THE ORIGIN, Nature and Treatment of Fever, IN THE LIGHT OF MODERN PHYSIOLOGY. BY CH. RAUSCHENBERG, M.D, ATLANTA, GEORGIA. REPRINTED FROM THE ATLANTA MEDICAL AND SURGICAL JOURNAL. ATLANTA, GEORGIA: Herald Publishing Company’s Steam Press. 1873. THE ORIGIN, Nature and Treatment of Fever, IN THE LIGHT OF MODERN PHYSIOLOGY. BY OH. RAUSCHENBERG, M.H., ATLANTA, GEORGIA. REPRINTED FROM THE ATLANTA MEDICAL AND SURGICAL JOURNAL ATLANTA, GEORGIA: Herald Publishing Company’s Steam Press. 1873. THE ORIGIN, NATURE AND TREATMENT OE FEYER, XX THE LIGHT OF MODERN PHYSIOLOGY. Tile changes which have gradually taken place during the last twenty or twenty-five years in the views and conceptions of the medical profession of Europe, and particularly of Germany, in relation to the causation and nature of the febrile process, and the fundamental principles governing its treatment, have as yet—if my intercourse with medical men, and my acquaintance with the current medical literature of this country, enable me to judge correctly—obtained but a very limited recognition on the part of the profession at large in Georgia, and perhaps elsewhere throughout this country, and have not yet exercised any marked influence on the current of thought, and the thera- peutical action of medical practitioners generally, in relation to this subject. If this observation is not entirely incorrect, it will explain why I bring this old but important matter, in its new physiological relations and pathological features, to the consideration of the profession.* The pathological process commonly called fever has, more than any other one, engaged the general attention of the medi- cal world since the days of Hippocrates. Its name, from the Latin “febris,” and the Greek “piiretos,” heat, indicates plainly that the ancients had already recognized unusual heat of the * A synopsis of this paper was read before the Georgia Medical Association, at its meeting in this city, last April, but was not published in the Transactions, as the author was unavoidably prevented from finishing it in due time. C. R. 4 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. body as its most prominent and most constant symptom, and when Hippocrates advocated the doctrine of critical days and critical phenomena in fevers, as manifestations of the internal process of coction by which the morbid substances were grad- ually prepared and fitted up for elimination from the system, he already sowed the seed which, two thousand years later, ripened into the views of von Helmont, Sydenham, Stahl, Booer- have and others, who looked upon fever as an increased activity of the vital process, as a curative effort of nature intended to reestablish health, or in their own words, as : “Instrumentum naturee, quo partes impuras a purls secernat” (Sydenham); or as “actum vitalem motorium, secretorium et excretorium mediante quo proesentes queedam noxce removeantur” (Stahl.) It would be an easy matter to fill pages with a recapitulation of the many theories which have since then been developed and entertained by different medical authorities. De Haen, Cullen, Brown, Pieil, Pinel, Broussais, Schoenlein, and others, have advanced more or less abstract—Henle, Stilling, Wunder- lish, and others, more exact neuropathic—doctrines on the origin of fever, based upon the physiological discoveries of Bell, Muller, and Marshal Hall. A consideration of these or the still later observations and views of Claude Bernard, Ttschet- chechin, Traube, etc., on the same subject, seeking to establish, as a cause of fever, a morbid depression of the nerve-centers, regulating the production of caloric within the organism, falls beyond the limits of this paper, which is only intended to em- brace those points relating to genesis, nature, and treatment of fever, which have—as far as its author is able to judge—the greatest weight of evidence in favor of their correctness and are most generally accepted at the present period of time. The prominent merit of all pathological investigations of the present day consists in the persistent effort to base all our con- ceptions upon physiological and anatomical observations and facts, and to define morbid phenomena as perceptible changes of function, and, if possible, as tangible changes of structure of definite elements, parts, or spheres of the system, necessa- rily resulting from the operations of the laws of life under cer- tain abnormal influences. When we undertake to analyze the abnormal organic process of life, which we call fever, in its most general sense—not as a Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 5 specific disease, or species of fever, but as the most frequent result and manifestation of morbid impressions upon the hu- man organization—we should very cautiously distinguish per- manent and important from accidental and unimportant, primary from secondary, and coordinate from subordinate occurrences. Phenomena which exist in every case of febrile excitement as primary effects of the cause and coordinate to each other are : Acute hypercemia of the capillaries of the entire system, with expan- sion of their volume, redness and heed of the surface and tissues gen- erally, and a more or less marked general increase of the tempera- ture of the body above the normal standard, connected and seemingly depending upon an increased activity of the heart and arteries A These are the constant and the essential pathognomonic marks of fever; but as the degree and uniformity of their develop- ment depend, like the normal circulation, upon the quantity and the quality of the blood and the irritability of the nervous system, in each case the production of caloric as well as the degree of vascular excitement and capillary hyperaemia will, in different cases, exhibit different grades of development, and these again will be grouped together in various combinations. In debilitated and anaemic individuals with weak and frequent contractions of the heart, as the normal condition, febrile ex- citement will often cause only very moderate elevation of tem- perature, and lessen, for a time, the frequency and increase the force of the heart’s action. In extreme cases of that kind, and in the last stages of long-continued fevers, the frequency of the pulse will be very great; but the production of heat, from want of material, so small that the degree of bodily temperature, while it is still relatively higher than it would be without the fever, may not reach the normal temperature of the body, but without a relative or absohde increase of bodily temperature, fever proper, does not exist, and the very essence of fever consists in an in- creased metamorphosis of the organic material of the body. The disengagement of latent heat in nature takes place, in a large number of chemical processes, in consequence of the me- chanical rearrangement of the molecules constituting the sub- stances engaged in action. In men and higher animals, be- cause their organisms consist principally of oxydizable material, * Spiess’ Patkologische Pkysologie. See chapter on Fever. 