CooKE. \5°»« ^0 AoLA*J~*-d rfa*** y o<** THE TRArVSYXVANIA JOURNAL OF TttEDI y AND THE ASSOCIATE SCIENCES. Art. \'11I.—Remarks on a Review, in the May number of t Jour, of Med. Science&fiof "A Treatise of Pathology and Thera- peutics, by Joiix E. Cooke, M. D., •fee." By the author of the Treatise. A im. TREATISE of Pathology and Therapeutics, published by the writer of the following observations in 1828, and for sale at Carey, Lea and Carey's bookstore in Philadelphia since that time, has been noticed in the last number of the American Journal of the Medical Sciences, (No. XV, May, 1831,) it is presumed from the signature, by one of the collaborators of that periodical. It is proposed to make some remarks upon that review in this journal; and although they may not be as extensively circulated, and will not even be presented to the same readers, as the review, yet it is the best that can at this time be done to set the views of the author in a correct light. If the Editor of the A:>i. Jour, of Med. Sciences should consider them fit to publish in his periodical, his sense of justice will, it is presumed from his reply to the application made to him to publish an answer to the review, cause him to give,them a place in his next number. The Reviewer, after an introduction complimentary to the West, proceeds thus. " The treatise opens with some judicious observations on the proper method of pursuing medical investigations, in order to arrive at just and permanent principles; and the author next expatiates on the causes which have retarded the progress of the science. The great cause of this evil he attributes to the extreme proneness of physicians to frame hypothetical theories from partial and limited premises, instead of tracing up the varied phenomena of disease through their chain of causes to the first or remote cause of the derangement, in the true spirit of the inductive philosophy. After such an explicit avowal of views which we have been taught to con- sider as the only sound procedure for the attainment of a correct system of pathology, aided, however, by a knowledge of the laws of physiology -vol. A.—no. 3. «}g $80 Cooke's Remarks on a Review of his Treatise and autopsic inspection, we did not expect to find the author straightway propounding a theory of his own, which we fear will be found to rest ori no better data than he had the page before deprecated. This theory is no further novel than in the extensive application made of it to explain the production of the multiform characters of disease, but as it constitute? the key-stone of the system of pathology, which this treatise is devoted to verify and enforce, we shall give it in the author's own words, that the reader may be fairly put in possession of the aim and tendencies of the work imder consideration." With this view the reviewer then proceeds to give an extract from the preface to the treatise. This however the author cannot admit a3 giving a fair view of his work. That part of the preface given in the review was writ Ion to show, not the doctrine of the treatise, but merely the manner in which he was led on to investigate the leading points of that doctrine. And although these leading points are men- tioned in the preface, they are barely mentioned; and he is persuaded that every man who takes the trouble to read the two pages of the preface given in the review, and compare them with the whole tenor of the work, will say, that this extract does not "put the reader fairly in possession of the aim and tendencies of the work under considera- tion." The assertion contained in the above quotation from the review, that the author has straightway propounded a theory of his own, and • he intimation, that he has departed from the proposed plan of inves- tigating the subject, the author thinks far from being \ifttll founded. The first chapter of the work is occupied by a notice of the theo- ries of various deservedly celebrated writers, and an attempt to point out the manner in which the investigation should be conducted. In the 10th and 11th sections it is said, l% The remote causes of disease, operating on the human system pro- duce uniform effects. This must be the consequence of their operating in an uniform manner, and of the system's acting, under their influence, uniformly according to certain laws by which it is governed. The exposi- tion of this manner and of these laws, or a statement of the immediate effects of the remote causes on the system, and of the changes wrought in it in consequence of these effects, will show the whole connexion be- tween the agents ascertained to be the remote causes of disease, and their effects the symptoms; and is the true theory. " In the following pages I shall attempt the investigation of this con- nexion, or, a statement of the immediate effects of the remote causes on, the system, and of the changes wrought in it in consequence' of these effects. of Pathology and Therapeutics. 287 The course which, it is believed, the inquiry must necessarily take to be successful, is stated in a few observations which follow." The sum of these observations is given in sectioa 18 in the fol- lowing words. "Applying these manifest truths and inferences to the phenomena of disease, the remote causes of fever, and the whole train of symptoms pro- ceeding from them, denominated a febrile paroxysm, with all the inter- mediate links, constitute a series of causes and effects: &c." In section 19 an inference is drawn from section 18, in the follow- ing words. "Henceit is evident that, in order thoroughly to investigate the con* nexion between the remote causes and the symptoms of disease, we may in- quire into the effects of the causes ascertained; next into the effects of those effects, or new causes; and so on, descending until we arrive at the ultimate effects, the symptoms in question; or, that we may inquire in- to the causes of the symptoms, and into the causes of those causes, and so on, ascending until we arrive at the remote causes; or, that these two modes may be combined, and that the agreement of the two in the same result is a strong confirmation of its truth." After showing at some length that this mode of investigation had not been followed by the authors of the theories that have been promulgated, the chapter concludes in these words. " I shall now attempt the investigation of this connexion by inquiring into the effects of the remote causes; next into the effects of these effects, or new causes; and so on descending to the ultimate effects, the symptoms in question." After such an explicit avowal of views which we too have been taught to consider as the only sound procedure for the attainment of a correct system of pathology, it would indeed have been extraordi- nary to find the author departing from the plan proposed and straight- way propounding a theory of his own. But he cannot agree with the reviewer, that this has been done "in the work under considera- tion." On the contrary, the plan proposed has been most rigidly ad- hered to, it is believed, throughout the whole. It is not intended to say that the book contains no theory. On the contrary, the absolute necessity of a knowledge of the true theory or explanation, of the operation of the remote causes of disease in producing their effects, in order to scientific and successful practice, is strongly urged. It is a hypothetical theory of which the reviewer speaks, and which the writer has in view here. The work in question is devoted to the ex- planation nr theory of the operation of the remote causes of fever. 