MEDICAL REPORT ON THE CONDITION OF THE SURVIVORS OF THE G REELY PARTY, WHEN RESCUED BY THE RELIEF SQUADRON BY EDWARD H. GREEN, M.D., SURGEON OF THE U. S S. THETIS, OF THE GREELY RELIEF SQUADRON. ROM THE MEDICAL NE September 6, 1884. MEDICAL REPORT ON THE CONDITION OF THE SURVIVORS OF THE GREELY PARTY, WHEN RESCUED BY THE RELIEF SQUADRON.1 As a preliminary to the medical history of the cases of the survivors of the Lady Franklin Bay Expedi- tion, it is well to give a brief resume of their mode of life at Camp Clay, their quarters, rations, etc., so as better to appreciate the condition in which they were found. On September 29, 1883, Lieutenant Greely landed with his party at Baird Inlet after thirty days' ex- posure drifting on an ice-floe; the record left at that time stated the party was all well. Having sent an advance detachment ahead, which found and re- ported that a cache of provisions existed at Cape Sabine (fifteen miles further to the northward than he was at this time ), it was deemed expedient to move the whole command up to that neighborhood rather than send for the provisions, and winter at Baird Inlet. Finally, on October 25th, they moved around to a point between Cape Sabine and Cocked 1 This paper was specially prepared for The Medical News, to which it was forwarded by Surgeon Green, through the Bureau of Medicine and Surgery of the Navy Department. 2 Hat Island flat. 783 45' N., long. 74° 15' W.); the site of their winter-quarters was sheltered between high ridges of mountains, which screened them in a measure from the northerly and southerly winds. A glacier was situated at the foot of the mountains on either side of them about a mile distant. They con- structed a house of loose rock and moss, the walls be- ing three feet in thickness. The roofing consisted of old canvas stretched over a boat; the dimensions of the house were 25 feet long by 17 feet wide by 4 feet high, making a cubic air-space of 1700 feet, in this the twenty-five members of the party lived all winter, having a cubic air allowance of about seventy feet for each man. The whole party could barely squeeze in and lie at length, two or three being obliged to occupy the same sleeping-bag; the effect of this diminished air-space will be seen later on. Their hut was but 100 yards removed from the ice-foot of the sound, and 200 yards to the south of them was an artificial lake, from which they drew their water supply by melting up ice; as the sea water strained into this lake, they were drinking brackish water all the while. On November 1, 1883, Lieut. Greely took a careful account of his stock of provisions, and found there was but a whole ration for each man (estimated as an army ration, about forty-six ounces of solid food per diem) for forty days. Doctor Pavy and he advised together, and it was with some reluctance that they determined to divide up the rations so as to make them last until March 1, putting aside from time to time, so that at the end they would still have ten days' supplies left with which to attempt the trip to Littleton Island, if the Straits were frozen over. Doctor Pavy did not think the party could exist on the ra- tion during the winter, but the common voice was 3 to make it go as far as it would; so each man was given the following daily allowance: Meat and blubber, . . .4.33 ozs. Bread and dog biscuit, . -6.5 11 Canned vegetables and rice, . 1.4 " Butter and lard, . . . . 0.75 " Soup and beef extract, . . 0.90 " Berries, pickles, raisins, and milk, 1. " Making the daily allowance for the four months 14.88 ozs. During the winter the following amount of game was secured, which added to their stores: 2 seals, yielding about 120 lbs. of meat, one bear, yielding 300 lbs. of meat, 8 foxes (4 lbs. each), and 60 dovekies (uria brunnichii), a small bird, weighing about a pound. March 1 found the party intact, with the excep- tion of Sergt. Cross, who died in January with well- marked scorbutic symptoms-the only case of pro- nounced scurvy that developed-and Hans, their Esquimaux hunter, who was lost in his boat while hunting seals, early in February. The Straits having been kept open during the winter by a succession of violent gales, the