EVALUATION OF THE NITROUS OXIDE METHOD FOR THE DETERMINATION OF CORONARY BLOOD FLOW* by P. A, Green, Capt., M,C,, E, R, Munnell, Capt., M.C. L, J, Czerwonka, Biophysicist and Dr. D. E, Gregg, Chief Research Physician. from Medical Department Field Research Laboratory Fort Knox, Kentucky- 30 August 1949 *Sub-project under Study of Body Reactions and Requirements under Varied Environmental and Climatic Conditions, Approved 31 May 1946, MDFHL Project No. 6-64-12-06-(21). Project No. 6-64-12-06 Sub-project MDFKL 06-(2l) MEDEA 30 August 1949 ABSTRACT EVALUATION OF THE NITROUS OXIDE METHOD FOR THE DETERMINATION OF CORONARY BLOOD FLOW OBJECT The employment of the nitrous oxide procedure utilizes the animal in a state more closely approximating normal than any method for coronary blood flow measurement heretofore reported. The importance of establish- ing its validity is apparent. A comparison has been made of the simultaneous values for left coronary blood flow in the open-chest, anesthetized dog as measured indirectly by the nitrous oxide method, and directly by an optically recording rotameter. The inflow side of the rotameter was connected to a carotid artery, the outflow connection was tied within the left coronary ostium. The dog breathed a nitrous oxide mixture, and saturation and desaturation curves were established by blood samples drawn from the rota- meter and from a catheter within the coronary sinus. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS Based on dyed heart weight (the left heart injected with Evans Blue, ante mortem or post mortem), the nitrous oxide values differed maximally from the rotameter measurements by 450 to -17 per cent in 15 comparisons on 10 dogs. In 11 comparisons in 9 dogs, a somewhat better correlation (+1B to -10 per cent) was found between the two methods when the rotameter flow measurements were based on left heart weight (left ventricle, left atrium and total septum) • The nitrous oxide values exceeded the rotameter flow values in 10 of 15 and 9 of 11 comparisons when based on dyed and weighed myocardium, respectively. Since tests have established that the maximum error with the rota- meter approximates 5 per cent, these sizeable differences between the values obtained with the two methods could arise either from the inaccuracy of the nitrous oxide method as applied to the anesthetized dog, or from inability to determine accurately the weight of the myocardium fed by the left coronary artery. These possibilities are being investigated. RECOMMENDATIONS None Submitted by: Paul A, Green, Captain, M#C. Edward R. Munnell, Captain, M.C, Lawrence J, Czerwonka, Biophysicist Donald £. Gregg, Chief Research Physician Approved: RAY CJ GGS (J (J Director of Research Approved FREDERICK J Lt. Col., M.G. Commanding EVALUATION OF THE NITROUS OXIDE METHOD FOR THE DETERMINATION OF CORONARY BLOOD FLOP/ I. INTRODUCTION A method whereby the myocardial blood flow could be measured in the intact animal and man would be highly desirable, not only in establishing normal values, but as a supplement to other methods of studying the heart in the diseased state. The nitrous oxide method for measuring blood flow as devised by Kety and Schmidt has been employed for the determination of cerebral blood flow in unanesthetized man (l-8), and for measuring the myocardial blood flew in anesthetized dogs (9), unanesthetized dogs (10), and humans (ll). This procedure approaches this aim more closely than other procedures reported. The importance of establishing the validity of the method is thus apparent. In brief, the Pick principle upon which the method depends, is as follows: The blood flow per unit of time through an organ is equal to the amount of a substance taken up by that organ in a given time divided by the difference in concentration of the substance in the arterial blood supply and venous drainage of the organ in the same time period. In the nitrous oxide method, the denomina- tor in the Fick equation is found by computing the integrated difference between the concentration of nitrous oxide in arterial (samples drawn from anv artery) and venous (samples drawn from vein draining the tissue studied) blood during the period of equilibration with low concentrations of respired nitrous oxide. The