greatest pleasure in adding a note to Case VI. (p. 27), received at the last moment whilst final proofs of these pages were going to press : Mr. Webb reports this patient at the present time to be ' wonderfully well, and no recurrence, now nearly four years. In her case the disease was very far advanced when she came to me.' He encloses a letter from Dr. Helen Sexton, Hon. Outdoor Surgeon, Women's Hospital, Mel- bourne, who performed the primary operation, and who fully confirms the result; that the growth was examined at the time by Dr. Bull, of the Melbourne University; that it proved to be scirrhus, and recurrence took place some weeks later. She not only expresses her delight at the success of Mr. Webb's treatment, but considers it is a result which he should report. SUMMARY 85 Trypsin.-From my experience so far of this remedy alone or with ox-gall, the results have been most encouraging : (a) Shrinkage and apparent arrest of growth; (b) alleviation of pain and pressure symptoms; (c) changes in the growth pointing to diminution of infiltration and induration ; (d) unequivocal improvement in general nutrition in which the appetite returns, bodily weight is maintained, and increases. To my mind these facts are most significant, and can only point to the direct efficacy of the treatment. Continued reflection on this subject impels the belief that in dealing with cancer something more than purely local treatment is indicated-that is to say, that after the surgeon has removed the source of local irritation represented by the primary growth, treatment should then be directed to the systemic origin of the disease. Were the lines of treatment I have indicated to be carried out subsequently to operation, it is reasonable to hope that recurrence might not so frequently occur. This opinion has been based on the experience gained in the treatment of cases of cancer in which the disease has passed beyond the sphere of surgical inter- ference. If palliative results can be obtained in such unfavourable cases as these, it is only reasonable to conclude that where the conditions are favourable the results should be eminently more satisfactory, and the tendency to recurrence diminished. Conversely, it is reasonable to hope that with improved nutrition and strength, cases regarded as inoperable may come within the reach of additional surgical relief; and that possibly in the future, operations on the stomach and intestines may be undertaken, not solely with a view to prolonging life for a short time, but with a view to prolonged or permanent improvement. 86 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER Cases which are practically hopeless or gravely com- plicated cannot be regarded as affording a fair test of any method of treatment. It is nevertheless encouraging to note that even in such cases as these much can be done by the above methods of treatment in bringing relief to hapless patients, both physically and mentally, without having to resort to morphia or other sedative remedies with which so many disadvantages are associated. The treatment set forth above must necessarily be of a prolonged nature, and in the adoption of it attention to detail is an absolute necessity. Unless this be the case, disappointment and failure are almost certain to be the result. One small detail which may appear to be of a trivial nature is, nevertheless, one of extreme impor- tance-viz., the method of administering the injections. Unless this be done properly, extreme discomfort and inconvenience are caused to the patient, both of which are avoidable. Furthermore, the internal and general treatment seem to me to be of as much importance as the local, and extreme nicety is demanded in the selection and preparation of the pancreatic and intestinal extracts as well as of the ox-gall. I have already referred (p. 58) to the facts that cancer of the stomach stops abruptly at the pylorus ; that the small intestine is but rarely the site of cancer ; and that cancer of the large intestine and rectum for the most part increases in frequency the further the distance from the duodenum;1 to which may be added the slower rate 1 Captain Carroll quotes Riemann's