6 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. and the oxygen of the atmospheric air is in constant and direct contact with them, the production of animal heat is principally, but not exclusively the result of that specific chemical process called oxydation, which takes place partly within the blood, partly within the tissues, simultaneously with their metamor- phosis, and in close proximity to the capillaries, which furnish oxygen and nutritive material on the one hand, and remove carbonic acid and waste products on the other. The question arises now, How is this increased metamorphosis of tissue, this increased oxygenation and combustion, primarily occasioned? Do the first causes of it originate in the blood or in the nervous system, and what is their nature? Tbe experiments of Billroth,-' Bergmant and others, have proven beyond a doubt that the introduction of foreign sub- stances into the blood produces increased oxydation within it and the tissues, or, what is the same, fever. Distilled water, healthy blood, blood serum, the blood of fever patients, pus, putrid substances, pure pepsin, have been used for this purpose, and an increase of the temperature of the test animals, more or less considerable, and of longer or shorter duration, has in- variably been recognized after these injections. In traumatic fevers, pyaemia, septicaemia, etc., the presence of foreign sub- stances in the blood has almost become a certainty, and in the contagious, or so-called zymotic or catalytic diseases (measles, scarlatina, variola,) whose specific virus seems to be infinitesi- mally multiplied during the duration of the disease, like yeast during the process of fermentation, the introduction of a spe- cific poison into the blood as the first cause of the disease can not be denied. These foreign substances, disturbing the morphological in- tegrity and life of the blood—whether they be malaria or con- tagion from the outside world, mere molecular detritus, puru- lent or septic material from a hearth of inflammation, from a tuberculous or scrofulous deposit, from the surface of an un- healthy wound, or the mere stagnating contents of the capil- laries of a bruised finger, or abnormally retained secretory and excretory matter—are the primary instigators of the increased * Billroth and Pitha, Cliirurgie, p. 599, 1865. t Das putride Gift, die putride Intoxication. Petersburger Med. Zeitschrift Band, 1, 1868. Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 7 oxygenation within the blood and tissues, which we call fever. Where is the physician who, in course of his medical experi- ence has not arrived at the firm conviction that every functional derangement, interfering—to use the most comprehensive lan- guage—with the preparation or resorption of the nutritive, or the elimination of effete materials, consequently with the form- ation and maintainance of a normally composed blood, is one of the common causes of fever? If we frequently notice in com- paratively healthy persons a slight acceleration of the pulse, a flushed countenance, a hot surface, or, in other words, a slight febrile excitement after dinner, in all probability caused by an increased afflux of rich chyle, almost as a physiological process, we can not resist the conclusion that quantitative and qualitative deviations of the material furnished to the blood for the 'performance of its physiological functions, or the presence of foreign substances within it, disturbing them, are the principal and primary causes of fever. Does this view deserve the reproach of favoring a faulty humoral pathology, which attaches undue importance to the condition of the blood in fever and forgets the influence of the nervous system in its causation? It appears to the humble writer that this reproach would be just if the blood was a fluid, fully perfected by the process of digestion, undergoing no farther changes but quantitative con- sumption for the nutrition of the body. This, however, is not the case. Oxygen, new material from the lacteals of the ali- mentary canal, worn-out matter from the tissues, are continually received by it, and are, under the influences of chemical affini- ties, engaged—the former, in a process of progressive, the latter, in one of retrograde metamorphosis. Thus the blood under- goes continually a series of complicated but regularly estab- lished chemical changes, preparing on the one hand materials for the nutrition and growth of the different tissues, on the other, material for elimination and removal by the different secretory and excretory organs, and simultaneously developing and sustaining its own cell-life, and morphological constituents. Taking into consideration the multiplicity of physiological processes in the system, upon which the supply and preparation, the quantity and quality of the material needed for the normal progress of chemical metamorphosis and blood-life depends, 8 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. the frequency of blood-changes, from the very slightest degree of physiological abnormity to the highest grades of blood- poisoning, and with them the frequent occurrence of all grades of febrile excitement of shorter or longer duration, is easily un- derstood. Thus increased oxydation within the blood and tissues, “fever,” is always primarily caused by a disturbance of the normal blood-life, the normal development of the blood within itself by the introduction or retention of more or less noxious substances within it, which interfere with its morpho- logical or chemical integrity, or both. This is the first and primary occurrence ; changed innervation caused by and pro- gressing in direct proportion with this blood-change, the sec- ondary one in all fevers. In idiopathic fevers the noxious sub- stance finds its way into the blood directly from the outside world, and causes primarily a morbid condition of the same; in symptomatic fevers a local pathological condition within the organism—for instance, a local inflammation—furnishes this sub- stance,* and the abnormal state of the blood and the fever are secondary phenomena. Let us now inquire, What portion of the nervous system partici- pates principally and primarily, next to the first cause, (the morbid change of the blood) in the further development of the febrile process? t General hypercemia, expansion and fullness of the capillaries, increased temperature of the body, with frequent and often full pulse, the pathological symptoms of the febrile process, do most positively indicate a general excitement of that portion of the nervous system which presides over the action of the heart and blood vessels, and which controls the circulation and regulates the metamorphosis of tissue and the production of animal heat, to-wit: the ganglia and vaso-motor fbres of the sympathetic system. By their degree and mode of activity the conditions are created, in the volume of the blood vessels and the frequency and strength of the contractions of the heart, w'hicli restrict or increase the results of the chemical affinity between the free oxygen always present in the blood of the capillaries and the organic tissues susceptible of oxydation. The ganglionic system consists principally of motor fibres. *See The Genesis of Acute and Chronic Inflammation, by Dr. S. Samuel. Atlanta Medical and Surgical Journal, January, 1873, p. 590. f Spiess’ Pathologische Physiologie, p. 97, etc. Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 9 The sympathetic fibres of the heart, the motory fibres of the stomach and alimentary canal, and also the motory fibres of the blood vessels, excite respectively the muscles of the heart, of the intestines, the smooth muscular fibres of the arteries, and the contractile fibres of the capillary walls in the same manner as the cerebro-spinal motory fibres excite those of the voluntary muscles over which they preside; but they do not re- ceive their impulses for motory action from one general center, like the cerebro-spinal nerves, but generally direct and imme- diately at the locality where their action becomes manifest. It can not be denied that the action of the heart and arteries can be influenced from the cerebro-spinal centers by the agency of the nerve ganglia, from which the nerves of the heart originate; but the fact that the normal action of the heart takes place in- dependent of the influence of the cerebro-spinal system is just as well established. A frog’s heart continues its rythmic action even after having been separated from the body. The action of the smooth muscular fibres of the stomach and intestines, the contractions of the womb, of the bladder, of the contractile ducts of excretory glands, are almost without a doubt depend- ent upon the mechanical irritation of their ganglionic nerves and nerve-centers alone, by their accumulating contents. So is the contraction of the muscular fibres of the skin excited by the impressions of the cold atmosphere, and the contractions of the capillaries and arteries, and of the heart, by the irritation produced by the living blood which they contain. Oxygenized blood of a certain temperature is the indispensable requisite for the action of the heart and blood vessels in higher animals and in men. While the anatomical connections of the ganglia amongst themselves and with the cerebro-spinal system, and their mutual influence and dependence upon each other, the existence of localities within the medulla oblongata, spinal marrow, and pneumogastric nerve, which, when irritated or destroyed, pro- duce respectively increased or decreased action of the heart or tone of the vessels, is by no means denied—as an absolute inde- pendence of any one portion of the system does not exist in any living organism—a relative but very marked independence and isolation of the sympathetic nerve and its ganglia from each other, and also from the cerebro-spinal centers, is claimed as a charactei- 10 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. istic feature of this system of nerves, and as an essential ele- ment for the correct comprehension of its physiological and pathological manifestations. If we now inquire how such a general state of excitement of the entire vaso-motor system, as exists in the febrile process, can be brought about, wTe must necessarily come to the conclusion that an entire province of nerves can only be affected—1. Either by irritation of its general center and the uniform and simultaneous diffusion of the same to all its peripheric branches: or 2. By a uni- form and simultaneous irritation of all the branches ivithin their per- ipheric course and extension. One common center of the ganglionic system of nerves, from which all its parts and functions are simultaneously, and in the same manner influenced, has not yet been discovered, and its ex- istence, from many reasons, is quite improbable. The very safety of the organism forbids such an arrangement in a system of nerves, which provides for the supply of the different organs and all the different parts of the body with nutritive material. If such a center existed, or if all the vaso-motor nerves were alike subservient to impressions from the brain and spinal mar- row, the nutrition of the different organs and parts of the sys- tem, which is exclusively presided over by that.system, would be much more subject to general disturbances and not so often confined to single organs. If the vaso-motor nerves of the organism can not be excited from one common center, the cause of the irritation which pro- duces febrile excitement must be generally diffused throughout the entire organism in such manner that it remains in immedi- ate and permanent contact with all the vaso-motor nerves simul- taneously. The blood alone, and particularly the blood within the capil- lary system, comes in immediate and permanent contact with the vaso-motor nerves—and therefore only blood deviating from the healthy condition in some manner—and its influence on the peripheric extremities of the vaso-motor nerves can, primarily, occasion that excited condition of the entire system of vasb- motor nerves upon which the febrile process depends. The simultaneous influence of such a morbidly changed blood upon the different ganglionic centers, as well as the centers of the cerebro-spinal system, through which it flows, can not be de- Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 11 nied, as many of tlie different phenomena accompanying differ- ent kinds and types of fever, are produced by this influence; but the essential phenomenon of fever—the morbidly exalted organico-chemical process and the subsequent morbid produc- tion of caloric and the characteristic changes in the capillary circulation — are primarily excited by the direct influence of a morbidly altered blood, upon the peripheric vaso-motor nerves. The view that fever, although its first cause might be in the blood, could only be caused by the intermediate action of the brain, and particularly the spinal marrow, has been frequently advocated, but not well sustained. Phenomena which originate from the cerebro-spinal axis, bear a very different character in their manifestations from that of fever. They are generally very changeable as to intensity, duration and locality, and do not exhibit the regular uniform character of the febrile pio- cess, and indeed the most intense diseases of the substance of the brain and spinal marrow, unless they be inflammations, run their course positively without any fever. The general, uniform and. permanent abnormities of the circulation and production of caloric 'peculiar to fever can, therefore, only be successfully explained by the existence of a cause within the blood, in continued contact with the peripheric vaso-motor nerves, which stimulates the latter into morbid activity as long as it remains there. The heat, the hypermmia of the capillaries and the increased action of the heart characterizing fever are the immediate con- sequences of the increased activity of the vaso-motor nervous system, and their degree of manifestation depends upon the quantity of blood, its supply with oxygen, the condition of the structures of the heart and blood vessels, and the irritability of these nerves and the nervous system generally. According to the quality and quantity of the blood and the degree of irrita- bility of the nervous system or the manner in which these different conditions may be grouped together in different indi- viduals, we meet with sthenic and asthenic, erethic and torpid, cases of fever and their different grades and combinations. But not only the phenomena of the hot stage of fever—if we take a regular paroxysm of intermittent fever as the most per- fect and uncomplicated representation of the febrile process— but all others are alike susceptible of rational explanation by this increased action of the vaso-motor system of nerves. 12 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. Every irritation of the vaso-motor nerves causes first a contrac- tion of the blood vessels, a vascular spasm, folloiced by dilatation. The symptoms of the cold stage are fully explained by this fact. The contractile fibres of the cutaneous tissues, in consequence of the suspension of their normal turgor, the tempory anaemia and loss of caloric connected with it, contract, and therefore the surface of the body first appears cold—so much more so as external atmospheric impressions act, under these circumstances, as additional irritants. Thus the manifestations of the increased action of the vaso-motor nerves is counteracted for a time, and the symptoms at the commencement of a febrile paroxysm appa- rently contradict the idea of increased vaso-motor action and increased production of heat. As this contraction of the skin, under the continued impression of the fever-cause, yields, and as its capillaries cease to be contracted, the skin receives grad- ually more and more blood, the action of the heart becomes more and more free and unimpeded, the skin more and more hyperjemic, and the increased metamorphosis and increased production of heat are more and more developed, and become more distinctly perceptible. These phenomena, however, do