concentration of the gas in the tissue at the time of equilibrium (the numerator in the Pick equation) is unob- tainable directly in the Intact animal or man, and is assumed to be equal to the product of the venous concentration of the gas (after equilibrium is established) and a partition coefficient (unity in the case of brain (12) or heart (9)). When the equation is multiplied by 100, units for blood flow values are obtained which, in the case of the heart, are expressed as cc. of blood flow per 100 gin. of myocardium per minute. Bckenhoff ot al, (9) found satisfactory agreement between left coronary blood flow values obtained with the nitrous oxide method and values obtained simultaneously with direct measurements made with the babble flow meter (13) in the anesthetized dog. For the direct values, the arterial inflow through the peripheral end of a cannulated circumflex or anterior descendens branch of the left coronary artery was measured. The flow in cc./lOO gm. of left ventricle was determined by dividing the measured flow by the quantity of heart tissue stained when Evans Blue dye was injected into the cannula ted artery, either ante mortem or post mortem. The conclusion was reached that gross contamination of coronary sinus blood from the right atrium did not exist because, (l) a 0,1 per cent solution of Evans Blue dye injected into the inferior vena cava or right auricle did not appear in the coronary sinus blood before recirculation through lungs and heart (as sampled through a contained catheter (14)); (2) the nitrous oxide saturation curve of coronary sinus blood was similar from dog to dog. However, no comparisons of the direct and nitrous oxide methods were reported in which venous blood samples for the nitrous oxide 1 curve were taken from an indwelling catheter. Actually, the venous samples for the nitrous oxide procedure were taken from a cannula tied into the great cardiac vein (15). The present investigation is an endeavor to evaluate the nitrous oxide method for measuring left coronary artery blood flow, (l) when venous blood samples for the nitrous oxide procedure are withdrawn from an intravenous catheter introduced from within the venous system and lying freely in the coronary sinus; and (2) by comparing it with direct measure- ments of the total left coronary artery inflow continuously recorded with an optically recording rotameter (16, 17) during the test period. II. SXTEHIUISNTAL A, Apparatus, Methods and Procedures 1-ongrel dogs of either sex weighing 15 to 25 kgm, were anesthe- tized with sodium pentobarbital, 20 mgm./kgm. given intravenously, A cannula for infusion purposes was placed in the right femoral vein and kept patent by means of a slow drip of saline. A ho. 61-8 tapered intravenous catheter (14) was connected to a saline source containing 30 units of heparin/1000 cc. and inserted through a branch of the left external jugular vein into the superior vena cava. A slow flow of saline-heparin solution was established through the catheter to prevent obstruction by blood clots. Under fluoroscopy, with the animal in the right anterior oblique position, the catheter was guided into the coronary sinus. The catheter was usually pushed well into the great cardiac vein to prevent its possible escape into the inferior vena cava during sub- sequent manipulations of the animal. The dog was then placed on his right side with a sandbag under the thorax. Under artificial respiration through an endotracheal tube with an inflated balloon, the chest was opened and portions of the 7th-llth left ribs were resected. The pericardium was opened by a cross-incision after ligating any large vessels on its surface, and a cradle was formed by anchoring it to the chest wall with hemostats. The left auricle was retracted from the field by means of a suture tied to a small portion of its border. Retraction by hemostats on the fatty tissue inside the curva- ture of the pulmonary conus brought the location of the left coronary artery into view. The artery was carefully cleaned of all connective tissue from its origin to the region of bifurcation into the descendens and cir- cumflex branches and a No. 00 silk suture passed around it. Following intravenous anticoagulants (5 per cent pontamine fast pink 3 cc./kgm. and 15 units of heparin) a cannula with a three-way stop- cock attachment was inserted centrally into the right common carotid artery and connected by means of a short piece of rubber tubing with a 5 nan. lumen to the afferent side of an optically recording rotameter having a flow range of 0 to 200 cc. (17). 