collection of statistics (Prussian Hospitals, 1895-1896): ' He found 20,544 cases of cancer, in 10,537 of which the alimentary canal was involved as follows- Tongue, 269 times; mouth and throat, 192; oesophagus, 1,011 ; stomach, 4,288 ; intestines, 1,706. The small intestine was in- volved 20 times; the large intestine, 224; the rectum, 1,204; while in 255 cases the portion of intestine involved was not given. The cancer involved the liver and gall bladder 979 times, and the SUMMARY 87 of growth of cancer which obtains in the large intestine. While E. von Bergmann attributes the sharp delimitation of carcinomata in the region of the pylorus to the fact that the lymphatic systems of the stomach and duodenum only anastomose to a very limited extent; and others suggest the irritation of food in the stomach, or of faecal matter in the large intestine ; on the other hand, the natural and comparative immunity of the duodenum and small intestine would appear to support the treatment of inoperable cancer by the proteolytic and glycolitic ferments of the intestinal glands or pancreas and bile-salts. Nothing more remains for me than to leave the issue of these methods of treatment still further in the hands of the profession. Whatever their precise value or limitations may prove to be, already clinical and inde- pendent results have demonstrated the fact that alone or combined they have a direct and beneficial action on cancer. pancreas 92. Cancer of the large intestine, exclusive of the rectum, occurs most frequently in the sigmoid flexure, then in the caecum, and then in the hepatic and splenic flexures and other portions of the colon.' INDEX A Abram, J. H., on treatment of diabetes, 64 Acetone, solvent of cholesterin, 41 Acetonuria, 41 Acid, absence in gastric contents, 56 inhibition of intestinal glands, 57 pancreas, 57 ferment in blastoderm, 44 Adrenalin, glycosuria, 64 Age incidence, intestinal glands, 62 pancreas, 62 reversion to embryonic distribution of glycogen, 62 proliferation of cells, 62 Albumin (cancer), 49 Ashwell, S., on iodine treatment of uterine fibroid, 2 B Backer, De, on reduction of glycogen, 46 on yeast treatment in cancer, 46 phthisis, 46 Bacterial diseases, use of trypsin, proteolytic ferments, 64 Baldwin, A., on rectal carcinoma (case), 79 Beard, J,, on action of trypsin on living cells, Jensen's mouse- tumour, 80 alkaline ferment of pancreas, 49 'critical period,' nutritional changes, 48 cycle of development, 48 embryological researches, 48 germ cells, 48 nature of cancer, 48 pancreatic (trypsin) treatment, 49 • trophoblast,' 48 degeneration, 49 pre-embryonic, 48 Beatson, G. T., on nature of cells, 47 on oophorectomy, 18 Bellamy, H. F., on spleen, as aid to trypsin, 57 Beneke, F. W., on cholesterin, lecithin, diet, 38 88 INDEX 89 Bergell, on digestion of cancer cell by pancreatin, 50 Bergmann, E. von, on carcinoma of stomach, 58, 87 Bernard, C., on ferment action, 52 on glycogen, 44 Blake, E., on carcinoma of breast (case), 78 Blastoderm, glycogen, ferment, cell proliferation, 44, 52 Blumenthal, F., on biological change in epithelial cell, 49 on cancer albumin and ferment, 49 on chemistry of cancer, 49 on digestion of cancer cell by pancreatin, 50 Boas, J., on carcinoma and diabetes, 41 Brault, on excess of glycogen, rapidity of cell growth, 45, 46 Breast. See Mammary gland Brunton, L., Sir, on glycolitic ferments, 64 on treatment of diabetes, 64 Bull, on carcinoma of breast (cure), pathology, 84 Burgess, T., on preparation of purified ox-gall, 59 C Cancer, age incidence, 61, 62 albumin, 49 cure, spontaneous, 59, 61 treatment, 29, 34, 72, 73, 84 diet, 38, 59, 60 ferment, 49 nature of cells, 46 chemical, 49 cytology, 47 embryonic (somatic), 22, 39, 43, 46, 47, 49 germ, 48 glycogenic, 43, 45, 52, 82 non-parasitic, 47 ' parasitic,' 39 pre-embryonic, ' trophoblastic,' 48 reproductive qualities, 46 stimuli to growth (local, systemic), 43, 48 inhibition of control, 39,61 irritation, 39, 43, 48 nutritional, 43, 44, 46, 47 relation to diabetes, 40 alternation, 40, 41, 42, 43 antagonism, 40, 41, 43 simultaneous occurrence, 41 substitution, 43 intestinal glands, ferments, inhibition, 58 kidney, diuresis, 34 