TIME OF CONSCIOUSNESS DURING EXPOSURE TO VARIOUS PRESSURE ALTITUDES by A. P. Webster Commander, HS, USNR and Orr E. Reynolds Lieutenant (jg), HS, USNR 7 August 1946 Biodynamics Branch Research Division Bureau of Medicine and Surgery Navy Department Table 3 Time of Useful OOnMOaisness and Time to Unconsciousness at Various Altitudes Breathing Air. Altitude feet Time of Useful Con- sciousness sec. Time to Uncon- sciousness sec. Altitude feet Time of Useful Con- sciousness sec. Time to Uncon- sciousness sec. 25000 198 483 55000 17 27 26000 148 356 56000 17 26 27000 118 281 57000 16 25 28000 97 229 58000 16 24 29000 83 193 59000 16 23 30000 73 167 60000 15 22 31000 64 144 61000 15 21 32000 57 128 62000 15 21 33000 52 114 63000 14 20 34000 47 102 64000 14 19 35000 43 92 65000 14 19 36000 40 84 66000 14 18 37000 37 77 67000 14 18 38000 35 71 68000 13 17 39000 33 65 69000 13 17 40000 31 61 70000 13 16 41000 29 57 71000 13 16 42000 27 53 72000 13 16 43000 26 50 73000 13 15 ’ 44000 25 47 74000 12 15 45000 24 44 75000 12 14 46000 23 41 76000 12 14 47000 22 39 77000 12 14 48000 21 37 78000 12 14 49000 20 35 79000 12 13 50000 20 34 80000 12 13 51000 19 32 52000 19 30 53000 18 29 54000 18 28 CONTENTS Page I. Introduction 1 II. Notation 2 III. Theoretical Derivation of Relationship Between Conscious Time and Altitude 3 IV. Fit of Theoretical Equation (Equation 8) to Experimental Data 5 A. Time of consciousness (time to unconsciousness) versus pressure altitude 5 B. Time of useful consciousness versus pressure altitude 9 V. Applications of Equations 8a and 12a 15 A. Non-useful consciousness versus pressure altitude . 15 B. Relation between time of useful consciousness and time to unconsciousness • 15 C. Time to unconsciousness on air and oxygen versus altitude in feet 16 D. Time of useful consciousness on air and oxygen versus altitude in feet 16 E. Time of useful consciousness versus time to unconsciousness breathing oxygen 17 VI. Summary of Equations and Constants 25 VII. Source of Data 26 I. INTRODUCTION For any given set of anoxic conditions, the time of consciousness is identical with the measured time to loss of consciousness. The words time of consciousness then become synomymous with time to unconsciousness. For theoretical and practical reasons the time of consciousness may be considered as composed of two separate and distinct parts: (1) the time of useful consciousness, and (2) the time of non-useful consciousness. The first part represents that conscious time when deliberate and purposeful acts can be successfully carried out; and the second part represents that conscious time when deliberate and purposeful acts cannot be successfully carried out. The sum of these two times, then, is the time of consciousness or the time to unconsciousness. There are a number of situations and problems in high velocity, high altitude flying where a knowledge of the time of consciousness of individuals exposed to reduced atmospheric pressure may play a role in aircraft design, methods of escape, placement of controls and other mechanisms, etc. For altitudes up to approximately 40,000 feet, knowledge of the time of consciousness is important in event of sudden interruption of oxygen supply, necessitating certain actions on the part of the individual in the useful conscious time available to him. At higher altitudes where pressurized cabins may be used', sudden exposure to the ambient pressure, with or without oxygen supply, by explosive decompression due to failure of the pressurized cabin, will subject the individual to anoxia giving rise to a certain conscious time during which certain acts necessary to his well- being must take place. Knowledge of the time of useful consciousness and the time to unconsciousness in event that bail-out is necessary at high altitude may set the limits beyond which bail-out is impossible-- and may be fatal--for’a given type aircraft, cockpit design, and bail- out equipment. This paper was written in order to present the avail- able data on time of consciousness at various altitudes; to present a rational theory on time of consciousness at various altitudes to which the rather meager data is fitted; and from which theory tables and charts were prepared and presented from which the time of conscious- ness at any altitude may be obtained. 