The Care of Women in Pregnancy. CHARLES M. GREEN, M. D. BY Reprinted front the Boston Medical and Surgical Journal of February 25, 1892. DAMRELL & UPHAM, PUBLISHERS No. 283 Washington Street. 1892. BOSTON: S. J. PARKHILL & CO., PRINTERS BOSTON THE CARE OF WOMEN IN PREGNANCY.1 BY CHARLES M. GREEN, M.D. It is probably true that the great majority of preg- nant women are not seen by their physician profes- sionally until he is summoned to attend them in labor. If serious complications arise during the pregnancy, such as excessive nausea and vomiting, uterine haem- orrhage, unusual pain or convulsions, the doctor is necessarily summoned; but the minor ills and discom- forts are endured in silence, and no advice is taken except that of relatives and neighbors, who love so well to fill the ears of the young gravida with accounts of their own experiences. In other words, in the great majority of cases, no attention is paid to the hygiene of pregnancy, and the woman arrives at term in good, bad or indifferent condition, as the case may be. The reasons for this unsatisfactory state of things are not far to seek. Many women believe that preg- nancy is a more or less pathological process, and as- sume that its ailments must be borne as a necessary concomitant of childbearing. They do not know that most of the ills of gestation are preventable, or largely remediable, by competent medical supervision and advice, and that so far from being pathological, preg- nancy is indeed a physiological process, except in occa- sional instances. Again, probably a large majority of women are ignorant of the fundamental laws of health, and, while perhaps seldom very sick, are seldom quite well. When, in such women, pregnancy supervenes, it is not surprising that it is often attended with path- 1 Read before the Boston Society for Medical ImproxeiHent. De- cember 28, 1891. ' 2 ological conditions. To ignorance, then, both of the ways of correct living and of the advantages of proper advice during pregnancy, must be ascribed largely the unsatisfactory condition in which many women are found when labor overtakes them. Another reason for the lack of medical supervision during pregnancy is the attendant expense. The great majority of women are attended in labor by contract, so to speak ; that is to say, they expect to pay a cer- tain definite fee, usually a small, inadequate one, which shall cover the doctor's attendance during the labor and his subsequent visits during the convalescence. If the woman desires, or feels that she needs, to consult her physician during her pregnancy, she usually seems to take it for granted that advice at such times should involve no additional fees. It is not surprising that for the very small fees for obstetric attendance that obtain in most suburban and rural districts, medical men should be sometimes unwilling to extend their advice over the pregnancy as well as to take charge of the labor and convalescence. On the other hand, most women are unable or unwilling to pay fees for advice on matters relating to their pregnancy. For one or more of these reasons, to repeat my original statement, the great majority of pregnant women receive no medical advice or supervision. I believe this to be a misfortune, and a detriment to the best interests of the race; and it is the object of this paper to point out the importance, necessity and ad- vantages of proper supervision of pregnancy, how in my opinion it should be exercised, and how the obsta- cles in its way can be removed. There is, supposedly, no question but that pregnancy and parturition ought to be, and were in the divine plan intended to be, physiological processes : that in a large proportion of cases they are not so, a somewhat 3 extended experience leads me to believe. Making due allowance for the congenital and acquired defects of general or local character which are certain to make these processes pathological, the fact still remains, in my judgment, that, in a great majority of cases, preg- nancy and labor can be brought quite within physio- logical and normal limits. If this opinion is true, there is no necessity of dwelling on the importance of adopting such measures as will lead to this most de- sirable end. The true object of modern medical science is to do away with the necessity of medical art : in other words, the aim of the true physician is to make the further exercise of his profession useless. While the force of this statement is admitted in general, it has not seemed to me.that the extent to which it is applicable in obstetric medicine is fully realized. I believe that, accepting the existing states and conditions in which women of the present day are found, very much can be done by competent supervision during pregnancy to bring labor and puerperal convalescence quite near to normal, physiological bounds ; whereas experience has abundantly convinced me that to the lack or inade- quacy of such supervision much unnecessary suffering and disaster are due. But to relieve myself of the probable criticism that my expectations of preventive medicine are altogether utopian, let me hasten to add