liver, cholesterin, gall-stones, glycogen, 22, 39,43 pancreas, defect in ferments, inhibition, 43, 61 spleen, 57 suprarenals, 64 venereal disease, 65 90 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER Cancer treatment. See Treatment Carbohydrate diet, 39 Carroll, F. F., on carcinoma of stomach and intestines, 58, 86 on immunity of small intestine, 58, 86 Cells. See Cancer, nature of Chalmers, A. J., on incidence of cancer, 78 on pancreatitis, 78 on salt, in diet, 78 Chemical nature of cells, 49 Chian turpentine, action of, 11 leucocytosis, 11 removal of inflammation, 8, 9, n treatment, hypodermic injections, 3, 5, 84 dosage, 7 technique, 6 per mouth, emulsion, 5, 6 use in pelvic, uterine, inflammation, 12 tuberculosis, 12 Cholesterin, cause of fetor, 23 crystallization, change in liver secretion, 22, 23 local, 22 gall-stones, 39 irritation by, 39, 43 nature of cells, 22, 46 uncontrolled proliferation, 39 solvents, 40 Chromosomes, 47 Clay, A., on chian turpentine, 5, 6 Clay, Professor (the late), on chian turpentine, 5 Clay (Manchester), on ox-gall treatment, 37 Cohnheim on erepsin (intestinal), 57 on nature of cells, embryonic, 46 Cooper, Astley, systemic, local origin, 39 * Critical period.' See Beard, T. Crofton, A. C., on glycogenic function of suprarenals, 64 on nature of glycolitic ferment in diabetes, 63 Cure, spontaneous, 59, 61 treatment, 29, 34, 72, 73, 84 Cycle of development, 48 life, 61 Cytology, 47 D Development, age incidence, 48, 63 Diabetes, age incidence, 62 relation to cancer, 40 alternation, 40, 41, 42, 43 antagonism, 40, 41, 43 simultaneous occurrence, 41 substitution, 43 intestinal glands, ferments, 58 liver, 43 INDEX 91 Diabetes, relation to pancreas, defect in ferment, 43 nature of ferment, 63 treatment, preparations of intestinal glands, 58, 64 enterokinase, 64 erepsin, 64 secretin, 64 pancreas, 63, 64, 82 erepsin, 63 trypsin, 63 Diet, carbohydrate, 39 notes, 39, 59 salt, 60 sugar, 39, 59 Diuresis in apparent cure, 34 E Enterokinase, 57 preparations, 56 treatment in cancer, 56 diabetes, 64 Enzymes. See Ferments Epithelioma (cases), of auricle, 72 neck, 7 nose, 28 tongue,14 treatment by chian turpentine, 6, 7 by sodium oleate (soap), ox-gall, 13, 28 by trypsin, pancreatic preparations, 71 Erepsin, intestinal, 57 pancreatic, 58 plant and vegetable, 53 preparations, 56, 58 presence (universal), in all classes of animals, 57 animal tissues, 57 treatment in cancer, 56 diabetes, 64 F Farmer, J. B., Moore, J. E. S,, Walker, C. E. : on cell division, 47 on change in somatic cells, 48 on chromosomes, 47 on mitoses, 47 on stimulus, 48 Fats, neutral, solvents of cholesterin, 40 Ferments or enzymes, acid, 49, 53, 62 alkaline, 49 intestinal, 56, 58 inverting, 44 pancreatic, diastatic, glycolitic, proteolytic, 5i. 52 92 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER Ferments or enzymes, peptic, 62 peptone-splitting, 57, 58 peptonizing, 62 plant and vegetable, 53 proteolytic or glycolitic, 43, 44, 51, 52, 58 Fetor, removal of, 3, 8, 15, 22, 23, 31, 37, 38, 84 Foster, Michael, Sir, on glycogen, excess in embryonic tissues, 44 local cell metabolism, mammary gland, 45 nutrition, placenta, 45 pancreatic ferment action, 52 phases of life, age incidence, 61 reversion to glycogenic tissue, 45 Fraisse, G., on action of trypsin on living cells (case), 89 G Gall. See Ox-gall Gall-stones and cancer, 39 Gamble, F. W., on action of ferments on glycogen, 51 trypsin on glucose, 51 glycogen, 51 starch, 52 on ox-gall, aid to trypsin, 51 on preparations (hypodermic, trypsin), 55 Germ cells. See Beard, J. Glands, enlarged, disappearance under treatment, 16, 18, 23 Glucose, action of trypsin, 51 diminished consumption in diabetes, 43 Glycogen, action of ferments, 44, 51. trypsin (solvent), 44, 51 yeast, 46, 54 diminution in blood, 45 excess of, in blastoderm, embryonic tissues, 44, 52 in new growths, cancer, 45 local formation, 43 nitrogenous starch, 52 non-conversion in cancer, 43 nutritional in cancer, 46 in cell growth, 44, 45 in embryo, 44 in placental structures, 45 plant, vegetable, 53 proteid origin, 59 relation to diabetes, 43 to liver, 43 to pancreas, 43 reversion to embryonic distribution, age incidence, 44,62 Glycolitic