INTERNATIONAL SANITARY CONFERENCE OF WASHINGTON. PROTOCOL No. 5. Session of February 1, 1881. The Conference met at 1 o'clock p. m., pursuant to adjournment. The delegates of the following countries were present: Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Chili, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Great Britain, Hawaii, Hayti, Italy, Japan, Mexico, Netherlands, Portugal, Argentine Republic, Russia, Sweden-Norway, Turkey. The President (Mr. HAY) announced that the delegate of Germany (Mr. Schu- macher), the delegate of Belgium (Mr. Seve), and the delegate of Great Britain (Mr. Archi- bald) had informed him that they were prevented by imperative reasons from attending this session of the Conference. The Secretary laid before the Conference the following letter from the honorable Secretary of State: Department of State, Washington, February 1, 1881. Thos. J. Turner, Esq., Secretary of the International Sanitary Conference, Washington: Sir: I have to inform you that, according to a note of the 30th ultimo from the Belgian Legation, M. Ie Baron A. d'Anethan, now in charge of that Legation, will succeed Mr. Neyt as the Belgian representative at the Sanitary Conference. I am, sir, your obedient servant, W. M. EVARTS. The protocols of the third and fourth days' proceedings were laid before the Conference. On motion of the delegate of Russia (Mr. Bartholomei) the approval of the protocols Nos. 3 and 4 was postponed until the next session of the Conference. The President (Mr. HAY.) If any delegate has any emendations to make in the pro- tocols he will notify the secretary. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). Provided they are submitted at least twenty-four hours before the meeting. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I suggest that instead of applying the word "article" to the matters under discussion they be called "propositions"-"First proposi- tion," "Second," "Third," &c. And then when the Conference has finished its work the various propositions can be arranged in articles and numbered consecutively, as Article 1, 2, 3, 4, &c. There was no objection, and the suggestion of Mr. Outrey was agreed to. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). Mr. President :-As we have now reached a point in the consideration of the report of the Committee that touches the very heart of the system which has been established by tiic leg- islation of this country, and which is now earnestly recommended to the Conference for adoption by all the powers here represented, I desire to say a few words. Unwilling to consume the time of the Conference except when essential principles were placed in jeopardy, I abstained from any participation in the discussion at the last meeting on the first four special propositions of the report of the Committee (condensed into two articles by the decision of the Conference), although I was well aware that by my silence I exposed myself to the probable imputation of inconsistency in voting against an article couched in similar terms to those of a proposition to which I had given my assent in the Committee. Two of these four propositions had been submitted by the delegates of the United States, but merely as prepara- 2 tory and introductory to much more important and practical means of accomplishing the end for which the Conference was called. By a pure inadvertence they were at first expressed in terms which implied a binding obligation on the contracting parties to collect and communicate infor- mation as to the sanitary condition of' their respective ports. It was on my own motion in the Committee that this phraseology was so amended as to express nothing more than that it is de- sirable that each government should, as far as practicable, obtain such information and promptly communicate it to the other contracting parties. We consider it inexpedient to overload any International Convention which might spring from the deliberations of this Conference with obligatory requirements not absolutely essential to the attainment of the main object in view, however ready we may be to give expression to a wish that all civilized governments should adopt certain features of maritime sanitary administration which have been recently established in our own country. It was merely in this latter view that I was induced to accede to the third proposition of the Committee as offered by the distinguished special delegate from Portugal, whom I was the more anxious to please because of a substantial identity between the regulations of the maritime sanitary code of his enlightened country and those of the United States. I had, however, some apprehension that the incorporation of this proposition in the report of the Com- mittee might be taken hold of as a concession that the establishment and distribution of a Weekly Bulletin of Mortality Statistics would bean adequate compliance with the requirements involved in the first two questions of Mr. Evarts' memorandum. This fear has been realized already. The proposition in question, conceived in a scientific spirit with reference to purely scientific re- sults, has undergone a change by the skillful manipulation of experts in diplomacy. The change, it is true, is slight in appearance, but, of ominous significance, being calculated and doubtless de- signed to forestall other practical measures which we consider to be absolutely essential to the attainment of the great end for which a system of notification is desired by our government. That end, as stated in Mr. Evarts' memorandum, is the prevention of the introduction into the United States of contagious and infectious diseases, especially Yellow Fever and Cholera. Now, I affirm without fear of successful contradiction that a Weekly Bulletin of Mortality Statistics, whatever value it may have in other respects, is wholly unavailable to this end. The informa- tion, however reliable and trustworthy, would come too late to be of use. But there can be no guarantee that these statistics arc trustworthy. In many instances they are misleading and even absolutely false, and are particularly liable to be so in just those cases where accurate informa- tion is most needed. The actual or apprehended injury to the commerce of a port consequent upon the publication of the existence of infectious disease within its limits furnishes a motive and, as many openly avow, an excuse for the suppression of the facts as long as such suppression is possible. To obtain the earliest information of threatened danger-and it is this which is needed for the efficient application of preventive measures-it will be indispensable to employ agents who are independent of local influences, and who are responsible to the government to which the information is communicated. In a word, if a nation wants reliable and trustworthy information with regard to the sanitary condition of foreign ports with which it maintains com- mercial intercourse by sea, it must have its own agents, who will feel their responsibility in the matter, to collect such information and to certify to it. When the authorities of France aimed to put a stop to the frequently recurring introduc- tion of Cholera by way of the Red Sea into the Mediterranean ports, they did not ask the gov- ernments of Turkey and Egypt to establish and give the "greatest publicity possible" to a Weekly Bulletin of the deaths from that disease in Mecca, Medina, and the Red Sea ports. They resorted to very different and much more practical means of securing the desired end, and by their success won the applause and gratitude of all Europe. Let us hear the exposition of this system as found in a report made by the Minister of Commerce and Agriculture to the then President of the Republic in 1849. 3 This Minister said: "The ordinance of 1847 very materially modified the sanitary code of onr country. It not only reduced the duration of quarantines and abolished them under certain conditions, on ar- rivals from Turkey and Egypt, when these countries were free from any pestilential epidemic, but it also established (and it is this which gives the act a peculiar importance) upon rational data the new system of pecautionary measures which it prescribed. * * * * * * * Hitherto all defensive measures against the invasion of the disease had been organized merely on the sea coast. It was now deemed to be both more simple and more logical to extend the surveillance over the countries themselves where the disease took its origin. This was done by the nomination of resident physicians by our government (that of France) in Turkey and Egypt, to examine into the sanitary condition of those countries, and to fix the bills of health to be given to vessels on their departure, a measure that was the more useful as it provided for the more or less speedy introduction of important modifications into the regime of sanitary superin- tendence." I beg the Conference to observe how a measure primarily designed to protect the public health of Europe against the invasions of infectious disease in effecting that end also promoted the interests of commerce by superseding the necessity of quarantine restrictions at the ports of arrival. The brilliant success of this system was the subject of remark and commendation at the International Sanitary Conference at Paris in 1851-'2, and at Vienna in 1874, where it was suggested that similar measures should be adopted along the line of the approach of cholera from Persia by way of the Caspian Sea. What France has thus accomplished for Europe in respect to cholera we desire to effect for all nations wherever a similar exigency exists, by means similar in all essential features, though with certain differences in accordance with differences of local circumstances. In general, when any particular country is constantly or frequently in danger of importing infection from a given foreign port, it will, for its own safety, maintain a competent physician at such port to assist its consul, but until it becomes apparent that the exigency exists, or is near at hand, it is not to be expected that governments will be willing to incur the expense of send- ing medical officers to reside at all the ports at which an infectious disease may possibly exist at some future day, and yet it will be important to have the earliest notice of the first cases if any should occur. For this reason we proposed, in an original project, that each government should bind itself to give to the consul or other accredited agent of the others access to all hospitals, and to the records of public health, a proposition which assumes, by necessary implication, that the consul is to be the certifying authority to his government as to the sanitary condition of the ports of departure. Sec. 2 of the "Act to prevent the introduction of contagious or infectious diseases into the United States," which is printed in full in Protocol No. 2 of the Conference, provides that "all vessels sailing from any foreign port where any contagious or infectious disease exists shall obtain from the consul, vice consul, or other consular officer of the United States at the port of departure, or from the medical officer, where such officer has been detailed by the President for that purpose, a certificate, in duplicate, setting forth the sanitary history of said vessel, and that it has in all respects complied with the rules and regulations in such cases prescribed for securing the best sanitary condition of the said vessel, its cargo, passengers, and crew; and said consular or medical officer is required, before granting such certificate, to be satisfied that the matters and things therein stated are true." A part of Sec. 3 reads: "The Board of Health shall make such rules and regulations as are authorized by the laws of the United States and necessary to be observed by vessels at the 4 port of departure and on the voyage, where such vessels sail from any foreign port or place at which contagious or infectious disease exists to any port or place in the United States, to secure the best sanitary condition of such vessel, her cargo, passengers, and crew, and when said rules and regulations have been approved by the President they shall be published and communicated to, and enforced by, the consular officers of the United States: Provided, That none of the penalties herein imposed shall attach to any vessel, or any owner or officer thereof, till the acts and the rules and regulations made in pursuance thereof shall have been officially promulgated for at least ten days in the port from which said vessel sailed." The rules and regulations made by the Board of Health, in conformity with the provisions of the acts I have cited, having been officially approved by the President, have the force of law. Among them I cite the 5th rule: "Each consul, vice consul, consular officer, or medical officer of the United States in a foreign port shall keep himself thoroughly acquainted with the sanitary condition of the port and its vicinity, especially with regard to the existence of infec- tious or contagious diseases or epidemics, and shall, upon request of the owner, agent, or master, make or cause to be made an inspection of any ship or vessel bound for any port in the United States, and give the bill of health required by these regulations. Vessels carrying a foreign flag shall be inspected, when practicable, in company with the consul or consular agent of the nation to which the vessel belongs." The principles involved in these regulations did not originate with us. I am glad to render homage to the enlightened government of Portugal for giving prominence to these princi- ples in its admirable "Rftglement general de saute maritime," published in 1874. Under Titre III. a very comprehensive article thus prescribes some of the duties of the Portuguese consuls in connection with this subject: Art. 6. Il appartient aux fonctionnaires consulaires de Portugal, par eux et par leurs subordonnes: 1°. S'informer constamment de 1'etat sanitaire, non seulement des localites oft ils resident, mais de tons leurs districts consulaires, tachant de savoir s'il y a des cas de peste, de fievre jaune, ou de cholera morbus, et encore meme de petite verole, etc. * * * Ils doivent, en conse- quence, maintenir des rapports etroits avec les administrations des hopitaux civils et militaires, avec les departements de sante publique, et avec les medecins jouissant de la meilleure reputa- tion, etc. 4°. Communiquer au gouvernement, par la voie la plus prompte, et sans perdre un moment, Papparition de quelque cas de peste, de fievre jaune, ou de cholera-morbus, ft terre ou ft bord des navires mouilles dans les ports respectifs, et aussi quelque cas d'epizootie marquant le jour ou les jours de la presentation des cas, quand meme ils n'auront pas et6 fatales. 8°. Fournier au gouvernement, en cas de manifestation dans leurs districts de maladies con- tagieuses et epidemiques ou d'6pizooties, tous les edaircissements qu'ils pourront obtenir par rapport au caractere des maladies, informant sur Porigine de Pinfection, la statistique des attaques et des morts, la propagation dans les lieux voisins et les mesures adoptees; ils devront, dans ce cas, indiquer les ports du pays, ainsi que ceux de Petranger avec lesquels les points infectes maintiennent de plus frequentes et immediates relations commerciales. 9°. Adresser aux capitaines ou commandants de navires qui demanderont une patente de sante, et aux equipages respectifs et passagers ft bord, toutes les demandes qu'ils jugeront ft propos de leur faire par rapporte ft Phygiene des embarcations, tachant de les visiter et de les inspector, et mettre, si on lui fait la requisition, le timbre de bureau sur les ecoutilles qui fermeront la cargaison des navires. 11°. Signer et expedier des patentes de sante avec le sceau du consul at, rempliss ant les declarations du modele No. 1, qui fait partie du present rdglement, etc. Art. 7° Dans Pabsence ou Pempechoment des consuls et vice-consuls portugais et des employes qui les substitueront legalement, les patentes de saute et les visas pourront etre delivres par les employes consulaires de France, d'Angleterre, d'Espagne et d'Italie, etc. 5 According to Sir Sherston Baker (Laws of Quarantine, London, 1879), bills of health are given by Italian consuls to vessels of all flags, according to a prescribed form, one item of which is the "sanitary state of the vessel." He cites a decree of the 20th of November, 1870, of the Italian Government, which requires all vessels leaving the ports of the United King- dom of Great Britain for Italy to provide themselves with a bill of health from Italian consular authorities, under pain of the penalties imposed by the ministerial decree of 29th of April, 1867. The suspension of pratique, however, is limited to 24 hours in the case of vessels pro- vided with any other bill of health. Austria requires that bills of health from foreign ports shall be given by the local sanitary authorities or by tne Austrian Consul. With regard to this I have only to say that if the choice between these alternatives be left, not to the captain of the vessel but to the government of the country of destination, we should not object to the terms of the Austrian regulation. We have no desire to make it obligatory on any nation to require bills of health to be given by the consuls, or indeed to require bills of health at all. We only ask that consuls who are required by their governments to furnish bills of health, should have the requisite facilities to enable them to inform themselves as to the facts to which they certify. The Government of Great Britain also required that vessels sailing from Mediterranean ports shall be furnished with bills of health signed by the British consul. (Sir Sherston Baker, loc. c it. p. ) Thus it will be seen that the United States are not alone in requiring that vessels sailing from any port in which contagious or infectious disease exists shall carry bills of health to be furnished by the consul of the country of destination. I now ask permission very briefly to notice the three points in the argument of the Special Delegate of the Netherlands, as printed in the Protocol No. 3 of the committee, in opposition to the policy of requiring consuls to investigate the sanitary condition of ports and places by visits to hospitals and other similar means. Dr. Van Leent's first argument cites two objections, namely, first the sacrifice of the consul's personal dignity, and secondly his presumed incompe- tence to decide medical and sanitary questions. It is a satisfactory reply to the latter, and will at the same time remove whatever force may belong to the former, to say that in almost all cases the consul will discharge this duty by the agency of a medical officer sent by his own govern- ment for that purpose, and when this is not the case then on information obtained from medical advisers residing in the locality, in whom he has confidence. For the rest, it is by no means necessary that the consul or even his medical assistant should undertake to decide a question of doubtful diagnosis. It will suffice to report the facts that doubts exist as to the nature of certain suspicious cases. The second argument is based upon the facts that there are special departments of hospitals to which for reasons stated admission ought to be forbidden to all but the hospital physicians and nurses. In such cases all that the consular agent needs to know is that admission is precluded because of the existence of infectious disease. The third argument rests upon the assumption that the inquiry indicates a distrust of the loyalty and truth of the government of the country. This is an unwarranted assumption. No such imputation is implied by the suggestion of reciprocal concessions, which, if they contained ground of offense on this score, would be equally offensive to our own government. But the central government itself may be uninformed as to the appearance of a case of infectious disease in some one or more of its ports, and very imperfectly informed as to the general sanitary condi- tion of some or all of them. I am free to confess that we do distrust the willingness of the local authoritities to admit the existence of the first cases of a threatened epidemic. I know this to be the case with the municipal authorities throughout this country, and I have no reason to believe that the fact is different in other countries. 6 Such being the utter worthlessness of weekly bulletins and of information to be obtained from the local authorities as means of a notification of the commencement of an infections epidemic, I am constrained to say that nothing short of the Portuguese regulations, which we have borrowed, will satisfy the people or the government of this country. It is but a small concession that we ask with reference to the means of collecting information as to the sanitary condition of ports and places, and one which of course will be reciprocal. It is but to recognize the official char- acter of the accredited agent of each government in his efforts to obtain seasonable and accurate information respecting the approach and the outbreak of infectious diseases in the ports of the other contracting parties. In respect of the proposed examination of vessels, I find it difficult to understand what rational objection nations can make to a sanitary inspection by foreign consuls of their vessels in their own ports, under the supervision, if need be, of their own officials, when the same in- spection will otherwise be certainly enforced at the port of arrival, with the additional exaction of a costly detention in quarantine. I have no authority to say what this government will do if some such facilities as these are not given to its accredited agents in foreign ports. But I can but observe and to some extent interpret the indications of popular feeling on this subject, and I think I am warranted in saying that our people intend to prevent, if possible, the further introduction of infectious diseases into the country by the use of whatever means may be lawfully used to that end. It would be a very simple process to amend the existing law, to which your attention has been called, so as to enforce its penalties irrespective of the two conditions which now impede its execution. This has actually been proposed, and I verily believe would have been carried out had not the National Board of Health been anxious to secure the result by an international agreement involv- ing an offer of reciprocity. It was themore disposed to do this because the Cuban authorities had laid us under an obliga- tion, for which we are glad to make a public and grateful acknowledgement, by the very polite and courteous manner in which they received a Commission of Yellow Fever experts sent to Havana by the National Board of Health to study that disease in the various Cuban ports. An auxiliary commission of eminent medical men of the country was appointed by the Captain General in order that through it the United States Commission might obtain promptly such information and assistance as was required. What was thusspontaneously accorded to a special scientific commission we ask, in the interests of the public health and those of commerce, shall be regularly accorded in each country to the accredited agents of the other contracting parties. So far as yellow fever is concerned, it may possibly be said that there is small ground for reciprocity, the disease in question being almost always imported in this Country, and almost never exported to foreign countries; but I well remember that on one occasion the Cuban authorities conceived it to be necessary to quar- antine against all the ports of the United States because of the reported existence of cholera in Philadelphia. As late as August, 1879, the Portuguese Government quarantined against the ports of New York and New Jersey, under an apprehension that yellow fever existed in these ports, although the National Board of Health gave them assurance that there were no cases of that disease on the Atlantic coast, except occasionally in the New York quarantine, as happens every year, reminding them that no regulations known to us considered cases in quarantine to be a ground ofsuspicion against the port. Had the Cuban and Portuguese authorities made suitable inquiries and inspections by their agents on the ground, they would surely have found it quite unnecessary to place such restric- tions on their own commerce. I now propose this amendment to proposition 5 of the committee. 7 Strike out the second paragraph in toto, and amend the first paragraph so as to casuse it to read- "Art. 3. It is recommended that each government should permit the accredited agents of the other contracting parties, assisted, when necessary, by medical sanitarians, to examine every- thing that can help them to form an accurate idea of the sanitary condition of the country." It will be observed that this proposition is made up in part of the 5th and in part of the 8th propositions of the committee. I recorded my vote against the former because the second paragraph was out of place. I approve in the highest degree both the spirit and the letter of that paragraph, but as our governments gave us no authority to include such a recommendation in the proposed convention, I was sure that if it were thus incorporated it would expose us to the risk of losing all. I was willing to express such a wish in an addendum to the convention, but not to include it in the convention itself. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I have an amendment which I hope you will allow me to offer first. At the last meeting I presented a proposition which I said I would add to the proposition of the Delegate of Russia to complete the idea contained in his proposition. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I thought we had disposed of the first four. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). No, sir. I stated, last time, that I would ask the Conference to decide to-day whether this proposition should be added to the first one of the Delegate of Russia in order to complete it. The proposition was read as follows: " In the interest of the public health, and for the general good, the sanitary authorities of the countries represented in the Conference are authorized to communicate directly with each other, in order to keep themselves informed of all important facts which may come to their knowledge, respectively; but nothing herein contained is intended to relieve them from any duty now imposed on them of giving information to the consuls residing in their respective countries." The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE), jointly with his colleague from the Netherlands, submits a substitute for the proposition of the Delegate of France. The dif- ference between the two propositions is, that in the one the words "central sanitary authority'' are used instead of " sanitary authority," and that said authorities shall be " bound " to notify instead of being " authorized " to notify. In order that entire faith should be placed in the notifications which it is intended to establish, it is necessary that the notifying authority be in a position to do so reliably, and that it should have no reason to hide the truth. In these days of railways and rapid communica- tions it is not sufficient to be acquainted with the sanitary condition of a given locality, it is also necessary to be acquainted with the sanitary condition of all localities which have frequent intercourse with it. It is, therefore, only the central sanitary authority (which collects its infor- mation throughout the entire country) that is in a position to give trustworthy information. It is a well-known fact that the local sanitary authorities are naturally apt to conceal the existence of disease, which, should it become known, would work injury to that locality. The Delegate of the United States acknowledges this fact, and has given some examples of it. The central sanitary authority is, on the other hand, interested to let the entire truth be known, as in order to favor one locality it would not risk that all ships coming from all the ports in the country should be considered and treated as being "suspected." Moreover, the composition of the central sanitary boards offers greater guarantee of impartiality. What the Delegate of Italy has just said about the local sanitary authorities applies in a 8 great measure to the consuls to whom the Delegate of the United States would intrust this service. The sphere of information of the consuls is too limited, and it is too great a responsibility to put on them. The Delegate of France proposes that the sanitary authorities should not be "bound," but only " authorized," to notify each other of the appearance of disease. The object of the system of notification which this Conference is intended to establish is to give to each government the certainty that it will be warned of the appearance of disease. If every government be at liberty, as is now the case, to give or not to give such warning, then he does not see the mean- ing or the object of the notification which it is proposed to establish. The principal object of the Conference would thus be defeated. The Delegate of Italy concludes by saying that, as the other points contained in the proposition which jointly with the Delegate of the Netherlands he presents are identical with those contained in the proposition of the Delegate of France, he does not think it necessary to say anything further about them. The proposition of the Delegates of Italy and the Netherlands was read as follows: " In the interest of the public health, the central sanitary authority of each country repre- sented in this Conference shall notify one another of the appearance and disappearance of epi- demic and contagious diseases, yellow fever, cholera, and plague; such notification is, however, not to interfere with the information which the local authorities are bound to communicate to the consular officers residing within their district." The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO}. I think the points under discussion are contained in the proposition of the Delegate of France and the amendment of the Delegate of Italy. I will therefore examine these two propositions together. The proposition of the Delegate of France appears to me to be almost identical with Article III of the Inter- national Sanitary Rules of February 3, 1857. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY) stated that at the last meeting he had already said that this article was only copied, and did not claim to be its author. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO). I am of the opinion that if we are repeating in the Conference of 1881 something proposed thirty years ago, we are making no advancement. But, if I understand the object of our labors, we have something very differ- ent in view. Our object is to arrive at some means of establishing a system of sanitary notifi- cation, and the creation of a system of inspection which can be applied to the ships of all countries. We have already examined the first part of our programme, viz, optional sanitary notification from one government to another by means of local authorities. The proposition of the Delegate of France sums up all the propositions which have so far been presented to the Conference. This proposition stipulates that the authorities of the different countries should mutually communicate to each other the sanitary information which they have obtained. The Delegate of Italy, on the contrary, would like to give an obligatory character to this proposition. If I rightly understand this proposition, it is that this information should be communicated by the central sanitary authority; but from whom would this information come if not from the local authorities? I therefore do not see the advantage of centralizing this service in the hands of the central authorities. I very much fear that neither of the propositions will fulfill the object in view, especially if mistrust is shown towards the information given by the local authorities. A general international understanding would alone settle the question without any injury to the pride of nations, particularly if practical and useful results can be obtained without touching upon the political side of the question. I take advantage of this occasion to thank the Delegate of the United States for what he has said about the sanitary regulations of Portugal. These regulations are, in my opinion, those which will give most satisfaction, and it is with great pleasure that I see so respectable authority add the weight of his opinion to the fact. But I 9 must say that we desire more, and this desire was expressed as early as the promulgation of these rules by the commission in charge. It is true these rules grant to consuls the right of inspect- ing vessels, and of holding themselves informed of all that may interest the public health in the different ports and towns where they reside, but in order to give more accuracy to this service the commission was of the opinion that doctors (other things being equal) should be chosen in preference to others to fulfill the duties of consuls. This commission also expressed the desire to see established in the different ports exposed to epidemics a sanitary corps, and it was that desire which I submitted to the committee, and which I had the satisfaction of seeing adopted. I must add that this question, every time it has been submitted to diplomats and physicians, has always been solved in the same manner as it has been by the committee, and if this Conference adopts a different opinion it will be for the first time. The original idea of the establishment of an international corps of physicians belongs to the French, who in 1851 gave the outline of that system. The sanitary conference of Paris had admitted the necessity of the establishment of a body of sanitary inspectors in America for the study of yellow fever. If this desire has not been realized, it was owing to the fact that the American continent was not represented in that conference. The establishment of these medical posts in the east has given the best results, both as regards the public health and commercial intercourse. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I beg to begin by answering an observation of the Delegate of Portugal. He says he thinks it strange that I should mention a proposition which was presented 30 years ago, and which was never adopted. It is true that the article in question is in the book of regulations published in 1851, but I must also mention the fact that this convention was signed by all the delegates present at the Conference of Paris. Without wishing to give the details of the project of the convention, I will say it was prepared at that time. I do not think, however, that I am wrong in saying that if it was never ratified by the government it was principally because this convention touched upon questions of interior regulation which were of a delicate nature. It does not follow as a necessary consequence because the work of this Conference was not adopted that the points discussed in it were of no value and may not be taken up again now in spite of their antiquity. The proposition that I make appears to me to fulfill one of the wishes expressed by the Delegate of the United States and by the committee. Speaking of the amendment of the Delegate of Italy, I do not see any objection to accepting the words "central sanitary authorities," which he proposes to substitute for the words "sanitary authorities." It is even possible that this wording would be more in conformity with the object in view, that is to say, the establishment of direct communication from one country to another. But I think there would be a serious drawback to oblige each one of the central administrations to furnish the information it will receive from all the countries which will have adhered to the international system we have in view. In my opinion it would be better to leave it the right to communicate its information only to those countries with which its own ports have frequent and direct maritime communication, and which consequently have a real interest in receiving infor- mation relative to the sanitary condition of the infected countries. It has been stated and even repeated in this Conference that the information furnished by the local sanitary authorities are of no value, are not trustworthy, and it is not from these authorities that exact information should be expected, but from the central authorities, which alone are not subjected to local influences. It may be that this criticism is in some measure just, but I do not think that all the drawbacks will be removed by changing the source of the information. To avoid a certain class of difficulties you may fall into other more serious ones. The central authority is certainly the best place and most competent to appreciate the general condition of the public health, to collect and forward technical observations about the whole of the country, but when you come to furnishing precise information on the sanitary condition of a place, I think it is from the local 10 sanitary authority that one would be able to get the most prompt and accurate and necessary information. As a matter of course, I reserve to the consuls the right to exercise such super- vision as will be compatible with the laws of the country. In all cases they must seek to obtain information by all means in their power in order to be able in case of emergency to inform their respective governments of their personal observations. If the local sanitary authorities are not to be trusted, and if it is thought that the intervention of a higher administration is neces- sary, why should the countries which have a regular sanitary organization not follow the example of France. That government has special delegates who have great authority and who belong to sanitary commissions along the coast. This institution offers the greatest guarantees against local influences. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). I agree for the most part in the observations which the Delegate of France has just made. I am of the opinion that the gov- ernment would abdicate the right which it now has of getting information through its consuls if it simply accepted the proposition of the committee. As the Delegate of France has said, it is the duty of the central authorities to furnish the sanitary notification, but I will add that these central or local authorities ought to be obliged to give the greatest publicity possible to these notifications as soon as they shall have received them. If, for instance, a case of cholera or of yellow fever should make its appearance at any point in the territory of the United States, the National Board of Health at Washington would be the authority whose duty it would be to publish the information. The Delegateof France has justly remarked that the government should not be obliged to forward the sanitary bulletins to all parts of the world, as that would lead to too great expense. This might be remedied by giving, as I have just said, the greatest publicity possible to such informations, for in these times of rapid communications, the sanitary notifica- tions, as soon as they shall have come under the notice of the press, will be forwarded in all directions without expense by the different telegraphic agencies. This would not, however, be a reason for dispensing with the transmission of these notifications from one board to another and then to the consuls. The Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN). In order to establish a satisfactory system of notification as to the sanitary condition of ports and places, it will be necessary to create some boards, in the hands of which this service could be trusted. The only duty of these boards would be to inform those governments which have acceded to the conven- tion of the sanitary condition of the public health. They would have no administrative power. The choice of the places where these boards should be situated offers no difficulty. In my opinion it would be sufficient that for the notification of the appearance or disappearance of yellow fever such a board be created in Washington, and that another whose special duty it would be to give notification of the appearance or disappearance of cholera and pest be situated in one of the European capitals. The board in Washington would comprise the American continent and the islands geo- graphically belonging thereto, whilst the board situated in one of the European capitals would extend its sphere of action to the whole of Europe, Asia, and Africa. The governments participating in this system would address their sanitary reports to the board in whose sphere of action they belong, and, similarly, each board would forward its in- formation to the different governments which have furnished it with sanitary bulletins. These boards will mutually exchange the information received, and then notify the countries coming under their jurisdiction. For instance, should the yellow fever make its appearance in the Brazils, the Brazilian Government would notify the board in Washington, which will then communicate this information, 1st, to the American government with which it is in connection; 2d, to the board in Europe, which will in a like manner transmit the information to the countries with which it is in correspondence. 