attempt to cross to Littleton Island had to be abandoned, and their ration was still fur- ther reduced to the following allowance: meat 6.8 ozs., bread and dog biscuit 3.2 ozs. The rest of the stores having been exhausted, the remaining supplies were divided up so as to last until May 12th. The sun had returned by this time, after an absence of one hundred and twenty-eight days, and those employed as hunters caught the shrimp (crangonidae), a small Crustacea, one-eighth to one-fourth of an inch long, consisting of about four-fifths shell and one-fifth meat. From 1 to 3 ozs. of these a day, according to the catch, were allowed in addition to the ration. After the last reduction the party began rapidly 4 to weaken and die. About the 24th of March the whole party was overcome with asphyxia, and nearly lost their lives, owing to the atmosphere being sur- charged with carbonic acid. They had lit their al- cohol stove in the hut to cook a meal, without pre- viously having removed the rags from the vent hole in the roof; the remaining oxygen of the air was soon consumed by the stove, and the whole party were seized with faintness, vertigo, and dyspnoea. It was with the greatest difficulty they struggled from their sleeping-bags, and stumbled and were helped into the open air, many fainting away and dropping unconscious after reaching the opening. Being poorly clad for a temperature such as prevailed out- side at the time (-46° F. ), many were frostbitten. The after-effects of this mishap remained for a long time, and weakened many of them. After May 12th everything like a regular ration was exhausted, and they struggled on as best they could, catching the shrimps (which they boiled); gathering reindeer moss, which, when boiled, yields a mucilage similar to Iceland moss, and boiling up the sealskin linings of their sleeping bags, from which a gelatinous mass was extracted. It was not till they had exhausted the supply of moss around the camp that they gathered the black lichen {crepe de la roche} growing on the rocks, and boiled it. Dr. Pavy urged strongly against its use, as he had the authority of Kane and Hayes that, when eaten, it would produce a diarrhoea which, in their weak- ened condition, would be fatal. They had no fuel for artificial warmth, and barely sufficient to allow for melting the ice for procuring drinking water and to cook a meal every other day; so that the living temperature of the hut for the winter was from 50 to io° F. They recognized the fact that the nearer they 5 could approach a state of hibernating, the better were their chances of getting through. Only those employed as cooks and hunters exerted themselves much, and they were given a double ration. The rest occupied their sleeping-bags, and slept sixteen to eighteen hours out of the twenty-four. In an- swer to complaints of hunger, Dr. Pavy's motto was, "Qui dort, dine," which was philosophical without being filling. There seemed to be but little acute suffering from the lack of food. It was only after the introduction of food into the stomach that the craving became great. For days they went without food without actually suffering. The deaths seemed to take place finally from heart trouble (hydrops pericardii). The feet and face became cedematous; for a day or so they would complain of pains over the heart; have a spasm of pain over the prsecordia; a slight general convulsion, and all would be over. Their chief suffering during the winter was from constipation. Many went eight to ten days without a stool, and one as long as sixteen days; the feces became so hardened and impacted in the rectum that at each operation they were obliged to dig the feces out with their fingers, the abdominal muscles being too weak to extrude the mass. Nearly every one would faint after having a stool, from sheer exhaustion. When it is considered that for nine months they were on the ration as detailed, had nothing but brackish water to drink, no artificial warmth, living in a temperature of 50 to 10° for the winter, with a cubic air-space of 70 feet per man, the condition in which the survivors were found will not be wondered at. There were but seven out of the twenty-five found