or proteolytic ferments, defect in cancer, 43, 44, 51, 58 diabetes, 43 old age, 62 young, 63 INDEX 93 Glycolitic or proteolytic ferments, inhibition, 57, 61 insufficient in transplanted growth, 63 nature of, 57, 58, 63 of intestinal glands, 58 pancreas, 43, 44, 51, 58 sera, 53, 74 Glycosuria, artificial production, 40, 63 • Gum, animal.' See Ox-gall H Harper, G., on sequence of diabetes and cancer (case), 41 Hartog, M., on ferment and saccharoid substance in blastoderm of hen's egg, 44, 62 Hawthorne, C. O., on case of cancer following diabetes, 41 Heberden on pain and joint trouble simulating rheumatism, 19 Herter, C. A., on carbohydrate diet, 59 on glycolitic ferment of pancreas, 63 Herzen on spleen as aid to trypsin, 57 Hiemann, on carcinoma of alimentary canal (statistics), 58, 86 Higgs, A. W., on case of recurrent breast cancer, sodium oleate (soap) injections, and ox-gall, 17 Horne, H., on preparation of purified ox-gall, 58 Hypodermic medication. See Injections I Ice, local anaesthesia, 7 Immunity, natural and comparative (small intestine), 58, 87 Inhibition, acid gastric contents, 57 mental influences, 61 nerve influences, 61 of intestinal glands, 57, 61 pancreas, 57, 61 Injections, hypodermic, in general, 1 in inoperable cancer, 3 intramuscular, arsenic and iron, 2 cacodylate, 1, 12 mercury, 2 subcutaneous, chian turpentine, dosage, technique, 6, 7 eucaine, 21 iodipin, 1, 2, 12, 19 sodium oleate (soap), dosage, technique, 13, 20 spermin, 3 strychnine, 3 trypsin, dosage, technique, 55 Intestinal glands, age incidence, decay, 61 ferments, defect in cancer, 58, 62, 64 diabetes, 58, 62, 64 old age, 62 94 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER Intestinal glands, ferments, defect in young, 63 glycolitic or proteolytic, 58 inhibition, 57, 61 insufficient in transplanted growth, 63 preparations, 56, 58 relation to cancer, 58 to diabetes, 58 to glycogen, 58 treatment in cancer, 58 diabetes, 64 Iodide of potassium in treatment of uterine fibroid and menor- rhagia, 1 Iodine in treatment of uterine fibroid and menorrhagia, 2 lodipin injections, substitute, 10 in treatment of enlarged prostate, 19 of tuberculosis, 12 of uterine fibroid, 1, 2 J Joints, pain of, simulating rheumatism, 19 septic, 19 K Kidney, diuresis in apparent cure (case), 34 L Labium pudendi (case), 38 Lancereaux, E., venereal and pancreatic disease, 65 Langton, J., on case of diabetes following cancer, 40 Lecithin, 38 Lepine on defect of glycolitic ferment in diabetes, 63 Leucocytosis under chian turpentine treatment, 11 under yeast, 46 Ligertwood, Colonel T., on injections of chian turpentine, 3, 7 of sodium oleate (soap), 3, 14, 16 on trypsin in cancer, diabetes, 64, 69, 70 Lint, De, on diabetes and cancer, 41 Liver (cases), 18, 33, 76 relation to cancer, cholesterin, gall-stones, 23, 39 glycogen, 43 to diabetes, glycogen, 43 M McDonnell, on nitrogenous starch (glycogen), 52 Macilwain, on spontaneous cure, diet, 59 MacKiddie, J. F., on case of apparent cure, pathology, 35 McNab, M., on cases treated by sodium oleate, ox-gall, 37 INDEX 95 Mammary gland, cancer (cases), 16, 25, 26, 27, 29, 31, 33,37, 66, 78, 80, 84 oophorectomy, 18 local cell metabolism, 45 Manders, H., on ferment treatment of cancer and tuberculosis, 46 Menstruation, influence on growth, 18 Mental, nerve, influences, inhibition of pancreas, and intestinal glands, 61 Minchin, W., on carcinoma of stomach (case), 73 Mitoses. See Farmer, Moore, and Walker Monsarrat, Keith, W., on excess of glycogen, 46 Moore, B., on the absence or marked diminution of free hydro- chloric acid in gastric contents, 56, 63 Moore, J. E. S. See Farmer, Moore, and Walker N Nattress, Colonel W., on carcinoma of rectum (case), 74 Nature of cancer cells, embryonic (somatic), 22, 39, 43, 46, 47, 49 germ, 48 pre-embryonic, trophoblastic, 48 stimuli to cell growth. See Cancer of ferment, glycolitic, proteolytic, in cancer, 43, 44, 51, 52, 58, 63 in diabetes, 58 Nittis, J. de, on glycogen, diminution in blood, 45 excess of, in new growths, 52 Nutrition, glycogen, in cancer, local, systemic, 44, 45, 46, 47 in cell growth, 44, 45 in embryo, 44 in placental structures, 45 improved. See Cases, summary, 85 O