A PEACTICAL SKETCH OP THE ASIATIC CHOLERA OF 1848, IN AN ENGLISH VILLAGE. [Price Two Shillings, ,] A PEACTICAL SKETCH OF THE ASIATIC CHOLERA OF 1848, ITS RATIONALE AND (PRESUMED) PATHOLOGY. SUPPLEMENTARY REMARKS TO PAMPHLET ON LOW INFLAMMATIONS. BY S. F. STATHAM, ASSISTANT-SURGEON, UNIVERSITY COLLEGE HOSPITA.L, LONIXqiJi LONDON: TAYLOE, WALTON, AND MABEKLY, 33ooftscllers & HJuMisfjcrs to QLolltQt, UPPER GOWER STREET, AND IVY LANE, PATERNOSTER-ROW. 1852. LONDON: BRADBURY AND EVANS, PRINTERS, WHITEFRIARS. * PREFACE. Inflammations form, perhaps, half the amount of all diseases. In a late pamphlet I called attention to that Low type of Inflammation which is possibly nearly as common as the simple form, and which by its severity is far more dangerous. Though exceedingly frequent of occurrence, yet from their not having been generally recognised as a distinct class, these affections have been too often overlooked, and that to such an extent that, though of not much experience in the science of medicine, nevertheless, I feel sure that by the due rank of Low Inflammations being acknowledged, a hew field will be opened in medicine, or, at the least, a fresh aspect, and that of a most practical nature both in the pathology and treatment of disease. I can no better express my estimate of the present want of appreciation of low inflammatory diseases as compared with those due to sthenic inflammation, than by likening our present neglect to that of sailors, who should take account only of those rocks appearing above the surface, unless when by low tide of the ocean (collapse of the vital powers) those dangers — far more to be dreaded on account of their want of prominence — become only too evident. Sailors, however, are wiser ; we too often know and name these diseases by the constitutional or local effects they induce. The poisons from the laboratory may act dynamically, or otherwise directly, on the system ; on the other hand, as a rule, 6 PREFACE. - it may be said, that poisons occurring free and active in nature, whether animal or vegetable, or from decomposition, act mediately ; in several instances this mediate action may be by a change induced in the blood ; in several instances this mediate action is by exciting a low inflammation ; now, as Low Inflammations have not been properly studied, may it not be fairly expected that their elucidation will tend to the comprehension of the action of many of those poisons on the system, which cause diseases acknowledged to be due to poisons taking their origin from natural causes, and which diseases present sufficient analogy to the low inflammations from similar causes met with in daily life ? I refer to Epidemic diseases, and hope that their special pathology may receive some light from this opposite and different-coloured side of the shield. The following remarks on Asiatic Cholera are of the composition of several years ago ; they are made public now in the hope that they will prove of use, although a well-known journalist having at the time declined them, it seems bold to expect that four years later a different opinion should be entertained ; now, however, claiming the rank of a Type or Class for Low Inflammations; these papers seem to me much more valuable. Should any one consider that from the above intimation of the opinion here entertained as plausible, of the nature of Cholera, it is useless to read further ; it might be fairly put to him whether he would deny the death of a patient having been caused by Erysipelas because after death no inflammatory nor other change of the integument were visible to his senses ; or, again, would he deny the death of a patient having been caused by Low Peritonitis when the only pathological change present is some amount of purulent or sero-purulent fluid in the cavity of the peritoneum ; or, again, would he in the last and similar cases suppose that there was no local affection, but that the local inflammatory product had been secreted from the general mass of the blood, yet only in this one spot ? PREFACE. 7 ". - That I could presume to give a different opinion from one whom I am now proud to consider myself a colleague of, — Dr. Parkes, is an evidence of the greatest temerity ; it may, however, be said, that he saw the disease in India under very different opportunities from those to be found in a solitary English village. Here nature had established quarantine, each individual was known to the medical man, and various excellent advantages were at hand for investigating the peculiarities of the disease. Having been otherwise occupied of late years, there cannot be here added any description of the Cholera fungoid-sporules, or investigation of some other points so intimately connected with the History of Asiatic Cholera. With hope, therefore, that Low Inflammations may explain other " Epidemic " maladies, possibly giving some light as regards the pathological cause of Plague, La Grippe, Trousse- Galante, or other pests, — I will only premise that the poison of these inflammations may be of a more intense form, allowing of its propagation by infection, or less intense and requiring contact, or even inoculation. In certain cases the poison of such a disease may occur in both forms, or in other diseases only in one, and that in either of them. That poisons from natural causes should not act at once dynamically on the system as the poisons of the laboratory may do, is one of those principles whose practical fulfilment is necessary for the continuance of life on the earth. That their influence on the system may be due to locally excited morbid action is evident ; that it is so in Asiatic Cholera seems to me the only probable view, and one based on sound pathology. On entering upon this subject in the autumn of 1848 having no opinion on Cholera, I pretend to say that the conclusions here arrived at are unprejudiced. 