alive. These were A. W. Greely, First Lieu- tenant, U. S. A. ; Henry Biederlich, Hospital Stew- ard ; D. Brainard, Sergeant, U. S. A. ; Morris 6 Connell, Private, U. S. A. ; Joseph Ellison, Sergeant, U. S. A. ; Julius Fredericks, Sergeant, U. S. A. ; Francis Long, Sergeant, U. S. A. The first four mentioned were taken onboard the flagship " Thetis" and placed under my care, and with them this paper will principally be concerned. On landing at the camp the condition of the party was so desperate that a delay of two hours was neces- sary to restore them sufficiently to permit their being removed on stretchers to the boats and taken off to the ships. Morris Connell, Private, was in extremis; was pulseless, unconscious, and unable to swallow ; limbs cold and respiration barely noticeable; auscultating over the heart, the sounds were heard very indis- tinctly. By propping him up, and forcing open the jaws, a teaspoonful of brandy was slowly poured into the back of the throat. The effect of the stimulant was soon noticeable, as a faint pulse appeared at the wrist; in ten minutes he could make an effort to swallow, when more brandy was administered, fol- lowed by some warm condensed milk at intervals. The rest of the party were served with brandy, milk, and beef essence, and finally transported to the ships. The time and space would hardly be allowed me to give more than a brief detail of the cases, and as they closely resemble each other, both in symptoms and treatment, I will confine myself to the case of Lieutenant A. W. Greely more particularly, alluding to anything peculiar in the other cases. June 2 2d, n p. m. , A. W. Greely, Lieutenant, U. S. A., set. 40. Disease, asthenia. On admission he fainted after being carried below in the ward-room, and vomited ; administered ammoniae spts. aromat. 6 c.c. (100 minims), renewed in ten minutes; placed him in a berth, gave a teaspoonful of raw, fresh beef, 7 minced; clothes were carefully cut off of him and heavy red flannels, previously warmed, substituted. On examination his body emitted a sickly, offen- sive odor (as of stale urine) ; emaciated to a degree. The skin hanging from his limbs in flaps; face, hands, and scalp blackened with a thick crust of soot and dirt (having not washed or changed his clothing for ten months). Nervous system : Excitable and irritable, at times almost irrational; eyes wild and staring; insists on talking, craving news, and demanding food; com- plains of no pain. Digestive system: Tongue dry and cracked, heavy brownish-black coat; ravenously hungry, abdominal cavity hollow and lying almost in contact with the vertebral column ; no movement of bowels for six days; liver dulness, on percussion, confined to right hypochondriac region. Respiratory system : Respirations 12 per minute; auscultation and percussion reveal no abnormal con- dition of the lungs ; vesicular murmur puerile. Circulatory system : Pulse 52, soft and compressible; auscultation shows marked murmur (blowing) in systole over base of heart. Integumentary system: Skin cold and clammy, sickly odor emanating from it, shrivelled and sallow; temperature 97.2' (under tongue). Locomotor system : Great muscular waste, unable to move or stand without support; body weight, 120 pounds; weight before leaving Fort Conger in August, 1883, 168 pounds. Urinary system: No specimen obtainable. Treatment, from n p. m. till 8 a. m., alternated every half hour; teaspoonful of raw, fresh beef (minced) with teaspoonful of milk punch; enjoined strict quiet; pulse then rose to 60 per minute, soft; temp. 970. 8 23d. Nervous system: Mind still active and rest- less, compelled to allow him some home letters to read, after which he became more composed; has not closed his eyes; talks rationally, but shows loss of memory, as he often repeats himself. Digestive system: Had a small, highly offensive stool; felt quite faint afterwards ; passed considerable wind from bowels; abdomen tympanitic; tongue still dry and coated. Circulatory system : Pulse slightly stronger, 60 per minute; respirations 12 per minute. Integumentary system : Same offensive odor; temp., a. M., 97.8°; p. m. 98°. Locomotor system : Still unable to raise himself up without help ; muscles very soft and flabby; some stiffness and pain in the joints. Urinary system: Urine passed in 24 hours 1630 c.c. (55 ozs.), sp. gr. 1014, acid, highly albuminous (one-tenth tube). Treatment: Continue raw fresh beef, at intervals of an hour, with a raw onion finely cut up, added also milk punch, one-half ounce every two hours ; no medication. 