not reach the highest degree of intensity as long as the existing cause of irritation of the vaso-motor nerves prompts the arteries to increased contraction. This contraction, so perceptible in the tense pulse of the hot stage, is only gradually overcome by the active hypenumia, the increased impetus of the heart, the increased organico-chemical process, and the increased metamorphosis in the tissues. In consequence of the latter, an abnormal consumption of the water of the solid and liquid constituents of the body is established, and with it the thirst so characteristic in fever. Again, in con- sequence of this deficiency of wrater, and of the still imperfect relaxation and expansion of the capillaries, the secretions and excretions continue to appear restricted; while, in reality, with the increased metamorphosis and combustion in the tissues, they have also increased, but their products are retained within the blood of the different organs. With the decrease of the exalted, vaso-motor action, the liypercemia of the capillaries reaches its highest degree, because, while the stormy action of the heart ceases only gradually, no obstacle obstructs, at the periphery of the circulation, any longer the Origin, Nature and Treatment of lever, etc. 13 wave of the blood current, and the exalted organico-chemical process in the tissues still continues awhile, in gradually decreas- ing strength, to attract and to consume more than the normal quantity of blood. With this stage of the fever, when the irritation of the vaso- motor nerves has ceased, and an entire relaxation of the walls of the capillaries and arteries has been established, the secre- tions and excretions show necessarily a considerable increase in quantity generally, as well as in the relative amount of their characteristic constituents—for instance, urea in the urine—be- cause now the products of the febrile metamorphosis are re- moved from the blood by the different secretory and excretory organs. Thus the name “sweating stage,” for this period of fevers is certainly not very proper, as all excretory organs are in the same physiological condition, and engaged in the same manner as the excretory apparatus of the skin, whose action, in all probability, is not of the same general importance in the removal of the febrile products as that of the kidneys. A more rational, uniform, and harmonious explanation of all the phenomena of fever in their regular course of occurrence as the theory advanced in the preceding pages furnishes, the writer has not been able to find anywhere else, but in the ad- mirable work of Dr. G. A. Spiess, Physiological Pathology,* from which the above views wTere principally taken, but which, unfortunately, with its rich treasures of pathological truths on all the subjects of medicine, has not yet been translated into the English language. Many other theories in relation to the agency of the nervous system in the production of the febrile process, very different from the one advocated in the preceding pages, have been ad- vanced. They are all based upon isolated physiological observ- ations appertaining to the influences of certain portions of the nervous system on the circulation of the blood. It is evident that this, with its many different phenomena—such as frequency of pulse, degree of blood pressure in the heart and arteries, velocity of the blood current itself—is dependent upon various more or less important nerve influences, emanating not only * Physiologische Pathologie, von Dr. G. A. Spiess. 14 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. from the sympathetic, but also from the cerebro-spinal portions of the nervous system. While the ganglionic centers and vaso- motor nerve fibres preside primarily and directly over the action of the muscular fibres of these organs, and while, without the presence of normal blood within the capillaries of the heart and the blood vessels, as the peripheric stimulants of their ganglia and vaso-motor nerve fibres, no cerebro-spinal influ- ences can affect these organs, the facts that division or paralysis of the vagus, or an irritation of the cervical portion of the sym- pathetic or medulla oblongata, exercise a controlling influence over the action of the heart and arteries—in the former case increasing, in the latter one decreasing, the frequency of their contractions — and that irritation of the medulla oblongata causes an increase in the tonicity and an abnormal contraction of the finer arteries—hence backward blood-pressure in the larger ones, and in the heart, etc.—are too well established by numer- ous experiments to be denied. They only demonstrate the great complicity of the process of blood-circulation, and therefore the fact that various nerve in- fluences may, in the course of the development of the febrile process become successively instrumental in fully establishing or modifying this morbid condition ; but they do not furnish a more rational basis for the interpretation of its morbid phe- nomena, nor disprove the fact that the vast system of vaso- motor nerves, in immediate contact with all blood vessels, is the first recipient of all morbid impressions arising within its most natural physiological stimulant, the blood, and that the febrile process takes its origin prominently and primarily within that portion of the nervous system, affecting the cerobro-spinal centers only secondarily. Thus, fever originates in more or less intense blood-changes, and its degree, character, and duration depend primarily upon the quantity, quality, and duration of the fever cause. A morbidly increased, general oxygenation and disintegra- tion of the blood and tissues—a general morbid increase of the metamorphosis within the human system—primarily the result of peripheric vaso-motor irritation by the abnormal Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 15 blood, and characterized, by an increased temperature of the body, constitute the essence of the febrile process. Irritation of any other part of the nervous system can not directly produce fever. The manifold and often grave cerebo- spinal disturbances of hysteria, for instance, may, through the brain and spinal marrow, produce functional abnormities of the vaso-motor* system of nerves. A hysterical woman may have a frequent pulse and a flushed countenance, and at the same time a cool skin; hence no fever, because the fever cause within the blood itself is absent. A so-called irritative fever is therefore an untenable pathological conception. Irritation of any portion of the cerebro-spinal system can never produce fever unless it affects the vaso-motor or trophic nerves of an organ of the system by reflex action, in such a manner as to produce local functional derangement or local inflammation, and thereby again chemical or histological alterations in the blood, and thus fever secondarily, in the manner above discussed. The metamorphosis in fever, however, is principally of a retrograde character. The functions of digestion and assimi- lation, in consequence of sympathetic participation of the or- gans by which they are carried on, become deranged at an early stage of the febrile process, and hence, as new material is but scantily furnished, the chemical affinities governing this metamorphosis are principally exercised in a retrograde direc- tion, and the organic material of the system is consumed by an increased production of carbonic acid and water on the one hand, and urea, uric acid, kreatin, etc., on the other. The interpretation of the febrile process of Bocerhave, Syden- ham, Stahl, and others, mentioned in the commencement of this paper, as a salutary and—so to say—physiological effort of nature to eliminate the very substances from the system which