SECOND EDITION. A SHORT HISTORY OF THE CHOLERA; WITH A FEW HINTS AS TO ITS PREVENTION BY HOMEOPATHIC TREATMENT. BY EDWARD HAMILTON, M.D., F.L.S., Member of the British Homoeopathic Society, fyc. " The growing pest, whose infancy was weak And easy vanquished, with triumphant sway O'erpowers your life. For want of timely care, Millions have died of medicable wounds. Where find relief ? The salutary art Was mute , and, startled at the new disease, In fearful whispers, hopeless omens gave." Armstrong's Art of Preserving Health. iLmrtfon : PUBLISHED BY Wm. HEADLAND, 15, PRINCES STREET, HANOVER SQUARE, 1848. Price Si&pence. A SHORT HISTORY OF THE CHOLERA. The Cholera, that justly dreaded disease, so extended in its course, so fatal in its visitation, has again made its appearance in Europe : it is advancing westward from Moscow towards the shores of the Baltic ; it is reported to have reached Duneberg, on the river Dwina, not far from Riga. It has appeared at St. Petersburg and Cronstadt, has extended to Gallicia and Moldavia, and broken out with severity at Tarnopol in the former province. It is following the same course, attacking the same places, and appearing with the same symptoms as in 1830-31. The great improvements in drainage, and other sanitary regulations in our populous cities since its last visitation, will doubtless diminish the severity of the disease, (should it make its appearance in this country,) and give us hope they may escape the great mortality which prevailed in so many districts at that time. It is confidently asserted that the present invasion is of a mild character, and yet the proportion of deaths to those affected, ranges from 35 to 65 per cent, quite as high as in 1 83 1 , and although fewer persons have been attacked, must we not infer from this high rate of mortality, that the physicians in Russia have not gained much by experience ; and is there not every reason to suppose that the same uncertainty with regard to treatment, will be found to exist here, should we be visited by the scourge ?* As the disease is appearing with the same symptoms which accompanied it in 1831, it may naturally be concluded, that whatever treatment was successful then, will be so now ; and, in reviewing the various methods, I think it will not be denied that the one put forth by Hahneman and other homceopathists % was by far the most effective in its results. To prove this assertion I shall place before the reader * Since the first edition of this pamphlet, the Cholera in many places on the Continent has assumed a most virulent form. A 2 2 the different statistics of both treatments; Allopathic and Homoeopathic. Previous to so doing, however, as much has been written on the subject of Cholera, and on the question, whether it is contagious or epidemic, and as many erroneous impressions exist regarding the true nature of this fearful malady, I think the following history, abridged from Dr. Copland's Dictionary of Practical Medicine, may not be uninteresting. " The term Cholera, has been in use since the time of Hippocrates, who admitted two species of the disease, — one humid, the other dry* According to Celsus, it is derived from Xokrj and Pe ber ; on the sth there were 94 patients, of whom 49 died and 39 recovered, rest left on treatment ; on the 9th, 7 1 cases : 22 had died, 32 recovered." Since the 30th of September, the day on which the disease manifested itself, there had been 2,0U patients ; 930 had died, 422 recovered, 639 left under treatment. The distemper manifested itself in those places it attacked immediately after the arrival of persons from infected districts, and who were themselves affected. It spared the colony of Sarepta, owing, as was supposed, to there being no indigent inhabitants, Extract from the " Riga Gazette." — " Saratoff has been greatly illtreated by the Cholera: up to 23rd of October, 18,594 cases had occured — 9,194 had terminated fatally. In Pensa and Woronesch it was comparatively mild, 3,329 had died, out of 8,398 cases. In Orel, 1,715 cases, 830 had died. In the neighbouring districts there were 1,518 deaths out of 3,772 cases. In Kouisk, 1,087 deaths out of 1,673 cases. In Kazan, 665 deaths out 1,224 cases. In Kiev, 113 deaths out of 278 cases. From the " Military Medical Gazette" of St. Petersburgh, 1848, it appears that from the 30th of June to the 21st of July, 19,772 persons had been seized with Cholera, of whom 4,834 had recovered, and 11,068 had died ; between 50 and 60 per cent. In the whole of Russia since the first appearance of Cholera on 25th of October, 1846, to 21st of July, 1848,-290,318 cases of Cholera had occurred, of which 116,658 had died* It is an interesting fact, that, on the last invasion of Cholera the rate of mortality was only increased about 1 1 per cent in London, whereas in Paris the increase was between 50 and 60 per cent over the average, and in other populated cities as high as 70. How far the disease is under the control of the medical men 12 the following table, taken from the "Medical Gazette," will give some idea :—: — In Kouisk, the deaths were 65 per cent, Kazan 54.5 Kiev 40.3 Kharkov 29.5 Moscow — last week in October 35.5 in month of October . . 