that whatever may be the possibilities of prevention in the field of epidemiology and general medicine by meas- ures of public and private hygiene, the day is doubt- less far distant when the services of obstetric medicine and surgery will be found useless. Supposing the obstacles in the way of medical super- vision of pregnancy, - namely, ignorance of its im- portance and necessity on the part of the patient, and the question of expense on the part of patient and 4 doctor, - can .be set aside, let us consider what can be done for the welfare of the young pregnant woman and her prospective offspring, when free and full op- portunities for obtaining medical advice are open to her. What are the respective duties of doctor and patient in the premises ? Suppose the woman to have passed over one or two menstrual periods, and in the absence of other probable causes of amenorrhcea pre- sumes herself to be pregnant: she consults her physi- cian. By a few simple questions he satisfies himself that presumably she is pregnant: is it his duty to pro- ceed to confirm his presumptive diagnosis by a physi- cal examination ? In most cases, certainly not. If important plans, as of journeys abroad, of changes of residence or manner of living, are dependent on a knowledge of the woman's condition, it may be neces- sary to determine, if possible, by physical examination whether pregnancy actually does exist; but under or- dinary circumstances it is proper to proceed with a presumptive diagnosis, knowing that time will settle the matter beyond question. But at this time it is im- portant that the physician should make careful inquiry in regard to the patient's general health. Of course, if he has been her medical adviser previously, her tem- perament, constitution and general condition will be known to him; but if not, he should inform himself on these points, and adopt such measures as may be necessary to promote good general health, and to rem- edy, as far as possible, constitutional defects. There are some special points, also, on which specific advice should be given : these points will be considered in detail. Nutrition is a process of great importance in preg- nancy, both to the mother and to her child: it is de- sirable for the mother to be able to put forth all her strength in her labor, and to endure its necessary suf- 5 ferings with the least possible shock to her system. To this end attention should be paid to her appetite, diet and digestion. Some women during pregnancy have inordinate and perverted appetites, which need to be moderated and controlled. Some purposely re- strict themselves unduly, in the hope of thereby retard- ing foetal growth and of thus having an easier labor. Others for some reason have an insufficient appetite, which needs to be stimulated by proper therapeutic measures. The diet of pregnancy needs differ in no important particular from that which is proper in other phases of hygienic living, unless some special condition requires specific modification. Some author- ities believe the food should be especially rich in phos- phates, to promote the bony development of the foetus ; but it seems reasonable that whatever food is best for the mother may naturally be expected to be most suit- able for foetal development. Simple, nutritious diet, in moderate but sufficient quantity, should be advised: candy, pastries and fries should be avoided. The use of tea, coffee and wine should depend on their effects and on the patient's habit. Some women, who habitu- ally eat too little, may require forced feeding, - a light lunch between meals and at bedtime, of milk, broth, egg-nog, malt, or bread and butter. Most women at this early period of their first con- sultation with their physician are suffering more or less with nausea and vomiting, although some happily es- cape this often distressing symptom. It is not my purpose to discuss the treatment of this affection, which usually disappears spontaneously when the ute- rus has become an abdominal organ; but rather to express my belief in the importance and wisdom of checking or limiting it in its incipiency. The water which will quench a small blaze will add to the fury of a conflagration; and measures which will control this 6 symptom in the beginning often prove worse than useless when once perverted function has assumed full sway. No one can tell to what end an apparently physiological nausea may attain. While occasionally no therapeutic measure short of induced abortion (and sometimes unhappily not even that) will control this symptom, in most cases simple remedies will suffice to remove it or keep it within due bounds: it is often found that attention to diet and digestion is all that is necessary. Morning nausea is often proved to be due to a want of nourishment, and is prevented by taking a lunch at bedtime, and another in the morning before raising the head from the pillow. If simple dietetic measures do not prevail, the cause should be sought for, and perhaps found, in a displacement or impaction of the uterus, or in an abnormal condition of the cer- vix : in other cases the cause will be found in a