8 PEEFACB. » In investigating the pathology of Cholera, and some other diseases, it seems to me that writers, frightened at the materialism of Broussais, have fallen into the other extreme, and would yet consider themselves the truer philosophers. A very great error is certainly committed by not taking every circumstance into account in Post-Mortem Examinations, and in neglecting various niceties of proceeding, such as examination of the body as soon after death as possible, examination of the intestines before washing them, the doing everything ones-self, and for this no slight practice or opportunities are requisite ; that the comparison of cases may be made as strictly as possible, there is subjoined here those cases of intestinal disease previously examined by me under the supervision of the physicians ; for the description I am answerable. It were utterly unjust, if any merit is to be found in the following pages, but that a large share should be referred to the philosophical and practical mind of John B. Hodgson ; to whom I would specially refer as being a strong advocate of the " Propagation by Infection " of Cholera. It has been said to me by several friends that the former pamphlet on "Low Inflammation" did not contain much novelty ; I shall esteem it a great favour to be informed where those descriptions call anywhere be found in print ? That the diseases are unknown Ido not assert ; that they are appreciated is another question. Oct. 19, 1852. CEETAIN CASES OF ASIATIC CHOLERA AT CHESHAM, IN THE LAST QUARTER OE 1848, WITH SOME REMARKS ON THE NATURE OF THAT DISEASE. The data referred to in the following account are; the Parish Medical Book ; my own Notes of twenty Cholera cases, of which twelve of the fatal ones are given at length, where post-mortem examinations were allowed ; the local Registry of Deaths, &c. ; the Registry of the Weather of the Rev. Mr. King Latimer's Observatory, with the freest use of which he most handsomely furnished me ; and much information furnished by Messrs. Faithorn, Hodgson, & Kitelee, the medical men of the place, most especially by Mr. Hodgson, the parish officer, to whom I was assistant for two months and a half, during which cholera was prevalent. Chesham, Buckinghamshire, is a small town of 6000 inhabitants, situated at the head of a valley among the Chiltern range of (chalk) hills, to the north-west of, and 28 miles distant from, London. In the character of the town there are a few circumstances of much importance as bearing upon the causation of disease, which may here be noticed. Many small streams, coursing through the town, unite at its outskirts, and the resulting watercourse being dammed up to supply mills situated upon it, and beds for watercress, becomes broad, always full, but never motionless ; hence there are no intermittent diseases. A number of houses of the lower class are situated on its banks, frequently within a few feet of the water, sometimes below its level ; many of the better class are built over one of the streams. All the drains of the town open into this stream, at least where they have any 10 A PRACTICAL SKETCH OF ASIATIC CHOLERA. outlet, for in many instances cesspools are made use of and emptied at intervals. The houses are often badly situated and worse built, and here a great difference is observable. Out of a number for which, the same or nearly the same rent is paid, some are airy, dry and clean ; these are generally modern houses. Others are below the level of the water, half-buried, choked by the houses around ; nearly air-tight, so as to prevent all effluvia from escaping; the walls and floors permeable to, and stained by, the excrements from the neighbouring privies, or the rooms small, or filled with dusty furniture instead of fresh air ; the trades (shoe-making, turning, platting) carried on in the same room that they live in, or no trade at all followed, and the house a complete specimen of the results of idleness. Fifty houses in Chesham could at once be named, which on one or other account are not suitable to live in. Some years since the inhabitants were in a very prosperous condition. This has undergone much change ; railroads, by increasing the importance of neighbouring towns, are lessening the trade of this one ; the change of fashion and admission of Tuscany straw plat at a lower rate of duty has caused a lucrative employment to become a mere apology for starvation ; no provision was made for future adversity, and