What a Vitamin C/ Cancer Study Prov: d To the Editor: | An article.ia your Sept. 30 Week in Review section, “Vitamin C Fails as a Caricer Cure” (with reference to mein the first sen nce), said that a con- trolled study of 150 Mayo, Clinic pa- tients with advanced cancer, pub-— lished in the New England Journal of Medicine, had shown no evidence that large doses of vitamin C help. OS ” This is indeed what was reported by. the Mayo Clinic investigators. They themselves and The Times: article do not point out, however, that the popu- in the Mayo Clinic was so different - from that investigated by my associ- ate Dr. Ewan,Cameron in Vale of lation of ag patients investigated — Leven. Hospital], Loch Lomondside, ~ Scotland, that the results observed.in the Mayo Clinid study cannot be con- | sidered to refute the results observed | in the study in Sdotland. oo The chief inv stigator in the Mayo Clinic study wrote to me fast year that he hoped to repeat Dr: Cameron’s work ,as closely as possible. I then — wrote to him, pointing out that cyto these protective mec ‘therapy ‘be used in |the _ chemotherapy. | chemotherapy. toxic 2m bddy’s protective mé¢chani an extent that subsequent t with vitamin C wou not to have much value beca C functions largely, by 1 recommended strongly t patients|who had no received chemio- ayo Clinic study. is recommendation, how- ever, was ignored. Nearly all the pa- tients injthe Mayo Chinic trial had re- ceived j|courses | of]. chemotherapy, . whereas|only 4 percent of hose stud- ied by, Dr:, Cameron ha received The Vale of Leven udy S owedthat large doses of vitamin C have ‘great _ value for cancer patients W o-have not ’ peceived! chernotherapy. - ‘ e -Mayo Clinic study answers. an important question |in-that it verifies that treat- ment, with vitamin Cris farjless effec- tive for patients whqse immune sys- tems have been damaged b | courses of ;_| LIN PAULING "Menlo Park, Calif., Qct. 24, 1979