1 II. NOTATION = rate of transfer of oxygen into or out of the organism. w = quantity of oxygen transferred in time, t, when the altitude is unchanged. Pa = constant pressure of air which will just maintain the oxygen supply to the organism sufficiently to barely maintain conscious ness indefinitely, mm.Hg. Pa = pressure at various altitudes, mm.Hg. U = overall coefficient of oxygen transfer. = quantity of oxygen transferred prior to unconsciousness. Wg = quantity of oxygen transferred prior to loss of ability to carry out.purposeful acts. = time to unconsciousness, sec. tx = onset of “physiological time”, sec. t2 = time of useful consciousness, sec. tg = time of non-useful consciousness, sec. 2 III. THEORETICAL DERIVATION OF RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CONSCIOUS TIME AND ALTITUDE It is tacitly assumed that consciousness depends on the main- tenance of a given rate of oxygen supplied to the organism. Whether consciousness depends upon supplying this oxygen to the organism as a whole, or to the cerebral cortex, or to any other tissue, is not important to this derivation. The mechanism by which oxygen is transferred and transported within the organism, from the air breathed, is also of no importance in this development. The major premise is that there is a constant pressure of air (or tension of oxygen) which (when this air is breathed) will just maintain the oxygen supply to the organism sufficiently to barely maintain consciousness at a near threshold level for an indefinite period of time. Let this constant pressure of air be represented by pa. It follows, axiomatically, that when the individual is exposed to (breathing) air at a pressure of pa or greater, consciousness will be maintained indefinitely. For any other air pressure, p , less than p/", the rate of trans- fer of oxygen (out of the organism, probably) is given by: 3f -U(p'-pa) (1) where dw/dt is the rate of transfer of oxygen, and U is the overall coefficient of transfer. The quantity - pa) represents the “driving force”. Integration of Equation 1 will give the quantity of oxygen, w, transferred in time, t. Jdw = U(pa - pa)/dt (2) Note that the “driving force”, (pa; - pa), is a constant for a given altitude. Then w = U(p a - pa)t + C (3) To evaluate the constant of integration, C, it is necessary to assume that the starting chronological time does not necessarily correspond with the onset of “physiological time” for this situation. That is, 3 when t = 0; chronologically, t = physiologically. It follows that when t = t/, w = 0, and C =-U(p/-pa)t' (4) Whence w = U(pa — pa)(t +t/) (5) Equation 5 represents the quantity of oxygen, w, transferred in time, t, at a constant altitude pressure, pa. If the organism be- comes unconscious when a given quantity of oxygen, Wp is trans ferred, we have Wi = U(pa - PaHti + t/), (6) where represents the time to unconsciousness at the constant altitude, pa. If we assume the organism will go unconscious when- ever the quantity of oxygen transferred is Wp regardless of altitude we obtain the relation between the time to unconsciousness, tp, at any pressure altitude, pa: = K4 (8) and Ki / 11 = ~ (8a) where K-, (9) 1 U 4 IV. FIT OF THEORETICAL EQUATION (EQUATION 8) TO EX- PERIMENTAL DATA A. Time of Consciousness (Time.to Unconsciousness) Versus Pressure Altitude. Table 1 gives the data obtained from the various references noted in Section VII of this paper for the time of consciousness (time to unconsciousness) at various pressure altitudes. TABLE 1. Pressure Altitude, Pa mm.Hg. Time to Con- sciousness, t]_, min. Source No. 34.4 0.25 1 41.4 0.28 1 48.5 0.33 1 56.5 0.38 1 66.2 0.45 1 77.5 0.53 1 123.7 0.83 1 140.0 1.15 2 140.0 0.75 3 168.0 1.33 1 178.7 1.50 3 198.2 2.00 1 225.6 3.00 3 267.4 7.00 6 281.9 5.00 3 281.9 7.30 • 7 281.9 10.00 6 Figure 1 is a plot of the experimental data from Table 1. on time of consciousness versus pressure altitude. The smooth curve in Figure 1 represents Equation 8 as fitted to the data by an ob- jective, semi-least-squares, method as follows: Equation 8 was expanded, then three simultaneous equations were set up and solved for the three constants: t'*, and K. 5 Figure 1. 7 A2 17 /17 3- Pal-ll - ZPa1! “ t iSZPa + 4(pat i - Ki) = 0. 