288 Cooke's Remarks on a Review of his Treatise But this explanation may rest on supposition or conjecture, as hav« many explanations or theories of disease. It was the intention of the author to avoid this entirely; and rigidly to pursue the inductive methsd of philosophising. The second chapter commences the investigation on the plan laid down in the first. After showing in the first three sections, that tho action of the heart is measured by the force of the pulsation of the arteries, and by the temperature and colour of the surface and ex- tremities; and stating, in the next section certain agents which have been considered remote causes of fever, the author lays down the proposition, (section 85) that "all the remote causes of disease directly or indirectly weaken the action of the heart,''' without pro- pounding any theory, or intimating to what this proposition is to lead; and in the following sections endeavours to show that this is true of each remote cause separately. In sections 86-88 it is shown that abstinence from food is a remote cause of fever, and produces weakened action of the heart. In sections 89-90, the same is shown to be true of fatigue. In section 91, the same is shown of external violence from a blow or a fall; in 92, the same is shown of the depressing passions; in 93, of want of rest or sleep; in 95-96, of every kind of stimulant used to excess; in 97, of strong tea and coffee; in 98, of intense applica- tion of the mind; and in99 &c. of cold. The 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th chapters consist of an argument, rigidly upon the inductive plan, to show that a dense gas the product of the putrefaction of vegetable matter is the remote cause of hot weather endemics. Several doctrines are noticed in the course of this investi- gation, and among others Dr. Ferguson's, at length. In the 7th chapter, section 595, it is shown that "weakened action of the heart is the consequence of respiring the dense gas arising during the putrefaction of vegetable matter." In the 8th chapter, the winter epidemics, called bilious pleurisy, «fee are shown to be the effect of the jojnt operation of the same dense gas, and of cold. The chapters 10 to 16, inclusive, contain arguments to show that contagion is not the remote cause of plague, yellow fever, or typhus. but that these diseases arise in precisely the same circumstances in which the annual hot weather endemics of this continent arise; and that the doctrine, that a general epidemic constitution of the atmosphere of Pathology and Therapeutics. 2S'J is the cause of the diseases of hot weather, is unfounded. In these chapters the evidence is drawn almost entirely from writers who ad- vocate the doctrine of the contagious nature of these diseases. In the 17th chapter, section 1204, the following is given as the sum of the argument. " We have now seen that all the known remote causes of fever weaken the action of the heart, and that weakened action of the heart precedes every fever. (691*) Weakened action of the heart is therefore one link of the chain of causes extending from the remote causes to the symptoms of fever; and all those causes which produce this link of the chain, are themselves remote causes of fever; inasmuch as all those causes which produce it, are remote causes of its effects." After a few inferences from this section respecting some other re- mote causes of fever, occupying less than a page, the volume closes; and the author ventures to say that a man might read the whole and have no conception of the theory to follow.f He has not time to read over the whole work to ascertain the fact, but is confident that in the whole seventeen chapters of the first volume, there is no part of the theory advanced but what has been mentioned; viz. that the remote causes of fever directly or indirectly weaken the action of the heart, and that weakened action of the heart precedes all fevers. The last words of the first volume are, "We next proceed to inquire into the ef- fects of weakened action of the heart:" and with this inquiry the se- cond volume opens. *The following references in support of the last clause of this sentence arc given at section 691. Boerhaave's Practical Aphorisms, Eng. translation, 563. Cullen's First Lines, xxxiv, xlvi. Darwin's Theory of Fever, Supplement, 1. 1. 6. Rush's Works, vol. 3, p. 3,4. fin the winter of 1837 the manuscript of the work in question was delivered, with occasional remarks and some omissions, as a course of lectures, the first delivered by the author in Lexington. A number of the. intelligent and inquis- itive of the class were struck with the novelty of the course pursued, and visit- ed the writer and were very urgent to know what doctrine or theory he had in view—what was to be the end of the discussion they were daily hearing, of prin- ciples, the tendency of which they could not perceive. Their inquiries were for some time evaded; they were told to be satisfied to proceed step by step, and inquire whether the successive points discussed were established, or not; so that they might be unbiassed by preconceived notions, when they should dis- cover the conclusions resulting from the doctrines advanced. These visits were however repeated, and at length the visiters became so importunate in their requests, that when the winter was well advanced, the writer gave them a sketch of the whole. 290 Cooke's Remarks on a Review of his Treatise In the first section of the second volume the question is proposed, What is the effect of this cause, weakened action of the heart ? In the next section, it is answered: One consequence immediately flowing from weakened action of the heart, is the diminution of the quantity of blood sent into the arteries; whence follows weakness of the pulse, a very obvious consequence of the diminution of the power which distends the arteries; paleness andcoldnes of the surface, con- sequences, as certain, of the failure of the usual supply of blood to the surface; and diminished bulk of the external parts, shrinking of the features, and shrivelling of the skin, all necessarily following deficient fulness of the cutaneous and subcutaneous vessels-. In the following sections, 1211 to 1218, it is shown that another consequence of weakened action of the heart inevitably following in every case, is an accumulation of blood in the great veins entering into the heart; and in the sections following, it is shown that this accumu- lation cannot be confined to the vena cava, but must extend into the large branches of that vein which proceed from the head, the liver, the spleen, and stomach and bowels, including the hemorrhoidal veins, the veins from the kidneys, and the veins from the pelvis including the uterine branches of the internal iliac veins. This being established, section 1248 runs thus; "Accumulation of blood in the venous cavity" (the vena cava and branch- es above-mentioned) "being the effect of weakened action of the heart, is another link of the chain of causes extending from the remote causes to the symptoms. The next question is, What are the effects of this cause, accu- mulation of blood in the venous cavity!" Chapter XIX is taken up with the answer to this question. It is there shown that accumulation of blood in the vena cava and its branches produces various effects; viz. enlargement of some parts, disturbance of the functions of the head, the stomach, the liver, the kidneys, and the uterine system; which it is unnecessary further to no- tice at this time, as the object now is to show not the truth or correct- ness of the various arguments or explanations, but that the proposed plan of investigation is followed. The writer has also in that chapter attempted to show that the alternations of low and high action in fever are the consequence of the operation of sudden accumulation of blood in the vena cava, upon the heart, exciting it to action too great to con- tinue and therefore after some hours fulling back into weakened action; thus allowing of a gradual rptwm ef tjjo accumulation of blood in thu of Pathology and. Therapeutics. 291 * vena cava, . -' • s I 294 Cooke's Remarlts on a Review of his Trcatisi reviewer docs not question. Of the depressing effects produced by cold it might be said with equal propriety, " This state of depression is not a state of fever; on the contrary, it is universally considered one of our most efficient means to remove or alleviate an existing fe- brile affection." True, the depression is not a state of fever; but it leads to a febrile state; and when fever is produced, as it very often is, the state of depression is called the cold stage of thefever. And, not withstanding that cold is universally and justly considered as one of our most effectual means of removing or alleviating an existing febrile affection, yet is it undoubtedly a remote cause of fever; and the re- viewer admits it. These reasons, therefore, for denying that absti nence is also a remote cause, are not valid. The Reviewer proceeds to say; "When abstinence is carried to the extent of producing disease, it does So not by weakening the action of the heart, which effect rather wards off for a time the evil, but by changing the character and qualities of the cir- culatory fluids, and rendering them so acrid and irrrtating as to produce not only most intense inflammation of the stomach and intestines, but also of other tissues of the system, which, when they prove fatal, destroy life amidst unexampled pain and suffering," &c. Does the reviewer seriously offer this explanation as one founded upon observation and the inductive method of philosophising? Has he produced any evidence cf this acrid and irritating state of the circulating fluids? Has he any to produce? The writer knows per- sons who suffer excessively from abstinence but for a few hours. Is their blood already in this acrid and irritating state ? On eating a few mouthfuls, the pain is removed. Is this by removing the acrid and irritating state of the circulating fluids? The writer has known the painful sensations arising from abstinence to go off in a few hours though the abstinence was continued, and the person abstaining the whole day, to rest in the latter part of it entirely free from pain. The case stated by Dr. Currie of Liverpool, in his Medical Reports, is entirely opposed to the Reviewer's opinion on this subject. A gentleman was prevented by a scirrhous tumour of the oesopha- gus from swallowing. The difficulty gradually increased with the in- crease of the obstruction. From October 17th " he was able to swal- low only a tablespoonful of liquid at a time, and with long intervals. It was with difficulty that he got down seven or eight spoonfuls of strong soup in a day. and this quantity gradually diminished. On the first of November, the passage seemed wholly obstructed." After of Pathology and Therapeutics. 295 that he continued to swallow two or three tablespoonfuls of milk daily, till about the 15th November; but though it rested in the oeso- phagus for some time, it was constantly ejected at last; and for the last twenty days of his life he made no attempt to swallow. After that time an attempt was made to sustain him by the*regular adminis- tration of clysters of broth. The result of this remarkable case was, that until Dec. 1st "no man had ever perhaps approached death by steps more easy." (p. 212.) This was fifteen days after he had de- sisted from making any attempt to swallow. On the first of Decem- ber, however, a change took place. " On the morning of the 1st Decem- ber it" (the pulse which had for a month previously been healthy,) "became small and frequent; and still more frequent after the deli- rium commenced; the state of the pulse, as well as almost all the other symptoms from that time forth, very nearly resembled the symp- toms of the last stage of fever, when it terminates fatally." The reviewer denies that famine is a remote cause of fever on the ground that a famine in France in 1817, produced certain chronic dis- eases, but that there was a remarkable exemption from febrile diseases. The author has, however, equally good testimony to show that fa- mine has produced epidemic disease. Russel, in his history of the plague at Aleppo in 1700, 61, and 62, says, (p. 9) "Through th<: summer of the year 1757, grain of every kind bore a very high price, and as the winter approached, became scarcer and dearer; insomuch, that from the month of December in that year, till the following June, most parts of Syria and Mesopotamia might be said to have suffered ail the miseries of extreme famine. In the month of February, 1758, a malignant petechial fever made its appearance at Aleppo, and ad- vancing rapidly with the spring, raged throughout the summer and part of the autumn. This fever reigned with influence not less exten- sive than the famine, and both together produced every where a mor- tality little inferior to that of the true plague." Here then is evidence on both sides; but with this material differ- ence. That of the Reviewer is negative; that of the author positive. The former proves only that in the case specified, famine did not pro- duce fever. The latter proves that fever did accompany famine; and the capability of an agent to produce certain effects being shown in one instance proves that agent to be one of the causes of those effects. Indeed, it would be no difficult matter to multiply proofs that famine produces fever. Numerous instances might be cited of famine in pla- 2:96 Cooke's Remarks on a Review of his Treatise ces besieged being followed by pestilential fevers; and these hav^ |4 ever been considered as so inseparable, that if famine prevail, pesti- lence is confidently expected shortly to make its appearance. Moreove-, the testimony produced by the Reviewer is not only in- ferior in character, but it is by no means inconsistent with that pro- duced by the author. An agent universally admitted to be a remote- cause of fever may and often does produce chronic and not acute epi- demic disease. Of this the occurrences on board of the Cha-inel Fleet of England in the years 1794,95 and 96, afforded a striking ex- ample. In 1791 an epidemic fever prevailed on board the fleet, in 1705 an epidemic scurvy, and in 1706 there were numerous cases of both scurvy and fever among the crews of the ships* The reviewer thinks that when fever is produced by excessive bodily exertion or by stimulant drinks, that it is during the excite- ment and hurry of the circulation. This the author would not call a slate of fever. The fact is, that febrile excitement frequently fol- lows the debility which the Reviewer admits to be often consequeqt on excessive bodily exercise; as well as the debility left after a niglit of intemperance. This however, is a matter respecting which every man must form his own opinion from his own observation. The Reviewer says; (p. 121*) " In making contusions from external violence, as falls and blows, the cause of fevers, the author has drawn his argument from the analogy of their first effects to the concussions of the brain from the same causes." The author is not aware of having done this. The whole he has said on the subject is given in section 91, as follows. "External violence from a blow or a fall produces fever and various morbid symptoms, besides the local symptoms from contusion. Blows have the eiiect of reducing the action of the heart in a remarkable man- ner. A violent stroke, not on the head only, but on any part of the body, will in an instant stop the action of the heart. Falls have the same effect precisely, it being immaterial whether a body be impelled against a man, or he against tue body. I have seen a person who had fallen from a horse continue for some time w ith a feeble pulse, pale countenance, and yawn- ing and stretching, as in the cold stage of fever." Iheamhoi cio not intend in this passage to represent contusion as the cause of fever. lit-, has seen fever follow the state of debility pro- duced by a fall, w hen there was no contusion properly speaking. He* has had a case of nephri is produced by a fall from a horse i-> which * See Trotter's Medicina Nautica vol. i. of Pathology and Therapeutics. 29v there was not the slightest appearance of contusion, and the patient it is believed lit ap jn her feet. Neiiher does the author, in making blows aid falls, remote causes of fever, draw his argument from analogy, «fec. He merely sates tho fact that they do produce fever; as may be seen by referring to the first sentence of the quotation given above. Argument in such a case is superfluous. Every man who has not yet made up his mind on this subject, must do so, if at all, from observation. The whole passage above quoted, after the first sentence, is occupied with showing that blows and falls weaken the action of the heart—and in support of this, reference is made to observations made by the author; but no argument is used. The author rests upon the alleged matter of fact for the truth of his theory, so far as there stated. The reviewer in objecting, combats al- leged matter of fact, not by an appeal to observation, but to an argu- ment founded upon a hypothesis, in which a case is supposed that was not in the view of the author at all when he wrote the passage in question; viz. a case of contusion in which tho part is so injured as to become " the seat of irritation and fluxion." So far from havi ,g such in view, the author expressly excepts that case in the first sen- tence of the quotation; and the tenor of the remainder of it, accords with that meaning. He will allow, however, that another word instead of besides might have conveyed his idea more clearly to the mind of the reviewer. The passage might have been expressed thus. "Ex- ternal violence from a blow or a fall produces fever and various morbid symptoms, independently of, or over and above the local symptoms proceeding from contusion." Nevertheless the word besides does cer- tainly bear the same signification with the other wrords used above; and that this was the ftention and meaning of the author is evident from the tenor of the subseqiie it part of the passage, from the express de- claration in section 1858, latter clause, and is well known to all those who have heard his views at large. The Reviewer says; (p. 130) "Cold is one of the most constant and evident causes of disease, and the author endeavours to prove, chiefly from the facts furnished by Currie, that it invariably does so by weakening the action of the heart." This is a singular misapprehension of the passage, it appears to the writer. The author in speaking of cold, does not, as he had done in the case of the previously mentioned causes, say any thing in the 298 Cooke's Remarks on a Review of his Treatise commencement of his remarks on cold, of its being a remote cause oi fever. He enters immediately upon the subject of its power to reduce the action of the heart. This he endeavours to show by reference to the well known experiments of Currie, to those made by Dr. Stork of Bristol, and Drs. Spooner and M'Donnel of Edinburgh, and to experi- ments and observations of his own. (Sections 109, 111, 112, 113.) This argument occupies 16 pages, in which there is no mention of the production of disease, except incidentally; and no effort made to prove from Currie that cold produces disease at all. The whole object in those pages is to prove from the facts stated by Currie and others, that cold weakens the action of the heart. This being established, the author states it as the conclusion at which he had arrived, in section 138, and in 139 proceeds to state the position, for the first time, that "Cold is one of the most common, and is the most immediately active of the remote causes of fever; in many cases producing fever in a few hours, independently of the assistance of other remote causes; as in the cases mentioned above from Currie, 122, 124." These two cases are incidentally mentioned by Currie in the statement of his experi- ments and observations, and are above alluded to. There is no attempt made, the author thinks, to prove that cold pro- duces fever by weakening the action of the heart. But the proposi- tions are considered separately and independently; 1, Cold weakens the action of the heart; 2, Cold is a remote cause of fever. On this last no proof was offered, as being undisputed. The object was here as elsewhere, not to anticipate, but to treat each proposition on its own merits; and the reader, from the work itself, cannot at that stage of the investigation perceive the object of the author, or what his theo- ry is. The Reviewer then proceeds to give his views and those of some. others on the mode of operation of cold, with which the writer con- ceives he has at present nothing to do, his business being to show that what he has stated as fact, is true, and what he has inferred, is correct- ly inferred, and no more. The Reviewer proceeds thus; (p. 130) « We think we have said enough to show that the author has not suc- ceeded, to use his own language, ' in tracing the remote causes through their cham of effects to the symptoms of disease,' by assuming weakened action of the heart, from the nature of these causes, to be an indispensable precursor of all fevers, and we shall not therefore, examine into the opera-. fan of the remaining causes with reference to this subject." of Pathology and, Therapeutics. 299 The quotation in the body of this extract, though not, ft is thought, hi the author's own words, comes near enough for the present purpose. As to the opinion of the reviewer, in the same extract, that he has said enough to show that the author has not succeeded in his object, the author does not pretend in that part of the work to have traced "the connexion between the remote causes and the symptoms of disease? but only to have proceeded so far in the accomplishment of his object as to have shown that weakened action of the heart is an effect, direct- ly or indirectly produced, of the remote causes of fever thus far men- tioned, viz. those mentioned in the second chapter of the work; the reviewer's remarks, when this opinion was expressed, having been confined to those two chapters and the preface. The Reviewer, in the same extract, above quoted, speaks of the author's "assuming weakened action of the heart, from the nature of the remote causes, to be an indispensable precursor of all fevers." The following are the words of the author, section 691. " It appears from the preceding pages that weakened action of the heart is the effect, directly or indirectly, of the remote causes of fever. This, therefore, is a link of the chain of causes and effects extending from the remote causes to the symptoms of fever. (18) This conclusion is confirm- ed by the fact long since ascertained, that all fevers are preceded by weak- ened action of the heart."* From this passage it is evident, that the author, in the first sentence, infers from the preceding pages, (in which, as he had proposed in sec- tion 85, he has adduced various facts and arguments to show its truth, of the several remote causes,) that weakened action of the heart is the effect, directly or indirectly, of the remote causes of fever. In the second, he infers from this conclusion, that weakened action of the heart is a link of the chain of causes and effects extending from the remote causes to the symptoms of fever. And in the third, he cites in confirmation of this conclusion, as " a fact long since ascertained, that all fevers are preceded by weakened action of the heart," and quotes Boerhaave, Cullen, Darwin and Rush, in a note, in support of this fact long since ascertained. This is very little like assuming this doc trine from the nature of the remote causes. The Reviewer in his observations on the chapters on the remote '*"Boerhaave's Practical Aphorisms, 563. Cullcn's First Lines, xxxiv, xlvi. Darwin's Theory of Fever, Supplement, 1. 1. 6* Rush's Works, vol. 3, p. 3,4." #00 Cooke's Remarks on a Review of his Treatise causes of the epidemics of hot climates, shows a disposition to speak favorably, which, the author thinks, would have been exercised more frequently but for the clashing of his facts with the reviewer's hypo- theses. There are one or two remarks, however, which it is necessary to make. The reviewer says, p. 131. " The author, in his eagerness to exclude animal matter from any agency in the production of these epidemics, has, we think, passed over too lightly the proofs of the power of exhalations from putrid animal matter to produce febrile diseases. Numerous instances of their agency in this respect, arc not wanting in the an- nals of medicine, and we ought not to reject them because they do not square with our own theoretical preconceptions,'1'' &c. The writer has marked in this extract two places in italics, as ob- jectionable. The author, so far from being eager to exclude animal matter from the list of causes, was a believer in their agency in the production of these epidemics, even after he had concluded, as he then thought, his investigation of this subject; and it was on a recon- sideration of the whole, just before publication, that his present judg. ment was formed. Evidence of this may be seen in an essay of his, published in the Medical Recorder for July, 1824. In that paper after citing a mini' er of cases on record, the object of which was to -how the power of exhalations from dead animal matter, in producing fever, tho writer concludes this. " These show unquestionably, that exhalations from the putrefaction of animal matter also produce ep- idemic fevers." So far, therefore, was he from rejecting the theory because it did not square with his theoretical preconceptions, that he rejected his theoretical preconceptions, because he conceived that they were not supported by facts. With regard to the criticism on the nature of the gas, the author agrees wich the reviewer that the argument is not conclusive, and that " :his branch of the inquiry is still subjudicc" This he was sensi! W of very shortly after that part of the work was put to the press, in 1S27 insomuch that he did not deliver that opinion to the class of 1S27 or to any subsequent one. The remarks of the Reviewer upon the subject of winter epideiiics ared.ily appreciated. Th, reviewer is correct in conjecturing the meaning of tho author respecting the operation of miasmata and cald in jointly producing these epidemics. If he will carefully re-peruse sec- tions 599 to 603, he will find that they are attributed to the operation of cold upon person who are not yet freed from(he secretion of both stomach and liver, "he 'ommenced with scamuionvi aloes, and calomel, in equal quantity, in pills, with directions to procure about three consistent passages every day." Following this plan he soon improved, but on his second call "the discharges being rather thin, he was directed to take pills of rhu- barb, aloes and calomel, instead of those first mentioned." The rhu- barb was here substituted for scamniony, in consequence of a condi- tion of the evacuations continually adverted to by the writer, which is never to be allowed to continue in chronic diseases, because it re- duces the patient's strength, whereas the cathartics which operate in the way proposed, bringing away consistent passages two or three times a day. may be continued to any necessary extent with a constant in- crease of the strength.* *In confirmation of the above see section 1612 of the work. In the case there stated, the patient was a lady, a little above thirty years of age, of a slender frame, of sedentary habits, the mother of many children, and on all these accounts in baft "health. She was advised to take the course above recommended, and long refused ; but at length, when she was so reduced in strength, as to be afraid to venture into the street for fear of faintness and of falling, commenced the use of them. " She took them several months. When she commenced, she walked along slowly, with the appearance of infirmity, and upon any exertion, as on ascending a flight of steps or a little hill, her respiration was hurried, and she could scarcely proceed. After si month or more, she walked from one side of the town to the other, in a quick and lively manner, and ascended a hill without difficult} or delay." She continues iu i^ood health to this day. (See section 1612; also 1811, 1837 and 2037 in connex- ion; 1S13 and 1841 in connexion; and section 1812.) Cases of this description, in any reasonable number, are at the service of the reviewer with names and dates. Two more relating to medical men shall here be mentioned. In the summrr of 1828, Dr. Owen of Alabama, came to Lexington for ru.nlierfl VOL. 4.— \o. 2. 41 *J10 Cooki::s Remarks on a Review of his Treatise The patient in question by following this plan of treatment soor recovered. The author proceeds to give a number of cases with minute parti advice and called on the writer for the purpose of obtaining it. He was exceedingly weak, pale, emaciated, and dyspeptic in the extreme, so that he had been compelled to lay aside all thoughts of continuing practice and had given it up. He was advised to commence immediately with pills of rh. al. and cal. in sufficient quantity to pro- duce two or three consistent passages every day. He followed the plan proposed and improved fast; insomuch that he went to dine out, and this indulgence was followed by a \ oiniting ice. and great prostration. This he at first attributed, with the writer, to the improper diet used at dinner: (among other articles were tomatoes and boiled com.) But afterwards, having discovered that he had been taking calomel,he attribu* ted the bad effect* to that medicine. He bad objected, at first, to the use of calomel, and the first dozen pills made for him contained none. But after the first, every par- cel was made by tiie young genUeraan in the office in the usual way, viz. with calo- nmel, the objection not being known to him, or not being recollected. He had there- fore folloutd the plan proposed, though he objected to it. His objections to continue the course, rrsuited in his leaving town, and at a friend's house, not far off, he treated his case in his o\\ a w ay. Hearing that he was likely to die, and that he was consider- ed as my patient, I railed to >ce him; and finding him on the bed and very low, I re- quested as n favor of him ihat. as he was uot following my advice, he would let it be underwood that he was not my patient; particularly as he was using some articles ihat in my view w ould not by any means benefit him. We parted in a friendly, but -oincw'.iat cool u av, and I saw no more of him for perhaps two months, when I was surprised to see him ride up to the door and get down with more strength than I ever before :-aw him exert. Mating bin. at the door, became, he told me, to do me jus- tke. II, told me that he had ,-«si*ted h. the course he was following when we parted until he was convinced he should die; and determining to make a last effort he had fully adopt,-.i the plan originallv proposed to him, had gradually regamed health and .„;„,„. and was now going home. Moreover, he had, with candour and generosity mined that the truth should not bo injured through him. This gentleman, the writer is inform,*!, has become IM and healthy, and has resumed the piact.ee Dr. CMrkc of Missouri, called on the writer in the summer of 1829, havi g^ ,„incn,„ for the purpose of obtaining advice in his case. He ™ and sou. .Uh ,bdomi„ul viscera. On ^•■H.^ob.^^.tta^not.sk.J^^ ,hBt «,,<.„.,, he i.,!,,.! .hat he knew what would relieve ,t, v,z. cathartics buta „„. disease was so obstinate, that to cure it he was compelled to use ***£«*£ he should be delved by the remedy. To this the reply was ™^>^ Then you could cure the disease if you had a cathartic that cou d be take, v h .educing your strength. Certainly, he answered. Then said the wne , * < vouol such an „,, The rh. aloes and calomel pill was then proposed *h»^ Uken in the usual way. Ho adopted it, and in a t^^^J"£^m was so much improved that he returned home, confident that he could cuie hrmselt, at least keep the disease down, so as to be comfortable. of Pathology and Therapeutics. 311 'culars from day to day, including among them all those cases which were most unfavourable in their termination. These cases occupy forty pages; and the author thinks that the numerous facts stated in them, so extraordinary in the estimation of the reviewer as to deserve the name of" infatuation? are deserving of other notice than a sweep- ing denunciation. They are not thus to be obliterated from the recol- lection of the writer, nor of the numerous physicians who have adopt- ed this mode of treatment, nor of the still more numerous class of per- sons who have heard of it, from the contests relating to it, and have adopted it, from seeing the success attending it in their friends and neighbours, without consulting any practitioner; thereby materially affecting the practice of some physicians as the writer is well assured from the best authority, and among whom he ranks himself. Having stated so many cases in which the mode of practice recom- mended, had relieved the patient in a remarkable manner, the author observes in section 1843; " These cases are sufficient to prove that dyspepsia is to be cured by medicines which produce free evacuations from the venous cavity, as above mentioned. The following cases go further, and show not only that such evacuations arc effectual, in re- storing health to dyspeptic persons, but also that tonics, when they are salutary, sometimes, and probably often, act in the same way." The author then proceeds to give in the two following sections, two cases. The persons were his own friends, who suffered excessively under long continued dyspepsia. Both had made great and persever ing efforts to obtain relief without success. One of them particularly, was a man of extraordinary energy, and "used tonics in the freest manner." But all in vain. These two men left that part of the coun- try and the writer saw them no more for several years. When he met them, they were both hearty men. This excited his surprise, and he immediately inquired how they had been restored to health. One stated that he had been cured by bark, which had purged him every day for three months; the other that he had been cured by bark and Epsom salts. From these remarkable facts the author drew the guarded inference stated above, that " tonics, when they are salutary, sometimes, and probably often act in the same way;" viz. by producing a loose state of the bowels How different the representation of the reviewer in the passage quo- ted. " Has the exhibition of the cinchona or the nitrate of silver cured 813 Cooke's Remarks on a Review of his Treatise a case of dyspepsia, it was by acting as a purgative." This sentence would naturally lead the reader to the conclusion, that the author's passion for cathartics not only led him to give them in dyspepsia, but that he asserted without limitation, that when bark cures dyspepsia it is by acting as a cathartic. But the author does not make this sweep- ing conclusion relating to tonics, from the good effects of cathartics alone; but from observing, in cases in which tonics had long been tried and failed, and years after succeeded, that in the latter trials they had produced a continued loose state of the bowels, he concluded that they sometimes and probably often prove beneficial in this way. As to the remark respecting the nitrate of silver, the writer Avill merely state the facts, and leave the reader to form his own opinion. The reviewer says, " Has the nitrate of silver cured a case of dyspep- sia, it was by acting as a purgative;" thereby representing the cases in which this medicine was administered by the author, as cured by it. The following are the circumstances of the only cases in which it was administered. The patient in the first stated, (section 183G) after long suffering the utmost extremity of the disease, was brought to the writer for assistance. No hopes were given of her recovery, but as she and her friends were desirous that an effort should be made to save her, it was made. She commenced taking pills of scammony, aloes and calomel on the third of February and continued them until the 17th. On the 17th ptyalism having come on, she took instead of calomel a quarter of a grain of nitrate of silver with the aloes and rhubarb. These medicines were continued until the 1st March, she taking every day or nearly so, pills containing from half a grain to three quarters of the nitrate with the rhubarb and aloes, The effect of these medicines while the calomel was administered, was to produce green and black discharges daily: the effect after the nitrate was given, was to produce the same, but much more abundant- ly throughout, but particularly on the 19th, 25th, and 27th February. All this is minutely stated in the work. The reader will observe that this is one of the two cases the author has spoken of above, as the most unfavorable. If the nitrate cured this case, as the reviewer intimates, most assuredly the author has a right to conclude that it did it by acting as a cathartic, seeing that after it was given the discharges were increased in number and in quantitv- and seeing that the nitrate of silver is an active cathartic of Pathology and Titer apeutics. 313 ''< The patient in the second case commenced taking scammony, calo- ■mel, &,c. on the 28th November, and continued with slight intermis- I'sions and some irregularities in the use of improper cathartics, viz. 'such as weaken by producing watery passages, until the 6th February, • when the attendance ceased. In the course of this time the calomel having affected the mouth, on the 27th January, two months after the treatment with cathartics had commenced, she look nitrate of silver; and in that and the five following days used eight and a half grains of the nitrate, when she returned to the use of calomel with the cathartic. The violence of the struggle, which commenced on the 8th January, when she was very ill through imprudence mentioned in the case, was over by the 12th, and from that day she improved regularly; viz. fifteen days before the nitrate was administered. And the reader will observe that all this is minutely stated in the detail of the case from day to day. What renders it more remarkable that the reviewer should attribute the cure in this case to the nitrate alone, in contradistinction to cathar- tics, is, that the progress of the disease and the way in which it was treated by various physicians, is noticed in a very particular manner in section 2037, and the whole shows in a remarkable manner the effi- cacy of cathartics throughout the w hole period, and the inefficacy of every other mode of treatment that was tried. The reviewer is not more correct in his remark respecting the author's views of the operation of tansy and lime-water in gout. The author's observation of the causes and the nature of gout, led him to the conclusion, that the immediate cause of the symptoms is congestion, and consequently that evacuations from the liver by the bowels, should relieve the patient. His own experience in years pre- vious to the time of his investigation was in full accordance with this conclusion; and the experience of many deservedly esteemed medi- cal writers was equally so. Dr. Chcyne says he knew a quack to administer sixty grains of rhubarb disguised with cochineal, every morning for six weeks, to a gouty person, who had no symptom of the disease for four years after- wards. Dr. Rush says he knew two persons who had been accustomed to two fits of the gout a year, who had been preserved from them sev- eral years by taking sulphur to obviate costivencss. Dr. Clark states that he had a patient who had had the gout ten 314 Cooke's Remarks on a Revieiv of his Treatise years, for two months of the twelve in some of the latter years, who drank every day a quart of lime water, which purged him two or three times every day; and latterly when it seemed to lose its laxative quality, he directed him to take four ounces more, after which it pur- ged him as before. He had had no fit nor any other ailment at the end of ten years, when the statement was made. He states another case, in which a gentleman, who liad the gout so severely as to be confined every winter two or three months, and some- times a month in summer, took near a pint of strong infusion of tansy every night, and had two easy passages every day. He had no return of the gout in seven years, but once slightly when he strained his ankle. He mentions another ease in which the same remedy had a good effect, and the patient had two easy passages every day. He mentions another in which a patient was entirely relieved by taking half an ounce of the elixir sacrum, every second night. This dose contains the substance of seven and a half grains of rhubarb and four and a half of aloes. From these statements, all made in the work, the reader may jud^e. whether the author was right or wrong in his opinion. The author was so far from attributing the good effects of calomel and squills in dropsy to their cathartic operation iciihout reference to their operation on the other emunctories, that he had used that remedy for years with reference to its operation on the kidneys alone, not withstands ing that he continually observed it to purge the patient. And when his investigations led him to believe that it was by its cathartic effect so far from having no reference to its operation on the kidneys, and throw- ing it aside for a mercurial cathartic, he gave the calomel and squills in the first case that occurred, and watched the effect on the patient. '•They operated on the bowels; the discharges were precisely such as are usually produced by pills of jalap, aloes and calomel. After a day or two, the latter were used and continued until the disease was entirely removed; which was in a short time. The patient was young, and the disease has never returned. This was above five years ago. This was considered, as it is, a strong confirmation of the truth of the doctrine; it being evident that the medicine used as a diuretic had pro- duced its good effects by purging the patient. In consequence of this it was determined to make a full trial of the pills of jalap, aloes and calomel in the treatment of anasarca, ascites and hydrothorax. The tf Pathology and Therapeutics". 315 success of the practice was such in the first cases, as to hold out a strong inducement to continue it." (See section 2407-8.) A number of cases are then stated, which support this practice in the strongest manner, and show beyond all doubt, that whatever other medicines may do, those advised are very useful in the treatment of dropsy. The reviewer continues to make remarks upon the character of the work, which he does not support by reference to particular passages he has in view in making them; and the author therefore, can only say, in general terms, that the doctrines advanced in the work are not rested up- on his own ipse dixit, nor upon the authority of great names. The au- thor cannot spend his time in searching through the whole two volumes, to make sure that there is not some slight reference to authority which iiiillht be construed unfavorably to the following declaration, but he fully believes that there is not a solitary reference to authority for any doctrine. There is undoubtedly reference to great names for facts upon which the doctrine is built; but the author is yet to learn that authors of great and deserved celebrity are not to be quoted for what they have seen or heard. As to the remark about novelty, {"'Well may the author observe that the treatment is, as far as he knows, new.'"1) the author will only observe, that he recollects no part of the work in which claims to ori- ginality are obtruded on the reader. There is a note to section 1537, m which he states the simple fact about a matter of sm::ll moment, not with a view to such a claim but as a reason for not quoting as the author of it, a writer who has also advanced the doctrine, when he did not derive it from him. The remark of the reviewer is made in con- nexion with his observations on the treatment of dyspepsia; and on turning to that chapter the following passage was observed at the close of the first case. " The unquestionable importance of the case, and the successful termination, will, I am persuaded, fully justify the space occupied by it. I shall state others as fully, because one case is not to settle the question of the propriety of amode of treatment nocelas far as my reading extends." Surely nothing can be more inoffensive than this manner of mentioning a new practice. There is no claim of credit for the novelty of the treatment,but its novelty and extraordinary nature, admitted by the reviewer, is simply mentioned as the reason which induced the writer to put the reader in possession of abundant materials to guide him in his judgment of its propriety.. 310 Cookies Remarks on a Review of his Treatise i; This similarity (says the reviewer) is not, we suspect accidental. At any rate we have no where tho least intimation that the author is acquainted with the labours of Parry, Armstrong, and Abercrombie of Britain, or with those ot Louis, Andral, and Laennec of France, with a host of others, who have con- tributed to base medical science on principles Unknown to former times." Does not the reviewer perceive that this very fact, that there is in the w ork no such intimation, is evidence that the author was not then acquainted with those authors? This would surely be a rational con- clusion for a plain, sincere man to make. The reviewer professes to know nothing of the author. Knowing nothing of him but from his work, and finding nothing in the work to indicate that he was acquaint ed with the authors he mentions, what are the grounds of his suspi cion? Is such conduct universal in authors? Certainly not. Front what internal feeling, then, springs this suspicion? The preface to the work seems, for the most part, to have been lost to the reviewer. He might have gathered from it, that the writer was for a long time, (until the beginning of 1822,) engaged in a laborious country practice, in which of course he had little time for reading: and during which, he in fact had few books to read. " The loni! and she improved daily in every resp