per- verted innervation or hysteria. But whatever thecause, it should be found and removed, if possible, before the development of serious results in the patient's condi- tion. A return of these symptoms in the later months should be given special attention. At the first early interview the condition of the bowels should receive careful inquiry. Not only are most women chronically constipated, but those with whom the function of defecation was previously nor- mal are often disturbed with sluggishness of the bowels in the early months of pregnancy : indeed, constipation is considered by some a symptom of pregnancy in those previously regular. No speedy resort should be had to drugs, but an effort should be made to correct the difficulty by hygienic and dietetic measures. The woman should be cautioned not to strain at stool ; enemata will suffice to ensure an easy movement when the failure is due to torpidity of the rectum. Much can be accomplished by proper exercise and dietetics ; 7 but should such measures fail, others must be employed to insure a regular, daily movement. The skin is also an important organ of elimination. The better the functional activity of the skin, the less work will be thrown upon the kidneys at a time when unusual demands are made upon them. If the patient has not the habit of daily bathing, the duty of adopting it should be enjoined, the bath to be followed by vigorous friction with coarse towels. Apart from the benefit of stimulating glandular activity in the skin, daily bathing has a sedative effect on the nervous sys- tem and tends to promote the functional activity of the bowels, and other digestive and eliminative organs. Unless the patient has some antecedent affection of the kidneys, there is seldom any disturbance of their function in the early months. Micturition is some- times frequent, owing to the pressure of the enlarged and anteverted uterus on the bladder, or there may be an irritability of the latter viscus caused by concentrated urine. Women proverbially drink too little water to properly dilute their urine, which is often high colored, of high specific gravity, and excessively acid. This condition is not, of course, peculiar to pregnancy; but it is liable to be aggravated thereby and should receive attention. A glass of water three times a day will often suffice to relieve this condition : failing this, lithia water or acetate of potash may be advised with bene- fit. Throughout the pregnancy the state of the kidney should be closely watched. By this is not meant that the urine should be examined necessarily at frequent intervals. The patient herself, if of average intelli- gence, can be taught to do most of the watching, and that, too, without exciting her nervous apprehensions. In these days when water-closets are to be found on every floor of most houses, bedside cabinets and the old-time chamber-vessel are seldom used: as a result, 8 most people rarely see their own urine and are unable to give much information concerning it. It is my cus- tom, therefore, to direct pregnant women to see their urine at least once a day: I instruct them as to the average daily amount in health, tell them that it is important that this amount should be maintained, and ask them to notify me, if they notice any departure from normal standards, either in color or amount. I also ask to be informed of the occurrence of oedemas, puffiness of the eyelids, headaches, disturbances of vision, nervousness, and indeed of any symptom of ill- feeling. Twice or three times in the later months it is well for the physician to examine the urine; but even without such examination there is no occasion for apprehension of eclampsia so long as the urine is nor- mal in amount, so long as the nervous system is in stable equilibrium, and so long as there is no appar- ent indication of central nervous irritation : the mere presence of moderate oedema and albuminuria, without other symptoms, does not disturb me in the least, al- though it makes me watchful. As may be inferred from the last paragraph, the condition of the nervous system should receive special attention throughout pregnancy. Making due allow- ance for a poor inheritance, most women can be brought into a state of nerve equilibrium by a skilful guidance on the part of the physician into ways of cor- rect living. There is no better medicine for unstable nerves than a plenty of sound sleep. If, therefore, it is found that the patient's sleeping habits are unsatis- factory, the cause should be sought for and removed. Suitable exercise, and a warm bath and a lunch at bedtime are often efficacious-; but sometimes a course of bromides may be advisable. In the later months the woman sometimes fails to sleep because she cannot lie comfortably in bed. She may be accustomed to 9 sleeping on her side, but finds herself unable to lie comfortably on her side when the abdomen is much enlarged. In such cases I have found that the use of a small pillow, upon which the abdomen can rest as upon a shelf, has been productive of comfort and repose. A pregnant woman's nervous system is often grieviously upset by the injudicious conversation of her friends and relatives. Some people are singularly, nay criminally, indiscreet in their talks with pregnant women. Accounts of appalling haemorrhages, of con- vulsions, and of the graver obstetric operations are certainly not conducive to nerve quietude in the preg- nant state. Neither is it judicious for the gravida to read all about it in the family medical books: such books are responsible for much harm. The more ignorant of the act of parturition a woman can be kept, the better: I would not have her know that there is such a thing as a placenta even. 1 always advise against any reading or any conversation with friends on the whole subject, and warn against listening to what may be well meant in the way of lay advice, promising that I will answer any question, if it be proper. If a women dresses properly at other times, she need make no changes during pregnancy, except to provide for the gradually enlarging uterus. Most women, however, still cling to the garter and the corset, both of which are more than usually deleterious during pregnancy. 11 is sometimes difficult to induce a woman to lay aside these abominations even in the later months ; but such a course should be advised, and the reasons why should be explained. It is gratifying to know that some women are substituting a comfortable waist for the corset; and are suspending the skirts from the shoulders, instead of buttoning them tightly around the waist. Garters are also to some extent 10 giving way to tapes attached to the corset-waist. It will be the better for all women, when they follow the advice of physicians in these matters of dress. How much exercise ought a pregnant woman to take ? It is often difficult to prescribe the exact amount that is suitable for any given person. Most women obtain all needed exercise in the. pursuit of their usual affairs; some, however, in the leisure class, need more than their habitual activity. Walking is probably the most suitable exercise in pregnancy, not carried, how- ever, to the point of fatigue: the august lady at the court of St. James set her subjects a good example in this respect. In the latter weeks, when walking may have become difficult, driving may well take its place. One might hesitate to prescribe gymnasium exercise for the pregnant; yet I recall one patient, habituated from early childhood to gymnastic exercise, who con- tinued her training during nearly the whole of her gestation, omitting only the heavier work, and she hqd a most rapid and easy labor and an uneventful con- valescence. Fortunately, most women are engaged in house-keeping duties, and except for the want of the open air, housework is probably the healthiest occupa- tion a woman can have. It is difficult sometimes to induce women to take sufficient open-air exercise; but there is no question that most women are greatly bene- fited by it during pregnancy, and have easier labors in consequence. Women should be willing to train them- selves in some degree for their labor, as an athlete would train himself for a race. Pregnant women should be cautioned against indis- creet exertion at the times which would be menstrual periods were they not pregnant. I have too often seen the unfortunate results of indiscretions at these times. When miscarriage occurs, it is usually at the time of a menstrual epoch. Some women are made aware of the 11 approach of these epochs during pregnancy by certain unmistakable sensations and feelings of malaise ; but to avoid oversight in those not so warned, they should be advised to mark off on their calendars the days when menstruation would ordinarily occur. In these days no undue exertion should be made, and exercise should be somewhat restricted: above all at such times nervous excitement should be avoided. This leads me to speak of the propriety of sexual intercourse during pregnancy. To many women I believe coitus during pregnancy is distasteful, to many even obnoxious, to all, in my opinion, it is more or less injurious. Aside from the mechanical disturbance of the uterus by impact, the sexual act injuriously con* gests the pelvic vessels, excites and then depresses the nervous system, and is often a cause of miscarriage, especially when practised at a menstrual epoch. So far as my knowledge of the animal creation goes, the pregnant female will not suffer the sexual approach of the male, but will fight, if necessary, to protect her- self. Certainly among enlightened human beings, men who have at heart the welfare of wife and children should be willing to forego sexual indulgence during the time when the wife needs all her vital powers for her own well-being and that of her expected offspring. Many men and women err through ignorance, and are grateful for advice on this subject. It is believed by some that the pelvis should always be carefully measured in the early months of preg- nancy with a view to anticipating some serious com- plication in labor at full term. In women who have a history of difficult and pathological labors, such a course is wise; but in primigravidte it has never seemed to me warrantable to subject