have given rise to it, is therefore entitled to a just degree of consideration. Where these noxious substances in the blood, which have in- stigated the fever, are of such a character, that they can be con- verted into excretory matter, and as such or with it removed from the system without causing too high a degree of and too long- continued combustion of the organic material of the system, the febrile process will terminate favorably; where this conver- sion and elimination excites a higher degree of temperature of Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 16 the blood, or larger amount of combustion of material than the system can bear, death takes place before its termination. A correct conception of the degree of the temperature developed in each case of fever, and the degree of the consumptive effect in each case upon the system generally, are, therefore, of the greatest therapeutical importance to the practicing physician. The great clinical importance of abnormal grades of temper- ature in diseases, and the high grades of it in fevers generally, will be more fully comprehended if the following physiological and pathological facts are taken into consideration : The temperature, of the human body in health is the same under all latitudes and in all climates, and this permanency of temperature, is an absolute necessity for the 'normal physiological action of all its elements and organs, and therefore for the continuation of health and life. The average temperature of men taken at the axilla is 98.6 F., or 37° C. The human body must therefore necessarily have the faculty to maintain its specific degree of temperature per- manently, independent of the changes in the temperature of the surrounding medium, and the different quantities of caloric produced within the blood and tissues at different times, or, in other words, the production and loss of caloric of the human system must regulate each other mutually; a high grade of production must always correspond with a high grade of loss, and so vice versa. Any material rise or fall of the bodily tem- perature above or below the normal standard can not exist any length of time without serious danger to the system: 35° C., (95° F.) and 42.5° C. (108.5 F.) are the extreme deviations of tem- perature observed in serious cases of disease; a decrease of 1.5° F., and an increase of 9.9° F., are deviations from the nor- mal standard, which, according to undeniable observations, are almost infallibly connected with the death of the patient. If an increase of about 10° F. is a certain indication of early disso- lution, it is quite reasonable to suppose that the intermediate grades of increase are connected with a corresponding degree of danger. Experience as well as observation support the fact that human blood, as soon as its temperature rises Ixyond the nor- mal degree, begins to undergo histological changes, which make it unfit for healthy nutrition, in direct proportion to the increase of its temperature. Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 17 Schultze* has microscopically demonstrated these changes in their full development on blood heated on an objective table to 50°C., a temperature which the human blood in life never reaches; but his experiments establish beyond a doubt the dis- integrating effect of heat as a physical agent on blood, and that this disintegration commences as soon as its temperature be- gins to ascend beyond the normal degree, is at least a very natural conclusion, and in full accordance with the general ac- tion of all laws of nature. It is also a fact, well established by clinical observation, that the reparative process required for the healing of wounds or ulcers is considerably or entirely suspended by the occurrence of febrile diseases. Liebermeisterf has seen chancroids become phagedenic in individuals who were taken with typhoid fever, and every phy- sician has seen wounds cease to granulate and assume an un- healthy appearance under similar circumstances. The anatomical condition of the different organs of patients who died under the influence of high grades of fever, revealed by the microscope, furnishes, finally, the most conclusive evi- dence of the decomposing and disintegrating effect of the febrile combustion on the tissues, and the plainest explanation of the deleterious influences of high febrile temperatures on the hu- man system. Numerous post-mortem examinations, of fever patients have proven beyond a doubt, that those of them who died under the influence of a high grade of temperature, and they alone, exhib- ited parenchymatous degeneration of the most important or- gans, while those cases where such a high elevation of temper- ature did not occur, were free from them. Thus the cellular elements of the liver are always found more or less plainly degenerated, sometimes entirely decomposed into loose detritus. Similar changes are observed in the kidneys. The heart is unusually loose, flabby, of a paler, grayish yellow or brownish color, and in the primitive muscular fibres, granu- lar opacity, indistinctness of the transverse stripes, and accu- mulation of fat granules are often plainly perceptible. The *See Atlanta. Medical and Surgical Journal, vol. x, page 29G. f Uber die Behandlung cles Fiebers. Volkman’s Klin Yortraege, No. 31, p. 211. 18 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. same changes and also waxy degeneration are often observed in the voluntary muscles. Similar degenerations are noticed in smaller blood vessels, in the substance of the brain, and many other parts of the organism. These changes are spoken of by Prof. B. Virchow, in the 16th chapter of his Cellular Pathology, as the highest grade of nutri- tive irritation (parenchymatous inflammation in his sense of the term) and as processes in which by the increased activity of the cellular elements of different organs an abnormal quantity of nutritive material is attracted but not converted into normal cell-substance, and which therefore terminate either in softening (necrobiosis) or in fatty degeneration. He speaks of them as very frequent and very serious patho- logical conditions, occurring principally in infectious diseases : the acute exanthemata (measles, scarlatina,variola,) typhus, puer- peral and traumatic fevers, phlegmonous and erysipelatous processes, and other blood intoxications. Prof. C. Liebermeister of Basel, one of the most prominent investigators of tempera- ture conditions in health and disease, and an acknowledged authority on these subjects, ascribes the frequent occurrence of these local parenchymatous degenerations in infectious disease, not to their infectious origin, but to the high grades of febrile temperature generally prevailing during their entire course, because these morbid anatomical conditions are alike observed in all cases of disease which terminate fatally, under very high grades of febrile temperature, whether they are of an infectious character or not." This deleterious influence of high febrile temperatures on the tis- sues constitutes one of the great dangers connected with acute febrile diseases per sc, and manifests itself principally, as it disturbs the heart or the cerebro-spinal centers prominently, by two trains of symptoms which terminate respectively in paralysis of the heart or the brain. An increasing frequency and weakness of the pulse, corres- ponding deficiencies of the capillary circulation, hypostatic troubles, cold skin and extremities, with increased internal tem- peratures—symptoms frequently called congestive—mark the former; delirium and versatility, followed by stupor, coma, in- *C. Liebet »iet>ter. Uber die BehancUung des Fiebers. Volkmann’s Samlung Klinischer Voitr.iege, No. 31, 1871. Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 19 sensibility, the latter condition of things, wherever a high febrile temperature continues for a longer time, the disease itself may be scarlatina or erysipelas of the face, pneumonia or acute rheumatism, or any other acute febrile condition. When prac- titioners speak of acute febrile diseases assuming an adynamic or typhoid type, they are generally dealing with the deleterious consequences of high febrile temperatures on the tissues of the heart or nervous centres, and the grave functional distur- bances which follow them. The most malignant forms of these diseases and their fatal terminations or their serious local se- quelae—for instance, the occasional malignancy of scarlatina, erysipelas, etc.—are caused by these structural degenerations of important organs. An acquaintance with these occurrences and their dependence upon high febrile temperatures is of great diagnostic and therapeutical importance. It demonstrates to the practitioner the great value of thermometrical observations in all febrile and inflammatory diseases, and the great necessity of controlling the temperature of the body in fevers in order to prevent the occurrence of these conditions, and enables him, finally, to explain severe circulatory and cerebral disturbances frequently without resorting to the supposition of meningeal inflammation or uraemic intoxication, etc. Another not less serious danger, directly resulting from the in- creased combustion and matamorphosis constituting the febrile 'pro- cess per se, consists in the morbid consumption of the organic mate- rial of the body and its subsequent depressing influences on the func- tions of the brain and nervous system. Every fever is a consump- tive process, and deserves more or less the name of a hectic fever. While in acute febrile diseases the high grade of febrile tem- perature causes the parenchymatous degeneration of important organs, in low continued fevers the long duration of a less ex- cessive febrile temperature sets up a waste of tissue material, which will destroy life in due time as certain as the former con- dition. A correct appreciation of the therapeutical importance of these pathological facts, the unavoidable results of the very na- ture of the febrile process per se, independent of its specific character, its local origin or complications,has initiated the most essential advances of modern clinical medicine in the treatment 20 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. of febrile diseases. It has taught the profession to recognize, by the use of the medical thermometer, the difference between a febrile condition, which is destitute of danger and will termi- nate in health, and one which, in cod sequence of the high or too long-continued febrile temperature, consumption and disin- tegration of organic material, excludes the possibility of the continuation of the various processes of life, and has estab- lished : reduction and control of high febrile temperatures as the most prominent and most important general indication in the treat- ment of all febrile conditions. The necessity for a more exact measurement of febrile tem- peratures than the mere subjective sensation of the observer can furnish, has been felt for a considerable length of time, and De Haen, J. Currie, and other isolated investigators have al- ready used the thermometer for that purpose. The clinical importance of a knowdedge of the physiological laws by which the production and consumption of caloric in the human sys- tem is governed in health and in disease has also been appre- hended, and numerous physiologists and pathologists—Sancto- rious, of Padua, De Haen, of Yienna, Ch. Martin and Hunter, in England, Lavoisier and Laplace, in Prance, James Currie and others—have investigated and published their physiological ob- servations on this subject; but the introduction of regular ther- mometrical measurements of the temperature in diseases as an important auxiliary measure in establishing a correct knowledge of each case, its prognosis and treatment belongs to the very latest period of time. Andral, Rogers, Demarquay, and others, have, since 1840, paved the way by valuable observations in this direction, but Derensprung, Traube, and most prominently, "Wunderlich, of Germany, are the real founders of clinical thermometry. The latter, more than any one else, has established the use of the medical thermometer as an indispensable necessity to arrive at a correct understanding of the prognosis, nature and treatment of febrile diseases, and has elevated thermometry to an im- portant branch of pathology and therapeutics. The doubts existing in the minds of many physicians yet as to the practical value of thermometry will be dispelled if they will take the pains of studying J Wunderlich’s and Seguin’s Medical Ther- mometry, published by Wood & Co., New York, 1871. Wuuder- Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 21 lich, on page 25 of that book, calls thermometry: An objective physical method of investigation which gives, earlier than all other methods, a more accurate and delicate measure of the changes in the organism, which may be graphically expressed by traces, or numerically by figures, and says : “ Thermometry is a part of our method of diagnosis or observation of disease, indispensable where temperature varies, useful in doubtful cases, and auxiliary in almost every case. A medical attendant whb undertakes to decide a case of fever or febrile disease without hioiving the fads of thermometry is like a blind man trying to find his way in an unknown locality.” This expression may sound harsh and perhaps extreme, par- ticularly to those w7ho are yet practicing medicine without ever using a thermometer; but an observer like Wunderlich, who studied 25,000 cases thermometricallv, and made careful records within their history of several millions of single thermometrical observations before he published his work, has a right to speak definitely on the subject. It is beyond the reach of this paper, which considers only the general pathology and treatment of the febrile process, to enter into detailed statements of the many important data which this late field of observation has furnished in relation to differential diagnosis, prognosis and treatment of various forms of febrile diseases. It is, however, one of the objects of it to impress the fact upon the mind of the profession that febrile diseases cannot be treated rationally and in harmony with the principles of modern pathology without the aid of the medical thermometer and an acquaintance with the facts of thermometry, because only that instrument enables the practi- tioner to ascertain the degree of fever and the amount of dan- ger connected with it. It is the measure by which the time when, and the degree of energy and perseverance can be determined with which, the now accepted antifebrile fneasures should be used for the prevention or amelioration of the above discussed dangers of fever, better than by all the other symptoms together, although no intelligent practitioner should, on that account, neglect a careful consideration of the condition of every part and function of the organism and the relationship and influence, which they mutually occupy to, and exercise upon, each other. Thus the thermometer is as great an aid to the physician and 22 Origin, Nature and, Treatment of Fever, etc. furnishes him as unmistakable indications in the treatment of disease as the compass does to the mariner, and its introduction into the practice of medicine has been and will continue to be followed by alike important and beneficial results. The most important general indication in the treatment of the febrile process has already