24th: No sleep; mind more tranquil, but too active; great desire to talk and read ; less persistent in demanding food ; complains of soreness in limbs ; tongue presents a moister appearance ; bowels slightly distended with gas, no stool ; pulse 62, not so thready ; heart sounds stronger ; still a pronounced anaemic murmur; blood examined microscopically shows large increase of white corpuscles; at first the field (one-tenth objective) appeared filled with the nucleated corpuscles ; close examination showed the proportion to be about one to twenty red ; the red corpuscles show but little disposition to cohere and run into "rouleaux," and lacked the distinctive biconcave disk shape; edges full and round (not ragged); urine 9 passed in 24 hours 1660 c.c. (56 ozs.), highly albu- minous, no casts revealed by microscope; skin clammy, dirty mottled yellow; temp., a. m., 97.6 ; p. m. 98°; muscles sore; slight oedema of hands and ankles. Treatment: Sponging with tepid water, afterwards briskly rubbed with flannels and a little linimentum saponis; four ounces, of oatmeal (thoroughly boiled) allowed in morning; beef essence, Liebig's, $j, in hot water every four hours; continue scraped beef and onion; no medication. 25th. Marked improvement; mind more tranquil; talks quietly without excitement; slept two or three hours naturally, awoke refreshed; tongue beginning to clean; had a large, dark, semi-solid stool; odor offensive in the extreme, evidently but little biliary secretion poured into the alimentary canal; pulse 65, some strength; respiration 14, principally costal; skin losing clammy feel, its emanations still sour and offensive; temp., a. m., 98.2° ; p. m., 98°; muscles sore; ankles puffed. Treatment: Shampooing muscles with dry cloths. No change in diet. No medication. 26th. Allowed to sit up in bed and read a little; slept six hours soundly during the night, mind tran- quil, has a loss of memory of words ; tongue clean- ing, still has heavy coat at back; bowels moved twice, stools pitchy and offensive ; abdomen tympan- itic, considerable borborygmus. Pulse 65; heart sounds stronger, murmur still pronounced. Urine passed in 24 hours 1800 c.c. (61 ozs.), sp. gr. 1016; albumen not decreased; no change in con- dition of skin. Temp., a.m., 98°; p.m., 98.8°. Treatment: Sponging and friction. Same dietary with tr. ferri muriat., 5 c.c. (80 minims) ter in die. 27th. Still extremely weak ; voice stronger ; mind easier; amnesic aphasia marked; appetite still 10 morbid, always hungry, considerable flatulence; no stool; aspect of skin somewhat improved in appear- ance, still dirty yellow (no petechiae). Temp , a.m., 98.4°; p.m., 98.8°; pulse 66; respiration 14; urine albuminous (1-12 tube) 1950 c.c. (66 ozs.) in 24 hours, sp.gr. 1018; muscles beginning to fill out, and are very soft. Treatment: Dietary increased to 8 ounces of broiled steak in morning; continued tr. ferri muriat. 28th. Gaining strength ; dressed and sat up for a couple of hours, then felt exhausted and returned to bed ; mind quite tranquil; slept well; appetite still morbid ; bowels moved, no change in character of stool; liver still inactive. Pulse 66, fairly good tone; anaemic murmur not so marked. Temp., a.m., 98.2°; P.M., 98°; urine passed in 24 hours i860 c.c., (63 ozs.), sp. gr. 1017, albumen present. Treatment: Takes food at five stated intervals: 6 a.m., oatmeal, 4 ounces; broiled steak, 8 ounces. 10 a. m., Liebig's beef essence, $j, in a teacup of warm water. 2 p. m., one soft boiled egg with milk toast. 6 p. m. , raw minced beef and onions, iop. m. , Liebig's essence of beef. Continue tr. ferri. muriat., 6 c. c. (100 minims) ter in die. 29th.