11 Exceptions to this rule would only be admitted in ease of urgent emergencies; governments which did not previously furnish health bulletins could then also enter into direct communication with the boards. Should any doubts be entertained as to the exactitude of the sanitary bulletins received, the boards should be authorized to enter in direct communication with the country furnishing such bulletins, and this country would have to give, as promptly as possible, the necessary explanations. The expenses incurred for the establishment of these notifying boards would be shared by the different governments acceding to this proposition, as is now the case for some of the per- manent international boards. Should the conference concur with my views, I will propose that a committee of five mem- bers be appointed to examine and report on my proposition. The President (Mr. HAY). It seems to me that the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary cannot be entertained unless as a substitute for the proposition of the Delegate of France and the amendment of the Delegate of Italy. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I have no objection to withholding my proposition until the question of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary has been examined. If the Conference think it better to establish the general principles first before the details are discussed I am willing to withdraw my proposition for the present. The President (Mr. HAY). The vote can then be taken on the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). That proposition was made before the Vienna Conference in 1874, and adopted, and nothing has ever come of it, and noth- ing will ever come of this. If it is adopted we might as well adjourn. We have no authority in this country to accept any such proposition, and I am sure no government of Europe will agree to it. The proposition has been made repeatedly and adopted in Conferences, and there it has ended. The Special Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN). In answer to Dr. Cabell, I would state that the proposition adopted at the Vienna Conference provided for the establishment of a permanent scientific commission, which is quite a different thing from this, which provides for an international notification commission. The Government of the United States in calling this Conference had in view the establishment of a satisfactory system of international notification, and it is with a view of attaining that object that I now submit this proposition. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I propose to withdraw it for the present. If the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary is accepted, it involves all the proposi- tions, and there is no use of submitting mine. The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPORE ALE). If the establishment of this committee be decided upon, what will become of proposition III? The question was taken on the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary, and was decided in the affirmative, yeas 12, nays 7, as follows: Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Chili, Spain, France, Italy, Mexico, Portugal, Russia, Sweden and Norway, Turkey-Yeas 12. Denmark, United States, Great Britain, Hawaii, Hayti, Japan, Netherlands-Nays 7. So the proposition was agreed to. The President (Mr. HAY). How shall that committee be appointed? The Delegate of Russia (Mr. BARTHOLOMEI). We have Count Bethlen on the one hand in favor of this proposition and Dr. Cabell on the other opposed to it. I would suggest, therefore, in order that every one may be satisfied with the composition of the com- mittee, Count Bethlen name five members and Dr. Cabell name five, and from those ten names the Conference could select five. 12 The Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN). I would prefer the President to name the committee. The committee might be composed of two of the diplo- matic delegates and three of the special delegates. The President (Mr. HAY). If left to me, I would name Count Bethlen, Mr. Schumacher, Count Lewenhaupt, Dr. Tach£, and Dr. Cabell. I think the Conference has entire confidence in the intelligence and loyalty of those gentlemen. The Special Delegate of Canada (Dr. TACIlF). I thank the President for having mentioned my name, but I am obliged to leave to-morrow for Canada; therefore, I must ask to be excused. The President (Mr. HAY). I would then appoint Mr. de Pestel in place of Dr. TachIl The proposition of the Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell) is now in order. The Delegate of Russia (Mr. BARTHOLOMEI). I move a recess of ten minutes, that we may examine the proposition. The motion was agreed to; and the Conference accordingly took a recess of ten minutes. After the Recess. The recess having expired, the Conference reassembled. The Delegate of Hayti (Mr. PRESTON) offered the following: The undersigned delegate proposes that the Conference has three meetings per week, and that the days of meeting be fixed from to-day. It is proposed, also, that each proposition will not be considered if it is not formulated in writing, and signed by at least two delegates present in French and English. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). For my part I am quite willing to accept the proposition of the Delegate of Hayti, provided that the Delegate of the United States or the President will bind himself to have the protocols ready every other day. The President (Mr. HAY). I think it will be impossible to do that. The Delegate of Hayti (Mr. PRESTON). If we cannot have three sessions a week let us have two, and let the day of meeting be fixed beforehand. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I would suggest a proposition more broad, more elastic. The experience of five meetings has shown us that the difficulty lies in having the protocols ready for the meetings. There are now three meetings of which we have no protocols. I suggest that a meeting should be called by the President when the protocol of the last meeting is ready. Otherwise we will come to the end of the Conference without any protocols in order to see what is done, and to which we can refer to guide us in our discussions. The President (Mr. HAY). The proposition of the Delegate of France is that the meetings be held as often as possible, and the invitation to each meeting shall be accompanied by the protocol of the last sitting. There being no objection, the proposition was agreed to. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. TURNERS. I move we adjourn. The Special Delegate of Canada (Dr. TACHfi). A telegram calls me back to Ottawa on public business. I have, therefore, to ask to be relieved from further attendance at this Conference. It is an agreeable duty for me to offer my heartfelt thanks to the authorities of this country, to yourself, Mr. Chairman, and to all my colleagues, for many acts of kind- ness and attention which have been bestowed on me during my sojourn in this city. This has been the occasion of my making distinguished, amiable, and valuable acquaintances, and I shall keep the pleasant recollection of my trip to Washington and of my connection with this Con- ference. 13 The President (Mr. HAY). I know 1 but interpret the sentiments of the members of the Conference when I say we all feel profound regret at parting with Dr. Tach6 and losing the benefit of his intelligence and the pleasure of his company during the remaining time the Conference may be in session. And I am sure our short acquaintance with, him will always be remembered with pleasure. [Hear! hear!] The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOKEALE) opposes the motion for adjourn- ment. All questions connected with the system of notifications can be postponed until the report of the committee on the Delegate of Austria-Hungary's proposition is received; mean- while the Conference might proceed to consider matters independent of the system of notification. The President (Mr. HAY). The motion to adjourn is first in order. The question was taken, and it was decided in the negative. So the Conference refused to adjourn. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. TURNER). The next question to be taken up is involved in the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary. It was for that reason I moved to adjourn. That proposition involves more or less all the means of notification. The Conference having turneel that over to a committee, now proposes to consider further means of notification. The committee may consider all these points. I do not see how we may go on until we hear the report of that committee. The President (Mr. HAY). Will the Delegate of Italy indicate what proposition shall now be taken up? Tha Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE). We can proceed with the sixth proposition. The sixth proposition was read as follows: " It is desirable that each government should consent that its ships, before and after taking on cargo, may be subjected to adequate sanitary examination in all ports by the agent of the country of destination under such rules as may be laid down by international agreement or treaty." The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE) offered the following amend- ment to proposition 6: The bill of health shall be delivered at the port of departure by the responsible agent of the central government ; the consul at the port of departure shall have authority to authenticate the bill of health and to add thereon such remarks as he may deem necessary. The Delegate of Spain (Mr. de VIGO) offered the following amendment to proposi- tion 6: g The bill of health will be delivered by the special naval sanitary director, who must be a responsible physician, and such bill of health must be authenticated by the consuls of the coun- tries of destination, who may add such remarks as they deem necessary. In case of disagreement, a committee, composed of the naval sanitary director of the port, of the consuls of the various nations which have adhered to this Convention, of the captain of the port or a naval official, will decide on the points of contest. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). It seems to me the propositions are substitutes for proposition 7 of the committee, rather than 6; that proposition is preparatory to 7. I would again remark that this touches the very heart of the matter. If this 6th proposition is voted down, I shall consider the Conference a failure in respect of the attainment of the object for which it was called by the Government of the United States. I do not think this is the proper point at which to introduce resolutions relating to bills of health. I should like to have the opinion of the Conference taken with regard to this 6th proposition. This relates to the policy of permitting to be made at the port of departure such inspection as is now in enforced by the quarantine authorities at the port of arrival. We recommend tins 14 policy because its practical execution does not interfere any more with the rights of sovereign States than the practice now enforced at the port of destination, while at the same time it will save the vessels from detention in quarantine on their arrival. It is proposed to transfer that inspection for sanitary purposes, under such safeguards as may be necessary to protect the com- mercial interests of the country concerned, to the port of departure. I ask for an expression of opinion on the part of the Conference on this point which is entirely separate from the question of cert if cates which comes afterwards. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I do not think we are bound in this discussion to follow the order of the propositions as submitted by the committee. If I am not mistaken, the Delegate of Italy proposes we shall examine questions entirely independent of the matter of notification. We were asked what we should discuss, and it was decided to discuss proposition 6; now it is said the amendments offered apply to proposition 7. How can you give the right of inspecting vessels to one authority and the right of giving the bill of health to another? The person who gives the bill of health ought to be the person who examines the ship. In my opinion, number 6 ought to have been number 7, and vice versa. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). What is a bill of health but a means of notification? It is a system of international notification, and the question ought to have been left aside in accordance with the resolution already adopted. But No. 6 refers to the matter of inspection, and it is quite conceivable that it may not be followed up by anything else in our Conference. Each government has the right to prescribe the duties of its own consuls. What we ask is that certain facilities be granted to the consuls-that they be recognized in their official capacity, and allowed to do in their official character that which is now done by them under our law. This has no necessary connection with notification as provided by No. 7, for a bill of health is nothing more than a system of notification. The Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. Cervera). Since the beginning of this Confer- ence I have abstained from voting on propositions 6 and 7. I cannot vote in favor of these propositions until it is first decided who shall be the sanitary agent whose duty it will be to issue the bills of health and to inspect the ships before and after loading. I will keep my vote back until that question is decided, as I can put no faith in an inspection made by the consul, or any agent who is not an expert. It happens that the scientific experts themselves do not agree upon the point of determining the sanitary state of a ship. In the propositions presented by me, and especially in article 9, I propose that the inspection should be made by a physician, or some officer assisted by a physician, and that the bill of health should be authenticated by the consul of the country of destination. If the consul or the officers of administration are not satisfied with the information furnished by the sanitary authorities of the port, they can, by virtue of the proposition I have presented, assist themselves at the inspection. The Special Delegate of Mexico (Dr. ALVARADO). I am absolutely of the opinion of the Special Delegate of Spain, and I should like to submit to the Conference a few observations on the mode of notification and of the choice of the agent who is to make the in- spection. This notification includes the two contracting parties; the authorities at the port of de- parture, and the authorities at the port of arrival. These two authorities ought, in my opinion, to take an equal part in this notification, which should be made by doctors, who alone are com- petent in such matters. To summarize my idea, I have the honor to offer the following amend- ment: The notification of the sanitary condition must be given by expert scientists, i. e., by two physicians; one to be appointed by the authority of the port of departure, the other by the authority of the port of destination. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). We have now before us the mem- orandum of Mr. Evarts and the report of the committee. We must decide which of the two 15 we will first discuss. I am of the opinion we should follow the order indicated in the mem- orandum. The report of the committee and the proposition of the special delegate of Mexico and of Venezuela are documents which we will have to consult, but I do not think we are obliged to follow the order which is indicated in the report; but if the Conference decides otherwise, I will, of course, bow to its decision; but in that case we must continue by article 6. The question is, whether the amendment proposed by the Delegate of Italy is the same as proposition 6, or whether it is different, as the Delegate of the United States says. If I have well understood the Delegates of Spain and Mexico, these two propositions refer to the first article of the mem- orandum of Congress. I think that it would be natural to follow that order in discussion, for the apparent confusion which is present in the discussion is owing to the fact that we did not follow the order indicated in this memorandum. Although the report of the committee is an important document, prepared by competent men, I do not think that it should be accepted as the basis of discussion. This basis is furnished by the memorandum of Congress, in consequence of which the different powers have consented to be represented at this Conference. The Delegate of France (M. OUTREY). I do not think the question as to who is to make the inspection of the ship before its departure should be discussed before having first decided which shall be the authority whose duty it will be to ascertain the sanitary condition of the ship. The bill of health, the form of which was presented by the Delegates of the United States, contains everything which has to do with the sanitary condition of the port, ship, and crew, &c., &c. How can you separate the question of inspection from that of the bill of health? Are we going to allow to one authority the right of delivering the bills of health and to another the right of inspection ? Certainly not, as the right of inspection is a natural consequence of the necessity of ascertaining the sanitary condition of the ship. If such is the case, is it not possible to discuss the two questions at the same time? It seems necessary to me to invert the order of the two propositions and commence first by discussing proposition 7. The Delegate of Portugal (VISCOUNT DAS NOQUEIRAS). I am ready to admit the conclusions of the Delegate of France, but I do not entirely concur in the views of the Delegate of Turkey. In all discussions of the project of a law, it is the report of the committee (whose mission it was to study this project) which should serve as the basis of the discussions of the final measures to be taken. I am speaking now from personal experience, having for a long time been a member of deliberative assemblies. As to the expediency of first discussing proposition 7, I am of the same opinion as the Delegate of France. I think it is better to de- termine first who is to be the authority that is to make the inspection of the ships and to deliver the bills of health. This double duty ought, in my opinion, to be confided to one person. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). We are, at present, neither dis- cussing the project of a law nor the project of a commission, but a simple report, the conclu- sions of which are not in any way final, and which, if they were accepted in their present form, could hardly be presented as an international act. As I have before said, the memorandum of the State Department furnishes us a basis for our discussion in a very methodical manner, which we ought to follow, and the length of our discussions is owing to the fact we have not followed, that order. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO). A committee was appointed to examine all the questions which should be submitted to it. After having made this exami- nation, it submitted its report, and it is the duty of the Conference to examine this report and discuss it. If it had only been intended as an ordinary work to prepare and present, then we did not understand our mission. The Conference chose principally scientific delegates to make 16 part of this committee, because the questions to be discussed were technical questions. If to-day the Conference does not trust them, they are not responsible. The Conference can correct, in- crease, or diminish this report, or even change all the propositions if it chooses to do so, but I think, nevertheless, that it ought to examine the report. The Special Delegate of Spain (Du. CERVERA). I think we would gain time by discussing immediately propositions 6, 7, and 9, commencing with the latter one, which refers to the choice of the agent whose duty it will be to deliver the bills of health. The President (Mr. HAY). I was not present at the last meeting, but it seems to me the order adopted by the Conference at its last session was to take up the report of the committee in the order presented. In that case, I think it would be necessary for the Conference to vote to take up the 7th proposition before the 6th, if it is desired that that order should be followed. Otherwise, I should say the vote should be taken on the 6th proposition before the 7th. The special delegate of Canada (Dr. TACHE). I certainly agree with the views expressed by Dr. Cabell on the vote of the committee to which all the proper documents, in- cluding the memorandum of the Secretary of State, were referred by the Conference. The committee has understood its duty to be to study all these papers, and to frame from them, in- spired by the joint resolution of the Congress, a series of propositions, to serve as a basis for the deliberations of the Conference. It therefore reported first a preamble, which is as a sort of introduction to the whole sub- ject; then two fundamental propositions, setting forth, in the shape of an assertion of principle, the two questions embodied in the resolution of the Congress, as interpreted by the Secretary of State. The first of these two propositions asserts the desirableness of an international system of notification about the appearance and disappearance of communicable diseases. The second asserts the desirableness of an inspection of ships al; the port of departure by agents of the port of destination, each government, by mutual and reciprocal concessions, waiving a portion of the exercise of the sovereignty covered by its flag and resting in its seaports. Why to allow this inspection by foreign agents? Because this foreign agent represents the port which is in danger of being infected. Dr. Cabell is right in finding it strange that it be proposed to substitute for the 6th prop- osition reported by the committee another proposition which goes to designate the agent who is to deliver the bill of health. Not to answer directly the simple questions laid down by the United States is equal to a plea of non-suit. I think it is too late to lodge such a plea. It was not done when invitation were made to the various powers, who, by appointing delegates, have contracted the obligation of considering the two questions, and of answering them squarely. It must not be forgotten that in the United States' proposal the idea of notification and the idea of inspection are intimately connected. The question as to whether the bill of health should be signed by a physician or by a consul is not at all essential. If an inspection is allowed, it ought to be left to the inspecting power to select its own agents and to satisfy himself. A minister of state is not always acquainted with the matters intrusted to his administration, but he knows them by agents whom he selects to inform him. From the beginning I have held the strong opinion that the Conference should not enter too much in the modus operandi and the details, which ought to be left to the governments to adjust from time to time, in order to regulate the service of the privileges mutually conceded. It is unfortunate, I think, that a departure was made from the plan of proceedings laid 17 down by the committee. Following the ordinary ways of logic, the committee had first estab- lished the premises, leaving the Conference to follow-here we are drawing conclusions, post- poning the premises in order to make them to fit. I think that an answer should be given to the United States Delegates whether their propo- sitions, in their simplicity, without any complication of details, are admitted in principle or not; because, if they are not admitted, the examination of details has not its raison d'etre, these details being to the two fundamental propositions mere consequences more or less proximate, more or less distant therefrom. The President (Mr. HAY). I will take the sense of the Conference on the matter under discussion. The proposition of the Delegate of France is that No. 7 of the report of the committee shall be considered before No. 6. The question was taken and it was decided in the affirmative. The President (Mr. HAY). These amendments, then, will be considered as amend- ments to No. 7. The first to be voted on is that of the Delegate of Mexico (Dr. Alvarado). The Delegate of Portugal (VISCOUNT DAS NOGUEIRAS). It is better to know if it is possible to discuss this proposition before the other. The Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. CERVERA). If I proposed a moment ago to discuss proposition 9, it was because I was convinced that propositions 6 and 7 were intimately bound together, and that we could discuss them after proposition 9. The question was taken on the amendment of the Delegate of Mexico, and it was decided in the negative by a unanimous vote. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I think the vote on these amendments should be taken by the yeas and nays. The President (Mr. HAY). In all cases where there is a division the vote will be so taken. In the present instance the vote was unanimous-no one voted in the affirmative. The question was taken on the amendment of the Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. Cervera), and it was decided in the negative, yeas 5, nays 14, as follows: Yeas-Argentine Republic, Denmark, Spain, Hayti, and Netherlands-5. Nays-Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Chili, United States, France, Great Britain, Hawaii, Italy, Japan, Mexico, Portugal, Russia, Sweden-Norway, and Turkey-14. So the amendment was rejected. The question uext recurred on the proposition of the Delegate of Italy (Prince de Camporeale). The President (Mr. HAY). Perhaps the Delegate of Italy would like to explain his amendment. The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE). I think it would save time if I should first hear the objections urged against it; and afterwards I could reply. At present I do not know what objections I will have to meet. Perhaps the Delegate of the United States will give his reasons against the amendment. The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. DE BILLE). I am in full sympathy with the idea contained in the amendment of the Delegate of Italy, but I think he has used some expressions which are not quite clear. I do not know who is the responsible agent of the local authority. I would have preferred to have it said that it is the medical authority of the port of departure who is to give the bill of health. I understand, however, that at the present time we are voting more on principles than on details. I shall, therefore, vote for the amend- ment of the Delegate of Italy, expressing the opinion, however, that it would be better to have the bills of health, in all cases, delivered by the sanitary authorities, and have them vised by the consular agents. I think that by this combination it would be possible to obtain all the 18 advantages and to avoid all the drawbacks connected with the present system. The local authorities will be inclined to conceal or diminish the cases of contagious disease that may occur at their respective ports. Even if they be medical men they will be under the influence of the commercial interests of the place. At the same time they are the persons best fitted for carry- ing out all the inspections. But if the consular agents have the power to correct and supplement them, then I think we would be sure of always having the truth put in the bills of health. I shall vote for the amendment, but I do so with a reservation, believing that some slight change should be made in the wording at a later stage. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). The Delegate of Italy has asked me to express my objections to his amendment. I may say I have already done so this morning. I will add, however, that if the consul who is to vise the bill of health given by the local authorities is to have the opportunity of getting at the information in a responsible way, I can see no possible advantage result from the adoption of the proposition of the Delegate of Italy. Indeed it will be a disadvantage, and put the consul at times in the position of dis- crediting the information given by the local authorities. I think I speak the sentiments of my colleagues when I say we would rather dispense with this double vise, and take the consul's statement alone. You will either have the consul shielding himself behind the local author- ities for his own malfeasance, or else discrediting the official statement of another government. I feel tolerably sure this government is going to adhere to the rules it has made on that point, and that it will require an agent responsible to itself to give the information. It does so now under existing law. If a convention was made abrogating that practice, the law would, of course, have to be repealed. But we have no authority to say that the law on that point will be repealed. It seems to me a formidable objection to the amendment to place the consul in the delicate position I have suggested. And we have had experience on this very point. AV e have had clean bills of health brought to this country, and at the same time notification from our consul that there were numerous and fatal cases of infectious diseases at the place from which we had received such clean bill of health. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. TURNER). I can indorse that by saying that I have received two bills of health from local authorities stating no contagious disease ex- isted at a certain port, and a notice from the consul that over 80 cases of infectious disease existed at the place. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). To which bill did you pay atten- tion ? The Delegate of the United States (Dr. TURNER). To neither. The vessel was put in quarantine. The Delegate of Sweden and Norway (Count LEWENHAUPT). At present every government has a right to decide not only what kind of bill of health a vessel shall carry in order to enter its ports, but also a right to decide by whom that document shall be issued. I do not believe it will be possible to arrive at any other conclusion than that the bill of health must be issued according to the special legislation in the port of destination. The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE) answers to the Delegate of Denmark that he has used the words responsible agent of the government: first, because he thinks that to be trustworthy the bill of health must be issued under the responsibility of the central government; and, secondly, because it is not expedient to say to any government who shall be its own certifying officer. In Italy, for instance, the bill of health is signed by the prefect of the province as representing the Minister of the Interior, who is at the head of the sanitary organization of the whole country; but no doubt he is, in so doing, advised by the physicians attached to his office. 19 The Delegate of the United States objects, that if the consul is allowed to make annotations on the bill of health it might compel him, at times, to contradict the facts stated by the authority that has issued them. The Delegate of Italy answers that the provision he recommends is in force at present in France, in Italy, and, he believes, in most countries. The statements of the authority issuing the bill of health and of the consul control one another. If they are contradictory it is for the government of the country of destination to say to which statement it will give credence. Moreover, the data which it will be necessary to collect for preparing the weekly bulletins mentioned in propositions 1 and 2 already voted will diminish the probability of conflicting statements. The Delegate of the United States would prefer that the bills of health be delivered by the consul of the country of destination. The Delegate of Italy thinks there are several objections to this course. As at pres- ent organized, the consulates could not properly attend to this duty, and it is not to be expected that every government will attach to each of its consulates a sufficient staff of medical and other inspection officers to enable them to do it. Besides, he does not think that the consuls are or can be in possession of sufficiently complete information as to the sanitary condition of the coun- try. Lastly, giving authority to consuls to visit and inspect vessels not carrying the flag of their nationality may involve very serious questions, and is, he thinks, not to be admitted as the gen- eral rule. He will, however, be disposed to allow sufficient authority to the consuls to enable them in suspicious cases to obtain such information as will put them in a position to make their annotations on the bill of health en connaissance de cause. The Delegate of Hawaii (Mr. ALLEN). This measure is unquestionably of the highest importance. I represent a small kingdom of ports which are the great depots of shipping of the North Pacific. We have vessels arriving and departing from every country, and had the original principle of this Conference been in operation long since we should have been saved a large amount of suffering and death. On one occasion we had come to our port a vessel which had small-pox on board. It was concealed and we had no knowledge of it. The government had been careless in regard to vaccination and we had swept from us between five and six thousand people. We did everything we could, everything that the best medical treatment could suggest, to prevent the progress of the disease, but it was beyond our control. Now this bill of health, if it means anything, should come from the very highest authority of those who represent the port of destination. If in former days vessels from California, for example, had been compelled to carry bills of health as perfect as this committee proposes these shall be, we would have been saved this suffering. Now, what I apprehend and) fear, if the amendment of the delegate of Italy is adopted, is this: Every port is anxious to preserve its reputation for health, and its authorities are apt to conceal the real sanitary condition, if that condition is bad. Is it not better to have an independent person who is connected with the port of destination, whose duty it is to see that his own people are guarded; is it not safer to have him go into this examination and to give the bill of health, than anybody else? Of course these consuls will be under careful instruction from their respective governments. They will be instructed to have examined by competent medical men the cargo, vessel, and seamen, before they give a bill of health. But when the bill of health is given it may be relied on, for it will be given in the interest of the port of destination especially, and that is the port that is endangered by the introduction into it of infectious diseases. I know that we are all in pursuit of the same object, viz, to guard ports against these contagious diseases, and it seems to me it would be better if the giving of the bills of health were in the hands of the consul without the interference of the local health authorities. 20 The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. de BILLE). I agree with the Delegate of Hawaii that it is the land of destination which has the greatest interest in preventing the importation of contagious diseases into its boundaries, but at the same time it is my impression that the medical authorities are much more able to examine vessels than the consul. If the consuls are to give the bills of health there is great danger of having the matter reduced to a mere formality. People go to the consular office, and there they get a bill of health often without any inspection of the vessel, the cargo, the men, the provisions, or anything else which should be examined. It is all very well when the first cases of yellow fever or cholera have appeared. Then the consuls will be full of zeal-no consul would then be guilty of giving a bill of health without first having examined the vessel most conscientiously. But in every-day-practice there would be very great danger that the consul would give these bills in a manner altogether formal. Therefore it is my opinion that by combining the two authorities you obtain the largest measure of accuracy. On one side you have the local authorities, the quarantine physician, who will make it his endeavor to examine the vessel, who knows how to do it; and, on the other hand, you have as a check on, and a supplement to, him the consular agent of the land of destination, who will always counteract the tendency of the authorities at the port of departure to give it a higher reputation for health than it possesses. If you add, however, what some members of the committee have proposed, viz, that a staff of medical consular agents be employed, then perhaps it would be right to leave the issuing of bills of health to them ; but as long as the consular agents are commercial representatives, and so long as they are only paid by the occasional fees they obtain, and for the rest are thrown on their own resources in order to gain a livelihood, so long I very much fear that in ninety-nine cases out of a hundred the bills of health if given by them will be given out pro forma, without that close inspection which is so important. I agree, therefore, with the Delegate of Hawaii, in the aim of his remarks, but I differ from him as to the means to • be followed to obtain that aim, and I still am of the opinion that it is in the combination of the two authorities that the greatest accuracy is to be obtained. The Delegate of Hawaii (Mr. ALLEN). In reply to my friend from Denmark, that these consuls will have to perform this duty without medical advice, I will say lie must have medical advice. In relation to the other point-the power of the consuls; if I understand the amendment of the Delegate from Italy, the whole power is vested in the local agent to prepare the bill of health and the consul must vis6 it. He has no authority under these circumstances. He can make a remark, but that is all. The Delegate of United States (Dr. CABELL). It will be difficult to make the consul, who has nothing to do but vise the bill of health, feel his responsibility. He will shield himself for his official acts behind the local authorities. By the other method he is made to feel his responsibility, and he will have medical men to help him. In the few instances where he would be unable to obtain medical men of his own country, he would be able to employ native physicians and be himself responsible to the government for the information he collects. The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. de BILLE). Suppose we adopt the form of bill of health proposed by the United States, would it then be possible for the American consul in Liver- pool to examine and inspect every vessel, and to give conscientiously all the declarations you want from him? I do not think it would be possible. At New York would it be possible for the British consul to fil 1 out properly these bills of health ? I do not think it would be. If, however, a case of yellow fever or anything of that kind occurs in a port, then of course the consul would provide himself with medical advice as long as that contagious disease was existing at the place, and would exercise all the discretion possible. But in common every-day practice, where no such disease has appeared, then there is great danger of having these bills of health reduced to mere formalities. As long as you permit the sanitary authorities to make these inspections they are 21 not made as matters of form, they belong to that department; they are constantly in the harbor; they know everything; they can see at once what would employ a consul half a day or four or five hours to inspect. Therefore I think it is better to combine the two interests. Now, I have understood the proposition of the Delegate of Italy in this way : The consul is not obliged to give his vise on a bill of health as a matter of course. On the contrary, the consu- lar agent is to act as a check on and prevent the local authority from concealing the sanitary con- dition of the harbor. There shall not only be a bill of health, but a vise at the same time of the consular agent. Perhaps it would be possible to turn the matter the other way. Perhaps it would be possible to have the consul give the bill of health and have a vise from the local sanitary author.ties. However, I have not heard that proposition made. To my mind the essential point is to have a combination of the two things, and I cannot but feel that in this combination alone is to be obtained that security we want. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). But suppose the statements made by the two sides are contradictory ? The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. De BILLE). Therein lies the value of the system. It is that what is wanted. The local sanitary authority may give a clean bill of health, and the consul may say, "I am sorry to state that the facts given above are not quite correct-we have six cases of yellow fever." There can be no doubt that the consul's government will attach most importance to his declaration. What will be the result? The result will be that the local sanitary authority, having received this rebuke, will be very careful in the future not to allow the consul another opportunity of "giving it the lie," I think you would call it. I am not afraid to have some collisions now and then between the consuls and the local sanitary authori- ties. Such collisions happen between consuls and medical authorities. It is necessary that they should occur occasionally. I repeat, again, that I feel sure by combining these two interests you will obtain something. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I would like to ask a question for informa- tion. Suppose consuls give the bills of health. Take a ship sailing in the Antilles that will in the course of a week stop at a French island, an English, and a Spanish one; is that ship ex- pected to take out a bill of health every time, or will one be sufficient, and the consuls at the other ports required to vis6 it? The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). It is the intention to have but one bill of health, given at the original port of departure-that bill to be vised at the inter- mediate ports. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). According to your rule, it seems that a new bill of health must be given by each consul. I have seen nothing in any of the regulations about the bills of health being certified by the consuls at the intermediate ports. As the propo- sition is now presented, it appears that an American ship leaving New Orleans and stopping successively at Havana, Martinique, and Jamaica must provide itself with different bills of health from each of the consuls of Spain, France, and Great Britain. If that is not the plan, which is the consul who shall deliver the bill of health ? It is not a criticism I am making. I ask for information. The Delegate of the United States (Mr. ASHTON). All these questions must be decided by the different governments. It is provided here that "commanders and captains of vessels shall provide themselves with bills of health at the port from which they primitively sailed; and in the ones called at or put in, with vis6s on the same bills of health." The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). At each intermediate port the bill of health is to be vis^d by the consul of the next port of destination. The President (Mr. HAY). The question now recurs on the amendment of the Dele- gate of Italy. 22 The Delegate of Russia (Mr. BARTHOLOMEI). I move we now adjourn. The President (Mr. HAY). The amendment of the Delegate of Italy will be printed and sent to every Delegate, and will come up at the next meeting as unfinished business. The question was then taken on adjourning, and it was decided in the affirmative. So the Conference adjourned to meet at the call of the President. INTERNATIONAL SANITARY CONFERENCE OF WASHINGTON. PROTOCOL No. 6. Session of February 9, 1881. The Conference met at 1 o'clock p. m. pursuant to the call of the President (Mr. Hay). The following Delegates were present: Germany: H. A. Schumacher. Argentine Republic: Seiior Don Julio Carrie, Secretary of Legation and Charge d'Affaires ad interim at Washington. Austria-Hungary: Count Bethlen, Special Delegate. Belgium: Baron d'Anethan, Councillor of Legation and Charge d'Affaires ad interim at Washington; and Mr. Edouard Save, Consul-General of Belgium in the U. S. Chili: Seiior Don Francisco Solano Asta-Buruaga, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary at Washington. China: Chin Lan Pin, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary at Washington Denmark: Mr. Carl Steen Andersen de Bille, Charge d'Affaires and Consul-General at Washington. Spain: Senor Don Felipe Mendez de Vigo, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipo- tentiary at Washington; and Seiior Don Rafael Cervera, Doctor of Medicine and Surgery, Special Delegate. United States: Dr. James L. Cabell, President of the National Board of Health of the United States; Dr. Thomas J. Turner, Secretary of the National Board of Health of the United States; J. Hubley Ashton, Esq., Special Delegate; James Lowndes, Esq., Special Delegate. France: Mr. Maxime Outrey, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary at Wash- ington. Hayti: Mr. Stephen Preston, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary at Wash- ington. Italy: Prince de Camporeale, Charge d'Affaires ad interim at Washington. Mexico: Seiior Don Ignacio Alvarado, Special Delegate. The Netherlands: Jonkheer Rudolph von Pestel, Minister Resident at Washington; and Dr. F. J. van Leent, Directing Health Officer of the 1st class in the Netherlands Navy, Special Delegate. Portugal: Viscount das Nogueiras, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary at Washington; and Professor Jose Joaquim da Silva Amado, Special Delegate. Russia: Mr. Michel Bartholomei, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary at Washington. Sweden-Norway: Count Carl Lewenhaupt, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Pleni- potentiary at Washington. Turkey: Gregoire Aristarchi Bey, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary at Washington. The protocols of the third, fourth, and fifth days' proceedings were laid before the Con- ference and approved. 2 The President (Mr. HAY) said that he had just been informed that the Delegate of Great Britain (Mr. Archibald) had been called away from Washington by the severe illness of a member of his family, and would probably not be able to attend the future meet- ings of the Conference. The President (Mr. HAY). The first business before the Conference is the proposition of the Delegate of Italy. The proposition was read as follows: Proposition of the Delegate of Italy (Prince de Camporeale) Proposition No. IV. "The bill of health shall be delivered at the port of departure by the responsible agent of the central government. The consul of the country of destination at the port of departure shall have authority to authenticate the bill of health, and to add thereon such remarks as he may deem necessary." The Delegate of the United States (Dr. TURNER). I have to state, in response to an inquiry made at the last session of the Conference by the Delegate of Denmark (Mr. de Bille), concerning the detail of the sanitary examination of vessels suggested in the proposed International Bill of Health presented by the committee, that such examinations have been and still are required by the bills of health of France and Portugal. I have also to reiterate the objections of the Delegates of the United States to the proposi- tion of the delegate of Italy (Prince de Camporeale), providing, in the first place, for the issuing of bills of health (a means of notification) by the local agent of the central authority at the port of departure; and, in the second place, for the vise of the consul at the same port as to its authenticity, together with such remarks as he may deem necessary, and for the following reasons: In the United States, boards of health are the local sanitary authorities, and in many instances do not have the power to grant bills of health. We are aware also of the fact that the board of health of a large city estimates its population at 60,000 beyond the number ascer- tained by official governmental census, thus rendering any numerical standard of the health of that community based upon its population valueless. We are aware of the fact that a board of health in another large city declines to have its mortality statistics published, unless by their express consent first obtained, thus rendering any information upon such statistics dependent upon caprice. We are aware of other boards of health that have deliberately suppressed the facts as to the existence of infectious disease. We are also cognizant of a board of health granting that which is called a clean bill of health, upon which it was stated "that the port and its environs are free from the suspicion of contagious and infectious diseases, especially yellow fever, etc.," and issued under the seal of office, whilst at the same time the sworn statement of an officer cited over 80 cases with 34 deaths from yellow fever during the week preceding the date of the bill of health. This bill of health was issued, as has been stated, by a board of health, said board being at the time the local agent of a central authority. It is but uttering a truism when it is stated that it does not require much observation to determine the fact that, accepting local standards, there is not an unhealthy city in the world, nor a city whose inhabitants do not resent the imputation of being unhealthy, in more or less decided terms, according to the amount of their pretentiousness, ignorance, and filth. Such, it is submitted, is the demonstrated value of any notification by local agencies of the port or place. We are not prepared, however, in like manner, to demonstrate the same want of confidence in consular signatures to any means of notification, such as a bill of health, although many 3 members of this Conference are fully aware to what amount of credence such sanitary notifica- tions are entitled. Such as they are, they have heretofore been received as evidence, but of a character more or less doubtful. What we ask is that the consul or like accredited agent shall have all means to obtain trustworthy information concerning the sanitary condition of his con- sular district. Over a consul his government has control, and he should not be permitted to get beyond the limit of its power to secure a prompt and efficient discharge of a duty the execu- tion of which, in this instance the issuing of a bill of health, is designed for the protection of the lives and health of his countrymen. Over the local agent of the central authority in his consular district his home government of course has not, nor can have, control. In the mixed proposition presented responsibility rests nowhere. It affords a convenient apparatus for defeat- ing its own object. It is granted that it has the plausible air of being eminently practical; it is, however, preeminently worthless, as it offers to the prejudices of the local sanitary agent, and to the almost enforced ignorance of the sanitary condition of the port of the consul, the oppor- tunity of adding falsehood to distrust. " Lastly, giving authority to consuls to visit and inspect vessels not carrying the flag of their nationality may involve very serious questions, and is, he thinks, not to be admitted as the general ruled' If, also, the statement of the Delegate from Italy (Prince de Camporeale) represents the opinion of the majority of this Conference, then it is the opinion of the Delegates of the United States that the principal objects for which this Conference was called will not be attained. The right to determine by an inspection the sanitary condition of a vessel, her cargo, passen- gers, and crew, in a port, it is stated cannot be admitted as a general rule, to a foreign accredited agent, even when it is proposed to make such inspections reciprocal. If this cannot be admitted as a general rule, specialization of the circumstances under which it is to be permitted destroys at once any efficiency or value such sanitary inspection may be considered to have as affording trustworthy information. It is an essential that the sanitary condition of a vessel, her cargo, passengers, and crew, should be known. Ships are the carriers of pestilences. Rapid commercial intercourse means also the rapid transmission of pestilential disease. At the port of New York alone, in December, 1880, 72 steamers carrying emigrants arrived on an average of one every 10| hours. It is of more importance to know these sanitary conditions as pertaining to a vessel than it is to know those of the port from whence she sails, and it is of still greater importance that these sanitary conditions should be known at the port of destination for the protection of the lives and health of that community. That such examinations are made now by foreign agents at ports of departure is well known. The examinations of vessels, passengers, and crews, at Jiddah, Yambo, Suez, and other ports of departure on the Red Sea, of pilgrims on their return from Mecca by foreign agents of ports of destinations, has saved Europe from irruptions of cholera. What we ask in this connection is the transfer of a thorough sanitary examination of the vessel, cargo, passengers, and crew from the port of destination to the port of departure, because it is more consonant ivith good judgment, common sense, and, without interfering with commercial interests, largely promotes the arrest oj transmissible disease. If the vessel at the port of destination, under certain circum- stances, is subjected to vexatious delays to ascertain her sanitary condition-often by foreign agents-it seems that it is simply a wise measure of prevention to have these measures carried out at the port of departure by the consul or other accredited agent of the port of des- tination. Who can be more concerned, both from interest as well as duty, in obtaining and forward- ing such information than the consul, or like accredited agent, of such port? No one. It is he who has, or should have, official cognizance of all the facts relating to vessels, their cargoes, 4 passengers, and crews; and in subserving the sanitary interests of the port of destination he decreases the liability of commercial interests being affected by vexatious and costly detentions. It is a maritime sanitary axiom that a yellow-fever ship is ipso facto a foul, dirty ship, and cholera has been brought to our shores in foul vessels with dirty crews, and these are the dis- eases especially noted in the act of Congress upon which notification is desired. Failing to secure such an inspection by the accredited agent of the country of destination, it follows as a consequence that he can make no truthful notification as to the sanitary condition of a vessel. To recapitulate: First, then, as to the port- The Delegates of the United States have no confidence in the method of notification pro- posed as to the health of a port or place founded upon local statements. Secondly, as to the vessel- The Delegates of the United States declare that if no sanitary examination of a vessel, her cargo, passengers, and crew, can be made by the accredited agent of the port or country of des- tination, it follows that no truthful notification of such sanitary condition could therefore be made. To repeat. If, however, the results arrived at are determined to be the sense of the Con- ference upon the means to the ends proposed in the act of May 14,1880, then, as I have before stated, it is the opinion of the Delegates of the United States that the principal objects for which this Conference was called will not be attained. The Special Delegate of the Netherlands (Dr. VAN LEENT). Mr. President, in asking the Chair to explain my amendment to the proposition of the honorable Delegate of Italy (Prince de Camporeale), I beg at the same time to be allowed to say a few words respect- ing the speech of the honorable Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell) in the last session of the Conference, my views on the subject being closely similar to the basis of the amendment which I have at present the honor of submitting to the Conference. It is not my desire to criticise this speech, but I think it my duty to notice certain points which have caused me impressions of a different nature-partly of disappointment, and partly of satisfaction and sympathy. I shall begin by explaining the least agreeable of the two impres- sions. In his speech the honorable Delegate of the United States considers the three arguments used by me against Article III of the project of the Delegates of the United States. This article is the following: " Every government shall bind itself to give to the consul or accredited agent of the others access to all hospitals and all the records of the public health." I insist on the fact that if I opposed this article, and even proposed to strike it out, it was on account of my entire conviction, founded upon an experience of more than thirty years' practice in the sanitary and medical service, that for important reasons I consider that such a permission, or rather such a duty and obligation, would fall totally short of the proposed object, and would prove defective in their execution. They would also unavoidably give rise to recrimi- nations, when, on the contrary, it is our desire to have all authorities coincide with our views. I shall not repeat the arguments in question, the honorable Delegate of the United States having briefly mentioned their object. This manner of examining my arguments gives but an imperfect explanation of their meaning, and an argument, to retain its force, should be fully considered. These arguments can be found on page 10 of the 3d protocol of the committee, and I beg the honorable members of the Conference to be kind enough to take them into con- sideration before voting on the new proposition of the honorable Delegate of the United States; this proposition, by which the honorable Delegate closes his speech, has a vast signification. I beg to state that, after having submitted my arguments against Article III of the proposi- tions of the Delegates of the United States, the Consuls-General of Great Britain and of the 5 German Empire, and also the honorable Delegate of Canada, agreed with my reasons for elimina- ting this article. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. Turner) then proposed a substitute for Article III, and with exception of a certain reserve on the part of Dr. Tach£ and myself, this substitute was accepted by the committee. Dr. Cabell did not then take the defense of the original Article III, and was not opposed to the acceptance of its substitute, proposed by Dr. Turner. I was therefore led to believe, and was satisfied and proud, that my arguments had convinced the honorable Delegate of the United States, but on listening to his speech I obtained the proof of the contrary, and it was evident that not only had I not convinced Dr. Cabell, but that it is more than ever his desire to grant the consuls, or accredited agents, the fullest right of inspection. It will now be appropriate to remark that the honorable Delegate of the United States brings as an argument against my remarks that the consuls, in the discharge of their duties, will use the agency of physicians to obtain information of the sanitary conditions, etc. This argu- ment did not exist in the substitute to Article III, as it is proved by the pamphlet containing the propositions of the Delegates of the United States, which are to be found on the 6th page of the first protocol of the sessions of the committee. From the fact that the honorable Consuls-General of Great Britain and Germany agreed at once with my views, it will be easy to foresee what will happen should the consuls be intrusted with a duty which it is quite impossible for them to perform. But I do not fear to see any government impose upon them the duty or grant to them the power of inspecting the hospitals or of consulting the records. This is the only point in the Article III to which I was opposed, and which I successfully combated in the committee. But, at the end of his speech, the honorable Delegate of the United States brings forward the Article III as amendment to the first paragraph of the fifth proposition of the report of the committee, and striking out the second paragraph of the same proposition. As I say, the proposition, Article III, of the Delegates of the United States, makes its reappearance, but is in terms much more absolute, and of a much wider signification, than in the original Article III. The proposition of the honorable Delegate of the United States specifies that it is recom- mended that each government should permit the accredited agents of the other contracting parties, assisted when necessary by medical sanitarians, to examine everything that can help to form an accurate idea of the sanitary condition of the country. Now, I am sure, Mr. President, that no government will ever grant to any person powers so unlimited, the results and extent of which it is impossible to foresee. The sanitary condition of a country depends upon many causes and is influenced by many things. It is not only the hospitals and their records, as specified in Article III, which are the objects of inspection, it is everything which influences the public health; that is to say, all the institutions of the country, the public works, the factories, the hospitals, the warehouses, the schools, the prisons, the barracks, the war and merchant vessels, and many other things-in a word, everything that can influence man in general in regard to both the public and private health. I particularly insist on the extensive range of this proposition, and I submit its judgment to the wisdom of the Conference. In regard to the trustworthiness and impartiality of the information furnished by the local authorities, I have full confidence in those furnished by the sanitary or medical authorities, by the chief surgeons of hospitals, or by other agents belonging to the medical bodies. When the central authority under whose orders such agents are placed shall have ordered or even per- mitted them to furnish to the consuls or accredited agents all the information which they may ask for or need, I have not the slightest doubt that they will fully, impartially, and loyally fulfill the duty which they were accepting. On this score it does not appear to me that there can be 6 any doubt, and that is all that is necessary as a basis to the system of information to the consul. I do not, for this reason, wish to cast any doubt on the trustworthiness and impartiality of local authorities, but I think that the plan which I have just submitted will be the easiest, surest, and most trustworthy. Regarding the principle of the system of international notification, I may safely say that my country, the Netherlands, with its possessions and colonies, has laws in force, and a medical and sanitary organization, which fully answers to all that may be desired in regard to prompt and trustworthy information. The special institution known in the Netherlands as the Medical and Sanitary Superintendence of the State, which includes everything of interest to the sanitary condition of the country and to the practice of the medical art, was established by law in 1865. This law was previous to the Law on Contagious Diseases, which completes the former. This law, which naturally includes the regulations on medical inspection and quarantine, imposes on every physician the duty, under severe penalties, to inform the local magistrate, directly and immediately, of all cases of infectious and contagious diseases which he is called upon to treat. This law enumerates the diseases of which notification must be given. These informations are forwarded, postage free, by postal cards of a particular form, and which are delivered gratuitously on application to the magistrates. Each province has, besides, its board of health, its sanitary inspector and assistant inspectors (physicians), who are under the orders of the Minister of the Interior, and have continuous communication, by the most rapid means, if necessary, with the different local authorities. The interior department has its sanitary service division, under the direct orders of a superior official (advisory physician). In our possessions and colonies we have about the same institutions, regulated and adapted according to the local conditions, but the principle is the same. For these reasons, Mr. President, in the Netherlands and its possessions and colonies the bill of health delivered by the magistrate has an undoubted value and trustworthiness. Nevertheless, it appears more rational (although the principle which I have just submitted to you has great advantages) that the local sanitary authority should deliver the bill of health and should, make the inspections mentioned in proposition sixth of the report of the committee. And I ask if the sanitary authority of a port or place is not more apt to be well informed to collect all the necessary information and to furnish it to those interested? In a word, is not this authority better than all other to fulfill all the medical duties? The ninth proposition of the report of the committee expresses the same views. Were the sanitary authority to be made absolutely responsible for its acts, the object for which we are here assembled would, I believe, be entirely and satisfactorily attained. I propose that an international character be given to this local sanitary authority. I quite agree that the consuls or the local authorities should certify the International Bill of Health proposed by the honorable Delegates of the United States (this document is most important, and bears the proof of a most thorough understanding of the subject); but I never- theless think that the sanitary authority, which has the responsibility, and has an international character, should not be left in the background, as has been the case until now. It is useless, unjust, and annoying. I now give an answer to the first question in the Memorandum of the honorable Secretary of State, Mr. Evarts: "Which shall be the officer certifying the sanitary condition of ports, places, and vessels?" In the ports it should be the physician, or physicians, intrusted with the quarantine inspec- tions. It is from him, or them, that the bill of health should be obtained. I do not understand why this sanitary authority (the inspecting physician of quarantine) who examines the vessels on arrival; on whose declaration the vessels are put in quarantine, or 7 receive clearance; who, in a word, judges and decides, and is the only competent judge-I do not see why he should not also deliver the bill of health to the vessels at the point of clearing, after having inspected them, their cargo, crews, and passengers. The certifying officer should, therefore, in my opinion, be the medical inspector of quarantine, sworn in and invested with an international character. In such places, where there are no medical inspectors of quarantine, the above-mentioned duties should be fulfilled by a physician practicing in the place itself, and who shall be sworn in and invested, with an international character. I do not think that such organization could offer any serious objections. With regard to the principle that it ought to be the duty of the sanitary medical authority to collect the information, make the inspection, and deliver the bills of health, this opinion is shared by several honorable Delegates in this Conference, and principally by the Delegates of Denmark, Italy, France, and Spain. The honorable and learned Special Delegates of Spain, Portugal, and Mexico have ex- pressed their views on this subject, and have submitted propositions which prove that they agree with the principle I have just explained. I think I may safely say that the honorable Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell) is personally of the same opinion, considering the end of his speech at the last session, and the well-merited praise he bestowed on the brilliant results of the Sanitary Commission in Constantinople, the success of which is due only to physicians. I am entirely of the opinion of the honorable Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell) on the subject of the Bulletins of Mortuary Statistics published by the different governments. If I voted against the proposition 3 of the report of the committee submitted by the honorable Special Delegate of Portugal, it is not because I consider that such bulletins, published weekly or at short intervals, have.no value for giving information in a universal sense. I can even say that I saw them introduced with satisfaction in the two propositions of the honorable Delegate of Russia, for I was convinced that the publication of these bulletins would not in any way prejudice a different system of international notification-i. e., by telegraph-everywhere that it is possible to use it. For the weekly bulletins, it appears to me not to be a sufficient means of transmitting prompt, exact, and trustworthy information, such as an international preventive system would necessitate. These bulletins will nevertheless be of use during the epidemics and after their cessation. I do not wish to deny their usefulness in this respect. Every one admits that prompt information is necessary, and it is only such information that can immediately report the sanitary condition, and give a timely warning of an existing or imminent danger. At times, contagious and infectious diseases affect a slow and insidious progress; their inva- sion and spreading have an indolent character, which should be distrusted. Ordinarily they spread with an astounding and fearful rapidity. I take the yellow fever as an example. The last appearance of this disease proves that it has taken an increasing malignant form. It is continually extending its pernicious and deadly sway, especially on account of its suddenness, and the insidious and unlooked-for character of its invasion. The continually increasing facility of communication and the rapidity of the means of transportation, which have arrived at a surprising degree, are so many powerful allies of infec- tious and contagious diseases. Yellow fever is spreading in a fearful manner in the Western Hemisphere. It is urgent to oppose barriers to its invading progress. This Conference will deserve the thanks of humanity if it succeeds in taking the first prac- tical, the most difficult, steps toward arresting the progress of this disease. 8 Not only the coasts but also the interior of the United States are continually threatened by the yellow fever. In the North it appeared at Boston, and has spread from the coast and the interior to Montevideo and Buenos Ayres in South America, including the whole line of coasts and the West Indian Islands. It has crossed the Isthmus of Panama and spread to the coast of the Pacific Ocean. The western coast of Africa has its two zones of endemic yellow fever, including at least ten degrees to the north and the south of the equator. From thence it has been exported to the neighboring islands, and also to Great Britain. Europe has been partly attacked, only temporary, it is true, but not less fatally. It is continually threatened. The first vessel that, sailing from an infected port, shall pass through the canal of Suez east- ward, is the. sword of Damocles suspended over the heads of the Oriental populations. The first vessel which shall sail from an original or secondary source of infection, and shall pursue its course from the Caraibean Sea or the Gulf of Mexico (through a Panama Canal, or by means of transport across the Isthmus) to the Pacific Ocean, and bound westward, will be a fatal threat for a part of the globe until now free from infection: i. e., the Eastern Archipelago and countries, of China, Japan, the British Indian Empire, the Spanish, French, Portuguese, and Netherlands Colonies, Australasia, Polynesia, will all be threatened by infection. I can foresee the misery, the panic at its approach, and the immense disaster resulting from the invasion of this terrible angel of death. And once imported into these tropical and sub-tropical regions, the yellow fever will never leave! I will now close, but I wish to add that yellow fever is a terrible plague, more terrible still than cholera, to which we have been able to oppose, with some success, certain general and special hygenic measures, particularly pure drinking ivater. Yellow fever is a threat to the whole humanity, and populations at present free from con- tamination have no safeguard against it. It causes great hinderances to, and can completely stop commerce, industry, and immigration. It threatens the existence, the propagation, the prosperity, and the domination of the white race in the tropical and subtropical climates. My amendment is as follows: Amendment To the proposition (called proposition IV) of the Delegate of Italy (Prince de Camporeale) by the Special Delegate of the Netherlands (Dr. F. J. Van Leent). To insert between the words responsible and agent (first paragraph of the proposition), the Word SANITARY. The first paragraph, amended, to read as follows: "The bill of health shall be delivered at the port of departure by the responsible sanitary agent of the central government." The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAM PORE ALE). I accept the amendment of the Special Delegate of the Netherlands. The Delegate of Spain (Se^or de VIGO) presented the following proposition, in order to complete the idea contained in the proposition of the Delegate of Italy: "The consul of the country of destination shall have the right to be present at the examina- tion of ships made by the representative of the central government, under such rules as may be laid down by international agreement or treaty." The Delegate of Italy (Prince CAMPOREALE). I accept the amendment. The Delegate of Portugal (Viscount das NOGUEIRAS) presented the following amendment: "The authorities of the port of departure shall deliver the bill of health when requested by the captains of vessels. It is recommended that each of the contracting nations should allow a physician of the country of departure, holding a public office, to visit the hospitals and inspect 9 the vessels. Or else this permission should be granted to the international sanitary physicians. In the first case the physician should be appointed by the consular officer of the country of des- tination." I am ready to accept any modification which the Conference may deem necessary to suggest in regard to the wording of this proposition, provided they do not change the substance of the amendment. By submitting this proposition, 1 am arguing in favor of the legislation of my own country. In Portugal the bills of health are optional, and we leave to each vessel the liberty of taking or refusing to take one. These bills of health are delivered in the interest of the countries of destination, and it is their place to ask for them, if they deem them necessary. Article 127 of the General Sanitary Maritime Regulations, which was enforced by the act of November 12,1874, says, " Bills of health for ships leaving any Portuguese port shall be de- livered by the officers (guardas mores) of the respective sanitary ports, and will only be de- livered on demand of the captains or masters of vessels." What I have just quoted refers to the first part of the proposition which I had the honor of presenting to the Conference. In the second part of my proposition, laying aside all national pride in the matter, I ask that the visits to the hospitals and the inspection of vessels be made by a physician at the port of departure, chosen by the consul of the country of destination. I hope in this way to insure the reliability of the information, and, while not wounding the national pride, protect the port of destination, the latter naturally being the party most interested in knowing the sanitary con- dition of the port of departure and of the vessels. It does not appear to me that there are any serious practical difficulties in the way of this method. The physicians intrusted with this service would receive the same remuneration as for an ordinary medical visit. The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPO RE ALE) asks leave to say a few words in reply to the remarks of the Delegate of the United States. The greater part of Dr. Turner's speech is intended to demonstrate the unreliability and untrustworthiness of the in- formation given, and of the action taken by the boards of health. As regards the sanitary organization of Italy, it is fully competent to accomplish its task, and does so reliably and well; it is concentrated in the hands of the Minister of the Interior, in Rome, assisted by a central sanitary council, in whose hands the supervision and the responsibility of the acts of all local authorities entirely rest. Consequently the information it collects and imparts is complete and founded on well-controlled data. When in his proposition he speaks of the central authority, he means some such authority, having the same duties and responsibilities. Lastly, as for the bills of health being issued by the consuls of the country of destination, I can only refer him to what he stated at the last meeting; that the consulates, as at present generally organized, offer less guarantee of doing well the work that would be intrusted to them than the local authorities. In localities where for local reasons it may be unavoidable, or in cases of special emergency, the several governments may be willing to go to the expense of furnishing the necessary staff, medical and other, to their consulates, but to establish it as the permanent normal duty of consulates in countries in which the lack of competent sanitary organization does not render it imperative, is not practicable in his opinion. The Delegate of Russia (Mr. BARTHOLOMEI). As far as the Delegate of the United States speaks for his own country I accept his judgment, because he is aware of all the facts in the case; but so far as his remarks refer to other countries I reserve my opinion. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. TURNER). I make no special distinction of any country, but speak from observation based upon facts. The remarks of the Delegates of Italy and Russia are in consonance with the principles 1 have already enunciated. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). Will the Delegate of 10 Portugal be willing to add the following words after the word "vessels," at the end of the first sentence: "But such bill of health shall bear the vise of the consul of the country of destination." The Delegate of Portugal (Viscount das NOGUEIRAS). Certainly; I will accept it. The Delegate of Sweden-Norway (Count LEWENHAUPT). I wish to ask a question for information relative to the amendment of the Delegate of Portugal. Who is to deliver the bill of health when the local authority does not deliver it, and when the captain of a vessel does not ask the local authority for one? The Delegate of Portugal (Viscount das NOGUEIRAS). Nobody; there will be no bill of health. The Delegate of Sweden-Norway (Count LEWENHAUPT). The question is: If the captain does not choose to ask for a bill of health from the local authority, has he the right to go to the consul and ask him to deliver it? The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I suppose it would be as the authorities of the country of destination would prescribe. Each country has its own rules on that subject. The Delegate of Sweden-Norway (Count LEWENHAUPT). Could that propo- sition be divided? The President (Mr. HAY). The proposition is placed before the Conference as a whole, and it cannot be divided save by a vote of the Conference to that effect. The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. de BILLE). There are now so many amendments and counter-amendments before us that it is difficult to form an opinion of the respective value of each. If I rightly understand the proposition of the Delegate of Italy it embodies a clear and wel 1-defined principle. He says the bill of health should always be delivered at the port of departure by the responsible agent of the central government, and that the consul of the port of destination should vise it. I think if a majority could be brought to favor this proposition the Conference might congratulate itself. But it is to be feared a majority of the Delegates will vote against it. I should be willing, therefore, to vote for some amendment on which we might all agree, and I think we ought to be able to find such a compromise for the propositions of the Delegates of the United States and of Italy in the amendment of the Delegate of Portugal, on which all might unite. The Delegate of Portugal, in his proposition, says the authorities of the port of departure should deliver the bills of health, not as local authorities, but as representatives of the authority of the land of destination. I understand the honorable Delegate of Portugal wishes the inspection to be made at the port of departure by physicians, but by physicians chosen by the consular agent of the country of destination. The second part of the proposition refers more especially to the visits to the hospitals and the inspection of vessels. But the bill of health would always have to be delivered by the local authority. This proposition, while taking into account certain objections, coincides partly with that of the Delegate of Italy. If the Conference adopts the proposition of the Delegate of Italy I shall be satisfied, but I could also, as a compromise, favor the ideas contained in the proposition of the Delegate of Portugal. Thus situated I ask our honorable President to tell us in what order he intends to take the votes. In my opinion it would be expedient to begin with the amendment of the Delegate of Italy, as the most radical, and to pass next to that of Portugal. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I wish to say on behalf of the Delegates of the United States, that, while the proposition of the Delegate from Portugal falls short of what the United States Delegates had hoped might be accomplished, it approaches nearer to it than any proposition yet made, and we are willing to accept it as a compromise. I hope therefore the proposition of the Delegate of Portugal will meet with the approbation of the Conference. The Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. CERVERA). As the Delegate of Denmark has just said, it is very difficult to arrive at an understanding in a discussion conducted with so little 11 method, and encumbered with so many amendments. It is the logical consequence of our way of proceeding. We are discussing very difficult sanitary questions, upon sanitary principles not well defined. It is not astonishing, therefore, if we always find ourselves at the same point without reaching a definite conclusion. Our object is to establish a system of international notification, and of inspections of vessels, which will give us more safety against the invasion of infectious diseases. If I am not mistaken, the principal aim of this Conference ought to be how to defend the different countries against the importation of yellow fever, cholera, and other contagious diseases. What progress have we made in this direction up to the present time? The Conference has refused to deal with that question in a scientific point of view, and the result is that every moment affirmations are made too absolute in their nature. The honorable Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell) said at the last session (and I find that in his speech) that yellow fever is constantly imported into the United States, and is never exported from it to other countries. I cannot agree with my honorable colleague in regard to that declaration. To deal with yellow fever, and the means to prevent its ravages, is a duty of high importance, and one that belongs to this Conference. The yellow fever is an endemic disease in certain latitudes on the shores of the American continent. Its principal center is without doubt the Mexican Gulf, but it is not correct to admit a given point as the origin of that disease, because it is found everywhere, and it can break out in Cuba, at Vera Cruz, at the mouths of the Mississippi, or on the shores bordering on the Gulf. We cannot concede this Gulf as an immense center for the production of this disease. On the contrary, there are different centers of productions found on low and humid ground in large cities, in maritime ports, as well as towns situated on rivers. That disease affects the coast of the United States as far north as Charleston. These facts are very well known, and therefore I was astonished when I heard Dr. Cabell say that yellow fever is never exported from the United States. I was the more astonished because the medical authorities of his own country do not agree with him in his assertion. Medical science recognizes to-day the existence of a germ of animal nature and of telluric origin as the principle of yellow fever. The evolution of those germs depends on certain favor- able conditions for their development and distribution. It augments in certain regions more rapidly than in others, under certain climatic circumstances, where a large population is settled closely together. The yellow-fever germ increases or decreases under certain conditions of high temperature, wet lands along the coast and large rivers, sudden changes in the temperature from dry to wet, and accumulations of organic matter in decomposition; a certain degree of heat is a very favor- able element of propagation. Facts exist proving that this germ can be produced in low tem- peratures also, and the frost alone can destroy its influence. The effect of the frost in New Orleans and Louisiana in 1853 is proof of what I say. The epidemic of Cuba in 1857, from October until May, is another proof. It is also shown that the disease can reach as far north as the 50th degree of latitude. From what I have just said you can see that if the morbigene germ of yellow fever resides, so to speak, in a latent state in the Gulf of Mexico, and along its shores, it is found also in Brazil and Sierra Leone, in Africa; and in those regions, under the influence of certain conditions, which I have explained, it can de- velop to a great extent. I have just said, and I repeat, yellow fever is susceptible of importation into certain coun- tries, and the best way to prevent its transmission and propagation, with the exception of the means already known, is to create a sanitary international commission for its study, as has been done in the East relative to cholera. It is well known that the disease can, under favorable conditions, pass very rapidly from an endemic to an epidemic state. In that case it is more to be feared, because those germs to which it owes its birth are communicated very easily to all the surrounding objects, and especially to ships, their cargoes, passengers, and crews. 12 Of all infectious and contagious diseases, I undertake to say that yellow fever is the least known; that its germ is not yet defined. Its contagion has less life than the cholera, but it is perhaps more easily communicated by ships and merchandise than any other contagious disease. Very often it happens that a ship supposed to be perfectly clean is sometimes contaminated by the germs of that terrible disease. We have an instance in the well-known case of the Portu- guese vessel, Dona Maria, in which the fever broke out after the ship had been in quarantine and submitted to a very rigorous disinfection. We must confess that medical science, at the present moment, does not possess sure means of determining the existence of the germs of disease in ships. It is true we can arrive at sufficiently accurate conclusions by taking into account certain circumstances and conditions, and that is why at the head of the system of notification and inspec- tion and bills of health competent physicians are placed, as they by their knowledge and skill will afford a guarantee against the importation of contagious disease. Let us try first to find the conditions under which those germs can be developed. Let us fix the home of this scourge, and after that we can arrive at an understanding. I have made only some few remarks on the medical questions involved, but I am sure they are not interesting to the diplomatic delegates, and so I have abstained from giving more details. As for the amendment of the honorable Delegate of Portugal, I must say that I am not ready to adopt it, as I am convinced it is impracticable. Dr. Van Leent has proved this; and even had he not done so, I could not agree that bills of health should be delivered by the local authorities only at the request of the captains of vessels. The Delegate of Portugal (Viscount das NOGUEIRAS). We are assembled in this Conference in order to arrive at a practical result. If there is a point on which we can agree it will, in my opinion, be very advantageous to arrive at it. The proposition that I have offered seems to me to answer to the object we have in view, viz, to have information of the sanitary condition of the ports and ships. The Special Delegate of Spain does not think that it will be a good thing to leave it optional with the captains of ships to ask or not to ask for a bill of health. To that objection I will answer that the country of destination only is interested to know the real sanitary state of the country of departure. I do not see why the local author- ities of a port should deliver a bill of health when they are not asked by the captains of vessels. I also think that the consuls residing in any port will always be able to give to their respective countries notification of the sanitary condition of those ports, and I believe that the Conference will arrive at a practical result by leaving the choice of the physicians who are to make the inspections of hospitals and of vessels to the consuls. The question was taken on the proposition of the Delegate of Portugal (Viscount das Nogueiras), as amended by the Delegate of the United States, and it was decided in the nega- tive, yeas 3, nays 15, as follows: Chili, United States, Portugal-Yeas 3. Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, China, Denmark, Spain, France, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, Netherlands, Russia, Sweden-Norway, Turkey-Nays 15. The question was then taken on proposition IV, offered by the Delegate of Italy (Prince de Camporeale), and it was decided in the affirmative, yeas 11, nays 7, as follows: Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Chili, Denmark, Spain, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, Netherlands, Portugal-Yeas 11. Belgium, China, United States, France, Russia, Sweden-Norway, Turkey-Nays 7. The President (Mr. HAY). In the absence of any other order, the next business is the proposition of Dr. Cabell, which is as follows: "Art. 3. It is recommended that each government should permit the accredited agents of the other contracting parties, assisted, when necessary, by medical sanitarians, to examine every- 13 thing that can help them to form an accurate idea of the sanitary condition of the country." The Special Delegate of the Netherlands (Dr. VAN LEENT). The proposition of the Delegate of the United States has a wide range, and I am convinced not one government will admit such inspectors. The Special Delegate of Belgium (Mr. SEVE). I do not admit the opinion of the Delegate of the Netherlands, but besides the question of delicacy there is also a question of right for the consuls to verify the information which they collect and see whether it is trustworthy. I am compelled to say it is in the interest of cities and ports to conceal their real sanitary state. Cities that have a considerable trade, as New York, Philadelphia, and Antwerp are interested not to prejudice their trade. Such a prejudice will amount to millions when a contagious disease is known to exist at those ports. I have mentioned New York and Philadelphia especially, be- cause of the dirty condition of the streets of those cities. The condition of the streets is really shameful, and it is a question with me whether it is not my duty as Consul-General of Belgium in the United States to notify my government that an epidemic of small-pox exists in those places, and that the cholera will very probably make its appearance on account of the insalu- brity of those two cities. I have this information from very competent physicians of Philadel- phia and New York. For all those reasons, I am of the opinion that the consuls ought to have the right to control the affirmation of the local authorities. They should be allowed, moreover, to visit hospitals and lazarettos in order to be convinced de visu of the existence of contagious disease. I am convinced that, notwithstanding the danger of such inspections to the consuls, they will never shrink from their duty. I agree consequently with the proposition of the Del- egate of the United States, and hope the Conference will adopt it. The Delegate of Spain (Senor de VIGO). I cannot understand why the Special Delegate of Belgium declares that he has not confidence in the information given by the central sanitary authorities. I cannot understand why he should make such accusations. As for my- self, I have entire faith in the good will of those authorities, and also confidence in the consuls and consular agents in the countries where perfect sanitary organizations exist. I think that the central authority is more able than the consuls to know the exact sanitary condition of the country. If it is said the central authority is under the influence of the central local authorities, it can also be said that the consuls can be influenced by their close connection with the mercan- tile classes of the large centers, and that they will conceal the truth in their reports to their gov- ernments. But I am sure that both sides will do their best towards giving the most trustworthy information. The question for the present is who will be the most competent authority to fur- nish this information. I cannot see a more competent one than the central authority-I mean, of course, in those countries where perfect sanitary organizations exist. The Special Delegate of Belgium (Mr. SEVE). In answer to the honorable Delegate of Spain, I will say I have never pretended that more confidence should be placed in the statements of consuls than in those of the local authorities. I have only asked that con- suls be given authority to verify the information given by the local authorities. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO). The Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell) proposes to strike out the second paragraph of proposition 5 of the com- mittee, and to replace the first by another tending to authorize the consuls to examine every- thing that can give them an accurate idea of the sanitary conditions of the countries to which they are accredited. We all agree that it is necessary at all times to have accurate information as to the sanitary condition of different countries; but our disagreement begins when we come to consider how this information shall be given. Some ask that the necessary examinations be made by the agent of the country of departure, others by the agent of the country of destination, in order to control the declarations of the local authorities. These inspections should be made 14 by physicians. It is impossible for me to hold a contrary opinion. The proposition of the honorable Delegate of Portugal (Viscount das Nogueiras) conciliates, I think, in a very satisfactory way, all the different interests, but as the Conference has not approved it I will not take up the time of the Delegates with arguments in its defense. For the reasons I have just given, I prefer the wording of the first paragraph of the committee to that proposed by the Delegate of the United States. As for the paragraph he proposes to strike out, I am more and more convinced that it ought to be retained. If it was necessary to advance proofs in its favor, we have just had them offered. We have already witnessed the difference of opinion between two highly respected physicians. The President of the National Board of Health asserts that the yellow fever is constantly imported into the United States. On the other hand, the Special Delegate of Spain says that disease is endemic on the coast of the Mexican Gulf, and consequently in an important part of the United States. I ask myself how is it possible that two physicians so eminent have a dif- ference of opinion on such an important question. Evi lently it is necessary to study the yellow fever more, and that is why your committee stated it was necessary to create an international corps of sanitary physicians residing in cities where endemics and epidemics are, in order to study the etiology, the progress, prophylactics, and treatment of this disease. Yes, we must study this terrible disease; we must go to its home; we must study the secrets of its origin and of its diffusion, in order to be able to stop its deadly march. We have used the weapons of science against the pest and cholera, and those two terrible scourges are on the decline. The admirable plans for rendering healthy infected districts in the East Indies by the English, and the sanitary measures taken in the East by international agreement, have produced these splendid results. We must do the same for yellow fever, a disease that has made great progress in this century, and threatens to extend more; a disease scarcely known in the fifteenth century, and which has appeared in the Gulf of Mexico only since the seventeenth century, and which has now invaded all the eastern part of America, from the mouths of the La Plate to those of the St. Lawrence; and lately it has appeared on the western side, where, it is to be feared, it will become endemic, as it has at some eastern points of America and on the eastern coast of Africa, and which is destined to penetrate into the warm and temperate regions of Asia, Australia, and of Europe, if we do not oppose a strong barrier to its march. I repeat, it is necessary to study that disease with all the means afforded by an international organization. It is the first time a Conference has been called to study the means of preventing the propagation of yellow fever, and I think the object of the Conference will be lost if we do not express at least a wish that an international study of this disease must be undertaken. If the Conference does not design to embody that wish in the convention, let us at least express it in the form of an appendix, as Dr. Cabell suggests. Who can be opposed to the realization of such a wish? The governments? No. They have expressed, by the voice of their delegates in the sanitary conferences of Paris, Constantinople, and Vienna, the desire to establish the basis of the international system of prophylactics. The physicians? No. In the sanitary conferences of Brussels in 1876, and in Paris in 1878, and Stuttgard in 1879, and Turin in 1880, they have expressed the same wish. If they all agree, why do they not realize the wish. Is it on account of the expense? No. The expenses occasioned by epidemics arc far more considerable than the cost of preventing them would amount to. In January, 1879, a com- mission composed of competent persons calculated that the means of restriction imposed on the commerce of the city of New Orleans alone in 1878 occasioned losses amounting to $100,000,000. From this basis it is easy to calculate the immense losses inflicted on the different ports of the world by this disease. A commission of epidemiologists residing in ports where such en- demics and epidemics exist, and paid by the countries interested, will not, in my opinion, be a very heavy burden for the treasury of those countries. The National Board of Health has 15 shown that it was convinced of the advantages of such international studies when it sent a commission to Havana to study the yellow fever. But such works should be pushed by the cencentrated efforts of all nations interested. In such case the results will be very great, and all the countries who will take part will receive the benefits. The Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. CERVERA). It is unfortunate, but whenever we undertake to discuss the report of the committee we fall into confusion. I agree with my honorable colleague, the Special Delegate of Portugal, on the scientific questions he has just explained, but I am opposed to the adoption of the proposition just submitted to us. Why is there a division among us? I will tell you. In Article V of the committee it is said that it is desira- ble that consuls should be assisted by medical sanitarians, who should furnish them with all necessary information. After that they add, those physicians should belong to an international corps of sanitarians. That will necessitate the creation of quite an army of physicians, and I am opposed to that, because it is not practicable and not clearly stated. What I desire is, when the Conference conies to decide on the question of yellow fever a commission of experts be created, the members to be chosen in the different countries interested, to study the nature of that terrible disease and to provide means for its prevention. I do not ask the creation of an international medical corps in all the countries, but the establishment of a medical commission residing in the different towns of the Mexican Gulf, which will hold meetings at stated times. That commission may be composed of very few physicians-9, 11, or 12. The only object of those physicians will be the study of yellow fever, its origin, progress, the laws that regulate its reappearance, its spread and disappearance, and also to find the cir- cumstances favorable to its spread. That is an object worthy to be taken into consideration by the Conference. That commission will obtain exact information of all that relates to the public health and will communicate it to the contracting parties. That is what I understand will be the mission of such an international sanitary conference. Did the proposition of Dr. Cabell answer to that end? No. Dr. Cabell proposes simply to give to the consuls and consular agents the right to inspect everything in the country to which they are accredited. I am opposed to giving such a right, and cannot vote for his proposition. In every country where there are consular agents the authorities will have the courtesy to give them the information they want. As a proof of this, I will cite the reception of the yellow-fever commission sent to Havana by the National Board of Health, spoken of by Dr. Cabell at the last meeting. The authorities are always willing to give consuls all necessary information. But the question is to determine what rights you will give to these consuls. For my part, I am willing to grant them the right to be present at the inspection of vessels by physicians representing the territorial authorities. But there is a vast difference between that right and the right which Dr. Cabell gives them by his proposition, viz, to allow them to inspect everything they may judge necessary in the country to which they are accredited. After this explanation, I am certain that Dr. Van Leent will be of my opinion, and will understand the reason of my reserve on the subject of this article. I came to this Conference with most liberal ideas, and am ready to do everything in my power to protect ourselves against epidemics; but I do not wish to exceed my object nor my instructions. I propose that we should try and word this article in another manner touching what concerns the consuls. We ought to try and insert a very clear article relative to sanitary inspections of ships, and we shall then have done something very useful. It would be the beginning of work which we should complete later, and the Conference will not have proved a failure. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). Mr. President, it seems quite obvious that the second paragraph of proposition 5 of the committee relates to an entirely different subject from that of the first paragraph of the same proposition. For this reason I moved to strike out the last paragraph entirely. It relates to a method of studying the history, development, and mode of prevention of contagious and infectious diseases by means of an in- 16 ternational commission, while the first paragraph relates to such current information as consuls representing the country of destination are required to communicate to their respective govern- ments. I have heretofore expressed the opinion that the appointment of an international com- mission for the study of epidemic diseases in the countries of their origin would be a very desirable advance in international hygiene, and that, as a sanitarian, I should be delighted to see such a movement. But though such a proposition has been made in former international conferences in Paris and at Vienna, no practical result has been obtained, and I feel sure that a similar fate will attend the adoption of the proposition now, while it may jeopard the success of other and more urgent measures which may be incorporated in the proposed convention. For this reason I shall vote against proposition 5, now that the Conference has rejected my proposed amendment. While I am up I beg leave to read some of the articles of the International Treaty of Paris of 1852 : "Art. XXIII. In addition to the name of the vessel, of that of the captain or master, and the particulars relating to the tonnage, cargo, number of the crew, passengers, &c., the bill of health shall state exactly the sanitary condition of the place, as ascertained by the health authorities, and the sanitary state of the vessel. "If there should be any sick on board, mention shall be made of it. "The bill of health must in fact contain all particulars which will enlighten the health authorities of the port of destination, and enable them to form, as accurate as possible, an idea of the public health of the place of departure and its suburbs, of the condition of the vessel and its cargo, of the health of its crew and passengers. "Those places shall be deemed suburbs which are in constant communication with the port of departure, and which form part of the same sanitary district." Now, sir, if the consul who is to authenticate the bill of health by his vi^e is to do this intelligently, and to be responsible to his government for the trustworthiness of the information, he should have the opportunity to make himself acquainted with all the facts referred to in this 23d article of the Paris Convention. I beg now to call the attention of the Conference to the special and exceptional regulations incorporated in the same convention for the security of the public health of Europe against the importation of infectious diseases (cholera and plague) from the East: "Art. CXXVIII. The number of European doctors now appointed as medical officers in the East shall be increased up to 26 and distributed into 4 districts. "The Powers, signatories to the convention, shall finally arrange with the government of the Sublime Porte the details for carrying out in common this measure." " CXXXIII. The European doctors appointed medical officers in the East shall be entirely independent of the local authorities, and shall only be responsible to the governments by which they have been appointed. " CXXXIV. The duties of the medical officers shall be as follows: "1. To study in relation to the public health the country where they are, its climate, its diseases, and all its characteristics, as also the measures taken to combat with those diseases. " 2. With this object to make tours of inspection of their respective districts as often as they may think it advisable, in Egypt as often as possible. "3. To communicate everything relating to the public health to the central doctor of the district, the consular body, and, if needs be, to the local authorities of the country, twice a week in Turkey and every week in Egypt. In case of an epidemic or any other suspicious disease, as also in all extraordinary cases, the medical officer shall send without delay a special report to all the above mentioned authorities, and to all the medical officers and consuls of the neighboring 17 districts, and, if necessary, to same doctors and consuls more distant to whom such information might be useful. "They will furthermore have to follow, in matters of detail, the directions annexed to the present regulations. "CXXXV. When a contagious disease is suspected the medical officers shall immediately acquaint the health officer, and vice versa, and thereupon a medical consultation shall be held, the result of which shall be forthwith communicated to the above-mentioned authorities. "CXXXVL At the same time the health officers, stations, deputations, committees, &c., shall be bound to furnish the doctors with correct written particulars of everything relating to the public health, and they shall admit the doctors into the offices of the health administration every time that the latter shall see fit to go there to obtain information or verbal explanation." From this it appears that Europe, and especially France, took effective measures to protect the public health without waiting for the slow action of local authorities, by sending their own agents to do the necessary work. They were right, and they were successful. Now, observe the difference in the "Provisions relative to America ": "CXXXVTI. In the countries liable to yellow fever belonging to the Powers, signatories to the convention, and where there is not already a regular medical service, the respective gov- ernments shall appoint medical officers to study that disease, its source and propagation, to seek the means to prevent it, and to combat it and verify its cessation; to fulfill, in a word, officially, with respect to the yellow fever, the duties performed in reference to the plague by the medical officers in the East." I am not aware that this article was ever executed-and exactly such will be the fate of Article 5, if adopted by this Conference. The Delegate of Sweden-Norway (Count LEWENHAUPT). I beg to state that I shall be obliged to vote against the amendment proposed on account of the words "contracting parties." In my opinion, the amendment contains only what is already allowed in all countries, and what ought to be allowed, but I am not willing to recommend to my government to conclude a convention containing this article. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I have no objection to striking out those words and inserting in their stead the word "governments," and will make that change. The question was taken on the substitute of the Delegate of the United States Dr. Ca- bell) for No. 5, and it was decided in the negative, yeas 5, nays 11, abstaining 2, as follows: Germany, Austria-Hungary, Chili, United States, Sweden-Norway-Yeas 5. Argentine Republic, Belgium, China, Denmark, Spain, France, Hayti, Mexico, Nether- lands, Russia, Turkey-Nays 11. Italy, Portugal-Abstaining 2. The question then recurred on proposition 5 of the committee's report, and it was decided in the negative, yeas 2, nays 15, abstaining 1, as follows: Argentine Republic, Portugal-Yeas 2. Germany, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Chili, China, Denmark, United States, France, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, Netherlands, Prussia, Sweden-Norway, Turkey-Nays 15. Spain-Abstaining 1. Proposition 8 of the committee's report was read as follows: " 8 th. In those towns where there are sanitary physicians belonging to the international body, they should have the right to examine everything that can help them to form an accurate idea of the sanitary condition of the country." The President (Mr. HAY). This proposition was included in the proposition of the 18 Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell) which was rejected. If there is no objection this will be considered as passed upon. There was no objection, and it was so ordered. Proposition 9 of the report of the committee was read as follows : "9th. The appearance and the existence of any epidemic disease in cities and ports cannot be well known and attested but by physicians, so that the authority that should certify to the sanitary condition of cities and ports ought to be a physician responsible for his acts, but in case another administrative agent deliver a bill of health to the vessel leaving the port, he should be provided with official information supplied by medical authority; without this information it will be impossible for him to certify to the health of the vessel, and as the examination of the sanitary condition of a vessel properly belongs to a medical man, it is desirable that the officer in charge of inspecting vessels and delivering bills of health be a physician, and such physician should be attached to the consulate." The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. de BILLE). I think it will be impossible to adopt this article after what we have done. It has been already stated in the proposition of the Dele- gate of Italy who is now to give the bill of health, and this proposition is not in order. The President (Mr. HAY). If that is the opinion of the Conference this proposition will also be considered as passed upon. It was so ordered. Proposition 10 of the report of the committee was read as follows: "10th. As the permanency of a scientific organization has been approved by this committee, it is desirable that a permanent commission should be established." The President (Mr. HAY). This proposition should be postponed until the proposition of Count Bethlen is reported on. There was no objection, and it was ordered accordingly. Proposition 11 of the report of the committee was read as follows: "11th. It is desirable that the bill of health issued in compliance with international rules should be issued gratis." The question was taken, and there were yeas 8, nays 5, abstaining 4, as follows: Germany, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Denmark, United States, France, Hayti, Nether- lands-Yeas 8. China, Italy, Russia, Sweden-Norway, Turkey*-Nays 5. Argentine Republic, Spain, Mexico, Portugal-Abstaining 4. The President (Mr. HAY). A majority of the Delegates present have not voted in favor of the proposition, but the majority of those voting have done so, and I decide the proposition carried. So proposition 11 of the committee's report was adopted. The President (Mr. HAY). Consideration of proposition 12 of the committee's report will be postponed until the form of bill of health is acted on. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I move that the International Bill of Health shall be in the form reported by the committee. The bill of health was read, as follows : 19 International Bill of Health. I, . (consul, consular agent, or other officer empowered to sign) at the port of . , do hereby state that the vessel hereinafter named clears from this port under the following circumstances: Name of vessel: Tonnage: Apartments for passengers, No. Destination: Name of medical officer (if any): Total number of passengers: 1st cabin,... ; 2d cabin, .... ; steerage, Nature (vessel-of-war, ship, schooner, &c.): Guns: _ Where last from: Name of captain : Total number of crew: - Cargo: Vessel. 1. Sanitary condition of vessel (before and after reception of cargo, with note of any decayed wood). Note disinfection of vessel: ... - 2. Sanitary condition of cargo: 3. Sanitary condition of crew: 4. Sanitary condition of passengers: 5. Sanitary condition of clothing, food, water, air-space, and ventilation: ... Port. 1. Sanitary condition of port and adjacent country- a. Prevailing disease (if any): b. Number of cases of and deaths from yellow fever, Asiatic cholera, plague, small-pox, or typhus fever during the week preceding- Number of cases of- Yellow fever: Asiatic cholera: Plague: Small-pox : Typhus fever: Number of deaths from- Yellow fever: Asiatic cholera : Plague: Small-pox: Typhus fever : _ c. Population according to the last census: d. Total deaths from all causes during the preceding month: 2. Any circumstances affecting the public health existing in the port of departure to be here stated: I certify that the foregoino- statements are made by _ who has O J 7 personally inspected said vessel; that I am satisfied that the said statements are correct; and I do further certify that the said vessel leaves this port, bound for ... , in In witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand and the seal of office, at the port of , this day of , 188 , o'clock. [seal.] Consul. The Special Delegate of the Netherlands (Dr. VAN LEENT). I wish to say that this bill is the most complete I have ever seen. There may be some few modifications necessary, but those changes can be decided on by the Conference. The Delegate of Russia (Mr. BARTHOLOMEI). I suggest that we have time to examine this form. We mignt leave this for the present and proceed with the next business in order. 20 The President (Mr. HAY). It has been printed and under the eyes of the members for almost a month. It was unanimously adopted by the committee, but I will put the question to a vote, and if the Conference is not ready to consider it now, its consideration will, of course, be postponed. The question was taken on taking up for consideration of the bill of health, and it was de- cided in the affirmative, yeas 12, nays 5, as follows: Yeas-Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, Netherlands, Portugal, Sweden-Norway, Belgium, Turkey-12. Nays-Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, China, Russia-5. So the Conference agreed to consider the bill of health. The question then recurred on the motion of the Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell), that the form of bill of health presented by the committee be adopted. The vote was taken, and it was decided in the affirmative, yeas 11, nays 6, as follows: Yeas-Belgium, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, Netherlands, Portugal, Turkey-11. Nays - Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, China, Russia, Sweden-Nor- way-6. So the form for the International Bill of Health, as reported by the committee, was adopted. Proposition 12 of the committee report was then read, as follows: "12th. It is desirable that the bill of health issued in compliance with international rules shall be considered evidence of the health of the ship at the port and time of departure." The Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. CERVERA). At the time of the elaboration of this article I asked for some explanation relative to the range of this proposition. The bill of health can have great value or none whatever. For ordinary diseases it furnishes sufficient proof, but when it comes to the question of yellow fever it has no value whatever, for the vessel can leave a port with a clean bill of health and nevertheless have the germs of the disease on board. It is for this reason that all countries require additional proof to those furnished by the bill of health. Therefore I am of the opinion that the bill of health, instead of being considered evidence of the health of a ship at the time of departure, should be considered as furnishing proof of the sanitary condition of the port at the time of the departure of the vessel. If we are only to consider the bill of health proof of the sanitary condition of the vessel at the time of departure, without prejudice to what may happen during the voyage, I have no objection to offer. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I move proposition 12 be stricken out. It is useless now. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). I agree with the honorable Delegate of the United States, and I also think this proposition should be stricken out. The question was taken and it was decided unanimously in the affirmative. So proposition 12 was stricken out. The Delegate of Italy ( Prince de CAMPOREALE). In all the propositions up to the present time submitted to the Conference, it has been only as to the question of powers having complete sanitary organizations; but what will happen to countries having none? The memorandum of the honorable Secretary of State of July 29, 1880, justly asks that question, and I think the Conference ought to examine it. The President (Mr. HAY). Suppose you make the proposition that that be the unfinished business for the next meeting. 21 The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE). I propose for discussion at the next sitting the Sth question contained in the circular of Mr. Evarts of July 29, 1881. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTA RCHT BEY). And any other question perti- nent to this matter which has not been discussed. The question was taken, and it was decided unanimously in the affirmative. Then, on motion of the Delegate of the United States (Dr. Cabell), at 5 o'clock p. m., the Conference adjourned to meet at the call of the President. The President of the Conference JOHN HAY. The Secretary of the Conference THOMAS J. TURNER. The French Secretary RUSTEM. INTERNATIONAL SANITARY CONFERENCE OF WASHINGTON. PROTOCOL No. 7. Session of February 18, 1881. The Conference met at 1 o'clock p. m., pursuant to the call of the President (Mr. Hay). The following Delegates were present: Germany: H. A. Schumacher. Argentine Republic: Seiior Don Julio Carrig. Austria-Hungary: Count Bethlen. Belgium : Baron d'Anethan and Mr. Edouard Seve. Chili: Seiior Don Francisco Solano Asta-Buruaga. Denmark: Mr. Carl Steen Andersen de Bille. Spain: Senor Don Felipe Mendez de Vigo, and Seiior Don Rafael Cervera. United States: Dr. James L. Cabell; Dr. Thomas J. Turner; J. Hubley Ashton, Esq.; James Lowndes, Esq. France: Mr. Maxime Outrey. Hayti: Mr. Stephen Preston. Italy: Prince de Camporeale. Japan: Jushie Yoshida Kiyonari. Mexico: Seiior Don Ignacio Alvarado. The Netherlands: Jonkheer Rudolph von Pestel, and Dr. F. J. van Leent. Portugal: Viscount das Nogueiras, and Professor Jose Joaquim da Silva Amado. Russia: Mr. Michel Bartholomei. Sweden and Norway: Count Carl Lewenhaupt. Turkey: Gregoire Aristarchi Bey. The protocol of the 6th session was laid before the Conference and approved. The credentials of Dr. Carlos Finlay, Special Delegate from Cuba, were presented. They are as follows: In compliance with the dispositions of Royal orders, dated 25th of October and 17th of December last, copies of which are appended, by decis- ion of the 22d instant, H. E. the Governor-General has been pleased to appoint you, in union of the Minister Plenipotentiary of the nation in Washington, to represent this island and that of Porto Rico at the International Sanitary Conference, which is to take place in that capital in the present month. To this effect are likewise appended a copy of the instructions to which you arc to conform in the above-mentioned Conference, as also of the maritime sanitary dispositions enacted from the 14th of June, 1879, until the 21st of May, 1880, and a volume which comprises the legisla- tion on that subject in the Peninsula. H. E. has likewise decided that copies shall be delivered to you of the proceedings of the Superior Board of Health of Porto Rico, in order that you may bear in mind their contents when the public health of that island shall be referred to at the Conference. Finally, H. E. has decided that in order to provide for the expenses which may be occa- sioned to you in the execution of this commission the treasury of the island shall advance to you the amount of two thousand dollars in gold; for which purpose opportune orders have been given on this date to the General Direction of Finances for the execution of the present decision. [seal.] General Government of the Island of Cuba. Secretary's Office. 