been defined as: reduction and control of the temperature according to the data furnished by ther- mometrical measurement. This is the only indication which can be obtained by a care- ful study of the general pathology of that morbid process, and therefore a discussion of the question by what modes of treat- ment, and by what remedies it can directly be fulfilled, will form the only therapeutical consideration of this paper. The most direct anti-febrile or—as it is now more frequently designated—anti-pyretic mode of treatment consists in the ap- plication of cold water to the hot body of the fever patient by which a portion of its caloric is consumed and withdrawn. Physicians have in all ages, governed by the desire of their patients for cool drinks, cool air, etc., been more or less inclined to use cooling remedies, frequently, however, more for the com- fort of the patient than with a view of obtaining marked thera- peutical results. The application of cold water or ice to the head was, until quite recently, the most energetic remedy ever used for the purpose of reducing heat, and very few physicians would have ventured to use cold applications to the thorax o abdomen in [fevers, much less systematic reduction of the febrile temperature by frequent immersions of the entire body into cold baths. James Currie, an English physician, was the first who, near the end of the last century, used and introduced the systematic treatment of febrile diseases by cold water for the purpose of reducing the febrile temperature. His method found some suc- cessful imitators; but was soon forgotten. Priesnitz and his followers, the founders of the hydropathic treatment par excellence, used cold water for almost any other purpose but that of simply* reducing the temperature of the body, and very few physicians, during the first half of our cen- tury, had any confidence in its use in febrile conditions. It was reserved to Dr. Ernst Brandt, of Stettin, Germany, to rehabili- tate this method by his work on the treatment of typhoid fever. Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 28 Since that time it has gained ground rapidly, and has been extensively used and carefully studied by numbers of the most prominent pathologists of Germany. Bartels and Juergensen, of Kiel, Liebermeister, of Basel, Wunderlich, of Leipsic, Gerhardt, of Jena, Drasche, of Vienna, Ziemsen and Immerman, of Er- langen, Pfeufer, of Munich, and many others, have introduced this method in their hospitals, and have treated thousands of cases of enteric fever (abdominal typhus), one of the most com- mon diseases of Germany, in this manner. They have all published the results of their investigations, and are all more or less enthusiastic advocates of the antipy- retic treatment, as it has not only reduced the mortality of that disease greatly, but has a decided and marked influence in checking or ameliorating its various local symptoms. Both facts have been statistically demonstrated. Liebermeister gives the following statements in relation to the mortality of the disease under different modes of treatment at the hospital at Basel. 1. Under expectant and symptomatic treatment: Year. No. of Cases. Death. Percentage of Mortality. 1843—1853 444 153 30.4 1854—1859 643 172 26.7 1860-1864 631 162 25.7 2. Under imperfect antipyretic treatment: 1865-1866, Sept- 982 159 16.2 3. Under energetic and continued antipyretic treatment: 1866, Sept.—1867,(end) 339 33 9.7 1867—1868 181 11.... 6.1 1808—1869 186 10 5.4 1869—1870 139 10 7.6 845 64 7.6 Dr. Brandt’s reports show the same favorable decrease of mortality from 30 per cent, to 10 per cent.; Stohr’s in Wurzburg from 31.5 to 6.6 per cent.; Ziemsen’s from 15.4 to 3.1 per cent. Liebermeister’s experiments have further established the fact 1. That abstractions of caloric from the body of fever patients by cold baths, cause first an increased combustion followed after the bath by a decrease of combustion and temperature much greater than the preceding increase, and therefore more than ■compensating its effects. 24 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 2. That this decrease of combustion and temperature caused by the cold bath depends upon the duration and temperature of the latter. The colder the water and the longer the immersion, the more decided the refrigerating effect; a bath of short du- ration but sufficiently cold, has a more decidedly cooling effect than a bath of a few degrees higher temperature much longer continued. To Juergensen and Bartels in Kriel, belongs the merit of hav- ing demonstrated that in a very large majority of febrile pa- tients intensely cold baths can be used as often as needed, or in other words, as often as the febrile temperature rises to 39 de- grees C. (102 deg. F.) without any danger. From the introduc- tion of this energetic method of treatment (1866,) dates the great diminution of the mortality of abdominal typhus set forth in the above statistical statements. The leading practical points for the guidance of the practi- tioner in the use of this method of treatment are : 1. Cold water as a refrigerant should be used in all cases of disease where the grade of the bodily temperature—39 deg. C. (102 deg. F.) or above—threatens to initiate the above men- tioned dangers of the febrile process. Abdominal typhus, meas- les, scarlatina, variola, pueperal fever, epidemic cerebro-spinal meningitis, bronchitis, severe forms of pneumonia, etc., fre- quently require this treatment. 2. The success of it depends upon the energy and persever- ance with which it is adapted to the indications which each in- dividual case presents. The course of the temperature, the condition of the pulse, the respiration, and particularly the strength of the patient, must be carefully consulted, in order to decide what amount of benefit can be expected from abstrac- tions of caloric by the use of cold baths or cold applications : In anaemic and already much emaciated individuals and in dis- eases of a chronic character, for instance phthisis, its use is of doubtful propriety, as the increase of combustion during each application might, in some cases, do more harm than the sub- sequent decrease of it would do good. 3. Whenever its use is deemed proper, it should be resorted to early and energetically to obtain the most favorable results. Baths and other cold applications should be used—not promis- cuously and in irregular intervals—but as often as the febrile tem- perature measures in the axilla 39 deg. C. (102 deg. F.) or above. Origin, Nature and Treatment of lever, etc. 25 Full baths in water of 20 deg. C. (68 deg. F.) of about ten minutes duration, are used by Wunderlich, Liebermeister, Ziemsen, and others, as the most effective antipyretic applica- tion. The bathing tub remains in the sick chamber and the same water is used during the entire day for one patient. In hot weather it is cooled down by the addition of ice if needed. "Weakly patients are kept in it only from 5 to 7 minutes at a time. After the bath the patient is at once put to bed, wrapped up in a dry cloth, without being previously tired by an effort of wiping his body, and covered lightly. If shivering, he takes a glass of good wine and his feet are kept moderately warm by suitable applications. In very serious cases the treatment is commenced with baths of a higher temperature—24 degrees C. (72.2 deg. F.) or with baths of 35 deg. 0. (95 deg. F.) gradually cooled down by the addition of cold water, but continued each time as long again as colder baths. Applications cf wet cold sheets around the entire body, leav- ing only the feet free, are, next to baths, the most effective mode of reducing the febrile temperature. Three to four consecutive applications of from 10 to 