them to a routine examination unless there was a reasonable suspicion of some deformity in the parturient canal. Marked 12 forms and degrees of pelvic deformity are likely to be suspected during pregnancy, if the patient is under ob- servation, and in such cases pelvimetry should be made. The minor degrees of pelvic contraction, on the other hand, even if suspected and ascertained to exist, would not warrant obstetric interference before full term in a woman pregnant for the first time. In such cases the child is often proportionally small, and is safely delivered either by nature or by art. If, however, the first labor proves disastrous, and the woman demon- strates her unfitness to give birth to a full-term child, premature labor can be induced in subsequent preg- nancies. I do not, therefore, include pelvimetry among the necessary duties of the medical attendant, as a matter of routine. With a view to successful lactation the breasts should receive some attention. They should be relieved from injurious pressure by corsets and tight clothing early in the pregnancy; no other care except cleanliness is necessary until after the seventh month when it is ad- visable to begin to prepare the nipple. The old-time custom of applying a decoction of green tea and brandy in equal parts is familiar to all, and doubtless this mix- ture is very efficacious in toughening the nipple: I have found, however, that absolute alcohol, diluted one-half with water, is quite as satisfactory and less troublesome. I am accustomed to advise the use of this lotion morning and evening during the last two months. If the nipple is flat or inverted, it is well to draw it out by gentle suction with a heated bottle before applying the alcohol. With proper preparation in pregnancy and suitable care during lactation, sore nipples need rarely occur. As the abdomen enlarges in the later months, and the skin is tightly stretched, much comfort is imparted by inunction with sweet oil or lanoline. I have 13 thought, too, that the skin is thereby softened and made more elastic, and that there is not so much tear- ing in the deeper layer and consequently not so much disfiguration by scars. Some women are oppressed with the weight of the uterine tumor and are unable to go about with comfort: a well adjusted abdominal support is a great comfort in such cases, and often enables the woman to walk and drive until she is brought to bed. It is well known that a species of anaemia is a phy- siological condition in pregnancy : the red corpuscles, albumen, iron, and the salts of the blood are diminished ; while the white corpuscles, fibrin, and water are in- creased. Robust, well-nourished women may have sufficient reserve power to sustain the demands which pregnancy makes upon their vital energy without arti- ficial assistance ; but this type of women is not com- mon in my experience. 1 have already spoken of the importance of careful attention to nutrition during pregnancy, as a means of preventing undue impover- ishment of the blood; and it has seemed to me that most women are benefited by the administration of iron, especially in the last two months. Apart from the general benefit of iron as a tonic, there' is ground for belief that post-partum hmmorrhage is less likely to occur in those whose blood has not been too much impoverished by the unsupported demands which pregnancy makes upon it. It has long been my custom to prescribe Queveune's iron in the last two months of pregnancy, with great apparent benefit. There remains fur me to speak of one more subject of great importance to both patient and physician, the selection of the nurse. Too often this duty is at- tended to by the patient without consultation with her medical adviser; such, indeed, is the custom. While some men may be indifferent, most physicians would 14 prefer to select the nurse who is to be their lieutenant and assistant, as much as the commanding officer to choose his adjutant, as indeed it is his prerogative to do. It is only right that he who is to have the re- sponsibility of the case -should select or approve the nurse who is to carry out his orders: no man can do his best work, if handicapped with an assistant in whom he has not confidence. There is need, I think, of some educational work on this point among the laity : women engage their nurse long before their physician, and without consultation with him, because they have not a correct understanding of the relation of the nurse to the physician. In most cases when the patient's means allow her to employ a training-school graduate, the nurse may be entirely satisfactory to the physi- cian; yet it is unnecessary for me to assert in this presence that there is room for choice among trained nurses. And when we pass without this circle to the greater field of the old-time monthly nurse, we find them good, bad or indifferent, septic or otherwise, ac- cording to circumstances. I have long since declined to attend cases unless I could select, or approve of, the nurse, and my own results and peace of mind have greatly benefited thereby: it is needless to add that the patient's welfare