2 The rotameter arrangement is Illustrated in Figure 1. From the efferent side of the rotameter, a 12-inch rubber tube leads to the coronary cannula. The coronary cannula consists of a 12-cm. length of 4-mm, thin wall brass tubing. To one end, which has been cut off diagonally, a short brass lip is soldered at an angle of approximatley 135 degrees. A right angle bend is made in the same plane as the diagonal tip so that the dis- tance from tip to right angle is 4 cm. To prevent too deep an insertion of the cannula into the coronary artery and ultimate ventricular fibril- lation, the tip is 2 ram. or less in length. A rubber tubing shunt is included in the system whereby the blood flow can be shunted around the rotameter as desired. This affords a convenient means of establishing the rotameter zero before and after a flow recording and for calibrating the rotameter situ. The system is filled with saline, and 1 cc. of heparin is placed in the chamber above the rotameter float. The coronary cannula was inserted through an artificial opening into the brachiocephalic artery about 2 cm. from its origin and pushed down the ascending aorta to the region of the left coronary ostium, saline in the system was replaced with blood by opening a side tube and letting blood flow through the tubing, first from the right common carotid artery and then from the aorta. Besides removing the saline and any bubbles that may have been present, this served the additional purpose of verifying the patency of both the carotid and coronary cannulae. The blood was returned to the animal through the intravenous Infusion apparatus. The coronary cannula was guided by palpation and visualization of the prominence of its tip into the left coronary artery where it was tied as closely as possible to the aorta with the previously placed No. 00 thread. The sandbag and all hemostats were removed following the cannula- tion. The three-way stopcock on the carotid cannula was connected with plastic tubing to a mercury manometer and a Gregg optical manometer (18) for recording mean blood pressure. The catheter in the coronary sinus was then palpated for location and withdrawn or further inserted so that its tip lay 3-5 cm. inside the sinus. In no experiment after final placement of the catheter was there observable distention of the great cardiac vein. All experiments were done in open-chest animals with positive pressure respiration. Irregularities in cardiac rhythm occasionally developed an hour or so after cannula tion, but in general, the animals remained in an acceptable condition up until the time of sacrifice. After adequate technique had been established, the experiments were usually completed within 3 hours. In some experiments, spot rotameter calibrations were made before the nitrous oxide run, using blood withdrawn from the animal and checked with previous calibration curves made with a solution of methyl cellulose (specific viscosity, 4). In all experiments, a rotameter calibration curve was established with the animal’s own blood after the test period. The spot calibration points did not vary from the final curve by more than 5 per cent. 3 Except for the positive pressure respiration which was used in the present investigation, the nitrous oxide procedure for measuring blood flow i as similar to that of Kety and Schmidt as adapted for the coronary- circulation by Eckenhoff et this night be a source of error since a time lag approximating one minute existed between the arterial blood passing through the bubble flow meter and that flowing through the intact coronary artery, and a major branch of the left coronary artery which drains into the coronary sinus was not cannulated. However, in the present investigation, this error from arterial overlap is presumably less, for the time required for methyl cellulose (sp, vise., 4) to go from the carotid cannula to the coronary cannula through the rotameter system approximated 1-1/2 seconds at 70 mm. Hg