Odier, on glycogenic nature of cancer and glycolitic ferment treat- ment, action on living cells, 82 CEdema, removal of, under treatment, 10, 27, 30, 31 O'Hara, H., on case of recurrent cancer of breast, sodium oleate (soap) injections, and ox-gall (cure), 33 Oil, olive, solvent of cholesterin, 40 turpentine, solvent of cholesterin, 40 Oliver, J., on cancer and diabetes (alternation), 42 Oophorectomy in cancer of the breast, 18 Osler, W., on acetonuria in cancer, 40 Ox-gall, purified, ' animal gum,' 21 aid to trypsin ferment, 51 preparation, 21, 58, 59 selection, 58 solvent of cholesterin, 39 treatment with, 20, 21, 24 96 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER p Pain, removal of, 3, 8, 15, 22, 37, 38, 67, 75, 77, 84, 85 Pancreas, age incidence, decay, 61 ferments, defect in cancer, 43 in diabetes, 43 in old age, 62 Pancreas, ferments, defect in young, 63 glycolitic or proteolytic, 58 inhibition, 57, 61 insufficient in transplanted growth, 63 nature of (trypsin, erepsin), 44, 51, 52, 58, 63 solvent of glycogen, 44 preparations, 55, 56, 58 relation to cancer, 45 to diabetes, 45 to glycogen, 43 treatment by hypodermic injections (trypsin), 55 by local applications, 56 by mouth, 56 Pancreatin, solvent of cancer cell, 43, 50 Parasitic theory. See Cancer, nature of cells Pawlow, J. P., on succus entericus, aid to pancreatic ferment (nerve reflex), 57 Peptone-splitting ferments, 57, 58 Peptonizing ferment (acid), 62 Petry on cancer albumin and ferment, 49 Pfeffer, W., on plant, vegetable, glycogen, ferments, trypsin, yeast, 53< 54 Phthisis, treatment, cacodylate injections, 12 chian turpentine, 12 ferments, trypsin, 65 yeast, 46 iodipin, 12 Prevention, diet, salt, 60 sugar, 59 of recurrence after primary operation, 85 Prostate, treatment of enlarged, by iodipin injections, 19 Proteolytic ferments. See Glycolitic R Rectum, cases of, 18, 68, 74, 76, 79 Rheumatism, simulation of pain in cancer, 19 Rodent ulcer, cases: of forehead, 35 of inner canthus, 36 treatment by sodium oleate (soap) injections, 22 Rudyard, H. A., on carcinoma of rectum (case), 68 INDEX 97 s Saccharoid substance in blastoderm, 44, 62 Salt in diet, 60 Sarcoma, cases : abdominal, 9 superior maxilla, 69 treatment, chian turpentine, 9 ox-gall, soap, trypsin, 69 Secretin action, aid to pancreatic secretion, and treatment, 56,57, 64 Sera, ferments, proteolytic, 53, 64 Sexton, H., on scirrhus of breast (case), cure, 84 Shaw, J., on iodipin, other injections, 1, 2 Sigmond, G., on hemlock, 19 on pain of joints simulating rheumatism, 19 on rapidity of growth, 83 Sodium oleate (soap), hypodermic injection, 3, 13, 20, 84 local application, 22, 36 solvent of cholesterin, 40 Starch, action of trypsin, 52 nitrogenous (glycogen), 52 vegetable, 51, 52 Starling, E. H., on secretin, direct action on pancreas, 57 Stomach (cases), 72, 73 Sugar in diet, 39, 59 Superior maxilla (case). See Sarcoma Suprarenals, glycogen, 64 Syringes, 6, 21 T Thyroid extract, 25 Treatment, cancer, artificial production of glycosuria, 40, 59, 63 association with primary operation, 85 chian turpentine, emulsion, 5, 6 hypodermic injection, 6, 7 combined, 87 enterokinase, 56 erepsin, 56, 58 hopeful aspect, 87 intestinal glands, preparations, 56, 58 ox-gall, 20, 37 pancreatic preparations, internally, 56 local, 56 prolonged nature, 86 y secretin, 56, 57 sodium oleate (soap), hypodermic injection, 13,20 local application, 22, 36 trypsin, hypodermic injections, 54, 55 internally, 55, 56 yeast, 46 diabetes, 64 98 THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER Treatment, phthisis (tuberculosis), chian turpentine, 12 ferments, trypsin, 64 yeast, 46 iodipin, 12 ' Trophoblast.' See Beard, J. Trypsin, action on glucose, 51 on glycogen (solvent), 43, 50, 51 on living cells, carcinoma breast, 80 Jensen mouse-tumour, 80 on starch, 52 aids, 51, 56, 64 Trypsin (cases) auricle, 72 breast (recurrent), 66, 78, 80 liver, 76 mouth, glands, 71, 77, 81 rectum, 68 ,74, 75, 76, 79 stomach, 72, 73 sublingual region, 77 superior maxilla, 69 uterus, 77 glycolitic, proteolytic ferments of pancreas, 43, 44, 51, 58 defect in cancer, 43 in diabetes, 43 in old age, 62 in young, 63 inhibition, 57 insufficient in