is promoted, quite as much as the physician's, by thus allowing the doctor to give his patient the benefit of his own better knowledge as to the relative fitness of nurses. He surely can choose more wisely than his patient. I hope it will not be supposed, from the length of this paper, that under ordinary circumstances much time or money must be spent in the exercise of suitable supervision over pregnancy. When the woman is in good general health two or three interviews with her physician will usually suffice: at these consultations, distributed through the pregnancy, all needed advice 15 can be given, and the physician can assure himself that his patient continues well. If, however, at any time the pregnant woman is not well, it is needless for me to emphasize the importance of bringing her as near as possible to normal standards. It has often seemed to me that the physician's visits came at the wrong time: in most cases he does not see the patient during pregnancy, when he might be of great service, but makes numerous visits during the lying-in period which ought to be for the most part unnecessary. If the paiient approaches her labor in good physical condition, in the best possible physical strength and with stable nerves, - if then the labor is skilfully conducted and she is delivered without septic infection and left in the hands of a competent nurse, there is little or nothing to require the subsequent at- tention of the physician: his care and advice can be much more profitably bestowed before the baby is born. If the physician's visits could be transferred in part from the puerperal to the pregnant period, there would be in my opinion fewer abnormal labors, less suffering, more rapid convalescence and better obstetric results. How can this desirable state of things be brought about ? How can the two chief obstacles be removed ? Ignorance of the advantages of supervision among the laity can only be removed by active missionary work by the medical profession : when it comes to be under- stood in any community that the leading physicians will not attend obstetric cases unless women place themselves under observation early in their pregnancy, the lesson will soon be learned. Already among the more enlightened and well-to-do classes of this com- munity, it is quite generally the custom for women to inform their physician as soon as they have passed over one or two periods and to place themselves in 16 his care. And among those less well-circumstanced the lesson could soon be taught by well-directed effort in the circle of each physician's influence. The ques- tion of expense ought not to be an obstacle in the way of all necessary supervision of the pregnant: it is not, among those pecuniarily well situated. Indeed, it has seemed to me that less expense is incurred on the average when the patient has received adequate atten- tion during pregnancy, for the reason that fewer visits are necessary during the puerperal period. Among those who by force of circumstances or by custom are attended by contract, where the physician's services must be unrequited, if given during pregnancy, selfish motives alone would seem sufficient to induce him to give all needed attention to prevent complications and disasters which more or less affect his reputation, often give him much additional work and disturb his peace of mind. But appeals to such motives are unworthy of a liberal profession: the true physician is ever willing to give freely of his time and ability to pro- mote the best interests of those who are placed in his care. THE BOSTON Medicaland Surgical Journal. A FIRST-CLASS WEEKLY MEDICAL NEWSPAPErT PUBLISHED EVERY THURSDAY. Two Volumes yearly, beginning with the first Nos. in January and July. But Subscriptions may begin at any time. This Journal has been published for more than sixty years as a weekly journal under its present title. Still it is incumbent upon this Journal, no less than upon others to assure its patrons from time to time, as the occasion arises, of its desire, ability, and determination to meet all the requirements of the most active medical journalism of the day, without sacrificing any of that enviable reputation which is an inheri- tance from the past. It is under the editorial Management of Dr. George B. Shattuck, assisted by a large staff of competent coadjutors. Communications from all quarters of the country are acceptable. Liberal arrangements are made for reprints of original articles, and for such illustrations as serve to increase their value or interest. All editorial communications, and books for review, should be addressed to the Editor. Subscriptions and advertisements-received by the undersigned, to whom remittances should be sent by money-order, draft, or registered letter. Terms of Subscription : In the United States, and to Canada and Mexico, $5.00 a year in advance. To Foreign Countries embraced in the Universal Postal Union, $1.56 a year additional. Single numbers, 15c. Ten consecutive numbers free by mail on receipt of $1.00. Sample copies sent free on application. Published by DAMRELL & UPHAM, J283 Washington St., JESoston.