mean aortic pressure; the left coronary artery was cannulated and the contribution of the right coronary artery to coronary sinus drainage is considered insig- nificant (21). However, it is conceivable that with a low blood pressure and a low blood velocity through the rotameter system, a considerable error might be introduced in the nitrous oxide method if the right coronary over- lap was extensive. Overinjection of the heart with dye will cause the rotameter values per 100 grams of heart to be too loy. Similarly, the lower nitrous oxide values could be related to (l) understaining of the myocardium, (2) admixture of coronary sinus blood with blood which does nob drain the myocardium and which has a lower nitrous oxide concentration, such as that in the right atrium or that draining from the fatty tissue of the heart. 6 IV. CONCLUSIONS A sizeable difference can exist between the left coronary flow as determined with the rotameter and the nitrous oxide method. Since the maximum error with the rotameter approximated 5 per cent, the discrepancy could arise from the fact that the nitrous oxide method as applied to the anesthetized dog is in error and/or that the weight of the myocardium actually nourished by the left coronary artery cannot be precisely deter- mined and hence the rotameter flew values/100 gm. left heart/minute are not accurately calculated. At present no choice is possible between these two possibilities. V. RE COMMEND ATI ONS None, VI. BIBLIOGRAPHY 1. Kety, S, S, and C, F, Schmidt: Determination of cerebral blood flow in man by use of nitrous oxide in low concentrations. Am. J. Physiol. 53, 1945. 2, Kety, S, S, and C, F, Schmidt: Nitrous oxide method for quanti- tative determinetion of cerebral blood flow in man: Theory, procedure and normal values. J. Clin. Invest. 22: 476, 1948. 3, Kety, 3, S. et aid The effects of increased intracranial pressure on cerebral circulatory functions in man. J. Clin. Invest. 27: 493, 1948, 4. Kety, S. S. est : The blood flow and oxygen consumption of the human brain in diabetic acidosis and coma. J, Clin, Invest. 27: 500, 1948. 5, Kety, S# S0 £& .§!•: The blood flow, vascular resistance, and oxygen consumption of the brain in essential hypertension, J. Clin, Invest. 21* 511, 194B. 6. Kety, S, S, et al,: Cerebral blood flow and metabolism in schizo- prcnia: The effects of barbiturate semi-narcosis, insulin coma and electroshock. Am. J. Physiol. 104: 765, 1948. 7. Kety, S, S, ar*l C* F. Schmidt: Effects of active and passive hyperventilation on cerebral blood flow, cerebral oxygen consump- tion, cardiac output and blood pressure of normal young men, J. Clin. Invest. 2£s 10?, 1946. 8. Kety, S, S, and C, F. Schmidt 1 Effects of altered arterial tensions of carbon dioxide and oxygen on cerebral blood flow and cerebral oxygen consumption of normal young men. J. Clin, Invest. 22, 484, 1948. 9. Eckenhoff, J, E,, J, H# Hafkenschiel, M, H, Hamel, rf» T. Goodale, M. Lubin, R, J, Bing, and S# S. Kety: Measurement of coronary blood flow by the nitrous oxide method. Am, J. Physiol. 152; 356, 194a. 7 10, Spencer, F. C., S, R, Pa,vers, D. L. Merrill, and R. J, Bing: Coronary blood flow and cardiac oxygen consumption in unanes- thetized dogs. J. Clin. Invest. In Press. 11. Bing, R. J., M. M. Hammond, J, C. Kandelsman, S. R. Powers, F. C, Spencer, J. E. Sckenhoff, W. T. Goodale, J. F. Hafkenschiel, and S, S. Kety: The measurement of coronary blood flow, oxygen consumption and efficiency of the left ventricle in man. Am. Heart J. 23i 1, 1949 12. Kety, S, S, et al.s Solubility of nitrous oxide in brain. J. Biol Chem. XD.1 487, 1948. 13, Dunke, P. R. and C. F. Schmidt: Quantitative measurements of cerebral blood flow in the macacque monkey. Am. J, Physiol, 138: 421, 1943. 14. Goodale, W, T,, M, Lubin, J, S. Eckenhoff, J, H. Hafkenschiel, and V/. G. Banfield, Jr,: Coronary sinus catheterization for studying coronary blood flow and myocardial metabolism. Am. J, Physiol. 152: 340, 1948. 15# Sckenhoff, J. E,, J. H. Hafkenschiel, C, U, Landmesser, and M. Hamel: Cardiac oxygen metabolism and control of the coronary circulation. Am. J. Physiol. 149: 634, 1947. 16, Crittenden, S. G,, Jr, and R, E, Shipley: Electronic recording flowmeter. Rev, Scient, Instr. 343, 1944. 