2 By order of H. E. you are advised of the above for your information and satisfaction, urging you to undertake your trip without delay, inasmuch as, according to a telegram from H. E. the Minister Plenipotentiary of Spain in Washington, the sessions of the Conference have been taking place since the 12th instant. God preserve you many years. Havana, 28th of January, 1881. (Signed) Dr. Charles Finlay. JOAQUIN CARBONEL. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. TURNER). I have received a note from the Delegate of Great Britain (Mr. Archibald), written from Summerville, S. C., stating he is detained by the illness of his son, and inclosing a paper which he requests I should read. The President (Mr. HAY). If there is no objection the Delegate of the United States will proceed. There was no objection, and the paper was read, as follows: Mr. President, I beg leave to offer a few observations on the subject-matters before the Con- ference, and especially on that of the inspection of vessels, their cargoes and crews, at ports of departure by foreign agents. While I am equally desirous, with other members of the Con- ference, of adopting such measures as may be practicable and efficient, and, at the same time, not too burthensome on maritime commerce, toward accomplishing the objects proposed by the United States Government in convoking this Conference, I am constrained to say that I cannot approve a general application of the proposed system of inspection. It is open to the serious objection, among others, that its application must necessarily be partial, and consequently inefficient, in whatever country it may be adopted. I am willing, nevertheless, that it should be tried, experi- mentally, within certain geographical limits in those regions of the globe from whence there is the greatest danger of importing yellow fever or other dangerously contagious diseases. In the temperate zones the circumstances are exceptional and of rare occurrence, which would justify the burthens on commerce involved in the general application of the system, apart from the question of its efficiency. I think it therefore advisable that its operation should be restricted to ports and places lying within the tropics, or, perhaps, the parallels of 26 degrees of north and south latitude, as well as in the Mediterranean and Black Seas and the west coast of Morocco. Upon this topic, Mr. President, it is well that we should take into consideration the experience of the past in regard to international sanitary regulations. The most important Conference on this subject, within the present century, was that of Paris in 1850-'52, whose labors extended over a period of eighteen months. But it is remarkable that, although twelve powers were repre- sented in that Conference, the convention which resulted from it was made between two only, and was afterward acceded to by three other powers. A more thorough discussion of all that relates to the origin and propagation of infectious and contagious diseases, and to the prevention of their spreading by sea and land, than that which took place at this Conference, cannot well be conceived. The regulations adopted were very numerous and particular-designed to meet all possible contingencies. I shall, perhaps, be told that they related almost entirely to the subject of quarantine. That is quite true; but the inspection of vessels, their cargoes and crews, at ports of departure was also provided for in the regulations. It is, however, a significant fact that this treaty, which was the result of such long and careful deliberations, continued in force for five years only, and has not since been renewed. We may fairly assume, I think, that its provisions were found to be in some respects impracticable, and specially, perhaps, in regard to the inspec- tion of vessels. Then came the Conferences of Constantinople and Vienna, whose deliberations were very valuable, so far as regarded the study of the origin and propagation of cholera; but did not result in a convention. At these last-mentioned Conferences no discussion seems to have 3 taken place-at all events no provisions were adopted for the inspection of ships, cargoes, and crews at ports of departure, while great attention was given to the subject of quarantine. And now the question comes before us almost as a new one, and is manifestly the subject-matter which principally interests the United States Government in inviting this Conference. For, in regard to an improved system of notification and the statement of specific sanitary facts in bills of health, we are all, I believe, more or less agreed. Before passing from the subject of notifica- tion let me say that, concurring as I do in the principle of the resolution adopted on the 26th of January, I think all practical purposes would be answered if it were limited to a recommenda- tion that each government shall undertake to publish a weekly bulletin of diseases and deaths, with their causes, in its principal towns and seaports. The "greatest possible publicity" of such bulletins is not essential; but there should be an undertaking to furnish promptly and regularly to all foreign consuls and consular agents printed copies of the bulletins relating to their respect- ive consular districts. And all reasonable facilities for making themselves acquainted with the state of the public health within their districts should be extended to such consular officers and agents. Now, while I am, as I have said, willing that an experimental trial of inspection of vessels at ports of departure should be made in certain regions, I wish to point out some of the objec- tions to the system in general, on the ground of its inefficiency, as well as of the burthens to which it must subject maritime commerce. First, as to inefficiency. If the proposed system is to be of the value attributed to it, it should be uniformly enforced at all ports of departure of a country or district from whence there is danger of importing infectious or contagious diseases. Otherwise, it would be somewhat like attempting to repair a leaky roof by stopping two or three out of a dozen leaks. For, how many ports and places there are in which there is not only no consular officer of a foreign power, but not even a local health board or health officer, to whom the duty of inspection could be entrusted. On the other hand, in ports where there are consular officers, and a great number of vessels daily loading and departing, or where, as in not a few ports, the loading takes place in open roadsteads, at long distances from towns, how perfunctory would be the inspection, or in how many cases impracticable under such circumstances. The United States Government maintains more consular officers and agents than any other nation; and yet, in the maritime trade with Canada and other British possessions abroad, for one port in which there is a consular officer there are perhaps two or three where there are none. Again, if we take into consideration large seaports like those of Liverpool and New York, it would be simply impossible for the consular officers of the two countries, with any amount of medical assistance, to properly carry out the proposed inspections. So far as regards passenger ships leaving the United Kingdom, careful inspections are made, under the stringent regu- lations of the passenger acts, by competent and responsible officers, as well of the sani- tary condition of ships as of their crews and passengers, their provisions, and every- thing that relates to their health, and no person suffering from, or likely to com- municate, contagious disease is allowed to depart in the ship. But, with all this, you must still fall back on the time-honored protection of quarantine. I doubt if any amount of foreign inspection would sensibly lessen quarantine restriction, and I may add that it would be hazardous to relax it on the ground of preliminary inspection at ports of departure. Quaran- tine may be likened to a net which catches all vessels entering port; whereas foreign inspection, if relied on, might prove a delusion and snare. Secondly, as to the burthens on commerce. In these days, in which steam shipping is rapidly superseding sailing vessels, delays of even a few hours are very costly and vexatious to owners and shippers, to say nothing of incidental expenses and the fees and gratuities which in nearly all large seaports are already inevitable in order to insure dispatch. Then the interests of consignees and importers must be kept in view. 4 The services also to be rendered in connection with inspection by foreign agents, especially if medical men be employed, will involve a large additional expense, and by whom this is to be borne is an important question. Still, Mr. President, with whatever of disadvantages there may be, I am favorable to the adoption of a provision for the inspection of vessels, their crews, passengers, and cargoes, at ports of departure within the geographical limits above mentioned. In tropical regions, if in none other, vessels before loading should, as an invariable rule, be fumigated and have their bilges disinfected. This simple hygienic treatment should, indeed, be made imperative by every nation on its shipmasters. The vast improvement in the health of crews through the means used to extirpate scurvy furnishes an example of what may be accomplished by individual national action toward preventing the outbreak of diseases at sea. Now, whether inspections are to be made by medical officers of local health boards, where such exist, or by medical officers employed by consuls, must be left to the exigency of each case-provision being made that the consul or consular agent of the country of destination be allowed to take part in the inspection where it shall be made by a local sanitary officer. In general, I apprehend that such inspections will be made by the foreign agent of the country of destination. Vessels sailing under the flag of the country where they may be at anchor will, naturally, be inspected by an officer of the local health board, if there be such officer. That the inspection of ships, and especially of crews and passengers should, in order to be satisfactory, be made by medical men, I fully concede. But that such inspections can be conveniently made by members of a suggested international board of health, or medical board, I regard as impracticable. The expense, moreover, would be greater than most governments would consent to bear. Mr. President, there are means by which more effectual hindrances may be opposed to the generation and spreading of infectious and contagious diseases than can be accomplished by for- eign inspection of ships, by improved forms of bills of health, or by the most rigid quarantine. These are the adoption, especially in localities where malignant fevers are, so to speak, indigenous, of efficient domestic sanitary regulations, such as have been found eminently successful in temperate regions. If, as regards yellow fever, for instance, in those localities where it is found at almost all times of the year, an improved system of drainage of towns, of cleans- ing and ventilating streets and buildings, and an adequate supply of pure water were provided, we might hope to see, at no distant day, some of the more virulent infectious fevers and diseases, if not stamped out, at all events restricted to such reduced proportions as would remove, in a great measure, the dread of their exportation to other countries. How much has there not already been accomplished in this way to curb and mitigate the ravages of cholera ? We know that it is, in a great measure, because of the fear of importing yellow fever from the Gulf of Mexico into the United States that this Conference is being held; and it is due to the United States Government that we should adopt the most effective means to obviate the dreaded scourge. How far the appearance of the disease in any cities of the United States may be owing to the absence of proper hygienic regulations, I will not undertake to say; but I sincerely believe that if the voice of this Conference might be heard and heeded in tropical regions, then our earnest exhortations to the adoption of efficient local sanitary regulations would avail more than anything else toward accomplishing what it is hoped might be achieved by this international assembly. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY.) At the last meeting the Conference adopted, by a majority of four votes, a proposition relating to bills of health and the inspections of vessels, and no one, of course, would think of reconsidering this vote; but some of us have remarked with regret that the vote showed that the powers most interested in establishing an 5 agreement with their immediate neighbors were not of the same opinion on these two important questions. These observations, it is hardly necessary for me to say, apply more particularly to the United States and Spain, and all must understand that the principal object of this Confer- ence cannot be attained by the adoption of any international agreement to which those two countries and the States bordering on the Gulf of Mexico, whose maritime communications are so frequent, cannot agree. The question of protection against epidemical diseases, so far as the American continent is concerned, applies more especially to the coasts of the United States, Cuba, and Mexico, which are so near each other, and it is in regard to them that the greatest precautions will have to be taken. These considerations have induced us to see if we cannot find a new formula which would attain the object which the United States had in view in calling this Conference. There can be, according to our opinion, a medium between the American proposition, which is to take away from the territorial authority of the port of departure all right of intervention in what relates to the bill of health and to the inspection, and that proposition of the Delegate of Italy, which declares in an absolute manner that this bill is to be delivered by this authority. Some of my colleagues and myself have hoped to solve the difficulty by submitting a proposition to which, I am happy to say, the delegates of the United States have given their consent. It is in the names of my colleagues of the United States, Russia, Turkey, and Belgium, and in my my own name, that I ask the Conference to permit the insertion in the protocol of a new propo- sition, which will be considered the expression of the views of the minority. We do not wish to reopen the discussion, and therefore do not ask that this proposition be discussed and voted upon, but we only propose that it should be brought in this manner to the attention of the gov- ernments who will be at liberty to pass upon the different questions which have been the object of our deliberations. We would be well pleased should this proposition serve as the basis of agreement between the different States the territories of which are often threatened by epidemic diseases. This proposition is divided into two articles. The first reads as follows: " In the countries where the regulations provide that vessels should be furnished at the mo- ment of departure with a bill of health delivered by the local authorities, this bill of health shall continue to be delivered by those authorities, but the captain of the vessel is at liberty to have said bill of health vised by the consul of the country of destination, who will be obliged to give it with the least possible delay. The consul shall have the right to add to his vise any observation he may judge necessary. u If the vessel is not obliged to take a bill of health from the local authorities, the captain can ask for one from the consul of the country of destination, who shall be obliged to deliver said bill to him with the least possible delay." As you see, gentlemen, we maintain the right of the port of departure to impose a bill of health to be delivered by them, if they judge it necessary, but at the same time, if the country of destination should have more confidence in the opinion furnished by its own agents than in the statements furnished by the local authorities, we leave them the right to enforce the rules which it may judge necessary for its security, in permitting the captain to have the bill of health countersigned by the consul, and authorizing the latter to accompany his vise with such obser- vations as may appear to him to be necessary for the information of his country. Nevertheless, we do not consider that it is necessary to make this vis^ obligatory, for in many cases it will probably not be required by the authorities of the port of destination. You must leave liberty of action to the captain, who is the best judge of his interest, and you must trust to him to put himself in accord with the authorities of the port where he wishes to go. These general observa- tions apply with still more reason to those cases where the captain has only to consider the regu- lations of the country to which he is going. 6 The second article of this proposition is relative to the inspection of ships, and reads as follows: " In those countries the regulations of which require that the vessels before obtaining a bill of health from the local authority should be submitted to a sanitary inspection, the consul of the country of destination or his delegate may always, at the demand of the captain, assist at this inspection. If the vessel is not compelled to have a bill of health to be delivered by the local authority, the consul from whom the captain shall ask for this bill of health, or his delegate can make this inspection in conformity with rules to be established by common agreement be- tween the respective governments, but in such cases the inspections shall be made in concert with the consul of the country of the nationality of the vessel." In this article, as in the first, we make the distinction between the cases where the authority of the port of departure delivers the bill of health and that where this bill of health can be de- livered by the consul alone. In case the bill of health is to be visaed by the consul, it is natural that he should be authorized to assist at the regular inspection made by the local authorities, so that he may have the means of furnishing his government with information based on his own observations. If, on the contrary, it is he who is to deliver the bill of health, it is necessary that he should be able to make an inspection which will allow him to furnish information which is to be inserted in this document. But in this case, in order to avoid all abuse, we insert the condition that the inspection should be made in common with the consul of the country of the nationality of the ship. The intervention of this agent will be a sure guarantee that the regula- tions existing between the two countries will be strictly observed. Besides these special observa- tions, I think those which I have presented on the first article will be sufficient to indicate the sense and object of the regulations which we propose to adopt. The propositions in full are as follows: " 1-In the countries where the regulations provide that vessels should be furnished at the moment of departure with a bill of health delivered by the local authorities, this bill of health shall continue to be delivered by those authorities, but the captain of the vessel is at liberty to have said bill of health vised by the consul of the country of destination, who will be obliged to give it with the least possible delay. The consul shall have the right to add to his vise any observation he may judge necessary. "If the vessel is not obliged to take a bill of health from the local authorities, the captain can ask for one from the consul of the country of destination, who shall be obliged to deliver said bill to him with the least possible delay. " 2-In those countries the regulations of which require that the vessels before obtaining a bill of health from the local authority should be submitted to a sanitary inspection, the consul of the country of destination or his delegate shall always, at the demand of the captain, assist at this inspection. "If the vessel is not compelled to have a bill of health to be delivered by the local author- ity, the consul from whom the captain shall ask for this bill of health, or his delegate can make this inspection in conformity with rules to be established by common agreement between the respective governments, but in such cases the inspections shall be made in concert with the consul of the country of the nationality of the vessel." The Delegate of Spain (M. de VIGO) stated that, although he approved the propo- sition of the Delegate of Italy for which he had voted and to which he had added an amend- ment, he would nevertheless be willing to submit to the consideration of his government the proposition of the Delegates of the United States, Belgium, France, Russia, and Turkey, which had just been presented. He added that his government had always wished to entertain cordial intercourse with the United States and other powers, and he hoped therefore that his 7 government would look favorably upon the proposition presented by the aforesaid Delegates. The proposition was presented in a spirit of compromise, in order that an understanding between the powers directly interested may be arrived at. The President (Mb. HAY). The remarks and propositions of the Delegate of France will be printed in to-day's protocol. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). Mr. President, I ask per- mission to make a correction in the French translation of my remarks made at the last meeting of the Conference but one, and printed in Protocol No. 5. When at the last meeting of the Conference the honorable Special Delegate from Spain criticised the statement imputed to me that yellow fever was always imported into this country, and never exported, I supposed he had made the mistake of ascribing to me language which I had not employed, and, not wishing to occupy the time of the Conference, I contented myself with correcting his supposed error by a personal communication after the adjournment of the Conference. I learned from him that the language he had criticised was actually used in the French translation. I had said in English that yellow fever was almost always (presque toujours) imported, and almost never (presque jamais) exported; whereas the translation makes me say " constamment importee," and that the fever "n'est jamais exportee," which I did not say. I ask the privilege of making this statement in the next protocol, as, although my original remarks in English are correctly printed, the French translation makes me responsible for a position which I have not assumed. The Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. CERVERA) stated that, in his answer to the Delegate of the United States, he had been entirely guided by the French version of the speech of Dr. Cabell, as printed in Protocol No. 5, but the explanation of the Delegate of the United States is entirely satisfactory to him. The Special Delegate of Cuba (Dr. FINLAY). Mr. President, Gentlemen : My arrival has been delayed by circumstances wholly independent of my wishes and of those of the Spanish Government, which has appointed me to represent at this Conference its possessions of Cuba and Porto Rico. I regret it all the more, as I have thus been deprived of an oppor- tunity of bringing sooner before your notice certain facts which, I think, must dispel every doubt regarding the willingness of the Spanish Government to promote the interests of sani- tary science by giving access to every desirable source of information that might be asked. It is what I purpose doing now. Let me mention, in the first place, the fact that since the month of November last a news- paper of Havana, the " Correspondencia de Cuba," publishes each day a list of the deaths, as obtained from the certificates issued by the attendant physicians. The record gives for each case the name, age, and nationality, and specifies the disease to which the death has been attributed. Again, the conscientious obituary tables which our distinguished academician of Havana, Dr. del Valle (D. Ambrosio G.), has been publishing these last fifteen years or more are well known and, no doubt, duly appreciated in the United States. They are exclusively the result of disinterested personal enterprise; the more praiseworthy considering that their author, wholly unaided by any official mandate or otherwise, with immense labor to himself and no incon- siderable expense, has been toiling day after day at the ungrateful task of classifying heaps of death certificates, striving each successive year to improve the form of their publication, without the remotest afterthought of remuneration or of personal advantage. Yet am I not aware that his tables have ever been subjected to any restriction or censure whatsoever, nor have the authorities of Havana raised any difficulty in the prosecution of Dr. del Valle's meritorious work. 8 These simple facts evidently prove that Havana, at least, does not fall under the category of such cities as the honorable Delegate of the United States, Dr. Turner, alludes to in the Protocol of the last session of this Conference, when he refers to the case of some large city that he knows of whose Board of Health refuses to allow the publication of bills of mortality with- out its previous consent. Now let me add a further proof of the extent to which the official authority and the gov- ernment itself of Havana are disposed to afford such facilities as a thorough sanitary investiga- tion might demand. It is just a year since I took occasion at a meeting of the "Sociedad de Estudios Clinicos," a private medical association of which I have the honor of being a member, to propose the organization of a special commission for the study of yellow fever in Havana. My plan was accepted, and we number at present some twenty effective and six or seven auxil- iary members, distributed in four sections. The first section is composed of directors of hospitals who belong to the association, each of whom sends every month a detailed account of all the yellow-fever cases that have occurred in their respective establishments, mentioning for each case the ward, bed, name of patient, age, nationality, time of residence in Cuba and in Havana, date and hour of invasion, date of admis- sion, date of discharge or death, and, finally, the characteristic symptoms of the diagnosis. Now, by far the most important of these monthly statements is that of the military hospital; and I am happy to testify that no difficulty or unwillingness has been experienced by our commission in obtaining the necessary authorizations, so that Dr. D. Antonio Pardinas, director of that hospital, has joined our commission as director of the corresponding section. The second section has for its object the clinical study of the disease. Two of our members have undertaken to note each day every detail appertaining to symptomatology and treatment; two others attend to the urology; others to thepos^ mortem examination; and, finally, our most competent microscopists, with Dr. Lebredo at their head (director also of this section), propose to carry out the histological investigations. But the first condition for the execution of this plan was the disposal of some ward in one of the public hospitals. We soon had more than we had expected; for we readily obtained as many beds as we required, not only in the yellow fever wards of the civil hospital, but also in the military. Here, again, it will be seen that neither the civil nor the military authorities opposed the slightest hinderance to the prosecution of our studies. The third section has charge of collecting statistical data referring to yellow fever. We receive every month from the bishopric bills of mortality classified according to the printed forms of our commission, with permission to verify them, when required, with the original death certificate. From the port authorities we receive accounts of all the passengers that enter and leave the port of Havana each day, also classified according to our forms. From the mili- tary and naval departments we receive such information as is needed in order to appreciate the death rates of yellow fever in the army and in the navy. Finally, we receive from the "Escuela Profesional" their meteorological reports. The fourth section attends to the bibliographical researches, and has the secretary-general of our academy, Dr. D. Antonio Mestre, for its director. This summary account of the work which our commission has been carrying on during the past year will be accepted, I hope, as a corroboration of my former statement, and leads, moreover, to this conclusion: that a government which gives such facilities to those who might wish to consult the sources whence its information is derived, could never knowingly counte- nance any misrepresentation of the sanitary condition of its ports or of the vessels that sail from them. 9 I have, then, so far proved that not only in principle (as evidenced by the extensive sanitary regulations extant in all Spanish dominions), but also in practice, the Government of Spain is disposed to encourage every measure calculated to benefit the common interests of science and of humanity, subject only to such restrictions as a due regard for the fundamental principles of its legislation might demand. Let me only add that it cannot be expected that any government, after enforcing those measures which it deems essential to the well-being of its own subjects, shall yet experience the same predominant interest in the protection of other nations against the possible intrusion of disease, as those foreign nations must feel on the same subject. Hence, it stands to reason that the appointment of such sanitary officers as should make it their principal business to protect those foreign nations, and at the same time enjoy their full confidence, must be considered as a matter appertaining to international sanitary legislation. Upon this matter, I cannot see that Spain can do more than acquiesce in such appointments if the Conference should deem them advisable, thereby giving a final proof of its sincere desire to promote the cause of science and of humanity by every means in its power. The Special, Delegate of Spain (Dr. CERVERA) submitted the following: It is still time, in the opinion of the undersigned, to arrive at a just solution of the grave sanitary questions which have been presented for the deliberations of the Conference, and in which perhaps the hasty hopes of some have been disappointed. In order to arrive at a perfect understanding which will prove the loyalty of our purposes, we present the following projet, which, in our judgment, satisfies all the opinions that have been expressed during our deliberations: The yellow fever is an epidemic disease which, according to the testimony of a great num- ber of scientific witnesses, has its principal center among the islands in and along the coast of the Mexican Gulf, which is recognized as the cradle of the disease, although it also extends itself to Brazil, Sen^gambia, and to Sierra Leone, in Africa. We do not desire to overcharge the budget of the interested nations by excessive expenses, but only to provide for the indispensable needs of the service for obtaining protection which will be at the same time scientific and reliable and capable of furnishing by conscientious studies the information which is wanted on the nature and origin of the germ of the disease; the conditions which help its transmission and diffusion, and also the laws which regulate its appearance, its increase and disappearance. Convinced that, whatever may be the virtues of the measures adopted, the progress of the disease can never be stopped, nor can its propagation be prevented by the means proposed or employed up to the present time, and notwithstanding the system of notification, however perfect and important it may be, that the inspection of ships at their departure only and a vigorous disinfection can furnish complete assurance of the state of health of those places and countries, it is our pro- found conviction that, as long as a serious and thorough study of the disease has not been made, it will be impossible to arrive at a determination of the proper means to combat it, and above all the creation of a commission, which we have the honor of proposing, is necessary if we wish to attain the results which we have been vainly seeking, and which when established scientific researches can furnish us with. We therefore submit to the consideration of the Conference the following projet; Article I. A temporary Scientific Sanitary Commission will be established by the nations the most directly interested to protect themselves against the yellow fever, and also by such nations as will adhere to this proposition. Art. II. The duties of this commission will be- A. The study and ascertainment of the principal and permanent centers of the pathogenic germs of the disease. B. The conditions which favor its extension, and also the aetiology and circumstances which aid its propagation in their respective centers, and its diffusion to other countries. 10 C. The means to be employed to circumscribe more and more its effects, or to eradicate the disease entirely from the regions in which it originates and from the countries lately attacked. D. How to prevent its transmission by vessels. E. The best and most practical method of disinfection of ships, their cargoes and pas- sengers. F. And also everything relating to the prophylaxy and treatment of the disease. Art. III. The countries which desire to concur in the organization of this Scientific Com- mission will agree between themselves as to the instructions to be given to their delegates, in order to facilitate their labors. Art. IV. After having studied on the spot the different questions submitted to its investi- gations, this Commission shall present a collective report indicating the most practical means to attain the end proposed. (Signed) Dr. RAFAEL CERVERA. " J. J. Da SILVA AMADO. " Dr. IGNACIO ALVARADO. " Dr. F. J. VAN LEENT. " CARLOS FINLAY. The Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. CERVERA). From the beginning of this Conference I have been of the opinion that even if we should find means of stopping the progress of yellow fever and preventing its importation into countries where it has not yet penetrated and become localized, and of rendering the centers of the disease healthy, we would nevertheless arrive at no satisfactory result if we did not begin by instituting a scientific com- mission whose duty it would be to make the studies which I have mentioned in my proposition on the character, the nature, the development and increase of yellow fever. I am certain that three or four governments represented in this Conference will consent to adopt the means of making an earnest study of this terrible disease. This commission would add but little to the budget of the nations participating, and I think a combination of three or four governments would be amply sufficient to insure its creation. This commission could have its headquarters wherever it judges necessary-at New Orleans, Vera Cruz or Havana-as may be decided by the governments interested and who may take part in it. It should have full scope for its scientific researches and examinations, and sooner or later we would obtain, thanks to this work, useful and practical results. I therefore request the President will at the proper time submit my prop- osition to be discussed and voted on by this honorable Conference. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO). I so entirely agreed with the idea expressed in the proposition of Dr. Cervera that I signed it as it were with both hands. Therefore what I am going to say must not be considered an objection to his projet, in the same sense that Dr. Cervera is not opposed to the proposition which I am going to present, as he signed it. This proposition is also signed by all the special delegates with the exception of those of the United States, and they have not had time to come to a conclusion between them- selves, as the proposition was only presented to them to-day. As I have already stated, there is no antagonism between my proposition and that of Dr. Cervera. My proposition is but the complement of his. His proposition is general in its terras, while I enter into the details to show how practicable the matter is, and what pecuniary sacrifices it will necessitate. My proposition only specifies those nations which arc really inter- ested to protect themselves against yellow fever. Those governments which have no intercourse with the places where this disease exist are not indicated in my proposition as taking part in the studies which I propose. They will have the right to take part if they desire, but they will not be obliged to do so. As to the details of my proposition, I think that they ought to be 11 well received. The Sanitary Conference of Paris, the only one whose works resulted in an in- ternational convention, was not satisfied with making a vague projet. It indicated exactly what measures should be taken to stop the propagation of epidemics. When the Sanitary Conference of Constantinople, which was called together on the motion of the French Government, pro- posed to guarantee Europe against the invasion of cholera, this conference decided what should be the measures to be taken, and at what points international sanitary establishments and posts of observation were to be created in order to obtain complete supervision over the disease. What was done at Constantinople and Paris for the cholera, I propose to do here for yellow fever. The Special Delegates have profited by the meeting of this Sanitary Conference near the cradle of yellow fever to propose a plan of studies to be undertaken, with the help of the different nations, to combat the disease, which has no nationality, which yearly kills thousands of people, and causes great injury to commerce. Dr. Fauvel has said that yellow fever is a disease which is in a period of progress, and we have, as it were, only assisted at the first acts of the progress of this terrible malady. When the Isthmus of Panama shall have been opened, and the commerce of the Pacific shall have reached the same degree of developement that exists to-day on the Atlantic, yellow fever will find itself in a condition to frightfully increase, and if we now take measures to preserve our- selves against this increase which threatens us, it will be said in time to come that the Confer- ence of Washington has deserved well of humanity. I offer the following proposition : The undersigned Special Delegates to the International Sanitary Conference have the honor to submit a proposition, the object of which is to establish an international system to study the yellow fever, and which will enable the Conference to prepare a trustworthy system of in- ternational notification, and which will not be liable to the objections which arc made against the present system. This study will have besides the important object of seeking means to stop the propogation of yellow fever, as this disease extends itself daily further, and threatens to in- vade vast regions which have been free from its invasions up to the present time. This proposition will necessitate a great many details in order to clearly explain the idea which is contained in it, and in order to answer the objections which may be made as to the practicability of putting it into execution. By this proposition the nations mostly interested will be the ones who will undertake this study and pay the expenses. These nations are the United States, whose interests are the most important, Mexico, Hayti, the Republics of Central America, United States of Colombia, Venezuela, Brazil, Spain for its very important colony of Cuba, England and France for their West India Islands, Guianas and their colonies in Senegambia, Denmark for its Island of Saint Thomas, Holland for its Guianas and Caracas, Portugal for its colonies in Senegambia and on account of its commerce with Brazil. Although the advantages of such a proposition seem evident, the undersigned have wished to bring to the attention of the Conference some of the opinions of undoubted authority which have upheld the same ideas. Mellier, the learned epidemiologist to whom France owes its sanitary organization, ex- pressed the desire to see a medical corps created whose duty it would be to perform in Mexico, relative to yellow fever, the same service as that performed by the sanitary physicians in the East relative to the pest. Dr. Fauvel, General Inspector of the Sanitary Service in France, and one of the greatest authorities on epidemiology, expressed himself as follows at the Conference of Vienna: "Gentlemen: I have lately heard some doubts expressed about the yellow fever relative to the object of the studies of this Conference. It has been said the disease threatens Europe very little. I should like to share this opinion, but unfortunately the facts which we have had for several years before us will not allow me to do so. Up to within lately the yellow fever, 12 which had its origin in the Gulf of Mexico, remained, so to speak, confined there as an epidemic disease. From this more or less permanent and active center the disease extended itself from time to time in an epidemic form along the American coast to North and South, to say nothing of its importations into Europe. Since the beginning of this century, and more especially since steam navigation has rendered maritime communications very rapid, you see the domain of yellow fever take a considerable extension, and not only causes severe epidemics at points very far from its original center, but it also takes root and acclimates itself where a few years before this disease was considered as an exotic only. The indubitable fact deducted from what I have explained to you is, that not only has yellow fever a tendency to transmit itself and acclimate itself on the coast of the warmer parts of America, where heretofore it rarely appeared and only for a short time, but it no longer limits, as formerly (and this is an important point), its ravages to the maritime zone, but begins to penetrate very far into the interior of countries. The con- clusion to be drawn from those explanations is that if yellow fever generalized and acclimated ifself in the greater part of the States of North America it will be very difficult for Europe, by reason of the always increasing activity of maritime communications, to escape an invasion) and perhaps, also, an acclimation of the disease." The most remarkable of the French epidemiologists has said this: "Europe, the same as America, has the greatest interest to oppose a barrier to the propa- gation of yellow fever, and when there are so many doubts existing on the subject of this plague all efforts must be united to conquer such an enemy." At the International Hygienic Congress, Turin, September 7, 1880, Dr. Fauvel spoke as follows: "Each government, according to its convenience (in the East), following the example of the French Government, should create a corps of sanitary physicians whose members are to be sent to those countries from which pestilential diseases come, and the present supervision, in- creased in this manner, will give all the necessary guarantees of safety." Prof. Finkel burg, delegate of the Government of Germany to the Hygienic Congress of Turin, on the same day, said: "During times of peace several governments have for a long time taken the first steps towards a general understanding relative to the prevention of great epidemics. It is to France that the honor belongs of having first proposed to conclude, in 1851, a sanitary convention to shield itself from the pest, cholera, and the yellow fever. Italy and Portugal were the first countries which joined this meritorious enterprize. Indeed, there does not exist any other sanitary convention of the European States than that which was formed, in 1853, between France, the Italian provinces, Portugal, and Turkey, and which the other powers joined later and with certain restrictions. It was this convention which regulated the international quaran- tine, instituted the superior council in Constantinople, the sanitary stations and the sanitary physicians in the Ea^t, &c. All that was desired has not, however, been obtained from these institutions. The nature of these plagues must be studied in their places of origin, not only to erect barriers against their extension, but to render salubrious the countries which are threatened. This work is no doubt difficult, and can only be accomplished by the unanimous co-operation of the powers. The field of sanitary prevention and intervention must be carried not only to the political limit of each country, but to the limit of the focus of the disease. This is the only way to protect commerce from great loss of time and money." This opinion, which is as clear as it is important, is fully adopted by the undersigned. Prof. Pettenkofer, Member of the Supreme Council of Medicine in Germany, and delegate of the German Government to the Sanitary Conference in Vienna, said "he was desirous that scientific investigations should be made relative to yellow fever, and thinks that the study of 13 this epidemic would help at the same time to explain existing doubts relative to other epidemics, for this disease has localized itself more than other epidemic diseases, as has been proved by the studies made at New York and New Orleans during the last ten years." Prof. Siegmund, a well-known savant in the medical world, and delegate of the Austria- Hungarian Government to the Sanitary Conference in Vienna, said: "No object would be attained if the solution of the questions relating to epidemics is left to the zeal of individuals, of learned corporations, or of administrations. Experience has proved this sufficiently, since for more than half a century the plague of cholera existed and killed millions of men in the most civilized States, and even at this day the manner and condi- tion of its propagation is not agreed on, nor the length of time of its incubation, the process of disinfection, nor on the value of quarantines. These gaps, these doubts, and these controversies will exist as long as the nations will not unite to organize on a more important plan for time sufficiently long, or on points sufficiently numerous, to arrive at full and complete knowledge of the disease." What Prof. Siegmund asked for the cholera the undersigned ask with greater earnestness for the yellow fever. Dr. Mendes Alvaro, Secretary of the Sanitary Council of Madrid, and delegate of the Spanish Government to the Sanitary Conference in Vienna, expressed himself as follows: " To oppose a barrier to the incessant ravages of the epidemics which, from time to time, over- run the world, spreading mourning everywhere, would be a glorious enterprise. The Spanish delegation, therefore, hastens to approve this principle. " The question is the general defense organized by science with the help of the governments. It is generally known that Spain, and I begin with this country as it has been most cruelly stricken, Portugal, and Italy have also been frequently invaded by yellow fever in spite of excel- lent sanitary regulations. This pestilential disease which, during three-fourths of the present century, has carried away thousands of Spaniards, is well worth the attention of the Interna- tional Commission on Epidemics which it is now proposed to organize. That is what we ask in the interest of our country. I do not forget that yellow fever has recently invaded popula- tions which before were free from it, and which considered themselves safe by the topographical and climatic conditions under which they are placed. When all the nations shall have gathered the necessary materials, the principles will not fail to be discovered. It is therefore necessary to choose active agents, whose duty it will be to undertake these researches in the localities where the diseases originate, to complete them in the great centers of science, and to communicate the final result to the International Commission. The proposed organization would not necessitate much expense. It must be so organized that it will not be dependent on parliaments relative to the budget. " I have less confidence in the quarantines and in the inspections than in the results of studies carried on with perseverance and uniformity." These views of Dr. Mendes Alvaro are fully shared by the undersigned. The International Sanitary Conference of Vienna approved the desire expressed by the committee to study the project of instituting an International Commission on Epidemics. Article 13 of this proposition reads as follows: " Permanent stations will be established in the usual epidemic centers and temporary sta- tions in such places where infection may for a time show itself. The persons at these stations will study on the spot the disease and the means of stopping its propagation. In the same man- ner, at times of invasion by an epidemic, unions will be established whose duty it will be to study the progress of the propagation and the laws of its progress." All the scientific congresses which have assembled since (the objects of which have had more or less direct relations with medicine), have voted, and almost always unanimously, in 14 favor of realizing this desire. The Hygienic Congress of Brussels of 1876, of Paris of 1878, of Stuttgard, 1879, Turin, 1880, the Congress of Medical Sciences of Amsterdam, 1879, the Statistical Congress of Buda-Pesth, 1876, have all expressed this desire. In the printed instructions which the Royal Sanitary Council of Madrid has given to the Spanish Delegates in this Conference, the Delegates are recommended to approve the establishment of sanitary medical corps, and several of the other Delegates have received similar instructions. Proposition. The Conference recommends the creation of twenty-two international sanitary posts for the study of yellow fever, to be established at New Orleans, Galveston, Vera Cruz, Panama, and for the Pacific, Maracaibo; one in each of the Guianas; two in Cuba; one in each of the follow- ing islands: St. Domingo, Jamaica, St. Thomas, Guadeloupe, Martinique, Barbadoes; one in each of the following ports of Brazil: Para, Maranhao, Pernambuco, Bahia, Rio de Janeiro, and one in Senegambia. In each of these posts there will be at least two physicians, one from the country where the post is, and the other from the country with which the port or town is in the most constant communication. All other nations will have the right to send sanitary physicians to these posts. The expenses of each of these posts will be paid pro rata by the nations which have appointed sanitary physicians. The number of posts will be increased or diminished as the necessities of the case may require. The contracting nations will arrange between themselves as to the number of physicians that each nation shall appoint, and for the distribution of the different posts, and the same process shall be used in the future for the increase or diminution of the posts. The physicians of these sanitary posts will not be allowed to practice their profession generally, or accept any other employment, under pain of dismissal. They will only be allowed to accept the duties of physicians of the hospitals in which yellow-fever cases are admitted. At each post there shall be- 1. A laboratory, furnished with chemical and other instruments and material necessary for making analyses. 2. A cabinet, for experimental and histological studies, furnished with good microscopes for the necessary examinations. 3. A library, containing the most important works which have been published on yellow fever. The physicians of the sanitary posts shall- 1. Keep themselves informed of the sanitary condition of the town in which they are, in order to know when the first cases of yellow fever shall break out. 2. Follow the progress of the disease so as to know exactly when it decreases and ends. 3. Immediately inform the sanitary authorities of the country from which they are appointed of all the facts which can be of interest to them. 4. Always study the meteorological condition of the town in which are placed these posts, and see what relation exists between these conditions and the appearance, propagation, and gravity of the disease. 5. Study the telluric conditions of those towns with the same object, as in No. 4. 6. Make rapid analytical microscopic analyses of the drinking water used in these towns. 7. Help the authorities whose duty it is to inspect the ships in order to see if any relation can be found between the condition of these vessels and the eventual appearance of yellow fever on board. 8. Study the sanitary condition of the town and endeavor to find out if any relation exists between an unhealthy focus and the development of the epidemic. 9. Frequently visit the hospitals where cases of yellow fever are admitted, and study the progress of the disease from observation of the different cases. 15 10. Help to make the autopsy of the bodies of persons dying from yellow fever. 11. Make the anatomo - pathological and histological examinations of the humors and organs of these bodies so as to try and discover the nature of the lesions. 12. Make monthly report of what they have observed and transmit it to the governments by which they are appointed. These reports will be published and distributed by all the governments which have adhered to this institution. 13. Make an annual report, a copy of which will be sent to the governments by which they are named, and another presented to the conference of sanitary physicians. Every year there shall be a conference of medical sanitarians at which at least one member of each post shall assist. The first conference shall take place in Havana, and the places at which the others shall be held shall be designated at the end of each yearly conference, in such order that every year the meeting shall take place at a different place. The conference shall last ten days, and the reports of the different sanitary posts shall be read and discussed. It is desirable that the governments should send occasional inspecting committees to examine these posts. If an international commission of epidemics is created, as has been proposed, this commission should have the right to regulate the workings of those posts. (Signed) Count BETHLEN. EDOUARD SfiVE. Dr. RAFEAL CERVERA. Dr. CARLOS FINLAY. Dr. F. J. VAN LEENT. Dr. IGNACIO ALVARADO. J. J. DA SILVA AMADO. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). I have listened with great pleasure to the scientific explanation of Dr. Amado, but desire to make some few suggestions to the Conference relative to ideas contained in the proposition of the learned doctor, although it may appear presumptuous on my part to answer such a scientific explanation. I will first say the project of Dr. Amado is opposed to that of his colleague, Dr. Cervera, if I have well understood the Delegate of Portugal. He recommends the establishment of twenty- two posts of observation. Although not clearly stated in his proposition, I understand that the same proposition has been discussed by other conferences, but it does not appear that those conferences have carried it out. I am of the opinion that his proposition ought to be submitted to a temporary commission, whose mission it would be to study the questions which are enun- ciated in it, if the Conference so decides. This commission will have to study all these questions of detail. The Conference, in my opinion, should not enter into the details of the final regula- tions. Dr. Amado has said Dr. Fauvel is of the opinion that yellow fever threatens the European Continent. If this is the case, we have a personal interest in protecting ourselves against the invasion of this terrible disease. But I think we can do so without creating a permanent com- mission, as is proposed by the Delegate of Portugal. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO). I will answer in a few words the Delegate of Turkey. I will first refer to the question of fact. The Delegate of Turkey said my proposition was not practicable because it had been presented and adopted in other conferences but never put in execution. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). I did not say it was not practicable. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO). But you say it contains such difficulties that it was thought impossible to surmount them. 16 The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY.) I do not know the reason why the governments did not carry out the proposition. I wished only to state that fact. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO). The question of the creation of a sanitary post to study epidemics was mentioned for the first time in the sanitary conference of Paris, which decided upon the establishment of sanitary posts in the East, which have met with well-known success. The conference of Vienna again discussed this question and extended it to all kinds of epidemics. If that decision has not been carried out it is owing to the grave events which happened in the East. The principal objection mentioned against my proposition is that I propose the establishment of a permanent organization, while my colleague, Dr. Cer- VERA, only demands a temporary one. It is evident that the central commission and the dif- ferent posts will exist as long as this study is considered useful, and they will cease to exist when their object is attained. I therefore see no difference between the two propositions. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I merely wish to say that I concur in the general idea of Dr. Amado's plan, but the same principle is involved in Dr. Cervera's plan, and it seems to me it would be better on the ground of expediency not to go into such minute details of administrative measures, lest they might suggest grounds of objection on the part of the respective governments, and for this reason I should prefer the plan of Dr. Cervera. We should at least take it up first, for we must adopt the general principle before we need consider the details of administration. The Delegate of Turkey (A RISTARCHI BEY). I am very thankful to Prof. Amado for the kind manner in which he has answered me. I have the same hostility as Dr. Amado against yellow fever and other epidemic diseases. I repeat, I am not acquainted with scientific questions as is the case, I think, with most of the diplomats and consuls in this Conference. The questions treated by the Delegate of Portugal, being of an exclusively technical character, should be submitted to the scientific commission to study. It may seem strange that the Dele- gate of Turkey should interest himself in yellow fever, but, as Prof. Amado said, the learned Dr. Fauvel has some apprehension of the extension of yellow fever to the European continent. Besides the interest we naturally feel for the American people, who arc most directly threatened, there is as it were a personal interest to ourselves to think about this terrible disease. The Special Delegate of Cuba (Dr. FINLAY). I should like to explain why I have signed both Dr. Cervera's and Dr. Amado's projets. It is because I consider it urgent that this Conference should adopt a resolution favorable to the scientific investigation of yellow fever; and believe, moreover, that should either of the two measures be agreed upon a great step will have been made toward the realization of our sanitary aspirations. Without entering into technical considerations, which would be out of place, and simply as an example which shall render, so to speak, palpable the necessity of such an investigation as Dr. Cervera and Dr. Amado have demanded, I beg leave to remind my colleagues here present that the sanitary measures now generally recommended to prevent the propagation of yellow fever are founded upon a mode of viewing that disease which is completely at variance with a considerable number of observed facts. We have on one side the contagion ists, and on the other the non-contagionists, each endeavoring to deny the importance of the cases brought forward by the contrary party in support of their respective opinions. Well, gentlemen, I declare that it is impossible for an impartial mind to look into the stated facts without arriving at this conclusion, that many of the proofs cited in favor of each of those two apparently contradictory opinions must be accepted as perfectly authenticated facts, which conclusion necessarily leads to this other consequence, that we must admit the intervention of a third independent condition in order to account for those two orders of facts. It is my personal opinion that three conditions are necessary in order that the propagation of yellow fever shall take place: 17 1. The presence of a previous case of yellow fever within certain limits of time, counting back from the moment that we are considering. 2. The presence of a person apt to contract the disease. 3. The presence of an agent entirely independent for its existence both of the disease and of the sick man, but which is necessary in order that the disease shall be conveyed from the yellow-fever patient to a healthy individual. It will be objected that this is a mere hypothesis; and, indeed, it is only as such that I give it. But I believe it is a plausible one, which has, at least, the merit of explaining a certain number of facts which have remained hitherto unaccounted for by the current theories. I do not ask anything else, for my only object is to show that, if my hypothesis, or some other analo- gous to it, should be realized, all those measures which are now employed in efforts to disinfect and check the progress of the disease would turn out to be without effect, inasmuch as the principal efforts should have been directed against the third condition, by endeavoring to destroy the agent of transmission, or to divert it from the path that it follows in communicating the disease. You see therefore, gentlemen, how important it is that this question should be thoroughly studied if we wish not to be led away upon a false track while recommending particular measures against the propagation of the disease. The President (Mr. HAY). A vote will now be taken on the proposition of the Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. Cervera). The Special Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN) moved that the vote on the proposition of the Delegate of Spain be postponed until the next meeting of the Conference, in order that it might be examined. The question was taken on postponing the vote until the next sitting, and it was decided in the negative, yeas 4, nays 12, abstaining 2, as follows: Yeas-Germany, Austria-Hungary, Japan, Russia-4. Nays-Argentine Republic, Belgium, Chili, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Mexico, Netherlands, Portugal, Turkey-12. Abstaining-Italy, Sweden-Norway-2. The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE) stated that he abstained from taking part in the vote on this question, for although he did not doubt the usefulness of the scientific commission recommended by the Special Delegates of Spain and Portugal, yet they appeared to him to be outside of the plan proposed by the memorandum of the Secretary of State. So the Conference refused to postpone the vote. The question recurred on the proposition of the Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. Cervera), and it was decided in the affirmative, yeas 14, nays 0, abstaining 4, as follows: Yeas-Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Chili, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Mexico, Netherlands, Portugal, Turkey-14. Abstaining-Italy, Japan, Russia, Sweden-Norway-4. So the proposition of Dr. Cervera was agreed to. On motion of the Special Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN), a recess of 10 minutes was taken. AFTER RECESS. The recess having expired, the Conference re-assembled. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO) requested that his proposition should not be voted on, and that it be placed in the protocol as the expression of the scientific desire of the Special Delegates. 18 The President (Mr. HAY;. I am sure there will be no objection to that, and it will be so ordered. It was ordered accordingly. The Special Delegate of Spain (Dr. CERVERA) asked that the proposition of the Delegate of Portugal be submitted to the scientific commission, should it be appointed. The Special Delegate of Mexico (Dr. ALVARADO). Before the Conference takes into consideration the proposition which I have the honor to submit to your examination, I wish to call your attention to the two leading points contained in said proposition, and which are directed to give a solution, in my opinion favorable, to the questions that the Government of the United States, with the most laudable object, has desired should be treated in this Conference. The Government of the United States and the other nations represented here wish to pre- vent the spread of contagious diseases, especially that of yellow fever and cholera, by means of preventive measures, for the carrying out of which the common accord of the several nations is needed ; they wish besides to give better facilities to the commercial traffic which now encounters obstacles, by the use of some of the preventive measures which science advises, such as quarantines. The Government of the United States has believed, and in my opinion with great reason, that the most expeditious way and at the same time the soonest carried out, that each nation should adopt the means which she thinks proper to prevent the spread of contagious diseases, to provide for its own security and to facilitate its commerce, is to have an accurate and trustworthy knowledge of the sanitary condition of the other countries, with the end of taking in time the necessary measures to avoid the spread of those diseases. This is the capital idea, but to carry it out, to obtain an opportune, accurate, and trustworthy notice, two conditions are needed: first, that the person or agent commissioned to give this notice should have as much interest in giving it as the same government to whom it is com- municated; and, second, that this person may be able to know the state of the public health under all its aspects, and may therefore be responsible for his acts. The first condition is obvious, and that is the reason why I will not try to demonstrate it. Allowing that it is logical and natural that the agent commissioned to make the notification should belong to the nation interested in receiving it. because nobody better than him will try that the notice of the appearance of a contagious disease in his place of residence should oppor- tunely reach the knowledge of his government, inasmuch as he knows that the salvation of his country and perhaps of his own relatives from the terrible consequences of an epidemic will depend on the diligence he may use in giving the notice. A person foreign to the country who is to receive the notice will not take as much interest in the notification, not having the inspira- tion of love of country and that of his own interest in many cases. There is, besides, another consideration of much weight in favor of the appointment of a national agent in the ports of other nations, and it is this: The act of the notification being of the highest importance, as it lays the basis from which to allow or prevent the free communica- tion of two countries according to the tenor of notification, obliges the agent that makes the notification to have a direct responsibility; and in case of inaccuracy in the notice, whether through unskilfullness, omission, or some other motive, he is to suffer the penalty provided by law. If the one that makes the notification is not a national agent, how to exact that responsi- bility from a foreign subject, who resides in a country also foreign? There is no other means exempt from complications to make such responsibility effective than the proposed one; that is to say, that the agent commissioned to make the notification should belong to the country that is to receive it. The second condition I referred to above is the necessity there is that the person commis- sioned to make the notification should be able of knowing by himself the sanitary state of a 19 place. This question is not as simple as it seems at first sight, because it is not possible that a person foreign to the science of medicine may declare when there is or there is not an epidemic, and may, in general, be able to know the sanitary state of any place whatever. The knowledge of the moment in which a disease might be considered epidemical is one of the most discussed points in science, and it is enough to say that it is a point in discussion in order to understand that a doctor is the only one who is exclusively apt to give the most approximate opinion to the truth in this matter. It is not enough to know that there is one, two, or some individuals in a locality attacked by a contagious disease to be able to declare that there is an epidemic, as on this point there is dissimilarity in the opinions of physicians of all the countries. If such super- ficial knowledge were enough, that is, knowing that there are or there are not cases of a deter- minate disease in order to inform the medical authorities of the other countries of the sanitary state of a place, the great cities, such as London, Paris, New York, Madrid, and many others, would always be considered with suspicion, and their commerce would not be free, as there is not a month in which you may not read in their sanitary bulletins that there are in such hospital or in such quarter of the city so many cases of diphtheria, or in some others so many cases of small- pox. If the existence of some cases of a contagious disease, I repeat, were the rule, there could not possibly be any free commerce; many other technical considerations then are needed for this, such as the knowledge of the character of the disease, the epoch of the year in which it appears, the causes of its appearance, the point where it made its appearance in a city, and many others, which are useless to state, as they all in a mass form matter enough to oblige the person wishing to be the agent of a country to study medicine if he wants loyally and conscientiously to fulfill his commission. This way of viewing the question is not due to my profession of a physician, as it might be believed, but arises therefrom. The honorable representative of Denmark said in a few words, and with much better judgment, in one of the preceding sessions, as follows : "It is my impres- sion that the medical authorities are much more able to examine the vessels than the consul. On one side you have the local authorities, the quarantine physician, who will make it his endeavor to examine the vessel, who knows how to do it; and on the other hand, you have as a check on, and a supplement to, him the consular agent of the land of destination, who will always counteract the tendency of the authorities of the port of departure to give it a higher rep- utation for health than it possesses. If you add, however, what some members of the com- mittee have proposed, viz, that a staff of medical consular agents be employed, then perhaps it would be right to leave the issuing of bills of health to them; but as long as the consular agents are commeroial representatives, and so long as they are only paid by the occasional fees they ob- tain, and for the rest are thrown on their own resources in order to gain a livelihood, so long I very much fear that in ninety-nine cases out of a hundred the bills of health, if given by them, will be given out pro forma, without that close inspection which is so important. As long as you permit the sanitary authorities to make the inspections they are not made as matters of form, they belong to that department; they are constantly in the harbor; they know everything; they can see at once what would employ a consul half a day or four or five hours to inspect." The honorable representative of Italy has understood the question in the same way, as the proposition he presented and was approved by the Conference, provides that the sanitary author- ities of a place should be the ones to issue the bills of health. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL), has cited in defense of his own opinions the following words which the Minister of Commerce and Agriculture addressed to the President of the French Republic in 1849: "Hitherto all defensive measures against the invasion had been organized merely on the sea-coast. It was now deemed to be both more simple and more logical, the surveillance over the countries themselves where the disease took 20 its origin. This was done by the nomination of resident physicians by our government (that of France) in Turkey and Egypt, to examine into the condition of those countries, and to fix the bills of health to be given to vessels on their departure, a measure that was the more useful, as it provided for the more or less speedy introduction of important modifications into the regime of sanitary superintendence." Dr. Cabell adds further these other words on his own account: " What France has thus accomplished for Europe in respect of cholera, we desire, to effect for all nations wherever a similar exigency exists, by means similar in all essential features, though with certain differences in accordance with differences of local circumstances." And, lastly, the same American nation has said in "An act to prevent the introduction of contagious or infectious diseases into the United States" the following words: "That upon the request of the National Board of Health, the President is authorized to detail a medical officer to serve in the office of the consul at any foreign port, for the purpose of making the inspection and giving the certificates hereinbefore mentioned." And further adds: "That any vessel sailing from any such port without such certificate of said medical officer shall forfeit to the United States," &c. I believe, therefore, that I am in the right when I say that the sanitary notice of any place whatever, if it is to be wished that it should be opportune, accurate, and trustworthy, cannot be given by any person other than by a physician belonging to the nation interested in receiving the notification. The examination of all this question would seem ended here, if the exclusive object of this Conference should be reduced to treating it under the humanitarian point of view; but it is not so, as we have to consider it under the point of view of the mutual commercial interests, as it is inferred from the several official documents to be seen in the protocols of the past sessions, and in this respect I am going to present some considerations. The notification sent by the agents to their respective nations about the sanitary state of a port is going to influence in a direct and effective way the commerce of that port. If it is de- clared in the notification that there is an epidemic, the vessels which sailed from that port will irremissibly be subject to quarantine, and commerce will suffer all the inconveniences arising out of this prudent measure of hygiene; in the other case, commerce will be free. So that the free traffic of one nation with another, the interests of some millions of men would be at the mercy of a single foreign individual; these interests will depend many a time on a scientific error, on an involuntary omission; on a slight way of judging at things; in a word, on any of the im- perfections to which human kind is subject. It is to be seen that the notification is in itself highly important to the country that receives it, because it cautions her of a grave danger; it is also highly important to the nation that sends it, because it affects gravely its commercial in- terests. We have, therefore, to look for the means of conciliating these two interests, which have an equal right to be considered; and if we have already agreed that a foreign agent should be the one to make the notification to his government, we must establish, as a principle of justice and convenience, that the other interested power should have equal rights and equal interven- tion in the notification. If we act in any other way, if we grant that right to only one of the two nations, whoever she might be, and we deny it to the other, we would act unjustly, and I do not hesitate in saying that the Conference will end without deciding satisfactorily the questions for which it was called, and without carrying out the noble aspirations of the American nation. It is useless to say that the agent of the nation of the port of departure should likewise be a physician for the reasons given above; and besides, because, first, in the doubtful technical questions which might arise it is easier to arrive at an agreement between two connoisseurs than 21 iii the case where one of the contending parties should lack that quality; and, secondly, because it is more trustworthy the unanimous testimony of two witnesses contrarily opposed in a question than that of one alone, because it leaves a doubt in your mind in regard to its justification, and, above all, in regard to its impartiality. Adopting this idea, the basis of a system of international notifications will result therefrom with the conditions to be desired, to wit, to give an accurate and trustworthy knowledge of the sanitary state of a country for the benefit of the public health of the other nations without wounding, uselessly, the commercial interests. I have heard some of the honorable delegates present as an inconvenience to carry out these ideas the expense which the nations would be obliged to make with the duty of maintaining special agents to make the notifications. I do not think enough of this objection to attend to it, nor does it seem to me entirely true in the bottom. If it is to be believed that, in the present state attained by civilization, the system proposed should be the one offering more guarantees for the prevention of contagious diseases that decimate the population and diminish their capitals, I might then affirm, without fear of being contradicted, that a nation loses more in one or two epidemics than it would spend for several years in maintaining advanced sentinels that should caution her of a danger of this kind, and should give her occasion to avoid it. At New Orleans, for instance, Dr. Chopin, president of the board of health, has calculated that the pecuniary losses that she suffered during the last epidemic (1878) amounted to ten millions of dollars, and another physician states that the losses experienced in that epidemic by the cities of the United States victims of them, put together, amount to the respectable sum of one hundred millions of dollars. 