transplanted growth, 63 indication in bacterial diseases, 64 in cancer, 44, 51 in diabetes, 64 in venereal disease, 65 plant, vegetable, 53 proteolytic ferment. See Glycolitic treatment, hypodermic injection, 54, 55, 85 internally, 56 local, 56 Tuberculosis, treatment, cacodylate injections, 12 chian turpentine, 12 ferments, trypsin, 64 yeast, 46 iodipin, 12 Tyson, J , on adrenalin injections, 64 on glycolitic ferment of pancreas, 63 on injections (in animals), pancreatic extract, intra- peritoneal and subcutaneous, 63 U Uterus (case), 77 V Venereal disease, relation to pancreas and cancer, 65 Vernon, H. M., on erepsin, 57 INDEX 99 Vernon, H. M., on erepsin, intestinal, 57, 58 pancreatic, 58 plant, vegetable, 53 presence (universal) in all classes of animals, 57 presence (universal) in animal tissues, 57 peptone-splitting ferments (erepsin, trypsin), 57 preparations, 58 Vines, on plant, vegetable ferments, 53 W Walker. C. E. See Farmer, Moore, and Walker Watts, H., on glycogen (nitrogenous starch), 44, 52 ferment action, 52 yeast action, 52 Webb, J. H., cases, results, 25-36, 84 on cholesterin, crystallization, 22 change in liver secre- tion, 23 local, 22 on method of treatment by ox-gall, 20, 36, 84 by sodium oleate (soap) in- jections, 20, 21, 36, 84 on nature of cancer and cells, 22 on removal of pain and fetor, 22 on uncontrolled cell proliferation, 39 Williams, Roger W., oh diabetes and cancer, 41 on nature of cancer cells, 46 on nutritional stimuli, local, 47 systemic, 47 on reversion to embryonic cell activity, 47 reproductive properties, 47 Y Yeast, ferment in, 54 leucocytosis, phagocytosis, 46 reduction of glycogen, 46, 54 treatment of tubercle and cancer, 46 Yeo, Burney, I., on cholesterin, lecithin, diet in cancer, 39 THE END Bail Here, Tindall Cox, 8, Henrietta Street, Covent Garden. Ipress Comments on tbe jfirstOition SOME METHODS OF HYPODERMIC MEDICATION IN THE TREATMENT OF INOPERABLE CANCER By JOHN A. SHAW-MACKENZIE, M.D. (Lond.). ' Any method which holds out a possibility of relief to a hapless patient suffering from inoperable malignant disease is worthy of a trial, and in this brochure the author is able to point to some remarkable cases in which improvement has followed the use of certain drugs by means of hypodermic injections. .. . Herein, then, is a substantial reason for others following the lines laid down in this brochure, giving the methods of treatment described a full trial, at least in the interests of those patients whose pitiable state while suffering from inoperable malignant disease demands that everything should be done which holds out a prospect of relief, however small.'-The West London Medical Journal. 'In all, the results appear to have been remarkably good, and if such methods of treatment can be relied upon to produce results at all approaching those here recorded, then inoperable malignant disease can be shorn of most of its horrors. The results, indeed, were apparently so superior to those obtained by any methods of which we have had personal experience that we can hardly credit them. We think, however, that the author justifies us in making a trial of these methods of treatment.'-The British Medico-Chirurgical Journal. 'These methods are evidently worthy of more extended trial, and with a view of helping to shed further light upon this dark continent of medical science, those who have suitable cases under their care would do well to read Dr. Shaw-Mackenzie's admirably expressed and most suggestive little pamphlet.'-The Journal of Balneology and Climatology'. ' When we are brought face to face with a case of inoperable cancer, whether primary or recurrent, after operation, it is surely justifiable to use any system of treatment which has been successful 2 in the hands of some observers in relieving pain and other serious discomforts, even though it does not effect a cure. We think Dr. Shaw-Mackenzie has done good service in publishing the results of his experience, not with a view of posing as a cancer curer, but that in view of the urgency of inoperable cancer, no time may be lost in enabling others to put the treatment to a test.'