17. Shipley, R. E. and E. C, Crittenden, Jr.: Optical recording rotameter for measuring blood flow, Proc, Soc. Exper. Biol, and Med. £6: 103, 1944. 18, Oregg, 0, E, and H, D, Green: Registration and interpretation of normal phasic inflow into left coronary artery by an improved differential raanometric method. >im. J. Physiol, 130: 114, 1940. 19. Orcutt, F. S, and R. M, Waters: Method for determination of cyclopropane, ethylene and nitrous oxide in blood with Van Slyke- Neill manometric apparatus. d. Biol, Ohem. 117s 509, 1937. 20. Kety, S. S,: The quantitative determination of cerebral blood flow in man. Methods in Med, Research, Vol. I, Year Book Publishers, Chicago, 21. Oregg, Donald E.i Studies of the venous drainage of the heart. Am. d. Physiol. 151: 13, 1947. 8 f ■ SC : A V ‘fi.v.N 3F .. 'RANGEt/ENT OF APPARATUS FOR MEASURING CORONARY FLOW BY THE 9 FIG. 2. REPRODUCTION OF ORIGINAL RECORD FROM TYPICAL EXPERIMENT SHOWING MEAN FLOW AND MEAN 8L00D PRESSURE IN DOG WITH LARGE LEFT CORONARY INFLOW. (0 FIC. 3. GRAPH OF NITROUS OXIDE SATURATION CURVE FROM SAME EXPERIMENT AS IN FIG. 2. 11 EXP. BODY WT. HEART WT. HEART WT. LEFT COR. ART. INJECTED WITH 0.5% EVANS BLUE DYE LEFT HEART LEFT HEART NO. KG M. GM. % OF BODY WT. DYED HEART GM. UNDYED* HEART GM. DYED HEART % OF TOTAL HEART GM. % OF TOTAL HEART COMMENTS EE672 1 7 i 1 7,6 0.69 96.9 20.7 82.0 87.2 74.0 LEFT COR. ART. INJECTED POST MORTEM. EE674 1 6 177.8 1.1 148.3 29.5 83.0 128.5 72.0 LEFT COR. ART. INJECTED POST MORTEM. EE676 I 6 137,3 0.86 1 13.0 24.3 82.0 103,8 75.0 LEFT COR. ART INJECTED POST MORTEM EE678 t 0 87.3 0.87 65,0 22 3 77.0 ,67.3 77.0 RIGHT AND LEFT COR, ART. INJECTED AT EQUAL PRESSURES POST MCRT, EE679 1 2 102,6 0.85 80.5 22 . 1 79.0 70.8 69.0 RIGHT AND LEFT COR ART. INJECTED AT EQUAL PRESSURES POST MORT, EE679 1 0 76.8 0.77 63.8 13.0 83.0 59. 1 76.0 RIGHT AND LEFT COR..ART, INJECTED AT EQUAL PRESSURES POST MCRT. EE680 20 149.2 0.74 117.7 3 1.5 78.0 1 i 0.0 74.0 RIGHT AND LEFT COR. ART iNuECTED AT EQUAL PRESSURES POST MOR~ EE682 24 172 1 0.72 140,4 3 1 7 8 i .0 127.9 74 0 LEFT COR. ART. INJECTED ANTE MORTEM. EE683 113.0 i .0 93.8 19 2 83.0 85 3 75.5 RIGHT AND LEFT COR ART INJECTED AT EQUAL PRESSURES POST MORT EE685 1 6 151.6 0,94 I 17.0 34,6 7 7.0 1 1 5.5 76.0 LEFT COR. ART INJECTED POST MORT. E E686 ! 7 160.8 0 .94 136,0 2 4.8 64 0 125.8 78 0 LEFT COR ART. INJECTED ANTE MORT EE6S8 ! 3 95.9 0.74 77 2 24. 1 80.5 72.8 75.8 RIGHT AND LEFT COR. ART. INJECTED AT EQUAL PRESSURES POST MORT EE69I 18 116.0 0.65 92.4 23.6 79.6 86.2 74,3 LEFT COR. ART. INJECTED ANTE MORT, EE692 1 7 138.2 0.81 1 1 2,8 25.4 62.0 . 103.3 74.6 LEFT COR.ART INJECTED ANTE MORT. 1 5 5 0.83 103.9 — 24,8 |8i.5 96.0 7 4.7 PERCENTAGE OF HEART STAINED FOLLOWING INJECTION OF LEFT CORONARY ARTERY ••'UMOVED, OR THAT PORTION DYED BY INJECTING RIGHT CORONARY ARTERY. '' .EFT HEART = lEFT VENTRICLE. LEFT ATRIUM, AND TOTAL SEPTUM, TABLE I 12 MEAN LEFT CORONARY BLOOD FLOW PER MINUTE EXP. [blood PRES- SURE N20 ROTAMETER/DYED heart rotameter/left heart-* COMMENTS NO. cc/lOOgm cc/IOOgm N20-R0T.xI00 cc/100 gm N20-R0T.xI00 m rr,. Hg ROT, ROT. EE 667 86 57.8 (S) 49.6 + 16.2 £ E 6 6 8 105 87.6 (S) 7 4.4 + 17.7 EE674 75 79,6 (S) 63.0 + 26.0 72.0 + 10.5 EE680 92 99.4 (S) 9 1.7 + 8.4 9 8.2 + 1.2' EE682 77 73.3 (S) 72.0 + 1 .8 7 9,0 - 7.2 SALINE 25 cc.; EPINEPHRINE 1.5 cc. OF 1; 1000 DURING TEST PERIOD. EE685 100 94.4 (S) 8 0.6 + 14.5 84.2 + 9.7 EE686 62 67,9 (S.) 68.5 - 0.9 7 4.0 - 8.2 1 cc. C0RAM1NE; 50 cc. WHOLE BLOOD DURING TEST PERIOD. EES8 7 65 60 64 4 (S) 47.2 (D) 78.0 52.0 - 17.5 ‘ - 9.2 (88 62.2 (S) 6 5.0 - 4 6 FIBRILLATION WITH REVIVAL PRIOR EE689 TO TEST PERIOD. (93 80.2 (D) 73.0 + 9.6 N20 (D) CALCULATED AT 8 MINUTES. EE690 45 50 54,0 (S) 78.0(D) 36.0 52.2 + 50.0 + 50.0 EE69 I 95 103.0 (S) 106.5 - 3,0 11 4.1 + 9.7 • 105 15 i.O(D) 130.0 + 16.0 1 39.2 + 8,4 EE692 75 98,0 (S) 82.3 + *9,5 89.4 + 9.6 75 65 4 (D) 53.4 + 22 5 58.3 + 12.0 AVG. 8 1.0** 88.6-*-** 73.6 84.7 * LEFT HEART* LEFT VENTRICLE , LEFT ATRIUM, TOTAL SEPTUM, ** EXCLUDING THE FIRST TWO N20 VALUES. *** USING ONLY THOSE N20 VALUES WHICH COR RESPOND TO ROTAMETER FLOW S = N20 SATURATION CURVE VALUES BASED ON LEFT HEART WEIGHT. D* N20 DESATURATtON CURVE COMPARISON OF NITROUS OXIDE FLOW VALUES WITH ROTAMETER FLOW VALUES BASED ON DYED HEART AND LEFT HEART TABLE H 13