1 think that, even supposing these figures exaggerated and reduced one-half, the American Republic would not expend in many years this sum in the maintenance of said agents. On the other side, it is not my purpose to force on the powers the obligation to maintain special agents in all the ports of the world. I wish that they be granted the right to have them in the points which they may think necessary, with the considerations and privileges which will hereafter be granted. In this respect I can do nothing better than to repeat the following words of the honorable Dr. Cabell, as they condense my idea: "In general, when any particular country is constantly or frequently in danger of importing infection from a given foreign port, it will, for its own safety, maintain a competent physician at such port to assist its consul; but until it becomes apparent that the exigency exists, or is near at hand, it is not to be expected that gov- ernments will be willing to incur the expense of sending medical officers to reside at all the ports at which an infectious disease may possibly exist at some future day, and yet it will be import- ant to have the earliest notice of the first cases, if any should occur." I do not believe that it is opportune to go into the examination of other questions, however great their interest may be, as, for instance, what should be the most proper means to investigate the sanitary state of a place or vessel; what should be done in case of the infraction of any of the established rules, &c., because all of them presuppose that a system of notification has already been adopted; they all spring therefrom; they are the particular case of a general basis, what- ever that may be, previously accepted, and therefore they would have to be taken into account and decided after the nations that we respectively represent here may have approved the funda- mental proposition which I have now the honor to submit to the examination of the Conference as an amendment to the final proposition, of the private vote that the undersigned presented to this Conference through the subcommittee: "The necessary investigations for the knowledge of the public health of a place, the sani- tary inspection of the vessels, and the consequent international notification, shall be made by the sanitary local authorities; allowing, however, the nations that signed this agreement the use 22 of the right granted to them to associate with the above-mentioned authority in all and in each one of these acts through their sanitary agents. "Dr. I. ALVARADO. "Dr. F. J. VAN LEENT. "STEPHEN PRESTON. "JULIO CARRIE. "J. J. da SILVA AMADO." The President (Mr. HAY). I am sure we have all listened with interest to the judi- cious and learned observations of the Delegate of Mexico, but as they are not applicable to the matter at present under discussion, they will be printed in the protocol and receive the attention of the Conference. The Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN). Gentlemen, the committee of five appointed by the Conference at its session of February 1, 1881, whose mission it was to study the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary relative to the establishment of an international system of notification of epidemics, held its first session February 9, 1881. This committee did me the honor of choosing me its chairman. In its session of February 15, 1881, the committee adopted by a majority vote the projet of convention containing a well established system of sanitary notification. By submitting to you a projet of convention entirely prepared, instead of simply recommendations in the form of general propositions, the majority of the com- mittee thought better to discharge the duty with which it was entrusted. By its nature the proposition had to be treated in this manner. Its merits, if it had any, consisted in details. It was therefore necessary that these details should be studied and established in a clear and precise manner. I therefore take the liberty, Mr. President, of submitting this projet of conven- tion to the consideration of the Conference. The projet was read, as follows : Projet for the establishment of two International Agencies of Sanitary Noti- fication. Article I. There shall be established in Vienna and Havana a permanent International Sanitary Agency of Notification. The respective governments shall agree among themselves as to the formation of those agencies. Art. II. It will be the duty of the agency at Vienna to gather sanitary information from Europe, Asia, and Africa. The agency at Havana will extend its sphere of action to the Amer- ican Continent and the islands belonging geographically thereto. This system to be subject to such modifications as may be rendered necessary by the state of telegraphic communication. Art. III. The contracting governments shall have the right to establish, if necessary, a third agency in Asia. Art. IV. The governments agreeing to this system of notification will send their sanitary reports to that agency in whose jurisdiction it is. Every agency shall send its notifications to those governments sending its sanitary bulletins. The agencies will exchange the information they receive among themselves in order that it may be made known to the respective countries belonging; to the jurisdiction of each. Art. V. There shall be no exceptions to this system, save in cases of extreme emergency. In such cases, however, a government may enter into communication with an agency to whose jurisdiction it does not belong. Art. VI. In cases of doubt as to the correctness of the bulletins received, the agency is authorized to enter into communication with the respective governments, who will be obliged to furnish as soon as possible the information asked. 23 Art. VII. In those countries where international sanitary boards exist, the agencies shall establish communication with them. Art. VIII. In those countries which have not a perfect sanitary organization, or which have not adopted the conclusions of this Conference, the consuls of the contracting powers shall meet in an International Sanitary Council in order to give to the said agencies the information which cannot be obtained from the local authorities. Art. IX. The Governments of Spain and Austria-Hungary shall fix the annual budget of expenses, which they will submit to the participating governments. Art. X. The division of expenses between the different governments shall be as follows: Half of the expense will be divided in proportion to the number of population, and the other half in proportion to the amount of tonnage of the merchant marine combined with the commercial maritime value of every country. Art. XT. The Governments of Spain and Austria-Hungary shall submit at the end of every fiscal year the final accounts to every one of the interested governments. Art. XII. The present convention is concluded for the space of ten years. Any govern- ment, however, is at liberty to renounce the convention after three years. The right is reserved to make such changes as any one of the governments taking part shall designate. The Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN). Gentlemen, as the author of the project of convention which I have submitted at this session, I wish to be allowed to recommend it to your kind attention. The discussions which have up to the present taken place in this Conference, and the proposition which has resulted relative to the international system of sanitary notifications, has resulted in this recommendation, to transmit to the foreign agents residing in the country the sanitary information. In addition to the fact that these measures are already in force in most of the countries, they only, in my opinion, partially meet the end which the Conference has in view. The publication of weekly sanitary bulletins, and the optional right that the govern- ments have to grant to the consuls to control, as it were, the official assertions, appear to me to be insufficient. By adopting these propositions the Conference would only partially fulfill the mission that has been confided to it. Its sphere of action is more extended. This sphere is clearly established by the first special proposition which the President of the United States wished to submit to the Conference. The memorandum of July 29 of the honorable Secretary of State speaks of the establishment of a trustworthy international system of notification relative to the existence of pestilential diseases, and particularly of cholera and yellow fever. A system of international sanitary notifications should not, therefore, be limited to the transmission of information to foreign agents residing in the country, but should also be communicated from one government to another in a uniform and precise manner. These communications should be established on a large and solid basis, be regular and constant, and including all countries having communication with each other. It is true, sanitary information has, up to the present time, been furnished to the governments by the consuls. I do not propose to take from the governments this source of information. On the contrary, I ask to complete it and not to abolish it. My institutions would simply control the information furnished by the agents of the different countries. I propose the establishment of international agencies whose mission it will be to transmit sanitary information. This idea is not a new one. International agencies, whose duty it is to collect and transmit information relative to subjects which interest not only one country and a continent, but the entire world, are already operating with complete success. The brilliant results obtained by these institutions have encouraged me to propose a like system for the transmission of sanitary information. Who would to-day dare to propose to abolish the international system of meteorological notification? Surely, nobody. 24 By my system I propose to keep all the governments interested informed of the sanitary condition of all countries, to offer them, as it were, a map of the public health in all parts of the globe, in imitation of the Meteorological Chart. It is a complete system of information, and more simple and less expensive than ihat proposed by the honorable Delegate of France. It is for this reason I prefer it. Allow me, gentlemen, to add ^ome details to the different articles of the projet which the majority of the committee had the honor to submit to your consideration. I accepted Havana as seatof the American agency, having learned that the establishment of such an agency in Washington would be at the present time fraught with some difficulties. I think that Havana, being situated in the zone of infection, being itself one of the principal centers of yellow fever, recommends itself at first sight as headquarters of my agency. Vienna, by its geographical position, relative to the countries in which the cholera and pest have their birth or take rise, and relative to the other countries of Europe, necessarily recommends itself as the headquarters of the European agency. I intentionally avoided proposing a plan for the formation of the boards of my agencies. I think it would be preferable to leave to each government the duty of deciding this question. I nevertheless think it my duty to insist on this point, that is, that these agencies should be as inexpensive as possible. For that reason it will be necessary that the employes should be reduced to the smallest possible number. A delicate question is that of the control of these agencies. This point would be decided if an institution of an international scientific commis- sion for the study of epidemics should become an accomplished fact, for this commission by its very nature would be the most competent to exercise control over the agencies. I consider some control necessary in any event. By the last part of Article 2 I wished to leave the greatest latitude possible to the differ- ent countries relative to the subject of telegraphic communications to one or the other of these agencies. The financial resources of these agencies would be furnished by the subscriptions of the different governments participating therein. The manner of distributing these subscriptions offers in myopinion the advantage of conciliating, better than any other means, the more or less important interests which the different countries have relative to population, to the importance of their commerce, and participation in the institution of these agencies. In regard to England, however, I should be of the opinion that what has been accepted by the conference of Vienna in like case-that is to say, that the British Possessions in India should not be counted-would be unjust, as remarked on that occasion, that England, which makes such great effort to kill the cholera in its germs in India, should be called upon to contribute, in proportion to the number of the population of its possessions, money for the purpose of preventing epidemic diseases. The same observations might be applied to the Dutch Possessions in India. At the same time it was observed that it would be just to take into consideration in distributing the expense pro rata among the different governments the expenses incurred by the governments that maintain, for the common good, quarantines in the Caspian and Red Seas. In concluding, I declare myself in readiness to answer any objection which may be made against my projet. Dr. CABELL. I do not desire to consider all the objections that can be urged against the proposition at this time. I should not occupy the attention of the Conference at all if it did not appear from a statement in Protocol No. 2 of the committee that I have been mis- understood by Count Lewenhaupt. He says : "As Dr. Cabell has, for the reasons given at the first sitting of the committee, declined to enter into discussion of the merits of the system, I am not able to express an opinion either for or against the proposition presented by the Delegate of Austria-Hungary, and it is for that reason that I have abstained from voting." 25 It seems to me that all I said in the first meeting touched the very merits of the question as a practical means of accomplishing a particular end. I expressly disclaim taking the position of denying the competency cither of the committee or Conference to consider this question. I have considered either competent to do it under the instructions of Mr. Evarts. But I said the Delegates of the United States were disposed to go behind this large view which was opened to them with regard to the methods of notification, and to consider the ends for which we desired to establish a system of notification. That end is also expressed in the memorandum. It is the prevention of the introduction of contagious and infectious diseases from foreign countries. Having on a previous occasion expressed the opinion that no other means would be practically available for accomplishing that end in a satisfactory manner than that of requiring the notification to be made by a responsible agent of the country of destination, I then remarked that Count Bethlen's proposition, which by implication excluded the use of such means, was not, in my opinion, likely to produce the result we desired. It seemed to me that that goes into the merits of the question as a means to an end: I did not enter into the merits of the question as an abstract one-that we were not called upon to do. I add that it is entirely within the province of the Conference to adopt this system, and there is nothing to estop the government of the United States from considering it if the government should choose to do so. I do not know what view the government will take, but I am not prepared to recommend the proposition to our government in a very positive manner, because I believe it is useless for the attainment of the principal end for which this Conference was called; but, on the other hand, I have no wish or purpose to dissuade our government from adopting it. On the contrary, I should be glad, for other reasons, to see it in operation. The Delegate of Sweden and Norway (Count LEWENHAUPT). I regret ex- tremely this misunderstanding on my part, and I beg leave to explain the reason why I abstained from voting in the committee. The recommendation of the system proposed by Count Bethlen implies a recommendation to the governments represented in the Conference to make a certain expenditure in order to secure certain sanitary information, and it seems to me necessary to obtain some description of the information which could be expected before deciding whether or not that expenditure ought to be made. It is possible to suppose a system of daily telegrams from all principal cities sent by responsible physicians, who had been appointed by the central sanitary administration. The Special Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN). This system exists to a greater or less extent in all the countries which have a sanitary organization. The expense it would occasion could not, therefore, be considered as new expense necessary for the organization of the proposed agencies. The only expense of my system is that for the transmis- sion of information from the agencies to the central governments, and vice versa. The Delegate of Sweden and Norway (Count LEWENHAUPT). The central sani- tary administration might thereafter send daily telegrams to the bureau. On the other side, it can be supposed, as another extreme case, that the central sanitary administration would not be able to transmit more than the information contained in the weekly bulletin. In that case, I should not hesitate to vote against the system proposed by Count Bethlen, because I agree with the opinion expressed in the Conference by Dr. Cabell, that the weekly bulletin is insuf- ficient for the purpose of notification. The information which could be expected would, of course, be something more than the bulletin, but I beg leave to ask if it would not be possible for Dr. Cabell to give some detailed description of the information which could be expected concerning the United States? The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I have already stated that I have no objection to the question being proposed to our government for its consideration. I 26 do not propose to take any part in dissuading the government from accepting it, though I believe it will weigh down the convention if all these details of what appears to me to be a cumbrous and costly machinery are introduced. It is impossible for me to answer categorically such questions as Count Lewenhaupt has asked. I am not prepared to say what we could do if this system was adopted. I have not examined it in all the aspects in which Count Lewen- haupt has asked me to consider it. The Delegate of Sweden and Norway (Count LEWENHAUPT). I understand perfectly the impossibility for Dr. Cabell, under the circumstances, to take any other position, and I think that the reasons given could not be stated more clearly. I did not at all intend to touch that question. The Delegate of the German Empire (HERMANN A. SCHUMACHER). I am very sorry that our committee could not agree upon a question which seems to me of very great importance for the future and for the beginning of an international health-service. Although two members of our committee were not willing to enter into the deliberations of the merits of the question, I remain convinced that by the adoption of our projet the Conference will take a considerable step forward for the benefit of the mutual defense of the nations against the propagation of contagious and infectious diseases. By estab- lishing sanitary centers of information we will reach one practical result: we will make our knowledge about the existence, the growth, and the character of these dangers more perfect, and such progress would be the best fruit of this Conference that we can expect under the present circumstances. In Germany that part of the resolution of Congress concerning a reliable and satisfactory international system of notification as to the existence or diffusion of contagious and infectious diseases, more especially of cholera, plague, and yellow fever, seemed to be in harmony with the great progress of our time, with the modern reforms in international intercourse, with the century of mutual telegraphic communication from one part of the world to the other. Local publications have, without the assistance of a strong organization of official character, no worth at all; but if the Governments of Austria-Hungary and of Spain are willing to make the first steps for international sanitary agencies, as I am allowed to presume, then I do not see any difficulties for the beginning of the inauguration of the proposed international system. To-day we cannot do more than recommend the first steps, but in two or three years of practical experience we will have material enough for the development of this sanitary organization of international interest. I do not find any reason to make a scientific interpretation of the expression "contagious and infectious diseases," nor to discuss all the details of the proposition presented by the committee. I recommend, therefore, that a vote be taken on the report before us as a whole. The Delegate of Russia (Mr. BARTHOLOMEI). I am in favor of the proposition of Count Bethlen, and I share the opinion of the Delegate of Germany (Mr. Schumacher) that the projet of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary should be voted on as a whole. In the congress of Vienna, held in 1874, they thought of establishing a commission to study the cholera. To-day we wish to extend the sphere of action of this commission to all the contagious diseases and to the whole world. In the conference of Vienna the committee of five representing Austria, Hungary, Norway, Prussia, and Russia, prepared a report recommending the creation of such a commission against cholera. This report, which was'published in the protocols of this Conference, was entitled " Expression of the wish of the Conference of Vienna." This is a precedent which, in'my opinion, the Delegate of Austria-Hungary might well adopt. He might employ the same title for his projet and call it the expression of the wish of the International Conference of Washington relative to a centralized international system of sanitary notifications. 27 In conclusion, I wish to be allowed to recommend the projet of the Delegate of Austria- Hungary to the most serious attention of the Conference. The Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN) stated that he shared the opinion of the Delegate of Russia, and presented, in the name of his colleagues of the committee, the Delegates of Germany and the Netherlands, and in his own, the following preamble: Expression of the desire of the Conference for the establishment of a centralized system of Inter- national Sanitary Notifications. The International Sanitary Conference declares that besides the means recommended by it in order to create a satisfactory international system of notification relative to the sanitary conditions of the different ports and places, the creation of certain organizations which will concentrate that service in their hands seems to it indispensable. It recommends, therefore, the adoption of the annexed projet. The object of this projet is the creation of two international organizations of sanitary notification. The duty of those organizations will be to gather all the information relative to the commencement, the increase and decrease of cholera, plague, yellow fever, &c., and to communicate this information to the interested parties. The question was taken on the proposition and preamble, and it was decided in the affirmative, yeas 13, nays 3, abstaining 2, as follows: Yeas-Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Brazil, Denmark, Spain, Hayti, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Russia, Turkey-13. Nays-United States, France, Japan-3. Abstaining-Mexico, Sweden-Norway-2. So the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary was agreed to. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY). In one of the previous sessions I sub- mitted to the Conference a proposition as an addition to propositions one and two of the Dele- gate of Russia relative to the notifications from one country to another. The vote on this proposition was suspended until after a vote should be taken on the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary. The latter proposition having been adopted I withdraw mine. The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. de BILLE) stated that in his opinion the Delegate of France ought to maintain his proposition, and that for his part he was in favor of it. The Special Delegate of Austria-Hungary (Count BETHLEN) stated that his proposition having been adopted there was no occasion for voting on that presented by the Delegate of France. The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. de BILLE) insisted that a vote be taken on the proposition of the Delegate of France. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO) stated that in his opinion it would be useless to vote which had already been adopted by the conference of 1853, and which is still in force in the countries which accepted it. For instance, it frequently happens that the sanitary authorities of Bordeaux and Lisbon correspond with each other relative to the trans- mission of sanitary notifications. The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY) did not think that all the governments which adhered to the Convention of 1853 still enforced this article, but repeated that he was ready to withdraw his proposition. The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE) reminds the Conference that, with his colleague of the Netherlands, he offered an amendment to the proposition of the Dele- gate of France. He holds it necessary to maintain this amendment with such modifications, however, as the adoption of the proposition of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary renders necessary. In its original form it read "that central sanitary authorities shall notify one another of the 28 appearance/' &c. The words " one another " are now unnecessary, as, according to the proposi- tion of the Delegate of Austria-Hungary, these notifications are to be made through the inter- national boards. He also insists on the necessity of not leaving to the governments the option of giving or not giving information of the 'appearance of contagious diseases within their territory, as the Delegate of France proposes. The international boards will only be able to work regularly if each government is required to give them accurate and prompt information. " In the interest of the public health, the central sanitary authority of each country represented in this Conference shall notify of the appearance and disappearance of epidemic and contagious diseases, yellow fever, cholera, and plague; such notification is, however, not to interfere with the information which the local authorities are bound to communicate to the consular officers residing within their district." The Delegate of France (Mr. OUTREY) asked that a vote be taken on his propo- sition, and if it is rejected that a vote be then taken on the amendments of the Delegates of Italy and the Netherlands, as the two propositions appeared to be quite distinct, and stated the proposition of the Delegates of Italy and the Netherlands has a larger sphere of action than his own, which only has in view the epidemic diseases. The Delegate of the Netherlands (Mr. PESTEL). Our proposition contains the three most dangerous diseases. Pest, cholera, and yellow fever are expressly mentioned in this proposition. The proposition of the Delegate of France was read as follows: "In the interest of the public health, and for the general good, the sanitary authorities of the countries represented in the Conference are authorized to communicate directly with each other, in order to keep themselves informed of all important facts which may come to their knowledge, respectively; but nothing herein contained is intended to relieve them from any duty now imposed on them of giving information to the consuls residing in their respective countries." The question was taken, and it was decided in the affirmative, yeas 1 f, nays 6, as follows: Yeas-Belgium, Chili, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Mexico, Russia, Sweden-Norway, Turkey-11. Nays-Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal-6. So the proposition of the Delegate of France was agreed to. The Special Delegate of Portugal (Dr. AMADO) asked that the vote be not taken on the proposition of the Delegates of Italy and the Netherlands. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY). I think this is equivalent to a reconsideration. I remember when the Delegate of Russia proposed his articles 1 and 2 at the session of January 26 last, he mentioned after their adoption, that he had proposed two ways of wording his amendments; that is to say, to leave it so it would read either "shall" or "should," and he asked that it might appear that way in the text, but the Conference declared that the vote had been taken, and it was unwilling to reconsider its action. I think that the proposition of the Delegates of Italy and the Netherlands can be inserted in the protocol, for the same reasons as the proposition presented to-day by the Delegate of France. The President (Mr. HAY.) If there are no further propositions to be placed before the Conference, it is in order for any Delegate to move that the results of the Conference as thus far attained be formulated and presented to the Conference at the next session for its approval. The Delegate of Chili (Mr. ASTA-BURUAGA). I move that the suggestion of the President be adopted. 29 The Delegate of Russia (Mr. BARTHOLOMEI). I wish to call attention to the last protocol. According to that, there is still before the Conference question five of the memo- randum of the Secretary of State. The Delegate of Italy (Prince de CAMPOREALE) stated that if he had not followed up his motion respecting question five of the memorandum, it was because the proposi- tion presented by the Delegate of France includes the case of countries not having any sanitary organization. The Delegate of Turkey (ARISTARCHI BEY), referring to his own observations in the last part of Protocol No. 6, stated that he had no special proposition to make. He would propose, however, that an editing committee to prepare the final report should be appointed, and he suggested that the committee combine as far as possible the contradictory elements of the Conference; that is to say, the Delegates who voted in the negative and who abstained should be represented on the committee as well as those who voted in the affirmative. He would nom- inate the following delegates to form part of that committee: MM. Outrey, Bartholomei, Bille, Lowndes, Camporeale, Cervera, Dr. Turner, Rustem. The Conference adopted the proposition of the Delegate of Turkey, and the committee stood as above named. On motion of the Delegate of Russia (Mr. BARTHOLOMEI) Mr. Outrey was elected president of the committee. The Delegate of Spain (Mr. de VIGO). I regret exceedingly to say good-bye to my honorable colleagues in the Conference. I shall shortly leave Washington, and I wish, before my departure, to thank them for the kindness they have always shown towards me. The President (Mr. HAY). In reply to the Delegate of Spain, and on behalf of the Conference, I have to assure him of the high esteem in which he is held by us, and the great respect and affection with which we all regard him, and at the same time convey our deep regret at losing so valuable a member of the Conference. [Applause.] Then, on motion of the Delegate of Chili, at 5.30 o'clock p. m., the Conference adjourned, to meet at the call of the President. The President of the Conference, JOHN HAY. The Secretary of the Conference, THOMAS J. TURNER. The French Secretary, RUSTEM. INTERNATIONAL SANITARY CONFERENCE OF WASHINGTON. PROTOCOL No. 8. Session of March 1, 1881. The Conference met at 1 o'clock p. m., pursuant to the call of the President (Mr. Hay). The following Delegates were present: Germany: H. A. Schumacher. Argentine Republic: Senor Don Julio Carrie. Austria-Hungary: Count Bethlen. Belgium: Baron d'Anethan, and Mr. Edouard Seve. Chili: Senor Don Francisco Solano Asta-Buruaga. China: Chin Lan Pin. Colombia, U. S. of: Dr. Pio Rengifo. Denmark: Mr. Carl Steen Andersen de Bille. Spain: Senor Don Felipe Senor Don Rafael Cervera, and Dr. Carlos Finlay. United States: Dr. James L. Cabell, Dr. Thomas J. Turner, J. Hubley Ashton, Esq., and James Lowndes, Esq. France: Mr. MaximeOutrey. Hayti: Mr. Stephen Preston. Italy: Prince de Camporeale. Japan: Jushie Yoshida Kiyonari. Mexico: Senor Don Ignacio Alvarado. The Netherlands: Jonkheer Rudolph von Pestel, and Dr. F. J. van Leent. Portugal: Viscount das Nogueiras, and Professor Jose Joaquim da Silva Amado. Russia: Mr. Michel Bartholomei. Sweden-Norway: Count Carl Lewenhaupt. Turkey: Gregoire Aristarchi Bey. Venezuela: Mr. Simon Camacho. The protocol No. 7 was laid before the Conference and approved. The credentials of Dr. Pio Rengifo, Special Delegate of the U. S. of Colombia, were presented. The PRESIDENT. The first business in order is the report of the Committee appointed at the last meeting. The report was read, as follows: In the name of the Committee chosen at the session of the 18th February, 1881, and con- sisting of the following members: MM. Outrey, Chairman; de Bille, Dr. Cervera, Lowndes, Dr. Turner, Camporeale, Bartholomei, and Rustem Effendi, Secretary, to embody in a formal document the conclusions of the Conference, Mr. de Bille, as Reporter of the Committee, has the honor to submit the following report: In proceeding to give to the resolutions adopted by the Conference their final shape, your Committee has not deemed itself empowered to go in any case beyond the limits imposed upon it by the votes recorded in the protocols. The decisions of the majority should be regarded as 2 final, and, however much it may be desired to amend this or that resolution or to supply this or that omission, this cannot be done without reopening the discussion of questions already debated. On the other hand, your Committee has thought it to be not only within its power, but to be its duty, to deal with the form and the order of the decisions of the Conference. By reason of the wide liberty left to the Delegates of introducing propositions, and of having the vote of the Conference upon them, there are marked differences in the forms of the resolutions adopted, and the order of their adoption has depended less on their logical sequence than on the accidents of debate. Your Committee has endeavored to bring out the logical relation of the questions dealt with by rearranging the resolutions adopted with reference to their subject-matter. Beginning with the general rules for an internal sanitary service, it has placed next those relating to the forms of international notification, then those providing for the form, the delivery, the trust- worthiness, and the gratuitous issue of bills of health, and, lastly, the recommendation of a meas- ure for the scientific investigation of yellow fever. Of the propositions submitted to and adopted by the Conference, some were declarations of principles and suggestions couched in general terms. Others, on the other hand, with the view of exhibiting their whole scope, go into minute and exhaustive detail, giving even the drafts of conventions to be hereafter made. Your Committee hopes to have met the views, both of those who submitted the propositions and of the members of the Conference, by removing this want of uniformity, which they have done by restoring to the resolutions their quality of generality, and by embodying all details in an exhibit to accompany the resolutions. It has endeavored in this way to recast the resolution looking to the establishment of a centralized international sani- tary service, that relating to the form of bills of health, and, lastly, that providing for a tempor- ary scientific commission for the study of yellow fever. In fact, that which has been adopted by the votes of the Conference on these questions is the general principle expressed in the propositions. There would have been great hesitation in accepting at this time as binding every clause of the drafts of convention or every phrase in the forms for sanitary documents, matters of detail which have been very little or not at all discussed in our sessions. In the two first resolutions, relating to the internal sanitary service of the different countries and their seaports, it has been thought convenient to make a slight transposition, which does not in any way affect the substance of the propositions adopted. The question has been raised whether there does not exist a contradiction between the third of the resolutions herein reported and one clause of the draft of a convention contained in the third annex. Your Committee is of opinion that such contradiction is, in any event, only ap- parent, and that there is no reason for submitting the question anew to a vote. In the hope that the Conference will approve the principles which have guided the labors of the Committee, your Committee submits to the Conference for adoption the following series of resolutions, with their respective annexes and appendices, and proposes that an instrument embodying them be signed by all the Delegates, in the diplomatic order of the States represented. The Delegate of Denmark (Mr. de BILLE). I do not understand this report is to be the subject of discussion, but is only to be considered as the introduction to the resolutions proposed to the Conference for adoption, which I will now read. The resolutions were then read. (See final act.) Mr. de BILLE called attention of the members to the vote at the end of each resolution in order that they might be verified. The Delegates of Belgium, Chili, and Sweden-Norway asked permission to correct their vote on resolutions 2, 5, and 7. There being no objection, permission was granted. 3 Dr. CABELL. I move the report of the Committee, as far as read, be adopted as a whole. Mr. CAMACHO. I ask that the answers to the questions of the Delegate of the United States, which I had the honor to submit in the name of the Government of Venezuela at the session of January 12 last, and which is inserted in Protocol No. 2, should be placed among the resolutions of the Conference in the same way as the propositions presented by MM. Amado, Outrey, and Alvarado, whose propositions are in the appendix under letters A, B, and C. After some explanation given by the Reporter (Mr. de Bille), a vote was taken on the request of the Delegate of Venezuela, and it was decided in the negative. So the request of the Delegate of Venezuela was refused. Mr. SEVE. I ask the Chair to permit me to present some observations analogous to those of the honorable Delegate of Venezuela, and to ask the Conference to add to the appendix of the final report submitted to discussion, the projet of organization of public hygiene which was adopted at the International Congress at Brussels in 1875, a projet which I had the honor of presenting to the Committee and to the Conference. I particularly insist on the insertion in the final report of the resolutions which were accepted with particular favor by all the members of the Committee in session on the 12th of January. AU the members of the Conference were agreed to admit certain principles; the only division was as to our authority to discuss and decide certain questions. I think the moment opportune for renewing with the honorable Delegates of this Conference the efforts which I made in the Committee relative to the projet of the In- ternational Congress of Brussels. It was lengthily discussed and arranged in conformity with the resolutions of the International Conference of Vienna, and which I might say was in reality adopted by this honorable assembly, as we would see if we were to pass in review all its discussions, or if we only mention the propositions which have been presented and those submitted by the Editing Committee which prepared the final act of this Conference. We have adopted the proposition of the Delegate of Russia, which sets forth the principle of national sanitary organization (resolutions 1 and 2). The proposition of the Delegate of Italy, amended by the Special Delegates of Spain and the Netherlands (resolution 6), and the adoption of the form of international bill of health (resolutions 5 and 7), admit de facto the principle of the international organization, the necessity for which has been recognized and recommended by all the conferences and all the previous scientific assemblies. The proposition of the Delegate of France, which is similar to one adopted by the Conference of Paris, and which has been amended by the Delegates of Italy and the Netherlands (resolution 3), and the adoption of an international centralized system of notification proposed by the Delegate of Austria-Hungary (resolution 4), and the scientific organization proposed by the Special Delegate of Spain (resolution 8), and this resolution, amplified by the Delegate of Portugal, complete the measures necessary to be taken to arrive at an agreement as to the best international sanitary organization. I beg to be allowed to place before you this projet, the defense of which I have taken upon myself, and which, considering the propositions already adopted by the Conference, I thought I could present in my own name on my own responsibility, without in any way bind- ing the Government of Belgium. Proposed General Organization of Public Hygiene, by Dr. Th. Belval, presented by Mr. Edouard Seve, Delegate of Belgium. Propositions adopted by the Medical Congress held at Brussels in 1875. Hygiene, considered in an executive point of view, should comprise two distinct parts: 1st. A national organization. 2d. An international organization. 4 1. The national organization would include the establishment by law in each country, and in all degrees of executive authority, of health and hygiene. 2. These would consist- A. Of a superior board near the governmental authority; B. Of a provincial (State) commission in each of the departments, provinces, prefectures, governments, cordes, or districts; C. Of a local committee in each commune in which such an organization might be possible* In communes whose small size will not permit the establishment of a committee, sanitary circumscriptions should be established, comprising various communes or sections of communes taken together. 3. The surveillance (and in case of need the execution) of the measures recognized as being of public utility should be exercised: A. In a general way by the secretary of the superior board; B. Throughout each province by the secretary of the provincial commission ; C. In each commune or group of communes by the secretary of the local committee in the capacity, respectively, of inspector, provincial inspector, and of communal or rural inspector of the health service. They could, if necessary, be assisted, or their places might be supplied in the performance of this work, by a member of the board or of the commissions. 4. Reports would be published or issued annually by each branch of the service. 5. Independently of the communication which the three degrees of the hygienic service would maintain with their respective administrations, these branches of the service might main- tain continuous relations with each other with regard to all questions within their competence. 6. The greater the independence and the authority of the various branches of the sanitary service in their sphere of action, the greater will be the advantages to public health. 7. The budget of each of these branches of the service would form part of that of the respective administrations to which they might be attached, as is done in the cases of the budget of public instruction and public charity. II. The international organization would comprise- 1st. The frequent and regular exchange of communications between the superior hygienic boards of the various countries. These communications would bear principally- A. a. Upon the means used to improve the sanitary conditions of the various localities and of their population; b. Upon the hygienic measures adopted with a view to mitigating the effects of endemic diseases; c. Upon the precautions adopted for the purpose of preventing the importation of epidemic or contagious diseases; d. Upon the opposition of foci or of endemic diseases; e. Upon measures adopted to combat epizooties. B. Upon the results obtained in each of these cases. C. Upon the statistical data collected or to be collected with a view to elucidating the problems of public hygiene. 2d. The periodical meeting of International Sanitary Conferences (such as, for instance, the Washington Conference). A correct copy. Edouard S^ve. 5 We have all agreed that the scientific authority alone should summarize the sanitary inform- ation obtained in each country, and that this authority should always participate in the interna- tional inspection. It is, therefore, the central medical authority, that is to say, the highest councils of hygiene of each country, which naturally must be designated to constitute the inter- national sanitary administration; which question was indirectly solved by the convention relative to the establishment in Vienna of an international sanitary commission, and admitted on my proposition in the Committee by every one save the Delegate from Canada, and which affirmed that this proposition is necessary, that a permanent sanitary commission should be established. The existence of this commission, instituted by resolution 8, and the motives which determined its creation, will centralize international labors, and facilitate their transmission to the sanitary authorities of each country. It is in fact evident, and this is also the opinion of the Medical Congress of 1875, that if an international organization was legally established the necessity would soon be felt to constitute such a center of exchange, as has been done in other cases. We can give as an example the International Bureau of Telegraphic Administrations, the Postal Union, the works of the Convention of Geneva, the International Exchange Office of 40 governments at Wsh ington, which all, I think, work to general satisfaction and render impor- tant services. The principle of international sanitary administration having been discovered and adopted, the question now is to prepare a programme of the studies which it will be its duty to enter upon. Such a programme is summarized in the conclusions adopted by the Congress at Brussels. The judicious and important propositions of the honorable Delegates of Austria- Hungary, Spain, France, Netherlands, and Portugal having been admitted in principle, we have reached an important result. It is the real point of departure of international hygiene. I can- not sufficiently affirm this, that it will always be of a manifest utility and of great usefulness that the questions which have come to maturity should be decided in concert by diplomacy and by science. Their union is a moral assurance of the existence of the adopted conclusions. Dr. Proust says " there are questions which, by their international character necessarily in- volving the solution which is given to them by the numerous interests which are brought in play, imperatively demand the combination of the powers of all the world. The solution of these important questions of international hygiene is almost of a political character and necessi- tates real diplomatic acts." These congresses may come to useful resolutions and the establish- ment of international sanitary limits against cholera, as this disease has been studied for a long time and in all countries, but it needed 25 years between the Congress of Paris and that of Vienna to come to the actual result. In this point of view it was necessary that all the questions, the execution of which would necessitate international co-operation, should have been studied in the Committee of January 12th, in order the sooner to bring them to maturity and offer them, explained and accompanied by all the documents in their favor, to the deliberations of the Conference of Washington, in 1881. The moral support that this Conference should give to the projet of the Medical Congress of 1875 would besides regulate the operation of the national inspections which would later be put in force. The work of the superior councils as corollary to that of the sanitary administra- tion would follow an even path for this part of the researches, the results of which would be exchanged until the day when some practical conclusion should make itself apparent. This, of course, would not exclude the local care to be taken of the hygienic needs of the population. It is easy to understand that a rational method will in the end direct this portion of the mis- sion of the hygienist by reason of the reciprocal information. Dr. Belval, in his letter to me of February 10th last, writes as follows: "I am very much obliged to you for the efforts you have made for the adoption in principle of the resolution adopted by the Medical Congress of 1875. I may add that these resolutions have been strengthened by a new vote of the International Congress of Medical Science in 6 Amsterdam in 1879, at which I represented the government (Minister of Public Instruction). "A subcommittee was charged with the duty of considering this subject. "It was composed of Messrs. Palasciano, of Naples; Manatt, of London; Dr. Van Cap- elie, referendaire of medical force at the Ministry of the Interior, at the Hague; Belval, of Brussels; and Finckelbury, President Board of Health of Berlin, reporter. "The conclusions of the subcommittee were adopted in the terms which you will find indi- cated on page 15 of the annexed pamphlet. " Propositions for putting in practice this organization, both on a national and an interna- tional basis, and on general questions, as well as on certain particular points, were equally dis- cussed and voted at the International Congress of Hygiene of Turin, September, 1880. The proceedings have not yet been published, and I cannot give you the exact text. You can, nevertheless, I think, by the aid of all these facts, prove that solidarity in hygienic questions has been recognized and confirmed by all the nations of the globe. This solidarity is unde- niable, and served as a basis for my report of 1875. It is admitted that it is proper the centers to which in each country sanitary information is sent should be in as frequent and regular com- munication as possible. From this exchange will arise the necessity for a general sanitary organization in each country, to the great advantage of the population and the progress of hygiene. It is the conviction of the great good which will result from this proposition that causes me to continually revert to it for the twenty years I have been following up this matter. This is sufficient to prove to you how happy I have been to see you use the great influence you can bring to bear in behalf of this humanitarian cause. All hygienists will be very grateful to you. It seems that the measures adopted thus far, and which I find published in the protocol of the meeting of January, are a good augury. I would be much obliged to you if you would keep me informed of the other resolutions adopted, and of the final conclusions which will be adopted by the Sanitary Conference of Washington." The proposition of Dr. Finckelbury, President of the Board of Health of Berlin, to which Belval alludes in speaking of the International Congress of Hygiene in 1880, was presented as follows: "What is the practical object of international hygiene? By what means of organization can this object be attained?" The conclusions of the commission of the International Congress of Medical Science of Amsterdam in 1879 were adopted, as follows: "The international organization of public hygiene is of as great importance for the practical object of sanitary service as for the progress of hygienic science. Great epidemics and epizootics can only be efficiently met if the measures taken in each center of infection are indicated and watched according to the principles decided upon between the sanitary authorities of the civil- ized nations. The rapid development of international commerce in food and liquids necessitates an agreement on the part of the sanitary authorities of the guarantees to be mutually demanded relative to the adulteration of the merchandise exported. As for hygienic science, it should be based on accumulated facts, which could only be furnished with precision by the united efforts of the sanitary authorities. To attain this object an organized agreement which will as- sure to the facts obtained, the necessary conformity to enable them to be submitted as comparisons and for scientific uses. " Therefore the periodical Congress of Medical Science of Amsterdam earnestly recommends the putting in practice all the conclusions adopted by the Congress of Medical Science of Brussels in 1875, relative to the international organization of public hygiene." No oue would think of denying the usefulness and importance of this international organ- ization. It would result for our countries in an organization of the administrative services of hygiene. 7 The working of a complete sanitary service would answer two of the questions of the mem- oranda of his excellency the Secretary of State (Mr. Evarts). Let us therefore express the hope that the projet of the Medical Congress of Brussels will be realized. We have in our power the means of preparing if not regulating an international under- standing, and the whole world will be incalculably indebted to the International Sanitary Con- ference of Washington in the same way that it is indebted to the Conferences of Paris, Constan- tinople, and Vienna. I have the honor of proposing to annex to the final report the following resolution : "The Conference earnestly recommends putting in practice the conclusions adopted by the Congress of Medical Science of Brussels in 1875, relative to an international organization of public hygiene, which conclusions were also approved by the Medical Congress of Amsterdam in 1879, and of Turin in 1880." A discussion occurred between the Reporter (Mr. de Bille) and Mr. Seve relative to the insertion in the final act of the proposition submitted by the latter. The question being taken, it was decided in the negative. So the Conference refused to grant the request of the Delegate of Belgium. Mr. CARRIE moved that the Conference adjourn for 24 hours, in order to allow the Dele- gates to examine the final act which the Editing Committee had submitted. He stated that the Conference had decided at its fifth session on the proposition of A ristarchi Bey that all docu- ments relative to its deliberations should be submitted to the Delegates at least 24 hours in ad- vance of any meeting. The question was taken, and it was decided in the negative, yeas 8, nays 13, as follows: Yeas-Argentine Republic, Belgium, Chili, China, Japan, Mexico, Russia, Venezuela-8. Nays-Germany, Austria-Hungary, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Sweden-Norway, Turkey United States of Colombia-13. So the motion to adjourn was disagreed to. ARISTARCHI BEY stated he admitted the correctness of the principle of the motion of the Delegate of the Argentine Republic, but he voted against it because the Conference was anxious to terminate its labors; and, besides, having read the final act, he did not find in it any new things. Jie would propose, however, that the Conference take a recess for half an hour to give the Delegates time to examine the final act. There being no objection, the proposition of Aristarchi Bey was agreed to. So the Conference took a recess for 30 minutes. After the Recess. The recess having expired, the Conference reassembled. Mr. BARTHOLOMEI suggested that the word "March" be added after "February," in the preamble of the report submitted by the Committee. The Committee accepted the suggestion, and "March" was added accordingly. ARISTARCHI BEY. Although the opinions of the majority and minority have, accord- ing to my opinion, about the same moral value, copsidering that we cannot foresee whether the different governments will adopt in one way or another the views expressed by their Delegates, I wish to refer to what I declared to the Department of State on the 28th of December last, in an official letter, viz, that I could only take part in the Conference provided ray remarks and votes should be considered ad referendum. I ask that my declaration be inserted in the protocol. Mr. OUTREY stated he thought it necessary to repeat the declaration that he made in the meeting of January 26th, when he had the honor of presiding, that he understood from all the Delegates that the result of their labors was to be submitted to their respective governments, 8 which alone had the authority to give them a definitive character. In other words, that every- thing decided by this Conference has been decided ad referendum. The PRESIDENT. Of course it is understood by every one that the report is to be signed simply ad referendum. Mr. OUTREY moved that a committee, composed of Mr. Bartholomei and the Secre- taries, be appointed, to be charged with the duty of putting in order the work of the Confer- ence for the final printing; that this committee also have the right of making all the corrections and changes in the phraseology, and even in the order of discussion, which they may deem necessary. The question was taken, and the motion was decided in the affirmative unanimously. Mr. BARTHOLOMEI proposed that the President should invite the Delegate of Great Britain, who had been absent from the last meeting of the Conference on account of sad bereave- ment in his family, to sign the final act; that this would be an act of courtesy towards the Dele- gate of a power so important as Great Britain; and that the final protocol should not be closed before the Delegate of Great Britain should have signed it. Mr. OUTREY stated that he not only concurred in the remarks of Mr. Bartholomei, but thought the President oimht to invite the honorable Mr. Archibald to vote on each of the resolutions which was acted on during his absence, and that the final protocol should not be printed until the vote of the Delegate of Great Britain had been submitted. The PRESIDENT. I am sure every member of the Conference will join so heartily in those propositions that it is scarcely necessary to take a vote on them. The question was taken on the propositions of MM. Bartholomei and Outrey, and they were agreed to. The Delegate of the United States (Dr. CABELL). I wish to state, at the special request of the Delegates of Mexico and Portugal, that the Special Delegates of the United States will sign the annexes which they respectively submitted, and to which their signatures were not attached at the last meeting. The PRESIDENT. The vote is now on the adoption of the resolutions, with the reserva- tions already made. The question was taken, and decided unanimously in the affirmative. So the report of the Committee was adopted. The PRESIDENT. We will now proceed to sign the final act. Mr. de BILLE. The signatures will be attached to the final act subject, of course, to all rights of correction, which are reserved. The final act was then signed by the various Delegates. The President (Mr. HAY). Before putting the question on our final adjournment, I take pleasure, on behalf of the Delegates of the United States, in expressing their sincere feelings of gratitude through the Delegates present to the governments they represent for the prompti- tude and good will with which they have met the invitation of the United States on this sub- ject of great and universal concern, and also to the Delegates themselves, not only for the intel- ligence and zeal with which they have taken part in these deliberations, so important to us, but also for the impartiality and spirit of courtesy and candor with which all their proceedings have been marked. I venture to express the hope that what we have done will not be unfruitful of results for the good of the nations which we severally represent and the world at large. No one of us perhaps has seen accomplished precisely what he expected or desired, but it is altogether probable that the results at which we have arrived are better than any one of us singly could have devised. If I might be permitted one word personal to myself, I should be glad of the opportunity to express my sincere gratification at having been permitted to preside, however unworthily, over the deliberations of an assembly containing so much of intelligence, learning, and distinc- 9 tion. My duties have been rendered much easier to me, and my shortcomings have been made less evident even to myself, by your unfailing courtesy, kindness, and forbearance; so that the hours we have spent together will always be for me among the happiest recollections of my life. 1 beg to express to you, before we part, my profound sense of appreciation of the honor and pleasure which your acquaintance has been to me, and my most fervent wishes for your personal prosperity and welfare. Mr. BARTHOLOMEI. As we are on the point of concluding our deliberations, I wish to call attention to the debt of gratitude which is due to the Government of the United States for the initiative it has taken in this matter with so humane an object. The labors of this Conference (whose object it was to combat a dangerous disease) have resulted in tracing some new lines, and establishing a new starting point in the path which has been followed so long, and which preceding conferences have had in view. The progress made by our deliberations will be in its turn assured by the final development of the projets actually submitted to the consideration of the respective governments. If such measures were shortly to be put into execution a new collective deliberation of the countries interested would be necessary. Should another sanitary conference then become nec- essary, the precedent established by the United States in this case would be a just reason- a real encouragement-for them to resume at another date the generous initiative which has at this time been taken with so much success. The foreign powers would certainly answer the call with the same promptness and the same solictude which they have shown in the present case. I do not yet consider my duties fulfilled. I have still a few words to add. The labors of this Conference are on the point of terminating, and before we part I wish to propose a vote which I am sure will be received with marked satisfaction by all the Delegates and adopted unanimously. Our discussions have been guided alternatively by Mr. John Hay as President and Mr. Outrey as Vice-President. They have acquitted themselves of their duty with such impartiality and a spirit of conciliation and deference toward all the opinions advanced which should in return assure them of our warmest gratitude. I am, therefore, certain of interpreting aright the sentiment of all the Delegates in proposing a vote of thanks to the President, Mr. John Hay, and the Vice-President, Mr. Outrey, for the great services they have rendered to the Conference. (Applause.) Prince de CAMPOREALE. I am happy to have been chosen by my honorable col- leagues to express publicly our gratitude to Dr. T. J. Turner and Rustem Effendi, our honor- able Secretaries. The duties with which the Conference intrusted them were of the most arduous. The simultaneous use of two languages contributed to render their work very difficult. They have, nevertheless, acquitted themselves of their duties with a zeal and good-will that is above all praise. We have always found in them the greatest desire to render service to us. We especially owe our thanks to Rustem Effendi, who, although not a Delegate to this Conference, kindly assumed the great task of aiding us in our work. We will keep a most agreeable memory of these gentlemen, and in the name of the Conference I beg the President to be the interpreter to the Government of the United States of the gratitude we feel to our Secretaries. The Conference approved the remarks of the Delegate of Italy. Mr. SfiVE. Permit me to call your attention to two gentlemen who have rendered us very great services, viz, the English and French stenographers, Messrs. C. S. Chesney and J. T. Thompson. Their faithful and exact reports have been a constant help to us. In them we have ever found a courtesy and capacity for work seldom met with in the assistants of confer- ences. I therefore propose a vote of thanks to those gentlemen, who so well deserve it. The Conference approved the remarks of the Special Delegate of Belgium. The present protocol was then and there read and approved. Then, at 3| o'clock p. m., the International Sanitary Conference of Washington adjourned sine die. 10 Resolutions adopted by the International Sanitary Conference of Washington, drawn up by a committee composed of Messrs. Outrey, de Bille, Dr. Cervera, Lowndes, Dr. Turner, Prince de Camporeale, Bartholomei, and Rustem Effendi, Secretary. RESOLUTIONS. I. Each Government shall have such an organized internal service as will enable it to be regularly informed of the state of the public health throughout the whole of its territory. Yeas: Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Denmark, Spain, France, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, The Netherlands, Portugal, Russia-12. Nays: Chili, United States, Great Britain, Sweden and Norway, Turkey-5. II. Each Government shall publish a weekly bulletin of the statistics of mortality in its prin- cipal cities and ports, and shall give such bulletins the largest possible publicity. Yeas: Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Chili, Denmark, Spain, France, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, The Netherlands, Portugal, Russia-13. Nays: United States, Great Britain, Sweden and Norway, Turkey-4. III. In the interest of the public health, the sanitary authorities of the countries represented in this Conference are authorized to communicate directly with each other in order to keep themselves informed of all important facts which may come to their knowledge; but nothing herein contained shall relieve them from the duty of furnishing, at the same time, to the consuls in their respective jurisdictions the information they are required to give them. Yeas: Belgium, Chili, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Mexico, Russia, Sweden and Norway, Turkey-11. Nays: Germany, Austria-Hungary, Italy, The Netherlands, Portugal, Argentine Republic-6. IV. A centralized international system of sanitary notification being deemed indispensable to the successful carrying out of measures for preventing the introduction of disease, it is advisable to create international organizations to be charged with the duty of collecting information in regard to the outbreak, spread, and disappearance of cholera, pest, yellow fever, &c., and of conveying such information to the parties interested. A draft of a Convention to carry out this object has been voted by the Conference in the following manner. (Annex I.) Yeas: Germany, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Chili, Denmark, Spain, Hayti, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Argentine Republic, Russia, Turkey-13. Nays: United States, France, Japan-3. Abstained from voting: Mexico, Sweden and Norway-2. V. Bills of health shall be in the form hereto annexed. (Annex II.) Yeas: Belgium, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, The Netherlands, Portugal, Turkey-11. Nays: Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, China, Russia, Sweden and Norway-6. 11 VI. Bills of health shall be delivered at the port of departure by the responsible sanitary agent of the central government. The consul of the country of destination shall have the right to be present at the examination of ships made by the representative of the territorial government under such rules as may be laid down by international agreement or treaty, and the authority to authenticate the bill of health and to add thereon such remarks as he may deem necessary. Yeas: Germany, Argentine Republic, Austria-Hungary, Chili, Denmark, Spain, Hayti, Italy, Mexico, The Netherlands, Portugal-11. Nays: Belgium, China, United States, Erance, Russia, Sweden and Norway, Tur- key-7. VII. Bills of health granted in compliance with international rules should be issued gratis. Yeas: Germany, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Denmark, United States, France, Hayti, The Netherlands-8. Nays: China, Italy, Russia, Sweden and Norway, Turkey-5. Abstained from voting: Argentine Republic, Spain, Mexico, Portugal-4. VIII. A temporary and scientific Sanitary Commission shall be created by the nations most directly interested in protecting themselves against yellow fever, and by such others as may wish to take part in this arrangement, to be charged with the duty of studying all matters per- taining to the origin, development, and propagation of that disease. A draft of a Convention to carry out this object has been voted by the Conference in the following manner. (Annex III.) Yeas: Germany, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Chili, Denmark, Spain, United States, France, Hayti, Mexico, The Netherlands, Portugal, Argentine Republic, Turkey-14. Abstained from voting: Italy, Japan, Russia, Sweden and Norway-4. Annex I. The draft of a Convention mentioned in the Resolution IV is as follows: Article I. There shall be established in Vienna and Havana a permanent International Sanitary Agency of Notification. The respective Governments shall agree among themselves as to the formation of those agencies. Art. II. It will be the duty of the agency at Vienna to gather sanitary information from Europe, Asia, and Africa. The agency at Havana will extend its sphere of action to the American Continent and the islands belonging geographically thereto. This system to be sub- ject to such modifications as may be rendered necessary by the state of telegraphic communi- cation. Art. III. The contracting Governments shall have the right to establish, if necessary, a third agency in Asia. Art. IV. The Governments agreeing to this system of notification will send their sanitary reports to that agency in whose jurisdiction it is. Every agency shall send its notifications to those Governments sending sanitary bulletins. The different agencies will exchange the in- formation they receive among themselves in order that it may be made known to the respective countries belonging to the jurisdiction of each. 12 Art. V. There shall be no exceptions to this system, save in cases of extreme emergency. In such cases, however, a Government may enter into communication with an agency to whose jurisdiction it does not belong. Art. VI. In cases of doubt as to the correctness of the bulletins received, the agency is authorized to enter into communication with the respective Governments, who will be obliged to furnish as soon as possible the information asked. Art. VIL In those countries where international sanitary boards exist the agencies shall establish communication with them. Art. VIII. In those countries which have not a perfect sanitary organization, or which have not adopted the conclusions of this Conference, the consuls of the contracting powers shall meet in an international sanitary council in order to give to the said agencies the information which cannot be obtained from the local authorities. Art. IX. The Governments of Spain and Austria-Hungary shall fix the annual budget of expenses, which they will submit to the participating Governments. Art. X. The division of expenses between the different Governments shall be as follows: Half of the expense will be divided in proportion to the number of population, and the other half in proportion to the amount of tonnage of the merchant marine combined with the commercial maritime value of every country. Art. XI. The Governments of Spain and Austria-Hungary shall submit at the end of every fiscal year the final accounts to every one of the interested Governments. Art. XII. The present Convention is concluded for the space of ten years. Any Gov- ernment, however, is at liberty to renounce the Convention after three years. The right is re- served to make such changes as any one of the Governments taking part shall designate. 13 Annex II. International Bill of Health. I, (the person charged to deliver the bill), at the port of , do hereby state that the vessel hereinafter named clears from this port under the following circumstances: Name of vessel: Tonnage: Apartments for passengers, No. Destination:.- Name of medical officer (if any): Total number of passengers: 1st cabin, ; 2d cabin, ; steerage, Nature (vessel-of-war,ship, schooner, &c.): .... Guns: Where last from: Name of captain : Total number of crew: .. -- Cargo: Vessel. 1. Sanitary condition of vessel (before and after reception of cargo, with note of any decayed wood). Note disinfection of vessel: - 2. Sanitary condition of cargo: - 3. Sanitary condition of crew: 4. Sanitary condition of passengers: 5. Sanitary condition of clothing, food, water, air-space, and ventilation: Port. 1. Sanitary condition of port and adjacent country- a. Prevailing disease (if any): b. Number of cases of and deaths from yellow fever, Asiatic cholera, plague, small-pox, or typhus fever during the week preceding- Number of cases of- Yellow fever: Asiatic cholera: Plague: Small-pox: Typhus fever: Number of deaths from- Yellow fever: Asiatic cholera: Plague: Small-pox: Typhus fever: c. Population according to the last census: d. Total deaths from all causes during the preceding month: 2. Any circumstances affecting the public health existing in the port of departure to be here stated: I certify that the foregoing statements are made by __ _, who has personally inspected said vessel; that I am satisfied that the said statements are correct; and I do further certify that the said vessel leaves this port, bound for , in In witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand and the seal of office, at the port of , this day of , 188 , o'clock. [seal.] [Signature.] 14 Annex III. Article I. A temporary scientific sanitary commission will be established by the nations most deeply interested to protect themselves against yellow fever, and also by such nations as will adhere to these proposals. Art. II. The duties of this commission will be- A. The study and ascertainment of the principal and permanent centers of the morbigene germs of the disease. B. The conditions which favor its extension, and also the etiology and circumstances which aid its propagation in the respective centers, and its diffusion to other countries. C. The means to be employed to circumscribe more and more its effects, or to eradicate the disease entirely from the regions in which it originates, and from the countries lately attacked. D. How to prevent the transmission by vessels. E. The best and most practical method of disinfection of ships, their cargoes and pas- sengers. F. Also everything relating to the prophylaxis and treatment of the disease. Art. III. The countries which desire to concur in the organization of this scientific com- mission will agree between themselves as to the instructions to be given to their delegates in order to facilitate their labors. Art IV. After having studied on the spot the different questions submitted to its inves- tigations, this commission shall present a collective report indicating the most practical means to attain the end proposed. Appendix I. The Special Delegates to the Convention have agreed to recommend the adoption of the following proposition, which, because of its special and scientific character, they have not thought it expedient to submit to a formal vote of the Conference : Propositions. The Conference recommends the creation of twenty-two international sanitary posts for the study of yellow fever, to be established at New Orleans, Galveston, Vera Cruz, Panama, Maracaibo; one in each of the Guianas; two in Cuba; one in each of the following islands: St. Domingo, Jamacia, St. Thomas, Guadeloupe, Martinique, Barbadoes; one in each of the following ports of Brazil: Para, Maranham, Pernambuco, Bahia, Rio de Janeiro, and one in Senegambia. At each of these posts there will be at least two physicians-one from the same country, and the other from the country with which the port or town is in the most constant communication. All other nations will have the right to send sanitary physicians to these posts. The expenses of each of these posts will be paid pro rata by the nations which have appointed sanitary phy- cians. The number of posts will be increased or diminished as the necessities of the case may require. The contracting nations will arrange between themselves as to the number of phy- sicians that each nation shall appoint, and for their distribution at the different posts, and the same process shall be used in the future for the increase or diminution of the posts. The phy- sicians of these sanitary posts will not be allowed to practice their profession generally or accept any other employment, under pain of dismissal. They will only be allowed to accept the duties of physicians of the hospitals in which yellow fever cases are admitted. At each post there shall be- 1. A laboratory, furnished with chemical and other instruments and material necessary for making analyses. 15 2. A cabinet, for experimental and histological studies, furnished with good microscopes for the necessary examinations. 3. A library, containing the most important works which have been published ou yellow fever. The physicians of the sanitary posts shall- 1. Keep themselves informed of the sanitary condition of the towu in which they are, in order to know when the first case of yellow fever breaks out. 2. Follow the progress of the disease so as to know exactly when it decreases and ends. 3. Immediately inform the sanitary authorities of the country from which they are ap- pointed of all the facts which can be of interest to them. 4. Study the meteorological condition of the town in which these posts are placed, and see what relation exists between this condition and the appearance, propagation, and gravity of the disease. 5. Study the telluric conditions of those towns with the same object as in No. 4. 6. Make frequent chemical and microscopic analyses of the drinking water used in these towns. 7. Help the authorities whose duty it is to inspect the ships in order to see if any relation can be found between the condition of these vessels and the eventual appearance of yellow fever on board. 8. Study the sanitary condition of the town, and endeavor to find out if any relation exists between an unhealthy focus and the development of the epidemic. 9. Frequently visit the hospitals where cases of yellow fever are admitted, and study the progress of the disease from observation of the different cases. 10. Help to make the autopsy of the bodies of persons dying from yellow fever. 11. Making the anatomico-pathological and histological examination of the humorsand organs of these bodies so as to try and discover the nature of the lesions. 12. Make monthly report of what they have observed, and transmit it to the Govern- ments by which they are appointed. These reports will be published and distributed by all the Governments which have adhered to this institution. 13. Make an annual report, a copy of which will be sent to the Governments by which they are named and another presented to the conference of sanitary physicians. Every year there shall be a conference of medical sanitarians at which at least one mem- ber of each post shall assist. The first conference shall take place in Havana, and the places at which the others shall be held shall be designated at the end of each yearly conference, in such order that every year the meeting shall take place at a different city. The conference shall last ten days, and the reports of the different sanitary posts shall be read and discussed. It is desirable that the Governments should send occasional inspecting committees to examine these posts. If an international commission on epidemics is created, as has been proposed, this commission should have the right to regulate the workings of those posts. (Signed) COUNT BETHLEN. EDWARD SEVE. Dr. RAFAEL CERVERA. J. L. CABELL. T. J. TURNER. Dr. CARLOS FINLAY. Dr. F. J. VAN LEENT. Dr. IGNACIO ALVARADO. J. J. da SILVA AMADO. 16 Appendix II. Proposal presented by the undersigned Delegates, having voted against Article VI, and destined to be submitted to the favorable consideration of the Governments represented in this Conference: Article I. In the countries where the regulations demand that the ships at the time of their departure should have a bill of health delivered by the local authorities, this bill of health shall continue to be delivered by the above authorities; but the captain of the vessel shall have the right to ask that this bill of health be vised by the consul of the country of destination, whose duty it will be to give it with the least possible delay. This consul shall have the right to accompany his vise with such remarks as he may judge necessary. If the vessel is not subjected to the obligation of being furnished with a bill of health by the local authorities, the captain shall have the right to demand one from the consul of the country of destination, whose duty it shall also be to deliver it with the least possible delay. Art. II. In the countries where the regulations demand that the ships before obtaining a bill of health from the local authority be subjected to a sanitary inspection, the consul of the country of destination, or his delegate, shall always have the right, at the request of the captain, to assist at this inspection. If the vessel is not subjected to the obligation of furnishing itself with a bill of health delivered by the local authority, the consul from whom the captain shall ask such a bill of health, or his delegate, shall have the right to make the above-mentioned sanitary inspection according to such laws as shall be established by mutual agreement between the contracting powers, but in this case this inspection shall be made in conjunction with the consul of the country of the nationality of the vessel. Signed by the Delegates of BELGIUM, UNITED STATES, FRANCE, RUSSIA, TURKEY. Appendix III. The Delegate of Mexico to the International Sanitary Conference of Washington has pre- sented to the Conference the following memorandum read by him in the sitting of February 18th, and a proposition thereto attached signed by him and other Delegates: The necessary steps to obtain information of the state of the public health, as well as the sanitary inspections of the vessels, shall be made by the local sanitary authorities. Each Gov- ernment signing this treaty shall, however, have the right to take part through its own agents in all the operations of the above-mentioned authorities. (Signed) Dr. J. ALVARADO. J. L. CABELL. T. J. TURNER. Dr. F. J. VAN LEENT. STEPHEN PRESTON. JULIO CARRIU. J. J. DA SILVA AMADO. 17 In witness whereof, the undersigned Delegates to the International Sanitary Con- ference at Washington of the several Governments taking part therein have approved the foregoing final record of their proceedings, and have affixed thereto their signatures. Done at Washington this day of March, 1881. For Germany, HERMANN A. SCHUMACHER. The Argentine Republic, JULIO CARRIE. Austria-H ungary, Count EDMUND BETHLEN. Belgium, Baron ALBERT D'ANETHAN. EDOUARD SEVE. Bolivia, Brazil, Chili, F. S. ASTA-BURUAGA. China, CHEN LAN PIN. The United States of Colombia, PIO RENGIFO. Denmark, BILLE. Spain Dr. RAFAEL CERVERA. Dr. CARLOS FINLAY. The United States of America, JOHN HAY. J. L. CABELL. T. J. TURNER. J. HUBLEY ASHTON. JAMES LOWNDES. France, MAX OUTREY. Great Britain, The Hawaiian Islands, Hayti, STEPHEN PRESTON. Italy, CAMPOREALE. Japan YOSHIDA KIYONARI. Liberia, IVTexico Dr. IGNACIO ALVARADO. The Netherlands, R. de PESTEL. F. J. VAN LEENT. Peru, Portugal, Le Viscount de NOGUEIRAS. JOSE JOAQUIM DA SILVA AMADO. Russia, M. BARTHOLOMEI. 18 Sweden and Norway, C. LEWENHAUPT. Turkey, G. ARISTARCHI. Venezuela, SIMON CAMACHO. The President of the Conference, JOHN HAY. The Secretary of the Conference, THOMAS J. TURNER. The French Secretary, RUSTEM.