Reprinted from Annals of Gynecology and Pediatry, April, 1893. A CLINICAL LECTURE ON THE PREVENTION OF IDIOPATHIC ROTARY LATERAL CURVA- TURES OF THE SPINE. By H. Augustus Wiuson, M.D., Professor of General and Orthopaedic Surgery in the Philadelphia Polyclinic ; Clinical Professor of Orthopaedic Surgery in the Jefferson Medical College. [Annals of Gynaecology and Podiatry, May, 1S93]. Plate I. ' J>, * / / 7 Jy- 3 Ju. n ■ 7 ' 7 'r J't ir . tJ e 7f, Juj 'j 3 7'y /Q J'. , J'<// J / Idiopathic Rotary Lateral Curvatures of the Spine. {Annals of Gynecology and Pediatry, May, 1893]. Plate II. ly /'i //; J /J- /j •- /y Jr<L t / J / <■ // A 7< 2f Idiopathic Rotary Lateral Curvatures of the Spine. Annals of Gynecology and Pediatry, May, 1893]. Plate III. J? 2 7<<. 2 5 & (f J J' SA f) J * 'J'*', t. z J . Idiopathic Rotary Lateral Curvatures of the Spine. A Clinical Lecture on the Prevention of Idiopathic Rotary Lateral Curvatures of the Spine. BY H. AUGUSTUS WILSON, M.D., Professor of General and Orthopcedic Surgery in the Philadelphia Polyclinic; Clinical Professor of Orthopcedic Surgery in the fefferson Medical College. It will not be the purpose of this lecture to refer to that larger class of cases of rotary lateral curvatures of the spine where that deformity is produced by asymmetry of the legs or arms, but attention will be directed only to those that have no such apparent cause, and therefore would be classed idiopathic. Without entering upon the large subject of theoretical aetiology, it may be concisely stated that idiopathic rotary lateral curvatures of the spine are produced or influenced by two factors, namely: Constitutional debility, or enfeebleness, and pro- longed maintenance of an altered relationship normally existing be. tween the shoulders and hips. It will be apparent, therefore, that the prevention of the occurrence, as well as the arrest of the progress of this deformity, will depend upon the early removal .of those conditions which tend to the production and progress of this deformity. In the group of illustrative cases,1 photographs of which are here given, constitutional debility was a con- spicuous element. Scoliosis is first noticed usually from about the age of eight to sixteen years, during that period of life when rapid growth and development mark the transition into young womanhood. Occasionally the 1 Eight of these photographs were loaned to the Editors of the " American Text Book of Surgery," and will explain their presence there and here. 2 H. AUGUSTUS WILSON. same condition is found in boys of the same age, but this is rare, and the deformity assumes precisely the same character as seen in Figs. 15 and 18. It will require no argument to im- press the absurdity of relying upon more or less rigid shoulder braces or apparatus, or requiring a patient to remain in bed, or in any recumbent or quiet position, when such proced- ures or restraint can have but one object, and that to increase the en- feebleness already present. It would be as rational to attempt to prepare college athletes for field or aquatic sports by prolonged rest in bed so that they should become rested, and, therefore, ready for the severe exer- tions to which they were to be sub- jected, or to permit them to exercise once a week for an hour and then so encase their bodies as to prevent muscular effort, and, therefore, fatigue. The constitutional debility peremp- torily demands well-directed hygienic surroundings and the gradual and judicious development of the entire muscular system as well as the adjustment of the clothing to permit unrestrained action of those muscles whose function it is to hold the spinal column in the normal position. The clinical features of this form of spinal curvature are well shown in the photographs of the illustrative cases which are given here to afford an opportunity of studying a group rather than a single case. The gen- eral character of the deformity will be found to be the same in all of these cases, some features being more marked at times, such, for example, as the position of the greatest curve. The existence of some deviation from the normal positions of the shoulder, or shoulder blades, is usually first observed by the dressmaker, when she finds differences upon the sides of the patient, or the necessity for filling in the dress waist with cotton batting or other material in order to make the dress fit nicely. Sometimes there is observed an undue promi- nence of one hip, making the waist slanting, and the skirt is noticed to drag upon the ground upon one side. It occasionally occurs that a careful mother will observe the elevation of one shoulder and the undue promi- nence of one shoulder blade, but this rarely occurs until the deformity has progressed sufficiently to make it markedly conspicuous. It not infre- quently occurs that the corset maker is the one who finds out that the girl is crooked. Often the mother, dis- tressed at the habitual faulty positions assumed by the daughter, will exam- ine the back to find a cause, and the characteristic appearances will be observed. The patient standing firmly and evenly on both feet, with the body uncovered from the hips up so that a free inspection may be made, it will be observed that the right shoul- der is higher than the left, as shown in Fig. i ; that the right scapula is not only more prominent at its angle, but occupies a position posterior to that of its fellow, as shown in Fig. 12 ; that the ribs upon the right side, posteriorly, are more or less bulged out laterally and posteriorly, as shown in Fig. 2. Upon the left side there is a corresponding depression into which the left scapula sinks in pro- portion to the extent of the curva- ture shown in Fig. 15, and that upon examination of the spinous processes, PREVENTION OF CURVATURES OF THE SPINE. 3 by using the first and second fingers, placed one upon each side, pressing upon each side of the spinous pro- cesses, that a gradual curvature or deviation from the middle line will be observed. The most convenient method of making this inspection is to begin with the seventh cervical vertebra ; passing the fingers down with slow, firm pressure to the sacrum, turning the patient about so as to face you, the opposite conditions will be observed ; that the bulging of the ribs is upon the left side anteriorly, with a corresponding depression of the right side. It, however, not in- frequently occurs that although there may be a very considerable amount of deviation of the spinal column posteriorly, there may be very slight deformity manifested in front, shown in Figs. 23 a and 23 b, and I have rarely found it necessary to examine the front of the body to confirm a diagnosis. In Fig. 19 b there is a conspicuous prominence of the right hip in front and an apparent obliquity of the line of the waist, giving the appearance that would be present in a case with the right leg several inches longer than the left. The view of the back, as seen in Fig. 19 a, will show the low dorsal and lumbar lateral curva- ture, but it is the great rotation of the lumbar vertebrae in this case that so alters the contour as to make the right hip unnaturally prominent. The legs were found to be within a quarter of an inch of the same length, and could not, therefore, have pro- duced the apparent obliquity of the pelvis. I say apparent obliquity, because it was found to be apparent only, as the measurements from the anterior superior spinous process of the ilium demonstrated. It generally occurs, however, that no evidence of curvature is found in the front of the body, as well demon- strated by Fig. 23 b, where the con- tour is even and regular, as though there were no abnormality. The inspection of the back, however, as seen in Fig. 23 a, shows a decided lateral curvature, and the prominence of the right scapula demonstrates the presence of rotation. Occasionally the inspection of the front of the body reveals an apparent enlarge- ment of the left mammary gland, but this is found to be due to the torsion of the vertebrae throwing the ribs for- ward and therefore making the mam- mary gland of that side seem larger than its fellow. The character of the curvature is that of a slow or gradual curve in more or less of an S shape, proceed- ing with great regularity from the pelvis to the neck. The curvature may now be made more conspicuous by having the child fold her arms in front and bend forward from the hips, with the knees straight. In this position, by laying a ruler across the back, the scapula of the right side will be found to occupy a differ- ent plane from that of its fellow. Any irregularities of contour, such as unduly prominent hips, as seen in Figs. 1, 12, 15, 16, 19 and 20, will now be found not to depend upon unequal lengths of the legs, but to rotation of the lumbar vertebrae. Any doubt in this regard may be easily removed by measuring the length of the legs, or by measuring the distance from the floor to the great trochanters on each side as the patient stands erect. The patient, standing erect, should be requested' to slowly bend the body first to the right side and then the left, when it o z 4 H. AUGUSTUS WILSON. will be perceived that an inequality of freedom of motion exists, which will be made more apparent by re- questing the patient to turn her entire body, without moving the feet, first to the right and then to the left. The character of the curvature is, as already stated, a gradual curve, as shown in Figs. 1 and 2, and is totally unlike the angular curve of lateral deviation sometimes seen in Pott's disease, an illustration of which is afforded in Fig. 3. In the latter, the deviation is that of two straight lines bending at a single point, and the differences of appearance is so great that it would appear to be impossible to mistake them. But this case, No. 3, was treated for a time as scoliosis, while the case shown in Fig. 28 was treated for Pott's disease, and is evi- dence, therefore, of the possibility of confusion. A reference to the illustrations of pathological specimens from the Mutter Museum of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia will not only explain the characteristic curva- tures of each, but will plainly show the presence of rotation as an impor- tant element of scoliosis. Fig. 5 will show the resulting bone changes in a confirmed case such as Fig. 1 was when I first saw the case. The line of the spinous processes shows the curve of the lateral curvature, while the positions occupied by the ribs upon the right side will explain the undue prominence of the right shoul- der blade so well shown in Figs. 1, 2, 11, 12, 13, 16, 22 and 27 when these patients were standing in a relaxed position. The undue prominence of the angle of the left scapulae, as shown in Figs. 14, 15, 18 and 20, is explained by the patient's efforts to stand erect and hold the shoulders evenly. By reference again to Fig. 5 it will be seen that in the rotation of the vertebrae the shoulder joint is carried forward upon the left side, and any attempt in confirmed cases to make less apparent the appear- ances of the shoulders or scapulae would tend to throw out conspicu- ously the angle of the scapulae, as already referred to. Fig. 6 is a photograph of the front of the same specimen as Fig. 5, and shows the anterior view of the bodies of the vertebrae and clearly shows not only the lateral curvature, but, as well, the rotation of the vertebrae. Figs. 7 and 8 are larger views, and will show more in detail the ultimate bone changes that occur, and will be perceived to be such as would be produced by compression of India rubber balls. In the specimens, the changes in the lower lumbar verte- brae are so slight as to easily escape notice, and are most conspicuous at the points of greatest curvature. Here the bodies will be found to be wedge shaped, as though having yielded to pressure unequally applied. The rotation of the spinal column will also be better seen in detail in these two specimens by comparing the articulations of the ribs upon each side. These changes in the bodies, spinous processes and ribs may be due to compression while they are soft, or may be due to their more rapid growth in those parts where the resistance is the least, or as appears more probable to a combi- nation of these two elements. The changes in the chest walls as the ribs become distorted naturally produce alterations in the thoracic and abdominal cavities in proportion PREVENTION OF CURVATURES OF THE SPINE. 5 to the severity of the deformity. Not alone is the trunk, i. e., from the shoulders to the hips, shortened, but the unnatural positions of the ribs impairs their free movement in res- piration. Fig. 6 will clearly demon- strate these changes, and show the enlarged space in the thorax upon the left side and the diminished space upon the right, and the reverse of these conditions in the abdominal cavity. In marked contrast to those four specimens of resulting bone de- formity, Figs. 9 and io may now be studied in connection with Fig. 3 and its profile, as seen in Fig. 4. In the curvature of Pott's disease the curva- ture is angular, following the destruc- tion by bone disease of one or more vertebrae, throwing the upper part of the body forward. In cases where there is a lateral deviation, as shown in Fig. 3, it is undoubtedly due to one side of a body of a vertebrae yielding first and thus throwing the upper part of the trunk to one side at the same time that it goes forward. In well-marked cases of deformity there can be no difficulty in distin- guishing the character of the curva- ture, but in slightly-marked cases like Figs. 24, 28 and 29, it can be understood how the two first men- tioned were treated as Pott's disease. In these cases of slight curvature the diagnosis is often one of very great difficulty and must be made with great care, as the curvatures dependent upon active bone destruc- tion from inflammation will require immobilization, whereas rotary lateral curvature requires active movements and freedom from restraint. The most pernicious errors occur- ring in connection with scoliosis are: (a) That the patient will outgrow the slight deformity present at the beginning, and, therefore, requires no attention. (£) That shoulder straps or braces of any kind, especially when re-en- forced with pads, will, by concealing the deformity, be efficacious in its correction. (y) That any of the so-called plans of treatment will correct all cases. (d) That as it is a curvature of the spine it is to be considered to be amenable to the same plans of pro- cedure as are applied to curvatures produced by tubercular ostitis or Pott's disease. (<?) That being a spinal curvature it is hopeless to try to do anything for it. (/) That its occurrence cannot be prevented. (a) That a patient will not only not grow out of, but will, more or less rap- idly, grow into a permanent defor- mity is a matter of experience. Such an assurance was given to the case shown in Fig. n, which at the age of 18 had become confirmed beyond pos- sibility of correction. Ignoring its existence made it nec- essary to increase the application of pads in the clothing to keep it con- cealed, and as these became oppres- sive, and as the patient did not out- grow the deformity, it was deemed wise to have an additional profes- sional opinion, which was now of no avail. There is no deformity more insidi- ous in its progress than scoliosis, for its growth is very slow, and without pain or inconvenience it seizes the patient, whose hopefulness and nat- ural languor tend to postponement of inspection and the application of rational measures of relief. 6 H. AUGUSTUS WILSON. (b) That shoulder straps or braces of any kinds, especially when rein- forced with pads, will, by concealing the deformity, be efficacious in its correction. What a blessing it would be if all shoulder straps could be strapped upon their originators and makers to make them prove the assertions so freely made to cure those conditions which are, I believe, made worse by their use. In a clinical lecture entitled, " A Demonstration of Some of the Causes of Rotary Lateral Curvature," pub lished in the Journal of the American Medical Association, April 2, 1892, I showed the manner in which the head and shoulders are held erect in nor- mally constructed bodies. " The pres- ence of correlation of muscular force prevents a normal body from being deformed, and I believe its re-estab- lishment will correct deformity if ap- plied rationally and prior to serious bone deformity." "The spinal column is made up of a number of small bones or vertebrae so arranged that they tilt on one an- other at the will of the person, by the exertion of muscular force in the de- sired direction. What holds up this movable spinal column is the action of muscles, which by contracting force each vertebra against its fellow, mak- ing the column rigid." If the normal spinal column is capa- ble of being held in an erect position by muscular exertion, it is rational to believe that when the shoulders droop because a girl is feeble, that that fee- bleness will not be improved by con- structing a derrick to hold those shoulders in their proper places. That the use of supports will produce an atrophy from disuse, and although the muscular strength was not sufficient to hold the shoulders the time would speedily come when they could not hold the added weight of the shoulder braces. The progressive atrophy would then require more or less extensive braces or supports, rendering it pos- sible to dispense with muscles for the purpose for which they were made. Fig. 21 shows a brace that is in common use; it is a combination of steel-bound corset, shoulder straps, and padding combined, and when ap- plied it certainly conceals all appear- ance of a deformity. The deficiency upon the left side, posteriorly, being well concealed by the heavily-quilted pad, while a similar arrangement in front performs a similar office. In the illustrative cases may be found confirmation of the statements already made. Fig. i had worn braces for seven years. Figs, ii, 12, 14, 16, 20, 22, 23, and 28 had all worn braces of more or less elaborate construction for periods ex- ceeding four years, and the appear- ances of their backs will best tell the benefit or disadvantage to be derived from dependence upon such plan of procedure. (o') That any one so-called plan of treatment will correct all cases. The various plans advocated at various times by various writers may be grouped under the headings of oper- ative, section of muscles, now obso- lete ; prolonged recumbency, in either recumbent or prone positions; me- chanical, by some form of brace or apparatus ; gymnastic, by any of the many methods. It would be just as proper to treat all cases of pneumonia, or any other PREVENTION OF CURVATURES OF THE SPINE. 7 disease, on exactly the same plan as it would be to treat all spinal curvatures alike. There can be no doubt that cases have been benefited or cured by the plans referred to, but it is safe to say that there must have been many that were injured by the injudicious application of a single favored method, to the exclusion of all else. When it is recognized that the bones must be softer than natural in those patients who have rotary lateral curvature, and that the erect posture is sometimes prejudicial, that faulty positions are thereby induced, it will be apparent that a careful combina- tion or skillful application of such of those plans as are required should be resorted to. That to prevent further bone deformity by rigid restraining apparatus increased atrophy of mus- cles is apt to be induced, and that the attempt to increase the muscular power too vigorously may increase the bone deformity, and thus it will be apparent that great care and discern- ment is required to proceed on the safe course. (a') That being a spinal curvature it is considered to be amenable to the same plan of procedure as are applied to curvatures produced by tubercular ostitis, or Pott's disease. This error has already been shown in reference to improper use of braces. (e) That being a spinal curvature it is hopeless to try to do anything for it, is unwarranted, in view of the many absolute cures that have oc- curred in cases where the deformity was recognized in time, that is, prior to the occurrence of serious bone changes. Even after such changes have occurred the progress of the de- formity cannot only be arrested but often corrected in part, if not abso- lutely. Fig. 27 a will show the conditions present in a case that was again pho- tographed two years later and shown in 27 b, while Figs. 24 and 28 show cases that have been corrected with such slight remaining evidence of the previously existing deformity that it is difficult to believe that they ever were deformed. It is not the province of this lecture to speak of the treatment after a deformity has occurred, but rather to attempt to refute the last error referred to,/. That its occur- rence cannot be prevented. (/) The attention attracted by physical culture during the past few years clearly shows that its necessity was apparent for other reasons than in the prevention of rotary lateral curvature. A similar enthusiasm has been elicited in the subject of dress reform, and these two subjects, properly applied, will be all that will be required to prevent rotary lateral curvature, because the proper hygi- enic surroundings will naturally ac- company them. It is a mistake to depend upon gymnastic apparatus of any kind; although they may often prove an in- centive, they are never essential. The human form contains all the apparatus that can be required for its own development, and it needs simply a knowledge of how to obtain the best use of it. There are many so-called systems of gymnastics without ap- paratus, known as the German goose- step drill, the Dio Lewis, the South Kensington, Swedish, and they are very ingenious in their conception and execution. A wealth of information may be obtained from such works upon this subject as Schreiber's "Massage and Exercise;" Blakie, "How to Get 8 H. AUGUSTUS WILSON. Strong;" Checkley, " A Natural Method of Physical Training;" Har- telius, "Home Gymnastics," and other similar books. Of great importance is the matter of dress for such exercises, and I have found the skirt to be so much in the way of free, unrestrained movements that I have adopted a suit, made in one piece, consisting of very full trousers going below the knee, and a very full blouse open in the back. At the neck, waist and knees elastic bands assist in holding this garment so that it will not drag, and at the same time to avoid restraint. A pair of dark stockings and loose, soft slip- pers completes the costume, as shown in Fig. 25. The material should be preferably of dark flannel, to absorb the perspiration and protect the body from changes of temperature. The most convenient time for exer- cises is upon rising and upon retiring, and should other times be required an hour and a half after breakfast or dinner will be found most beneficial. To obtain the greatest benefit from exercises a cold shower-bath with a quick, hard rubbing should always follow, and where this is too severe for a delicate patient a sponge-bath, or even the rubbing only, may be re- sorted to. If this is followed with a prolonged rest of half an hour to an hour, with or without sleep, the pa- tient will be refreshed and not apt to become over-fatigued. Prudence dic- tates the advisability of covering the patient warmly after the exercises to avoid chilling. The most satisfactory results are usually obtained by giving the patient prescribed exercises to occupy a given time, and to add to them as the indi- cations of the case warrant, thus making them progressive. When a patient has been taught the value of self-resistance in exercise she will have within her control a method of obtaining exercises that will dis- pense with gymnastic appliances and at the same time avoid the risk of over-straining. The resistance will naturally be not of so many actual pounds but of a character adapted to meet the individual requirements. This may be illustrated by the use of the hand. If the arm is held in front of the body and flexed at the elbow and the flexor muscles of the forearm are brought into play to lift the hand or flex it, the action will require very slight effort upon those flexor mus- cles, simply enough to raise the weight of the hand. The exercise is therefore confined to'the flexors, while the extensor muscles remain largely inactive. If the patient is now in- structed to contract the extensor muscles at the same time the flexors are contracted and to repeat the exer- cise already given, it will be apparent that the flexor muscles will require greater exertion than when the hand was raised without impediment. The effect of this can be seen by watching the flexor tendons at the wrist, which are not especially apparent when the extensor muscles remain passive, but come into marked prominence when the resistance of the extensors is applied. Every group of muscles in the body has opposites or opposing mus- cles which can be taught to resist the action of those muscles, and in so doing increase the strength of both groups. The well-known method of showing the development of the bi- ceps muscle is illustrative of this re- sistance, for the biceps is made to contract and assume its much-sought PREVENTION OF CURVATURES OF THE SPINE. 9 contour, either by the resistance afforded by the contraction of the tri- ceps or by grasping in the hand some fixed article that will enable the bi- ceps to forcibly contract. The advantages to be derived from gymnastics depend upon the inter- mittent character of the exercises as well as the avoidance of fatigue and over-exertion. In evidence of this it is but necessary to refer to the scriv- ener's palsy and the blacksmith's atrophy. The great variety of move- ments adapted to physical culture and training give ample scope for the selection of those that will be the best adapted and most easily accomplished by the patient, and it is a matter of interest that over three thousand such movements have been devised. A very simple prescription, appli- cable to a very weak girl, may be given as an illustration of what these movements mean: Lying flat upon back, arms at sides. 1. Movements:-Both arms raising and full stretching upward. Five times without resistance. 2. Repeat with resistance. Once. 3. Right leg raising straight with- out resistance. Five times. 4. Repeat with resistance. Once. 5. Both arms stretching upward and sideways. Five times. 6. Repeat with resistance. Once. 7. Left leg raising straight without resistance. Five times. 8. Repeat with resistance. Once. 9. Both legs raising straight-touch fingers to toes-without resistance. 10. Repeat with resistance. Once. 11. Arise to sitting position without use of arms. 12. Recline with resistance. 13. Both legs raising and open side- ways without resistance. 14. Repeat with resistance. 15. Both legs raising with knees bent-touch knees to chin without resistance. 16. Repeat with resistance. A brief explanation may make these simple movements clearer: In the first movement the arms, fully extended, start from the sides of the body, are slowly raised and carried above the head, and then brought down into the position from which they started. 2. Requires no explanation further than the movement is necessarily very much slower because of the resistance. 3. In order to afford a complete rest to the muscles just in action the right leg is now brought into play, and the intermittent character of applied mecano-therapy is demonstrated. While these movements and exer- cises might appear to be directed to- ward improvement of the legs and arms they will, upon reflection, be found to act most upon the muscles of the trunk. The muscles of respira- tion are greatly affected by the arm movements, especially when they are performed with resistance. .In the leg exercises the abdominal muscles are especially developed, and thereby, by their opposites, are affected in- directly when the same movements are performed with resistance. If the entire body is made stronger and the faulty positions referred to are carefully avoided, the tendency to assume them will disappear. The rational procedure of making a weak girl stronger, instead of increasing her enfeebleness, would naturally in- dicate that while it was efficacious in the prevention of the occurrence of the deformity that it was also appli- 10 H. AUGUSTUS WILSON. cable in the correction of similar curvatures already existing. That such is the case is well attested by those whose attention is directed to the prevention and correction of deformities, but unfortunately its limits of full usefulness are narrowed to those cases that have not gone so far as to have the resulting perma- nent bone deformity. Many of these confirmed cases can be benefited or restrained by the judicious resort to mechanical appara- tus, the efficiency of which depends upon frequent adjustment to meet the changes that occur. Frequent visits to girls' schools where a pretense of calisthenics or the advantage of a gymnasium are offered, it has been found that an hour once or twice a week was all that was deemed expedient to devote to the subject. The possible benefit derived from such inadequate en- couragement to become strong was vitiated by improper clothing and disregard to the faulty positions at the desk or table, in sitting and in lying. If a girl is too weak to hold her shoulders erect and in the proper position-if she is so feeble as to re- quire recumbency or shoulder braces, she should be taken to Annapolis or West Point and see the transformation that so often occurs in the slouchy, slovenly carriage of the new cadet. His erect, graceful and manly bearing is in marked contrast to that before his training began. What is accom- plished in the cadet can just as effi- ciently be gained by the school-girl, with the result of preventing rotary lateral spinal curvature, as well as a host of other malformations and at- tendants upon the enfeebling methods now too frequently resorted to.