14 14 14 The equation of the smooth curve thus obtained is (322 - pa)(tx + 0.98) = 361 (10) and •> -drbr ' B. Time of Useful Consciousness Versus Pressure Altitude For practical applications in the design of controls, release mechanisms, and the like, it is convenient to separate the time to unconsciousness, tj_, into two components: to, the time of useful consciousness, i.e., that time after the onset of anoxia when deliberate and purposeful acts can be successfully carried out; and tg, the time of non-useful consciousness when deliberate and purposeful acts cannot be successfully carried out. It follows that the time to unconsciousness is given by tl=t2+t3 (ID Assuming that the point of demarkation between tg and to is reached when the quantity of oxygen transferred is wo, the equation relating time of useful consciousness and pressure altitude may be derived in the same manner as that for the time to unconsciousness versus pressure altitude. Hence (Pa - PaHt2 - tg) = K2 C12) Theory demands that the pressure altitude at which consciousness would be maintained indefinitely, p a, be the same for the two equations, 8 and 12. It will subsequently be shown that the data substantiate this argument. Table 2 gives the data obtained from the various references for the time of useful consciousness at various pressure altitudes. 9 TABLE 2. Pressure Altitude, pa mm.Hg. Time of Useful Consciousness t2, min. Source No. 140.0 0.50 2 144.8 0.25 4 154.9 0.58 5 178.7 0.77 5 225.6 1.22 5 230.8 1.00 4 267.4 2.00 4 246.9 1.83 5 246.9 2.00 2 281.9 5.00 8 307.4 5.00 4 Figure 2 is a plot of the experimental data of Table 2 on time of useful consciousness versus pressure altitude. The smooth curve of Figure 2 represents Equation 12 fitted in the same manner as the smooth curve of Figure 1. The three simultaneous equations are: The resulting equation for the smooth curve thus obtained is (322 - pa)(t2 + 0.28) = 143 (13) and '2 = ~ °'28 (13a) 10 Note that pain equations 10 and 13 for time and time of useful consciousness is given as 322 millimeters of mercury. Actually, in the solution of the three simultaneous equa- tions for the two situations, we obtained 321.84 and 321.63. Thus, the theory which demands that be a constant is substantiated by the data. Two points (reference 9) representing the time of con sciousness after arrest of cerebral circulation are shown the graphs, but were not used in fitting the experimental data to the theory. 11 13 V. APPLICATIONS OF EQUATIONS 8a AND 12a A. Non-Useful Consciousness Versus Pressure Altitude. The time of non-useful consciousness, tg, is given by Equation 11 as the difference between the time to unconsciousness, ti, and the time of useful consciousness, t2- Subtracting Equation 12a irom Equation 8a, we have t3 = ti - t2 =SL-J£2,) _ (tl' _ t2'), (14) Pa from which *3 = r3- - ■ - t3/, (15) Pa - Pa 13 where Kg = Ki - K2 , (16) and t3 = ti - t2/ (17) Equation 15 for non-useful consciousness is the same form as Equations 8a and 12a, all three equations being hyperbolas having the common asymptote, indicating the constant pressure altitude at which consciousness is maintained indefinitely; and three separate time asymptotes, tg'', and tcf, indicating the physiological onset of the particular phenomena. The equation for non-useful consciousness versus pressure altitude with the numerical constants inserted is then (322 - pa)(tg - 0.70) = 218, (18) and (16a) B. Relation Between Time of Useful Consciousness and Time to Unconsciousness. Eliminating the pressure altitude, p , between Equations 10a and 13a, we obtain 15 t2 = 0.396 tx 4- 0.108 (19) as the- relation between time of useful consciousness and time to unconsciousness. Note that this expression is linear and that the time of useful consciousness is approximately four tenths the time to unconsciousness for all pressure altitudes. Equation 19 is plotted in Figure 3. C. Time to. Unconsciousness on..Air-ami Oxygen Versus.. Altitude in Feet. Equation 10a is plotted in Figure 4, replacing the pressure altitude, p«, by the appropriate altitude in feet as obtained from the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, Report No. 218, “Standard Atmosphere - Tables and Data”, by Walter S. Diehl. Also, in Figure 4, the time to unconsciousness is plotted in seconds. Figure 4 then gives the time to unconsciousness in seconds versus the altitude in feet. In order to obtain the curve for exposure to one hundred per cent oxygen, rather than air, it was necessary to obtain a relationship