-Dressed and was assisted to walk in ward- room a few steps ; muscles soft; very weak ; limbs filling out; body-weight 129^ pounds (gain of 9^ pounds for the week). Pulse 68; urine 1650 c.c. (56 ozs.) in twenty-four hours, albumen less; temp., a.m., 98° ; p. m., 98.4°, normal; bowels moved natu- rally, stools still pitchy and offensive. Treatment: Continue the same. 30th.-Sleeps naturally and awakes refreshed ; al- lowed to read and talk ; walks around for an hour or so with support; limbs filling out; feet oedematous toward night; appetite still morbid, unable to be satisfied with his allowance; good movement of 11 bowels; albumen disappearing from urine; heart sounds stronger; temperature normal. Continue re- stricted diet and iron. July i.-Felt quite refreshed on awaking; had slept well during the night; enjoyed morning meal and ate without asking for more. As the sun was shining brightly, was assisted on deck, and sat in the air (well bundled up) for an hour; had but little ap- petite for midday meal; at 4 p. m., a small, dark, offensive stool; strained considerably, and was much exhausted afterwards (nearly fainted) ; administered spts. frumenti ^ss in water at 6 p. m. Complained of severe pains in abdominal muscles and over the region of the liver (pains resembling hepatic colic); con- siderable febrile disturbance; pulse 98, temp., 100.20; administered quiniae sulph. 30 cgm. (4)4 grs.) at 8 p. m. 2d.-Feels much prostrated and weak; muscular pains and soreness over abdomen and back; com- plexion sallow; appetite poor. Temp., 8 a. m., 98.8° ; 12 m., 99° ; 4 p. m., 99.20 ; exhibited hy- drargyri chloridi mit., 30 cgm. (4)^ grs.), at 8 a. m. Repeated dose at 2 p. M.: bowels moved three times, last evacuation watery; felt weak, but free from cramps; headache disappeared; light diet of oatmeal and milk ; discontinued tr. ferri muriat. yd.-Still weak ; muscular soreness over abdo- men ; no sharp pains ; two loose evacuations from bowels ; appetite returning ; pulse 68 ; temp, normal; whiskey toddy ^ss ter in die. 4th.-Considerable improvement; pains have dis- appeared from muscles ; tongue cleaner; complexion better ; allowed to sit up to his meals. Urine much improved, albumen (-^ tube), sp. gr. 1022. Re- sumed tr. ferri muriat., also vin. Portense ter in die before meals. yth.-Gaining strength gradually; muscles soft; 12 knees weak; encouraged to take some exercise •daily, weather permitting, in the open air; digestion good; appetite under better control; liver still torpid ; regular movement of bowels ; skin clearing and has lost its clamminess; sleeps well; continue same treatment. From this time forth there was gradual improvement; blood again examined micro- scopically-showed marked diminution of white cor- puscles. On 8th, no albumen found in urine. On 12th, anaemic murmur very indistinct. On 17th, arrived at St. Johns ; condition sufficiently good to warrant his going ashore for exercise ; muscles still weak and sore ; filled out rapidly. 19th had a slight attack of intestinal indigestion, was living ashore at the Consul's, having committed an error in diet; suffered for two days. On 25th, allowed to eat three full meals daily, with certain articles restricted ; encouraged to exer- cise in open air. On the trip from St. Johns to Portsmouth, N. H., (July 26th to Auy rst\ ran into damp, moist weather ; felt much prostrated, and mus- cles ached ; given quinize sulph. 180 cgm. (27 grs.), every night during the run. On being transferred at Portsmouth, his body-weight was 169 pounds, repre- senting a gain of 49 pounds in six weeks: 9^ pounds the first week, 15 pounds the second week. 8 pounds the third week, 7 pounds the fourth week, 5% pounds the fifth week, 4 pounds the sixth week. Ji emarks.