the consequent poorer nourishment and greater exposure to vicissitudes has had the usual effect in rendering them less able to withstand the attacks of disease. A moderate-sized silk-mill however has been built of late years. Chesham is generally considered a healthy town ; nevertheless its mortality is higher than that of the county, being 2*21 per cent., while that of Buckinghamshire is 2*13 (Mr. Grainger). Epidemic diseases are not severe ; small-pox occasionally, as this year, proves fatal, owing to the neglect of vaccination, and the mortality is certainly increased by scarlatina and measles. Three deaths are referred to typhus fever every year ; these were as high as 24 in the years 1844-5. Twenty-three deaths annually are accounted for by strumous diseases out of an average yearly mortality of 136, of which 50 are children dying in infancy. During the last quarter of 1848, 44 persons died of Asiatic cholera, and 2 more in the ensuing month of 1849. Fever, instead of 3, gave 7 deaths; low inflammations, as typhoid peritonitis, &c, 4, where usually 2, and in January 1849 alone, 6 ; (several of the last-named number being doubtless due to infection). Causes of death annually referred to old age, (fewer by many since the introduction of medical certificates,) to acute inflammations, chronic diseases, accidents and disordered bowels, are all insignificant or uninteresting. (See Appendix.) A PRACTICAL SKETCH OF ASIATIC CHOLERA. 11 «* *¦ It cannot be doubted that many of these deaths annually might be averted by proper precaution. Of seven individuals who had smallpox lately, four had been vaccinated and suffered it in a modified form ; of three others unvaccinated, who were all moving in a higher rank of life, the disorder was severe, and in one case fatal. Many of the deaths from fever, strumous diseases, and of infancy, are at once due to the absence of proper sanitary measures. To this is to be added cholera, which, in Chesham at least, has in all (?) instances pointed out those neighbourhoods or houses, those habits or individuals, which actively give rise or passively yield to diseases referable to the want of hygienic measures. These were entitled in the Parish Medical Book as epidemic cholera, 81 cases. Of these many appear, on after consideration, to have been of a mixed character, and by their recovering rapidly have shown that either the poison was too weak, or the subject too strong, or perhaps the remedies were very successful. On this plea I would only consider 56 of these cases as being sufficiently well marked to allow any medical man, who had seen Asiatic cholera before, to recognise the disease in each of them without reference to other cases. Of these cases, 35 or 62-| per cent, proved fatal ; [if I may compare the systemic affection in cholera to that in low inflammations, the proportion of deaths to the cases of " excitement " would be about 7 per cent., to that of " implication " about 44 per cent., to that of "invasion" 62 per cent. ; either one might be given to make out a wished for result. (See remarks at the end.) Compared with mortality elsewhere I expect about 50 per cent, is right.] These 56 cases alone will be referred to or quoted as cases of cholera, and, as might be expected, they include all the fatal cases. (See Appendix.) Of 56 cases, 26 occurred in the same house, where there had been a case previously ; 7 in persons, or in two of the cases in the sons of persons, who were at the time most zealous in their attendance upon cholera patients ; 4 cases among those living in the same bad neighbourhood as the cholera patients, and shortly after the occurrence of cholera in that spot. The above seems the simplest way of accounting for 37 out of 56 individuals being attacked; further on, almost all are shown to have had unhealthy habitations, and on looking over their names I find all the 37 are predisposed to disease, either by accident of position or by their own state of health, age, or habits. Thus of 56, 37 have sufficient predisposing causes, and to all appearance also, infection was the direct cause of their succumbing. Of the 19 primary cases, 7 were weakened by age ; one, the first case, aged sixty-three, will be referred to again. At this time doubtless A. PRACTICAL SKETCH OF ASIATIC CHOLERA. 12 the poison was most powerful ; three of seventy years or above, three of fifty-seven, of whom two were of dissolute habits, died. Of the 19 there remains 12 ; of these, 6 were weak through youth or infancy, and were either in a bad condition from want of necessaries, or had been subject to diarrhoea. Of the remaining 6, two were young girls eight years old, and had been delicately brought up. One, a young woman in poor circumstances, aged twenty-three, had been suckling seventeen months, and lived a few feet from the water, and from infected houses. The fourth, a lad eight years old, I did not see ; he was one of the first, and was at school where the mistress had lost two of her own children from cholera. The fifth, also an early case, lived below the level of the water, in a confined house, and was hawking, the day before he was taken ill, among the cholera houses. The