between altitudes breathing air and altitudes breathing oxygen. This relationship was obtained from the curve for equivalent altitudes, Chart A-2, “Handbook of Respiratory Data in Aviation”, CAM and CMR, 1944. The equation derived from this chart is hi qqq = 0.6h 209 + 33,800 feet, (20) where hi qQO Is the altitude breathing oxygen which is equivalent to the altitude breathing air, h#2Q9* By plotting the time to unconscious- ness corresponding to h>2Q9* against hi.000 as obtained from Equation 20, the curve for time to unconsciousness against altitude when breathing oxygen was obtained in Figure 4. D. Time of Useful Consciousness on Air and Oxygen Versus Altitude in Feet. Equation 13a is plotted in Figure 5 replacing the pressure altitude, pa, by the appropriate altitude in feet, the time in seconds, and the appropriate altitude breathing oxygen in the same manner as the curves of Figure 4 were prepared. Note that in the equations for time to unconsciousness and time of useful consciousness, the pressure altitude at which consciousness may be expected to last indefinitely (in the average individual) 16 breathing air is 322 millimeters of mercury, corresponding to 21,913 feet, and the altitude at which consciousness may be expected to last indefinitely breathing oxygen is 46,948 feet, corresponding to a pressure altitude of 101 millimeters of mercury. E. Time of Useful Consciousness Versus Time to Unconscious mss Breathing Oxygen. This relationship is given by Equation 19 in which the times are those breathing oxygen. 17 figure 3. Time to Unconsciousness (Minutes) Time of Useful Consciousness (Minutes) 19 Figure Altitude (Thousands of feet) TIME TO UNCONSCIOUSNESS 21 Time (Seconds) Figure 5 TIME OF USEFUL CONSCIOUSNESS Time (Seconds) 23 VL SUMMARY OF EQUATIONS AND CONSTANTS 1. Time of Useful Consciousness Breathing Air: to = 3-43 - .28 minutes. z 322 - pa 2. Time of Non-Useful Consciousness Breathing Air: to = —218 _ .70 minutes. 6 322 - pa 3. Time to Unconsciousness Breathing Air: ti = — - .98 minutes. 1 322 - pa 4. Pressure Altitude Where Consciousness may be Just Maintained Indefinitely Breathing Air: 322 mm.Hg. 5. Altitude in Feet Where Consciousness may be Just Maintained Indefinitely Breathing Air: 21,913 feet. 6. Pressure Altitude Where Consciousness may be Just Maintained Indefinitely Breathing Oxygen: 101 mm.Hg. 7. Altitude in Feet Where Consciousness may be Just Maintained Indefinitely Breathing Oxygen: 46,948 feet. 8. Relation Between Time of Useful Consciousness and Time to Unconsciousness Breathing Air or Oxygen: tg = 0.396t]_ + .108 minutes. 9. Times of Useful Consciousness, Non-Useful Consciousness, and Time to Unconsciousness Breathing Oxygen: Replace pa in air equations by the air equivalent pressure breathing oxygen. 25 VII. SOURCE OF DATA 1. Rasher, S. Experiments at Dachau. Communication to Medical Liaison Officer, Military Requirements Division, BuAer, Navy Department, from Lieutenant Commander A. H. Andrews, Jr., 17 October 1945. 2. Barry, Alexander. Emergency Descent from Altitude. U.S. AAF, Materiel Command, Engineering Division, Memorandum Report, 5 February 1946. 3. Evelyn, Kenneth. The Effects of Low Barometric Pressure on the Health of the Adult Male in the Age Group 19 - 32. National Research Council, Division of Medical Science, Committee on Aviation Medicine, Report No. 19, 3 July 1941. 4. Aero Medical Exploitation by AAF, Germany, 1945. Studies by Tavel. 5. Hoffman, C. E., Clark, R. T., Jr., and Brown, E. B., Jr. The Rates of Fall of Blood Oxygen Saturations at Simulated Altitudes Following Mask Removal: Period of Useful Consciousness and Time to Imminent Unconsciousness Following Change from 100% Oxygen to Ambient Air at Altitudes Above 28.000 Feet. BuMed Research Project No. X-572, 1 December 1945. 6. Commoner, Barry. Voluntary Pressure Breathing of Ambient Atmosphere as a Means of Increasing the Oxygen Saturation of the Blood. BuMed Research Project No. X-198, 19 October 1943 7. Houston, Charles S. U.S. Naval Air Station, Miami, Florida. Communication to Research Division, BuMed, Navy Department, 22 September 1944. 8. Bachrach, William H. Communication to Research Division, BuMed, Navy Department, February 1946. 9. Rossen, R., Kabot, H. and Anderson, J. Acute Arrest of Cerebral Circulation in Man. Arch. Neurol, and Psychiat. 50:510-528, November 1943. 26