-Vital depression, as exhibited by the temperature is not marked ; digestion fairly good all the time; nervous system soon calmed ; microscopic examinations of blood exhibited no marked unhealthy character of red blood-globules, but steady decrease of white corpuscles under the influence of the iron ; al- bumen disappearing ; anaemic murmur disappearing, showing that it is simply due to hydraemic condition of the blood; liver not secreting; large gain in 13 weight, due to rapid assimilation of food, owing to great muscular waste. Uurinary excretion large, 1950 c.c. (66 oz.), in one day, due doubtless to almost total inactivity of the sudorific glands. U S. S. Theiis, August 3, 1^84 On relinquishing medical charge of the survivors of the Lady Franklin Bay Expedition, prior to their transfer ashore for treatment, I respectfully submit ex- tracts from the medical journal of this ship, showing their present physical condition and treatment. i. A. W. Greely, First Lieutenant U. S. A., set. 40 years. Present condition: Able to walk some distance without getting tired; muscles beginning to harden and tone; face still has a swollen appear- ance, and puffed; complexion sallow. Digestive system: Tongue clean and moist; appetite not ab- normally large; bowels move regularly ; stools large' and dark colored, less offensive; passes less wind from bowels; no tympanites; at times heavy feel- ing over right hypochondriac region. Circulatory system: Pulse 78-82 ; good tone; auscultation over the heart shows almost total disappearance of anaemic murmur. Respiratory system: Lungs free from trouble; has slight dyspnoea on exercising. Integu- mentary system: Skin sallow; temperature of body 98.6°. Urinary system : Urine passed in twenty-four hours, fifty-six ounces; paleamber; acid; 1024 sp. gr.; no albumen. Nervous system: Mind tranquil; me- mory much improved; slight amnesic aphasia; sleeps well. Locomotor system: Muscles soft; has weak- ness, particularly in the broad muscles of the back (latissimi and trapezii); complains at times of cramps in the muscles of legs. General condition: Liver is torpid; muscular system lacks tone; is free from organic disease. Treatment: Rest; moderate exer- 14 cise; dietetic; port wine before meals; pil. quiniae sulph. grs. iij at night; pil. ferri et strychnias citrat. grs. iss after meals. 2. Morris Connell, Private U. S. A., aet. 32 years. Present condition: Sallow; muscles weak. Digestive system: Tongue clean, furred at the back; appetite abnormally large; bowels free, large stool daily; troubled at times with gaseous dyspepsia; bowels flatulent and tympanitic; liver contracted slightly. Circulatory system: Pains over praecordia disap- peared ; heart sounds normal; pulse regular, 74, lacks strength. Respiratory system : Normal. Integu- mentary system : Slightly oedematous about the feet; sallow; temperature of body normal. Urinary system: Normal. Nervous system: Sleeps well; mind active and retentive ; no pains in body. Lo- comotor system: Muscles getting tone gradually. General condition: In fair health; free from or- ganic disease. Treatment: Dietetic; tr. ferri muriat. npxv ter in die ; exercise. 3. Henry Biederlich, Hospital Steward, aet. 28 years. Present condition: Suffering from chronic rheumatic arthritis in middle joint of ring-finger of left hand ; has also at times flashes of rheumatism in joints and muscles. Digestive system: In good condition ; suffers at times from gaseous dyspep- sia ; bowels regular; appetite not morbid. Circu- latory system : Has anaemic murmur over the base of the heart; pulse dicrotic at times, 74 per minute. Respiratory system : Normal. Integumentary system : Face puffed, ankles oedematous, skin clear, tem- perature normal. Urinary system : Normal. Nervous system : Mind clear ; has neuralgic pains at times in muscles of chest; sleeps well. Locomotor system : Muscles getting stronger and harder; joints at times stiff from rheumatism; middle joint of ring-finger on left hand chronically swollen. Is in fair physical 15 condition and free from organic disease. Treatment: Quinine, small doses of potass, iodid., exercise. 4. D. Brainard, Sergt. U. S. A., set. 28 years. Is in fair physical condition, performs all functions naturally; pulse good, temperature normal, urine normal, feet slightly oedematous, muscles in fairly firm condition. Free from all organic disease. Treatment: Dietetic, quinine, tr. ferri muriati, port wine. 5. Julius R. Fredericks, Sergt. U. S. A. In good physical condition; all functions naturally per- formed ; pulse good, temperature normal. Has been under treatment of P. A. Surgeon Ames, on the 11 Bear." 6. Francis Long, Sergt. U. S. A. In good physi- cal condition. Under treatment of P. A. Surgeon Ames, of the " Bear." Very respectfully, Edward H. Green, P. A Surgeon.