20 minutes duration each, produce the same effect as one cold bath. This method recommends it- self in private practice on account of its simplicity. Winter- nitz uses the sheets without any cover over the patient, and continues to sprinkle cold water on the sheets where a very high temperature requires it, and uses frictions on parts which re- main unusually cool, a condition of things occasionally occur- ring. In cases running their course with mild febrile temperatures and less intense nervous symptoms, or in children where the amount of the surface in proportion to the weight of the body is always more considerable than in grown persons, this method of abstracting caloric is very applicable and often quite suffi- cient. Cold douches as well as ablutions frequently repeated can, particularly in cases of sopor, etc., where an exciting effect on the psychical and respiratory functions is desired, be made useful, but as refrigerants they are, according to repeated calorimetric measurements, of very little lasting benefit, and no substitutes for cold baths or cold sheets. This method of treatment reduces the temperature of the *26 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. body indirectly by the physical abstraction of caloric from its surface. Its energetic use is often sufficient to diminish the febrile temperature more or less permanently, and to obviate the dangers directly resulting from its continuation. Where this is not the case, or where this treatment is not well endured by the patient, or where the already existing high grade of bodily consumption and weakness as in phthisis forbids its en- ergetic use, other additional remedies are resorted to, wrhich by their internal influence on the blood or nervous system exercise a direct controlling eftect on the production of caloric. Quinine and veratrum viride are, next to cold water, the principal agents for the reduction of febrile temperatures. The former remedy is now extensively used in connection with the cold water for the accomplishment of this purpose. One large ■close from 20 to 40 grains in adults is given at once, or within the ■course of one hour, and repeated as often as the reduced temperature rises again, which is seldom the case before 48 hours from the time of the administration of the remedy. If 20 grains reduce the tem- perature to 38 deg. C. (100.5 deg. F.) this dose is sufficient. If they do not reduce it that far, a larger dose is given the next time; if they reduce it still lower, a smaller one. In this manner intermissions of the febrile process are produced as often as possible, and Liebermeister holds that the creation of complete intermissions in diseases running their course with long-con- tinued and high grades of temperature by this remedy, is one of the principal secrets of success in their treatment.* Any one, who has closely observed the effect of these large doses of quinine in severe cases of erysipelas, acute rheumatism, scarlatina, pleuritis, pneumonia, variola, abdominal typhus, phthisis florida, and who has measured the decrease of the temperature and seen the decided simultaneous amelioration of the circulatory and cerebral derangements following each dose, cannot long remain in doubt, that these derangements are prin- cipally caused by the effect of the high temperature on the heart and brain, and that quinine is, to use the older term, an antiphlogistic remedy in these diseases. How far it accomplishes this result by its direct influence on the nervous system remains undecided, as its relations to the *Uber die Behandlung des Fiebers, No. 31. Sammlung Klinischer Vortraege, v., Yolkman. Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. 27 same have not yet been determined by actual experiment. That such relation exists, however, can not be denied, as its depressing effects on the nerves of sensation and voluntary mo- tion are often too plainly perceptible, and its tonic effect on the muscular fibres of the spleen too well established. Binz’s and Scharenbroich’s late investigations," however, have plainly dem- onstrated that quinine diminishes the capacity of the red cor- puscles of the blood to bind oxygen, that it prevents the devel- opment of microscopic organisms and arrests the process of fermentation and decomposition of nitrogenous substances. These qualities of the quinine, if blood-changes giving rise to fever are frequently processes more or less analogous to fer- mentation and decomposition, account more directly for its un- questionable efficiency in the treatment of febrile diseases. While the veratrum viride in Europe is frequently used in the form of its alkaloid, the introduction of Norwood’s excellent tincture of this plant in the practice of this country makes it unnecessary for American physicians to resort to the use of veratrine for the purpose of reducing febrile temperatures. Every American practitioner is familiar with the use of Nor- wood’s tincture in pneumonia and other inflammatory diseases for the purpose of arresting or diminishing the intensity of the local morbid process. It is alike an invaluable remedy for reduc- ing and controlling febrile heat in idiopathic fevers, and clear intermissions can often be established by its use without any danger to the patient. The writer has used it for the purpose of controlling the frequency of the pulse soon after its intro- duction by Norwood, and long before he knew anything about the medical thermometer, with the happiest effect in enteric and other low continued fevers. It should be administered often enough and in large enough doses to keep the temperature and pulse as near the normal standard as possible, without produc- ing collapse, and five drop doses every three to four hours will prove sufficient for that purpose in a large majority of cases. Digitalis has a very similar effect on the pulse and tempera- ture in fevers, and is frequently used in Europe. The disagree- able cumulative symptoms however, which occasionally follow its use, and its less uniform influence on pulse and temperature, f Binz. Experimentelle Unter suchtingen ueber das Wesen der Cbinimvirknng, 1868.—Med. Centralbladt, 1867, No. 52. 28 Origin, Nature and Treatment of Fever, etc. will enable us to dispense with its use when we possess a much safer and more reliable remedy in veratrum viride. Binz’s late experiments* have also placed alcohol in its dif- ferent forms amongst the antipyretic remedies. He has demon- strated that it diminishes the activity of the metamorphosis in the tissues, and reduces the temperature in fever patients. When it is remembered that it furnishes at the same time hydro- carbons to the organism for combustion, and that it has a deci ded antiseptic effect, its judicious use in fevers, particularly of a septic and adynamic character (pyaemia, puerperal fever, ty- phus, erysipelas, etc.,) is certainly frequently indicated, and fre- quently followed by very beneficial results. These are the only direct antipyretic remedies now known, and therefore the only ones that can be considered in the treat- ment of the febrile process in its general pathological features. The importance of nutritious diet in febrile processes of long standing is too well acknowledged by the profession generally to require more than mere mention in this paper. How far vemesection is admissible and useful in the treatment of febrile and inflammatory diseases, the writer will endeavor to consider in a future paper. * The Therapeutical Effect of Alcohol. Atlanta Med. and Surg. Journal, vol. x, page 561. ERRATA. Page 4, fourth line, “ Booerhave" for Boerhave. “ 4, thirteenth line, “ prcesentes” for prccsentes. “ 15, twenty-eighth line, “Booerhave” for Boerhave. “17, third line, “5G° C.” for 50° C.