33.5 Let us compare these results of Allopathic practice with those of Homoeopathic, as shown in the treatment of Cholera on the Continent in 1830. These tables are taken from Dr. Quin's excellent Pamphlet, " Traitement Homceopathique dv Cholera." At Tischnowitz, in Moravia — Number of Inhabitants .. .. 6,671 Number of persons attacked . . 680 Of these there were — Treated Allopathically .. .. 331 Cured .. .. 229 Died 102 331 Treated Homceopathically . . 273 Cured .. 251 Died 27 07^ Treated with Camphor only, without a Physician . . . . 71 Cured 60 Died 11 71 680 13 This table was drawn up by order of the Authorities, who sent it to Dr. Quin. Again, at Wishney Wolotscok, in Russia, Doctor Seider treated 202 patients attacked with Cholera. The following are the results ; Treated Allopathically . . . . . . 93 Cured 24 Died 69 Treated Homceopathically . . . . 109 Cured .. 86 Died . . 23 The results of the treatment of the Cholera patients in Vienna, are as follows :—: — Treated Allopathically . . . . 4,500 Cured 3,140 Died . . . . 1,360 Treated Homceopathically . . 581 Cured 532 Died.. .... .... .. 49 Giving as a per centage of Deaths under Allopathic treatment, 31. Under Homoeopathic, 8. Results of treatment of Cholera patients in the Hospital at Bordeaux ; Treated Allopathically 104 Cured 32 Died 72 Treated Homceopathically . . . . 31 Cured 25 Died 6 Allopathic per centage of deaths ... . . 69 Homoeopathic ditto 19 * From Dr Black's Paper in British Journal of Homoeopathy, 1845. 14 In Dr. Quin's Pamphlet, the following table gives the results of the Homoeopathic treatment of Cholera. No. of Patients. Cured. Died. Dr. Schrcetbr . . 27 — 26 — 1 Dr. Lichtenpels . . 40 — 37 — 3 Dr. Vrecka .. 144 — 132 — 12 Dr. Shtxller .. 31 — 25 — 6 Dr. Seider.. . 109 — 86 — 23 Dr. Bakod? . . 154 — - 143 — 6 Dr. Gkrstel .. 330 — 298 — 32 Dr. Hantjsh . . 84 — 78 — 6 Lb perb Werth, M.D. 125 — 122 — 3 1073 998 95 Giving as the average deaths about 9 per cent. In comparing these results with the Allopathic, it cannot be denied that the Homceopathist has the advantage. In accordance with the law, similia similibus curantur, he prescribes a remedy which he knows has the power of producing symptoms analogous to those of the disease in question, symptoms with which he is perfectly conversant. To illustrate this law, we will take three of the Homoeopathic remedies for Cholera, and compare the symptoms produced by them with those of the disease, as Camphor, Veratrum and Cuprum. The chief symptoms of Cholera. Ist stage. Diarrhoea. Oppression at chest, anxiety at the prsecordia, collapse of countenance and surface of body, sudden loss of pulse, oppressed respiration, muscular spasms and tremors. Symptoms produced by Camphor. Cold over the whole body, sinking of all strength, skin bluish and cold, suffocating oppression of the chest, constriction of the larynx, sensation of burning heat at the epigastrium pulse remarkably slow, respiration deep and slow, cramps in 15 2nd stage. Giddiness, noise in the ears, remarkable oppression at the chest, weight at epigastrium, great depression of the pulse and all the vital powers, followed by spasms, commencing at the furthest part of the extremities, accompanied with watery purging and vomiting of a fluid resembling whey ; hands, face and extremities bluish, skin cold, damp and raw to touch, burning heat and inexpressible anxiety at the epigastrium, feeling of intolerable anxiety and weight about the heart, struggles for breath, voice nearly gone, the respiration is quick, irregular, most laborious and imperfect; patient calls frequently for cold water, speaks in a whisper and utters only a word at a time ; tongue white, flabby, cold and always moist. Spasms are generally of a passive kind, but sometimes, particularly in the loins and legs, are tetanic ; secretion of urine is totally suspended, as well as the biliary, salivary, and lachrymal fluids ; peculiar earthy odour from the body; singular foetor of the perspiration and evacuations. Sudden and immediate prostration of vital ppwers, inordithe calves of legs, convulsive movement of the arms. Vomiting, cold sweat on the face after the vomiting, cramps in the abdomen. Symptoms produced by Veratrum. Skin flabby, general coldness over the whole body, and cold clammy perspiration ; pulse slow, almost extinct, or small, quick and intermittent ; excessive anguish and inquietude ; confusion in the head ; dulness of all the senses ; face pale, cold ; hypocratic, cold perspiration in the face ; mouth dry and clammy ; tongue dry, blackish, cracked ; insatiable thirst, with desire for cold drinks; violent vomiting, with continued nausea ; great exhaustion; vomiting of black bile and blood ; continued vomiting, with diarrhoea and pressure in the scrobiculus ; excessive sensibility in the region of the stomach or scrobiculus ; excessive anguish at the pit of the stomach ; burning sensation at the pit of the stomach; cramps in the abdomen, with colic ; burning sensation through the whole extent of the abdomen ; violent diarrhoea, preceded and followed by gripings ; loose black, green, brownish evacuations : unnoticed evacuation of liquid fseces ; JS 16 nate discharge of serous fluid from stomach and bowels ; cramps and spasms of voluntary muscles ; no pulse, laborious perspiration, collapsed blue, wet and cold condition of the body, terrified countenance. obstructed respiration ; chest much oppressed ; cramp in chest, with painful constriction ; severe attacks of anxiety in the region of the heart ; violent cramps in the calves of the legs and feet. Symptoms produced by Cuprum Metallicum. Hiccough; nausea, with d&-sire to vomit ; violent periodical vomitings ; vomiting of bile ; violent vomitings, with pressure in the stomach : cramps in the abdomen; diarrhoea and convulsions ; excessively troublesome pressure on the stomach and on the epigastrium, aggravated by the touch and by the movement ; anxiety in the epigastrium ; spasmodic colic, with convulsions ; violent diarrhoea > difficult respiration ; suffocating fits ; painful contraction at the chest ; cramps at the chest, which interrupt the respiration and the voice ; great lassitude and sinking of the whole frame. A glance at these two columns will at once explain the reason why, according to the Homoeopathic law these medicines are giving for the cure of Cholera, with what result I need only refer the reader back to the statistics of the two treatments. Cautions necessary on the Invasion op Cholera In giving directions as to the necessary precautions to be taker in case of the invasion of Cholera, the nature of the disease 17 must be borne in mind, viz. : — that it has many of the properties of an infectious disease, but that an actual existence of a predisposing cause is necessary for its development ; it therefore behoves every one to keep themselves as much as possible free from any of these. The house should be well aired ; all noxious effluvia arising from decaying animal or vegetable substances got rid of. Cesspools and dust holes cleaned out. Sleeping apartments well ventilated, kept clean and dry. All exposure to cold and wet avoided ; on no account to sit in damp clothes, particularly damp shoes or stockings. Care should be taken to avoid chills, or to check the perspiration. The clothing must be sufficient to preserve the body at any equable temperature. Regular exercise in the open air. All anxiety of mind and other predisposing causes enumerated at page 8, to be avoided as much as possible. The diet should be wholesome and regular, and every one should be more than ordinarily careful not to eat those articles of food which experience may have taught them produce derangement of the digestive functions, such as veal, pork, &c. No raw vegetables should be taken, or cold fruit, such as celery, salads, cucumbers, pickles, melons, oranges, apples, &c. ; the more wholesome varieties of fruits and cooked vegetables should be used in moderation, non-acid wines and beer may also be taken in moderation by those accustomed to them. Dr. Antonio Blasi of Palermo, who had great experience in the treatment of Cholera, recommends as preservative means, " that the linen be frequently changed, that the hands and face be washed with water, in which are a few drops of vinegar. That the chamber utensils be always well cleaned, and the urine not allowed to remain, and that a little pure water be always in them. Not to walk about barefooted on arising from bed. Not to respire the morning air fasting. Avoid crowded rooms. Purify the chambers, but do not use the vapour of Chlorine or Bismuth, as they are highly injurious to other organs of the body, particularly the lungs, and does not guarantee in the slightest degree 18 from the Cholera. The fumes of vinegar, obtained by putting some on a hot plate of metal, is more preferable. Prophylactic (Preventative) Treatment. As regards the prophylactic (preventative) treatment. That this was of some avail in the last invasion of Cholera, may be adduced by the following facts. Dr. Marenzeller gave prophylactic medicines to 150,000 persons in Vienna, and none of them fell victims to the Cholera. The same results were gained among 80,000 people in Hungary and Poland. It is the general opinion of Homceopathists, that among those who took these medicines, and were attacked by Cholera, the disease showed itself in its mildest form ; whereas, at the same time, it attacked with great virulence those who had not undergone this prophylactic treatment.* The medicines given as prophylactics were, Cuprum and Veratrum, six globules to be taken, of the third dilution of one of these medicines every third morning, dissolved in a teaspoonful of water. The medicines to be alternated, f Dr. Blasi also considers camphor as a powerful preservative medicine, and was always in the habit of carrying about with him a bottle of camphor, and on approaching the bedside of a Cholera patient, either smelt or dipped his finger into the bottle and sucked it ; by these means, he is of opinion that he and many others were preserved from the infection. A small piece of copper worn next the skin, as also been declared useful as a preservative. Premonitory Symptoms Should the first symptoms actually appear, and it must be borne in mind that the premonitory symptoms should on no account be neglected, viz. : — feeling of general uneasiness, headache, giddiness, pain in the abdomen, oppression at the chest, diarrhoea, whitish evacuations, borborygmi ; any of these occurring when the Cholera is prevailing, should be at once attended to. * Black, on Asiatic Cholera. — Britisb Journal of Homoeopathy. •f No coffee, acids, spices, or aromatics of any kind should be taken whilst under the action of these remedies. 19 Two drops of spirits of camphor, prepared according to the pro* portions recommended by Dr. Quin, i. c. one drachm of camphor, dissolved in six drachms of spirits of wine (this may be procured at the Homoeopathic Chemists,) should be given every five or ten minutes, in a little iced or cold water, or on a little bit of sugar, this is preferable to water, and no time lost in obtaining medical aid. The patient should also be kept warm in bed. By at once attending to these instructions, the disease may often be arrested in its first stage. Dr. Blasi also recommends the external use of camphor, but, he says it is necessary to employ it with great care, owing to its powerful re-action, and therefore only uses a light a momentary friction to those parts where cramp is developed, and generally with great benefit. Under whatever form the Cholera presents itself, this medicine (camphor,) may be given during the first hour, with every probability of success. It is chiefly used when there is stiffness of the muscles. For a more detailed account of the treatment of Cholera, Dr. Quin's Pamphlet, and Dr. Black's Paper, in the British Journal of Homoeopathy, which can be bought separately ; and Dr. Laurie's Elementary Practice; (Homoeopathy,) may be consulted.* These few pages have been merely written for the purpose of giving nonprofessional persons some history of the disease, and a few instructions awaiting the arrival of the Physician ; it will suffice, therefore, to add the following summary, from Dr. Black's Paper : " The medicines given generally in ordinary cases of Cholera, are— 1. During the period of invasion, — Camphor. 2. When there is vomiting and watery evacuations, with slight cramps— Ipecacuanha. 3. If to these symptoms are added permanent cramps, great thirst, and excessive coldness — Veratrum. 4. In case of convulsions, bloody stools, or watery diarrhoea, and vomiting — Cuprum. Ipecacuanha is only .useful in slight attacks. It is indicated when vomiting is the predominating symptom, and comes on alternately with yellowish diarrhoea, uccompanied by colic. It is never suitable when the disease is at its height, and if improvement does not soon follow its administration, recourse must be had to Veratrum. The dose is a few globules of the first dilution, repeated in about ten minutes to two hours, according to the urgency of the case. Verathum is the principal remedy in almost all cases of Cholera, with * A Pamphlet has also been published by Dr. Dudgeon. 20 sudden and frequent evacuations upwards and downwards, coldness of the body,, great weakness, cramps in the calves of the legs, &c. The dose is a few globules of the third or sixth dilution, to be given in a spoonful of iced water, and if after ten minutes or half an hour there is no change for the better, the dose to be repeated. If the symptoms increase after several doses, and the cramps change to spasms and convulsions, recourse must be had to Cuprum, and in many cases this latter remedy is beneficially alternated with Veratrum. Arsenicum may likewise be alternated with Veratrum, when the disease is attended with a sensation as of burning coals in the stomach and bowels, occasional scalding evacuations, accompanied by violent colic and extraordinary prostration of strength, coldness of the skin, clammy perspirations and insupportable fear of death. Chamomilla is useful in Choleric Diarrhoea when it is attributed to great dread of being attacked with Cholera, and when the evacuations are bilious. The patient ought to be kept warm, and if necessary, bottles of hot water applied to the feet ; a little cold water is to be given from time to time, to allay the thirst, and if possible, occasionally, small pieces of ice. Lavements of iced water are often beneficial in cases of colic and cramps of the intestines. During convalescence, care should be taken to prevent relapses ;. and it is frequently observed that at the commencement of convalescence, the patient is tormented with a great craving for food, this should be restrained, and but little food, and that of a light digestible kind only, allowed to be taken. Care should also be taken to protect the surface of the body, and particularly the extremities, from cold. The results of the Allopathic and Homoeopathic treatment of epidemic Cholera in Edinburgh, as reported up to this date Oct. 25th,. 1848, are as follows :—: — Treated Allopathically. Cases of Cholera ... 175 Deaths 102 Mortality, abstract 58 per Cent. Treated Homceopathically. Cases of Cholera . . 14 Deaths 4 Mortality, average 28 per Cent. Assuming that the cases occurring under Homoeopathic treatment, were returned to the Registrar, we must deduct this number from the Allopathic returns, which would then increase their mortality to 60 per Cent. George Odcll, Printer, 18, Princes-street, Cavendish-square.