sixth, the last of the parish cases, was a lad nine years old ; the day before falling ill, he had been on a long walk into the country : his was a well-marked case ; he recovered. ~No other fell ill in the house, and but one case occurred afterwards in the person of an aged and worn-out woman. From the above it would appear that almost all those who were attacked were, either on one account or another, predisposed to be so, and when these circumstances are specified, the case becomes very strong, that these circumstances alone have much to do with the predisposition to cholera. Probably infection was the exciting cause. Of the 56 patients, 47 were in unhealthy habitations, of which 26 were in foul situations, 11 confined or damp, 11 close to the water, varying from one to half-a-dozen feet ; of the remaining 9, one woman of seventy-three was worn out ; a boy of three years was close to a foul house, where the cholera then prevailed, and where typhoid fever and erysipelas had each in previous years carried off their victims ; two lads of thirteen and eight were weakly and subject to diarrhoea ; in the same houses as the last there had been a case of choleroid diarrhoea. Another, a man aged fifty- nine, had been a drunkard, and when taken with diarrhoea used for several successive nights to go to the privy, out of doors, in his night-shirt and slippers. Another, a child of eighteen months, was strumous throughout, as seen on p.m.e, especially in the mesenteric glands, and had ulcerated bowels. The eighth, his brother, aged four, fell ill a few days after; he also gives signs of struma ; he recovered. The ninth, aged nine, the last which occurred, was not inquired into. To the above statement it may be added that half of those attacked (indiscriminately old and young) were in want of the common necessaries of life, either through poverty or depravity. On viewing the subject with reference to the fatal cases occurring A PRACTICAL SKETCH OP ASIATIC CHOLERA, 13 in all Chesham, one only appeared an exception to the remark that cholera is confined to the lower ranks of life (when as now the poison is weak), and that exceptional case can be fully accounted for by other circumstances predisposing the individual — debility after childbirth, and habitation over water. With reference to the 56 parish cases, I conclude that in 55 of them a predisposition to disease was evident from known causes that depress the health. It is, however, an easy matter to denounce all the houses or neighbourhoods, where cholera prevailed, as foul, or the persons as unhealthy; but, if possible, a statement should be given of how many of such houses or persons escaped. This cannot be done thoroughly ; the following is an attempt, and is only an approximation, for much must depend upon the sick houses being more open to observation and more observed. I arranged the 56 cholera cases in a table, marking those whom I consider to have been more likely to succumb to disease than their neighbours, with reference to age, habits (including wearisome nursing), habitation, nearness to water, poverty and previous health. (Neighbours here signifies either the family, or neighbours of the patient, or the inhabitants of the town, according as the cholera occurred in an individual, a household, or a cluster of houses.) Of the 56 cases, I consider 42 to have been, without doubt, more prone to disease than their neighbours under two or more of the heads mentioned above, 12 under one of the heads, and 2 not more prone. Of these one was a woman aged fifty-six, the other the boy aged nine mentioned before, both occurring near the end of the invasion. It may be noticed the great bulk of these numbers are furnished under the heads of unhealthy habitations and habits. From the above summaries I think I may conclude that at Chesham the occurrence of the cholera in individuals was explicable by ordinary morbific causes affecting their health ; so that in these cases there is no necessity for supposing a peculiar liability to the attack of cholera. It thus appears that certain known causes will in the present instance account for certain individuals being attacked; then the question arises, why were any attacked ? The presence of a peculiar poison will be* at once acknowledged, and that this was not endemic. As regards its being epidemic ; in 1832, there were no cases of cholera at Chesham ; no record was kept, but the fact is acknowledged. At this period it was severe at Aylesbury, thirteen miles distant ; in 1848 the disease was severe at Chesham, and at no other place near until full time had elapsed for propagation by infection. The nearest towns are Berkhampstead, Missenden, and Amersham, each about 14 A PRACTICAL SKETCH OF ASIATIC CHOLERA. four miles from Chesham, and equally distant from one another. Mr. Leat, a practitioner at Berkhampstead, was frequently at Chesham during the cholera, and stated each time that Berkhampstead was free from attack. Mr. Smeathman, of Missenden, informs me that, in the last quarter of 1847, 5 cases of looseness of the bowels came under his notice; in 1848, at the same time, 14; Mr. Talent, of Amersham, by his assistant Mr. Jenkins, that in 1846, 13 ; in 1847, 11 ; in 1848, 30 cases of looseness of the bowels occurred in the last quarters of each year. Since each of these gentlemen has the care of a parish practice, their returns will bear comparison with that from Chesham, always remembering that the last-named parish is a much larger one. Consequently in 1847, Oct., Nov., and Dec, we find 19 cases ; in the corresponding period of 1848, 366 ; the book being mislaid, I am unable to give the number of cases for 1846, but that that for 1848 is really excessive, is evident by comparing the preceding quarters of the year with the last one; for these the numbers are respectively 16, 29, 49, and 366. No case of cholera occurred in the hamlets (about a dozen in number) around Chesham, and to the best of my recollection, no extraordinary number of cases of diarrhoea, until weeks after the prevalence of these disorders in Chesham. There was no cholera at "Wendover, or Aylesbury at the same period. Mr. Jenkins remarks of the cases at Amersham, that many doubtless were trivial, and noticed from fear. Numbers were of a similar character at Chesham, but many such were classed under the head of colic, &c, of which I have not taken account here, and which amounted, in the last quarter of 1848, to 62 ; in that of 1847, to 5. Eeal cholera cases occurred later (by about six weeks) in at least four of the surrounding hamlets, and had not occurred earlier. Hence we conclude, that at the time cholera and diarrhoea were prevalent in Chesham, the surrounding places in every direction were little, if at all, affected ; and that therefore the evidence in this instance is against its purely epidemic character, in fact that this was of trivial importance in the propagation of the disease to Chesham. This will apply, of course, to the weather also, which, although of little consequence in introducing the disorders in question, doubtless encouraged occasional exacerbations or the reverse, and this we should expect to see in the present instance ; the less severity of the disease allowing us to estimate the importance of secondary agents. Comparing October (see tables in Appendix) and November, 1848, with the corresponding months of 1847, we find that, in 1848, there was more moisture in the air, a lower thermometer and barometer ; in October a warmer, in November a colder wind, and in November more sudden changes of temperature. This fairly accounts for an A PRACTICAL SKETCH OP ASIATIC CHOLERA 15 increased number of internal diseases in November ; and from the presence of the cholera poison, these were determined to the intestinal canal as diarrhoea : correspondingly, cases called "fever" in dispensarypractice (being generally a chill or reaction from it) are much increased in November, and both but slightly so in October ; there were, however, many cases of diarrhoea in October, 1848, probably partly accounted for by the air being often fully saturated with moisture, more than in 1847, much more than in September, 1848. In December, there was rather more moisture in the air, the barometer and thermometer rather higher and a southerly wind, the sudden changes rather more often than the year before, so that hardly any excess of diarrhoea, pulmonary complaints, or of "fever," over the former year could be expected ; but from the much greater saturation of the air with moisture, and the numerous sudden changes of temperature, in spite of a southerly wind in both years, numerous cases were to be expected in loth. Thus in December, 1847, many cases of pulmonary complaint and of "fever" occurred. In December, 1848, however, a new agent was present, and this determined the action of the weather to the intestinal canal ; hence pulmonary complaints and "fever" were not half the amount of the former year. In January, 1849, there was about the same large amount of moisture in the air, the barometer rather lower, the thermometer higher ; in both years cold winds, especially in 1848 ; many sudden changes of temperature in 1849. We should expect, therefore, numerous diseases both years, which, in 1848, occurred, as usual, as pulmonary complaints, while in 1849, the cholera was not forgotten ; and though numerous pulmonary complaints regained their preeminence, with many of "fever," still a large number (but much less than in the two previous months) of cases of diarrhoea applied for relief. It may fairly be concluded from this, that the weather alone is answerable for a larger number of cases of internal affections in the last quarter of 1848, as compared with 1847, thereby accounting for the somewhat increased number of cases of diarrhoea in the adjoining parishes, Amersham and Missenden, and doing away with all necessity of supposing any choleraic poison to have existed in the atmosphere at that time; indeed, as the "onus probandi" rests with those many and talented writers who assert the poison to be propagated through the atmosphere essentially, as long as we can account in another way for the facts seeming to support the opinion, that assertion must yet remain a mere opinion, at least as regards the propagation of Asiatic cholera in England. During the prevalence of the- cholera, 16 A PEACTICAL SKETCH OP ASIATIC CHOLERA. diseases of a low inflammatory type were very prevalent : this will be referred to again. It now remains to be shown how it was that the cholera spread. I am not able to prove its propagation by infection, but yet, having given negative proofs, hope to make out a strong case on the positive side of the question. I was not at Chesham at the first invasion of cholera, and no notes were then taken of the cases ; the first two or three cases which occurred were not, as I hear (from the patient or the medical attendant) of that marked character to enable any medical man to recognise the disease in them ; these are not, therefore, included in the list ; one of them was, nevertheless, yeasty diarrhoea, severe colic and cramp, prostration, but no sickness ; the other showed the severe symptoms for too short a time ; the one had not left his house, was very subject to constipation, had had "hepatitis" in summer, and lived in a close, choked, and dirty house, and the other had been travelling through a place where cholera prevailed. The next (first ?) case occurred in a filthy spot, and a crowded dissolute household, in an old woman of sixty-three, a widow, who used to travel (hawking) on foot with her married sister, and had been out much both on Tuesday. and "Wednesday, Thursday evening was taken ill, and died Saturday morning. Her' sister was taken ill on the Sunday. The widow used not to go into houses when out hawking ; this was done by her sister. They did not, to their knowledge, meet with any infected person or place. After this case, other members of the household rapidly sickened, and then the nurses and neighbours, until, in the course of eight days, five of the more predisposed houses were affected ; at the same time, detached cases, apparently by infection, occurred and proved fresh centres in similar unhealthy spots ; then a lull occurred, and except numerous cases of diarrhoea, the poison appeared ineffectual ; suddenly, however, it broke forth in a fresh dirty cluster of houses, or, should the house have been alone in its insalubrity, it was in several instances confined to this one. The first person attacked was very generally a young or delicate child (the two girls attacked were the most delicate members of the family), and after these the unsound or aged inmates were taken ill. There are great difficulties in the investigation of this subject : if, as in 1832, the cholera poison is powerful, its action is so rapid as to give no opportunity for observing its propagation; an individual might then infect numbers and be scathless himself ; then the poison might be called epidemic. On the other hand, supposing the poison to be weak, as this year, its action is confined to those already A PRACTICAL SKETCH OF ASIATIC CHOLERA. 17 enfeebled, or diseased, or naturally feeble, and numbers escape who, with a sound constitution, may have been much more exposed to it. Of two nurses whom I attended, who died of cholera, one was an old man of probably seventy, he said sixty ; the other, a woman who had but one ordinary-sized effectual kidney, the other was of little use from former (nephritis?). Several other nurses had temporary ailments, but recovered rapidly. One other case is worth particularising ; it was 'the third, a half-starved woman of forty-nine, living in a very confined house, and very poor. She was sent for on Saturday to lay out the first woman who died ; she had not been to that part of the town before, but had had diarrhoea for a day or two ; on Sunday she stayed in and had medicine for her diarrhoea ; was better on Monday and went out in a cold wind, but not near the part affected ; Tuesday, was taken with severe algide cholera, and died in twenty-four hours. Including this one, twelve out of the fifteen first cases were relations or nurses of those first attacked ; another, the boy at school near, where the mistress had lost two of her own children ; another, the hawker among the infected houses ; the last, a boy living a very few doors distant. After this more scattered cases occurred, either in nurses as secondary cases, or in those more predisposed than their neighbours. Here I may mention, that the bodies were buried the same day, and generally ventilation, &c, was employed. As regarding incubation of the poison, four of the secondary cases occurred in the same houses, after the death of the primary cases ; the intervals between the death of the first and sickening of the second were respectively five, one, five and four days, giving presumptive evidence that the period of incubation may be as long as this. The other inhabitants of Chesham avoided the water-side, the part attacked ; but the people living there did not avoid mixing, and suffered accordingly. I have attempted to consider another point, doubtless of much interest, as showing how far the propagation of the disease is favoured by the state of the weather ; and have attempted to show this in the Appendix : the saturation of the air with moisture, and great changes of temperature, seem to have the most effect ; the proof of its negative influence, by means of the fact that a frost frequently checks the cholera, as on December 20th, was also exemplified ; hence we may conclude, that of two parties equally exposed to the disease and equally prone to take it, the opposite states of weather for the time being might render the one obnoxious to attack, and equally protect the other from succumbing. o 18 A PRACTICAL SKETCH OF ASIATIC CHOLERA. Supposing the cholera is infectious, whether the dead body can propagate the disease is still sub judice ; in opening thirteen bodies, and spending two to three hours on each, no ill effects were experienced, nor in any other way ; but here there was no predisposition. As regards the number of post-mortem examinations followed by fresh cases, few examples can be quoted ; but the proportion was not more than in cases where no examination was made. Nevertheless, if believing cholera to be infectious, we must consider it may be propagated by the dead body, as by any other physical substance, which propagation may or may not be affected by the body being opened. Many objections to the doctrine of infection may thus be answered and inconsistencies explained, while its sudden cessation, likewise urged against its being infectious, is exactly similar to that observed occasionally in small pox and some other acknowledged infectious diseases. [As regards the propagation of low inflammatory diseases, it may be said, infection does not readily occur from a given case after death, though readily during life. Propagation by inoculation readily occurs after death in cases of low inflammation, but not in cases of erysipelatous inflammations, and equally so in life, for it appears to be dependent on the existence or not of low purulent fluid. According to this we should expect Asiatic cholera to be infectious during life, and after death the body to be non-infectious, unless in proportion to its capacity for retaining infection as any other physical substance, in which it would be far excelled by clothes, &c. ; — tKis we also find agrees with experience.] Gases of Cholera, of which Notes were taken at the time (abridged) . I. — A. E., set. 23, labourer's wife. Often subject to privation. House damp and bleak. Is good-looking and plump in health ; of ordinary figure. Has been suckling a child for seventeen months, it is her own ; she has been married seven weeks. Nov. 25th, 4i a.m. — Watery purging. ; 10 a.m., has had five motions ; very sick, cramps in the legs, no pains in the belly since being relaxed. Now has constant watery dejection; the motions are water with brownish flakes. No urine since 5 a.m. Countenance is sunk, pale, somewhat livid; the hands pale, shrunk. Pulse scarcely felt. Eespirations about 18. Heart sounds quick, soft, natural. The toes are at times black and contracted, but she is feeling better. — Has been taking Mist. Stimulans, and Pil. Cayenne et Hydrarg. Chlorid. every quarter hour between one another. Turpentine epithem and mustard poultices to the abdomen and feet. Was better the same evening. 19 A PRACTICAL SKETCH OP ASIATIC CHOLERA. Nov. 26th, 5 a.m. — Has not slept ; dozing. At times slight cramp occurred in the abdomen ; she then felt cold and looked pale ; this was followed by heat and sweating. Surface is warm, she perspires much, face flushed, talks much better. Pulse intermittent, soft. Breath warm. Eetches ; once sick in the night. Slight cramps in the legs during the night. Bowels constantly, but less open; dejections white, watery. Has made a spoonful of urine. 3 p.m. — Grums sore. Pulse 120, regular, soft. Abdomen tender. Otherwise the same, but the symptoms less pronounced. — Has had a quarter of a pint of brandy ; beef-tea and gruel ; three pills and the draught every half hour. 27th. — Perspires. Pasty fur on the tongue. Is sick, and this was bitter last night. Pains in the bowels at times, relieved by warm tile ; motions brown, watery, (bloody P). No urine. — Continue medicine, but less often. 28th. — On being moved, fainted. Is warm and perspiring. Face looks better, very pale ; eyes not so sunk. Gums continue sore. Is as thirsty, somewhat hungry. Passes urine copiously. To-day only two liquid, brown, uniform motions. No cramps, nor pain in head or belly. Pulse soft, full 117. Respiration free. Left breast swollen and hard. 30th. — Had yesterday Dec. Cinchon. and Sodae Carb. Tongue thick, white fur. Is very thirsty. Bowels open four times with pain. Pulse regular, full 108. Sleeps well. Urine copious, high-coloured. Takes arrow-root and brandy. From this time she progressed favourably ; occasional diarrhoea, and much weakness and craving for food remaining for some weeks. Dec. 7th. — Began to get up. This, a decided and threatening case, recovered with very slight consecutive fever. II. — J. T., 69, a labourer. Robust-looking, hale old man ; greyheaded. Health generally good. Poor. Cottage confined and damp. Is the second attack, the first was last Monday, 9 a.m. ; the purging said to have been bilious, except on Wednesday. Nov. 26th, Sunday. — Yesterday, for first day, went out to privy in the garden (weather was wet and cold), had frequent watery purging ; to bed at 6i p.m. ; sick at Bi, and continued retching and purging all night ; cramps began this morning ; the vomiting is yellowish, the stools white, watery. 9| a.m. — Is warmer and skin moist after brandy. Voice weak, stifled ; breath warmish ; lips rather dark and cold ; face shrunk ; eyes sunk, and have a dark rim ; fingers contracted, tongue pale. Pulse c 2 20 A PRACTICAL SKETCH OF ASIATIC CHOLERA. pretty good. Great tenderness of the epigastrium, especially to the left. — Pil. Hydrarg. Chlorid. et Cayenne, et Haust. £ part. horsß, &c. 3 p.m. — Voice slightly improved. Faeces run constantly on retching. Is thirsty and hungry. Breathes as a person in sleep ; is sleepy ; could not sleep last night. Eyes ghastly, not so dark. Pulse about 60, small. Gums sore. — One pill and three draughts in an hour. 28th. — Much better. Face fuller and flushed. Tongue clean. Had dark motions for first time to-day. Copious urine since 2 a.m. Much pain about descending colon. 29th. — Grot up against injunction, was fatigued, purged, and then relapsed. 30th. — Countenance not much altered. No urine, constant watery purging. Retches. No cramps nor cold. Is thirsty. Voice hoarse, husky. No sleep. Pulse jerking, regular. — Acetate of Lead and Opium. Stimulant Mixture. Brandy and sago. Dec. Ist. — Gradually failing, dark purging. 2nd. — Pallid, cold, drowsy, but can be roused. Eyes sunk ; gasping ; empty pulse. Dark purging, not sick. Passes some urine. Died 4 p.m. 3rd. — P.M.E., twenty hours after death : — Body wasted, great rigidity. Peritoneum healthy ; omentum, veins injected ; mesenteric glands enlarged and white. Small intestines, outer surface congested at free border. Mesenteric veins full. Stomach, contents green, viscous ; some punctiform and stellate injection. Duodenum generally brown. Jejunum pale with yellowish mucus. Ilium, brown faecal matter, lower portion congested, no glands visible. Colon, spots of redness surrounding some glands ; faeces thin, brown. Liver partly adherent to diaphragm ; large vessels full of blood. Gall-bladder extends an inch below the liver, and contains dark green bile. Eight kidney contains two large cysts, nothing remarkable. Spleen small, flabby, not softened. Pancreas natural. Bladder contracted, inner surface pale. Pleurae healthy. Lungs slightly emphysematous, not collapsed, are congested posteriorly ; contain frothy serum. Pericardium healthy. Heart, right side natural, much dark blood and some soft pale clots ; left side firmly contracted, some black blood. This case relapsed twice, and died at last of consequent exhaustion ; the symptoms of cholera were disappearing fast, and we should expect the morbid anatomy to be similarly imperfect. It was the first P.M.E., and a hurried one, although much aided by Dr. Marshall. 111. — J. D. ; 19, labourer. Stout, hearty, healthy-looking ; not very strong. A PRACTICAL SKETCH OF ASIATIC CHOLERA. 21 Nov. 27th. — Bowels open in the morning, relaxed and copious ; desire to defsecate, without doing it all day long. Poorly in the evening. Had tea and toast and brandy for supper. Slept well from eight to one. Had slept well night previously. 28th, 1 a.m. — Taken ill, broke wind frequently upwards. Purging. Gaped and felt sick ; on irritating his fauces he began, and then continued vomiting ; the first was bitter. Cramps in hands and legs, no numbness nor cold. — Mist. Stimul. Hydrarg. Chlorid. et Cayenne. Mustard poultices and warmth. 2. p.m. — Has continued ill. Face sunk and livid, flushes at times ; very hollow and dark round the eyes, pupils dilated. Hands shrunk and someAvhat cold. Cramps occasionally in the legs ; they were dark, but are now better. Has just vomited a half-pint of water; is very thirsty. No appetite. Tongue clean. Faeces frequently pass ; defsecation is felt, but there is no power to hinder it ; is like rice-water. No urine. Breath warmish, no tightness at the chest ; he noticed this last night. Has no pain except under the left ribs ; since the vomiting, none under the right. The liver does not extend . below the ribs. Heart about 100 ; none, or but slight radial pulse. No pain in the head, is heavy, and he feels sleepy. Talks pretty well, but thick and somewhat wandering. 29th. — Sleepy all day, pallid, bowels open once or twice, dark. No cramps. No urine. 30th. — Body warm ; no cramps ; hands less shrunk. Face not dark, is flushed; eyes less sunk, are dim, conjunctiva) injected, radiating and slight purulent discharge. Pulse 102, soft. Breath warm; slight cough. Gums turgid, sore. Tongue foul, whitish. Little appetite. Not thirsty. Is sick at times ; much eructation. Bowels open twice, brown, turbid. No urine. Belly sore on taking food. — Haust. Stimulans omni hora. Food. Dec. Ist. — Head heavy, very drowsy. No purging, sickness, or vomiting. — Mist. Salinae. 2nd, 9 a.m. — Very sleepy, head hot, eyes injected. No motion, but has made water to a pint. Pulse weak, but regular. Tongue dry and red. — Cold to head. Mustard poultice to the feet. (Ought now to have been bled.) 3rd. — Appeared better yesterday evening. Is now stupid. Face flushed, swollen. Pulse quick, jerking. Gams sore. Tongue white, clean. Perspires, no cramps, &c. 4