- The Australasian Medical Gazette (the Journal of the Australasian branches of the British Medical Association). ' The condition of patients suffering from inoperable cancer is so pitiable that any method of treatment which holds out the slightest prospect of relief is worth trying. Dr. Shaw-Mackenzie has tried hypodermic injections of sodium oleate and of chian turpentine in cases of carcinoma of the tongue, of the breast, etc., combined, when soap solution was used, with ox-gall internally ; his results described in the first part of the pamphlet were encouraging. Mr. J. H. Webb, of Melbourne, was the first to recommend sodium oleate hypodermically, and the second part of the pamphlet consists of extracts from a correspondence with Dr. Shaw-Mackenzie ... a number of his cases are detailed.'-The Indian Medical Gazette. ' The little booklet is worthy of very careful study, as it gives the record of several encouraging cases.'-The Canada Lancet. ' The chemico-biological theory of the etiology of cancer is one which all who are interested in this fell disease will do well to follow up. Indeed, it may not be long before some startling developments will be evolved in this regard, judging from the scientific hold which the theory is beginning to acquire. The whole matter simply teems with interest; it offers an entirely new field of investigation and research in the endeavour to elucidate what cancer is, and in view of the lamentable failure of the parasitic theory of the disease, one can only hope that in this new field of research tangible results will be obtained which will go far towards robbing cancer of its horrors. That there is, at least, a reasonable hope of the possibility of this is proved by the results recorded by the author in this pamphlet. . . . We have read this pamphlet with much interest, and can therefore cordially recommend its perusal, more particularly by reason of the important issues which it opens out, as well as upon the ground that it deals with facts which should be known to the profession generally.'-The Medical Press and Circular. Ipress Comments on tbe Second Ottion THE NATURE AND TREATMENT OF CANCER (Some Methods of Hypodermic Medication in the Treatment of Inoperable Cancer). By JOHN A. SHAW-MACKENZIE, M.D. (Lond.) ' We confidently recommend this book to all practitioners having such cases under their charge.'-The Journal of Preventive Medicine. 'A study of the question such as this lucid and altogether scientific work presents is one which should commend itself to every medical practitioner.-The Journal of Balneology and Climatology. ' So greatly have we been impressed by the perusal of this work that we can only recommend every practitioner to study it carefully and with open mind-inasmuch as we regard it as one of the most important contributions to the literature of the subject with which it deals which so far has been issued from the press.'-The Medical Press and Circular. ' Dr. Shaw-Mackenzie states his arguments and conclusions temperately and modestly, and the results of the experiments reported by Dr. Beard at p. 55 afford, so far as they go, confirmation of the theory that trypsin has a striking disintegrating action on cancer.'-The British Medical Journal. ' This is a little book of eighty pages, and is dedicated to Colonel T. Ligertwood, C.B., who is well known to at least two generations of our brother officers. He seems to have helped greatly in the work on which this booklet is based. . . . By various methods the author has tried repeatedly-and often successfully-to improve the condition, during their last days, of those unfortunates suffering from inoperable cancer ; nay, he seems even in some few cases to have produced what may turn out to be permanent cures. . . . There can be no doubt that he has done a great deal to alleviate terrible suffering by way of easing pain and by removing fetor in these veiy advanced cases of malignant disease, which are far beyond the surgeon's aid. We would ask all those of our readers who have the care at any time of such cases, to read this little book very carefully, and to follow out conscientiously his methods, and so give them ery trial.'-Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps.