THE PRINCIPLES OF ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION BEFORE VESALIUS FIELDING H. GARRISON THE PRINCIPLES OF ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION BEFORE VESALIUS A SPECIAL EDITION OE THIS BOOK, LIMITED TO ONE HUNDRED AND TEN COPIES, OF WHICH ONE HUN' DRED ARE FOR SALE, HAS BEEN PRINTED FROM TYPE ON KELMSCOTT HAND'MADE PAPER, WITH THE ILLUSTRATIONS ON JAPANESE VELLUM. EACH COPY IS SIGNED BY THE AUTHOR THE PRINCIPLES OF ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION BEFORE VESALIUS AN INQUIRY INTO THE RATIONALE OF ARTISTIC ANATOMY BY FIELDING H. GARRISON A.B., M.D. PAUL B'HOEBER'I*c NEW YORK * MCMXXVI Copyright, 1926 by Paul B. Hoeber, Inc. Published April, 1926 Printed in the United States of America To DR. EDWARD C. STREETER In memory of a pleasant collaboration PREFACE II ^HE intention of this slight per- formance is philosophical rather than historical. There is nothing new about the facts, which I have arranged in a certain way in order to stimulate thought. The facts and figurations of pre- historic and primitive art are due to the archeologists and explorers who discovered them and to Charcot, Richer and Hollander, who have interpreted these findings for the benefit of the medical profession. The relation of Greek sculpture to athletics and to muscular physiology is self-evident in the statuary of the Hellenic and Hellen- istic periods. The unpublished anatomic 7 PREFACE diagrams of the Middle Ages have been exhumed and interpreted by Professor Karl Sudhoff. How the Florentine artists of the Quattrocento outpaced the professional anatomists in knowledge of muscular anat- omy acquired by dissecting, has been in- vestigated and elucidated by Dr. Edward C. Streeter, whose promised book on the sub- ject will fdl a long-felt want. The wonderful physiological anatomy of Leonardo da Vinci has been subjected to minute analysis by Forster, Holl, Roth and Arnold Klebs. Some of the ground covered herein has already been traversed by Dr. Streeter and myself in "Sculpture and Painting as Modes of Anatomical Illustration" (1919). All the various trends of recent investigation in the history of anatomy are indicated en passant in Dr. Robert Fletcher's memorable essay, "Anatomy and Art." 8 PREFACE My immediate object is to demonstrate a thesis or theorem of Fletcher's, to the effect that the real content of artistic anatomy is not descriptive anatomy but ethnic morphology, physiology and pathol- ogy. This fact is of considerable interest to the practitioner, who, in bedside diagnosis, must cultivate something of the vision and the discriminating intelligence of the artist. The underlying thought suggested by the pictures herewith presented is this: Leonardo da Vinci and the unknown paleo- lithic artist, who carved the Venus of Willen- dorf, are really in the same trend, in respect of a natural faculty for acute, spontaneous (virtually clinical) observation. The primi- tives who fashioned achondroplasic and hydrocephalic dwarfs without knowing what they mean, the Spanish artist who rendered endocrine obesity on canvas, are really in 9 PREFACE the same case with Hippocrates, who described unknown diseases without label- ling them. The diagnosis tags were affixed long after by Emile Littre. The recent revival of Konstitutionslehre, which now has a special periodical of its own, is implicit in Lady Chettam's remark about her family physician: "Hicks was coarse and butcher- like, but he understood my constitution." The sense of this doctrine of the constitu- tion is to the effect that facial appearance and configuration of the body often convey certain outward diagnostic signs of inward metabolic or endocrine disorder, as well as of infectious disease. In lepra, tubercle and many another puzzling condition, infection may be, as Allbutt surmised, "the touchstone of diathesis" (Pettenkofer'sy-factor). In culti- vating the faculty of vision in bedside medicine, the student may learn something 10 PREFACE from such shrewd observers of human nature as explorers, artists, novelists and men of the world. The locus classicus is Richard Bright's memorable address of 1832 ("By the eye you will learn much"). The modern physician has at his beck and call the accumulated knowledge of the past; yet without what astronomers call the gift of good seeing, he is no physician at all. Extreme examples of this cultivation of visual perception are the snap diagnoses of Corvisart, Hebra, Da Costa and Joseph Bell of Edinburgh (the original of Sherlock Holmes), who could usually tell the occupa- tion as well as the disease of the patient as he entered the room. The recent slogan, "Back to the old family doctor," is a nat- ural reaction against the kind of machine- made, official medicine described by Billings as fain to "legislate a new layer of cortical 11 PREFACE gray matter into, or a cirrhosed liver out of a man." As a consequence of the self-Prussian- ization necessary to win the European war, we no longer make use of our minds, as the harp-player his harp or the flute-player his flute, but, like the unfortunate people of the Middle Ages, submit to have our thinking done for us in categories, because we our- selves have come to think in categories. Are we as well off in this respect as the untutored savage sculptor of Benin? When he sees an achondroplasic, he figures him realistically as an achondroplasic without knowing why, but not as a stage-angel, endowed with wondrous, mystic potentiali- ties. Americans are now regarded in Europe as the most legal-minded and legalistic of all peoples, given over to a timorous, superstitious reverence for verbiage, to a belief that people can be reformed by multi- 12 PREFACE farious rules, arbitrarily imposed, rather than through that spontaneous receptivity to scientific ideas and liberal sentiments which is in every decent, fair-minded indi- vidual. In the scientific regulation of alco- holism, divorce and suchlike, the Scandi- navian peoples are already a century ahead of us, while our criminal law, designed to protect the people from actual crime, tends to become "a scrap of paper." We are vic- timized by the timorous crowd psychology, the half-baked ideality and herd instincts of collectivism. There is plenty of Vernunft about, but a distinct decline in Verstand, in the robust power to "think straight and to see clear," which is found alike in cab- drivers, great artists and the old-fashioned bedside doctor of the past, who did wonder- ful things without artificial eyes to help him. Yet "being an American" was once a state 13 PREFACE of mind, the cast of mind which, in Henry James' reading of it, "indulges in boundless liberty of appreciation but upon which nothing imposes itself for long together." The remedy lies exactly there, away from the "discontinuous legal mind" of Rowland's aversion, out into the broad humanistic vista of mind in motion, which sees the world "from China to Peru," the kind of vision and intelligence that Leonardo and Goethe and Osler had. Washington, D. C. March, 1926. F. H. G. 14 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Initial from Vesalius; Fabrica, Basle, 1543 p. 17 Venus of Willendorf (Middle Aurignacian Period) facing p. 20 Recumbent female figure from Hal Saflieni, Malta facing p. 22 Neolithic figurines from Hagiar Kim, Malta.... facing p. 22 Neolithic figurines from Malta and Gozo facing p. 22 Achondroplasic dwarf gods of Egypt facing p. 22 Endocrine obesity. Painting by Juan Carino de Miranda (1614-85) facing p. 24 Achondroplasic figures in bronze from Benin, Africa facing p. 28 Faience figures of female votary from sanctuary at Knossos, Crete facing p. 30 Apollo of Tenea (Circa 600 b.c.) facing p. 30 Coil of intestines ex voto from Mycenae (600 b.c.) facing p. 30 Nike of Paionios (420 b.c.) facing p. 30 Doryophorus of Praxiteles (Fifth Century, B.c.). facing p. 30 Five Picture Series, from a medieval Persian MS. in the India Office, London facing p. 34 Five Picture Series, from MS. in Library at Stockholm facing p. 36 15 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Schematic eye. (From Sloane MS. No. 981, British Museum). 14th Century P-37 Rock-carving of Gautama Buddha from Gand- hara (Lahore Museum) facing p. 38 Aztec and Thibetan figures, presumably from the Five Picture Series facing p. 40 Physiological anatomy of muscles of leg (Leon- ardo da Vinci) facing p. 48 Drawing by Leonardo, showing muscular exertion as anatomia animata facing p. 50 Dissection of thigh by Leonardo, showing injec- tion of blood-vessels facing p. 50 A drawing by Leonardo, showing correct curva- ture of spine facing p. 52 16 THE PRINCIPLES OF ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION BEFORE VESALIUS HHE principles of an art or science, of an ethi- cal, financial, political or military system, are the basic ideas which inform and activate the minds of its practi- tioners in a given place and time. Thus, the principles of bedside practice of medicine or of evacuation of wounded soldiers from the battlefield were obviously different in different periods and countries, frequently to the detriment of the sick and wounded themselves. The principles of surgery before the days of anesthesia and antisepsis, in other words, 17 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION the modes of thought of surgeons prior to 1847 and 1867, seem strange and fantastic to us today, when even bacteriology is resolving itself into biochemistry, physical chemistry and the physics of ions and electrons. As conveyed in the material now acces- sible, the principles of pre-Vesalian ana- tomic illustration are two-fold: First, servile adherence to tradition, and therefore faulty rudimentary delineation, in manuscript hand-drawings and printed diagrams down to the time of Leonardo da Vinci (with isolated exceptions). Second, admirable first-hand observation of the external con- figuration of the body in the drawings, paintings and sculptures of all genuine artists (prehistoric, primitive or pre-Vesa- lian), inclusive of Leonardo. The content of the first category (diagrammatic anat- omy) is, like all pattern and copy-book work, static and stationary; a species of observation and delineation not much better than that of modern school-children. The rationale of such anatomy is that of Galen's 18 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION De usu partium or of the Bridgewater treatises: an attempt to deduce the nature of a structure from the presumable func- tion assigned to it by the Creator ("Struc- ture follows function"). The content of the second category (artistic or morphologic anatomy) is dynamic, vital and progressive, and (in the dictum of Dr. Robert Fletcher)1 physiological and pathological, rather than descriptive. Artistic anatomy may sub- serve the didactic aims of anatomical illustration either purposefully or inciden- tally, with or without intention; but here we continually realize, even in the artistic productions of paleolithic or neolithic man, that physiology is, in Haller's phrase, "animated anatomy" (anatomia animato), while pathology is "altered physiology" (disturbance of function). From the very start, the prehistoric artist appears to have been, sans le savoir, an acute observer of morphology, physiology and pathology, as far as the external configuration of the body was concerned. 1 Fletcher: Anatomy and Art. Washington, 1895, 3-4. 19 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION The earliest known figure representing the human frame is a limestone statuette of a nude woman of the Aurignacian or quater- nary period (40,000-16,000 b.c.), 4^ inches high, found by Szombathy in the deep loess at Willendorf, on the left bank of the Danube, and known as the "Venus of Willendorf." The physical habitus of the figure is distinctly negroid, that of the "Hottentot Venus" of Maupertuis. The gigantic breasts and buttocks (steatopygy) of the prehistoric and primitive woman are thrown into strong relief; the head is bowed over the breasts, so that the face is indistinguishable; the arms, ornamented with bracelets, are crossed over the breasts, and while the feet are missing, the calf of the leg, though full, is small in compari- son with the huge haunches. The hair is arranged in a cascade of curls, like the coiffure of Egyptian, Grecian and later Roman women. The depositions of fat were probably due, as Osborn surmises, to a diet rich in fat and bone-marrow, and to the sedentary life and confinement of 20 Venus of Willendorf (Middle Aurignacian Period). ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION women to caves in the glacial period. The figure summarizes the physiological con- cept of the female organism as, like the ovum, a sessile, conservative, physiological system, or, in the engineering phrase, an adiabatic system or storehouse of energy, in that dissipation of energy is inhibited (by the environmental milieu). In any case, this figure conveys all that is known of the physiological habitus and metabolism of prehistoric women, while the general obesity and lipomatosis of the buttocks tend toward the pathological. It is plain that the pre- historic woman did not take much outdoor exercise, and it is also highly probable that this physical habitus, that of the "plump and pleasing person" who is normally "fat, good-natured and motherly," was highly acceptable to prehistoric man. Simi- lar sculptures of the Cro-Magnon artists, such as the "Venus of Brassempouy," and other figurines in bone, soapstone or talc, from the caves and excavated areas of Laugerie Basse, Mas'Azil, Mentone, Sireuil, Trou-Magrite and Laussel, have the same 21 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION obesity. A good example is the sculptured bas-relief in limestone found by M. Gaston Lalanne at Laussel, representing a nude Auriginacian woman, 18 inches high, with large, pendent mammae and exaggerated haunches, holding a buffalo horn in her uplifted right hand; or the rock-painting in red and black in the cave at Cogul (Lerida) in Spain, representing nine danc- ing women, with pendulous breasts, nar- row waists, flaring hips, bell-shaped skirts and mantillas. In the many statuettes of women in baked clay or limestone, found in the neolithic sanctuaries of Malta and Gozo, and described by Zammit and Singer,1 the buttocks, breasts, thighs, extremities and general girth are represented as immensely adipose; in the recumbent female figure from Hal Saflieni (Malta) incredibly so. A fair representation of the spine is afforded in the pregnant or tumefied figure, with gigantic breasts, from Mnaidra (Malta). In many of these prehistoric statuettes, such 1 T. Zammit and C. Singer: J. Roy. Antbrop. Inst., Lond., 1924, liv, 67-100, 16 pl. 22 Recumbent female figure from Hal Saflieni, Malta. (Zummii and Singer.) Neolithic figurines from Hagiar Kim, Malta. (Zammit and Singer.') Neolithic figurines from Malta and Gozo. (Zammit and Singer.) Achondroplasic dwarf gods of Egypt. (Hollander.') ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION as those from the Grimaldi caves (Mentone) or the Maltese neolithic sanctuaries, the hypertrophied breasts, huge haunches and characteristic lipomatosis of the but- tocks are blocked out in the rough, in con- formity with the tenets of recent Cubist art. From the Maltese figurines, Singer infers that obesity, in neolithic times, was somehow associated with the idea of god- head. A startling likeness to this partic- ular physical habitus is to be found in such figures as the Queen of Punt in bas-relief on the walls of the temple of Deir el Bahri (Cairo Museum), in many women on the Assyro-Babylonian bas-reliefs, in the sculp- tures of female dancing figures in the rock- caves of India and Ceylon, in some repre- sentations of Cretan women excavated by Sir Arthur Evans at Knossos, and in the actual physical conformation of living primi- tive African women, of Jewesses of Tunis, artificially fattened upon fenugrec, or of Spanish and other women, inclined to over- indulgence in food and indolent habit of body (fiesta and siesta). That an exag- 23 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION gerated protrusion of the buttocks tends toward the pathological is indicated by the physical conformation in the particular lipomatosis known as lipodystrophia pro- gressiva. It is highly significant that this condition was first noted in Spain by Barraquer in 1906. That extreme obesity, whether exogenous (hereditary, racial, sex- ual) or endogenous (endocrine, metabolic, achondroplasic), tends toward the patho- logical can be verified by the evidence of actual patients or photographs of patients. On the other hand, wherever paleolithic and neolithic artists have represented male anatomy, as in the case of the warrior de- picted in bas-relief at Laussel, the image usu- ally features the broad shoulders, straight flanks, narrow hips, hard muscles and erect posture of the athlete par excellence. Thus, the content of prehistoric artistic anatomy is at once morphological, physiological and pathological, as Fletcher's theorem main- tains. At the same time, the line engrav- ings and mural paintings of animals exe- cuted by prehistoric man on stone and bone 24 Endocrine obesity. Painting by Juan Carino de Miranda [1614-85]. ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION convey a startling visualization of le mouve- ment; in other words, the artist's intuitive knowledge of outward manifestations of the physiology of muscle and nerve. Ethno- graphic parallels with this prehistoric art are to be found in the paintings and engravings on the walls of caves by Bushmen of South Africa, Esquimaux and North American Indians, in the Assyro-Babylonian bas- reliefs representing lion-hunting, and in the battle friezes and athletic groups of Hellen- istic art, which reveal the importation of primitive and Oriental elements, in that passion (pathos) and muscular contraction (animus) are substituted for the immortal repose (ethos) and physical dignity (anima) of true Hellenic sculpture in its prime. In keen intuitive sense of the external manifestations of metabolism and its dis- orders, there is no essential difference be- tween prehistoric and primitive art, whether in the paleolithic productions in the caves of Dordogne, Laussel or Alpera or in the artistic productions of living primitives all over the world. The figures are startlingly 25 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION alike. Here the time-relation, in Einstein's theory, is illusory, transcendental and fourth- dimensional; or as Carlyle put it, "Time has only a relative existence." Apart from figurations of prehistoric women, whose lives were static and sta- tionary and whose metabolism was adia- batic, prehistoric and primitive art are usually animistic, tending to vitalize inani- mate objects, in aid of portraying action and movement rather than perfection of form. In this regard, such art bears a strik- ing resemblance to the drawings, paintings and carvings of the insane1. The primitive (undeveloped) mind and the defective mind are tangent, coincident and identical at several points. There is pungency in the neat observation of Thoreau that while idiocy is half-witted, genius is once and a half witted. Everybody, as Osler said, has "a sane spot somewhere." Prehistoric, primi- tive and paranoiac art differs, therefore, from the art of developing civilized children as 'On this head see, G. Marro, Ann, di freniat., Turin, 1913, xxiii, 157-192. 26 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION being, in the main, physioplastic (original, physiological, dynamic) rather than ideo- plastic (imitative, lifeless, static). This is conditioned by the fact that thought itself is a function of speech and language. Pre- historic and primitive man had either sign- language (North American Indians, Sicil- ians) or a few grunts at best to convey his wishes and desires; he had to learn to count his fingers and toes before he could become an efficient star-gazer or land- surveyor; while savage arithmetic is the strangest chapter in the theory of numbers. In the savage, as Holmes has shown,1 the tendency to make and copy pattern-figures must follow upon the development of primitive metric and geometric knowledge. The growing infant in civilization, on the other hand, is learning to speak, to count and to follow copy (patterns) every day of its waking life. Civilized man is himself, in Matthew Arnold's phrase, a "frivolous baby," who requires manifold XW. H. Holmes: Rep. Bureau EtbnoL, 1882-3, Wash., 1886, iv, 443-465. 27 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION devices to nurse, feed, clothe, protect and bury him, usually does what he is told and tends to copy and imitate rather than to originate anything for himself. Cubist art is an attempt to hark back to the childhood of the race by hineinstudiren, to realize and visualize the feeling of pre- historic and primitive man about the body. Our passion for the movies is only the passion of the prehistoric and primitive within us for life as a mode of motion. It reaches its apogee in people whose lives are static and circumscribed. That the content of primitive sculpture is frequently pathological is evidenced by innumerable Egyptian, Maltese, Pompeian and Peruvian figurines representing achon- droplasic and hydrocephalic dwarfs. Just as neolithic man (in Singer's theory) tended to deify obesity, so achondroplasia was, in a manner, deified in the dwarf- gods of Egypt. The bronze statuettes in medieval armor, executed by the natives of Benin (Africa), are often unmistakably achondroplasic, sometimes with the pro- 28 Achondroplasic figures in bronze from Benin, Africa. ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION trusion or lipomastosis of the buttocks so characteristic of many African negroes. Endocrine disorders are indicated in many specimens of primitive sculpture and cer- amics. We find representations of cutaneous lesions in Peruvian pottery. Charcot found glosso-Iabio-Iingual paralysis in one of the gargoyles of Santa Maria Formosa in Venice. The natural talent for acute obser- vation in these unknown primitive artists shows plainly enough that, in some other relation of space and time, they might have been, with some reservations, effective clinicians. I n the later phases of Egyptian and Assyro- Babylonian art, there is revealed a striking sense of beauty, as in the stately figures of Isis and Osiris or the bas-reliefs representing the mother-goddess Ishtar. In Cretan, Mycenaean and later Hellenic art, one can trace the evolution of a statue from the upright pillar or column, the image first appearing as a crude ikon with no differen- tiation of the eyes or limbs. In the well- executed images of the Cretan mother-god- 29 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION dess found by Evans at Knossos, the exposed breasts are figured in sophisticated modern manner, and the gowns are of approved Parisian cut. The outward pre- sentment is that of a lady of fashion. In the Apollo of Tenea (600 b.c.), the pectoral, deltoid, biceps, gluteal, soleus, popliteal and other outstanding muscles are already well modelled, as is also the bony conformation, while flanks, hips and pre- patellar region are unmistakably masculine in character. The Doryophorus of Praxi- teles (5th century b.c.), the Apoxyomenos and Borghese warrior of Lysippus, the Nike of Paionios and the Laocoon of the Rhodian School are already supreme tri- umphs of the accurate anatomical figura- tion of bodily beauty in a seemingly intract- able medium, all the more remarkable in that the knowledge conveyed of the statics and dynamics of muscular physiology was acquired by observation alone. The stone ex-voto representing a coil of intestines, excavated by Schliemann at Mycenae, is far superior, in anatomical accuracy, to 30 Faience figures of female votary from sanctuary at Knossos, Crete. (Sir Arthur Evans.) Apollo of Tenea (Circa 600 b.c.). Coil of intestines ex voto from Mycenae (600 B.C.). Nike of Paionios (420 b.c.). Doryophorus of Praxiteles (Fifth Century, B.C.). ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION anything of the kind in Vesalius. In the figure of the Amazonian warrior on the metopes of the Parthenon, noted by Wald- stein, the pectineus muscle, in the bottom of Scarpa's triangle, is thrown into relief, although invisible in repose, a striking example of the Greek sculptor's power to record what he actually saw, even where the structure was unknown to him as such. The semblance of blindness is wonderfully conveyed in the harp-players of the Egyp- tian bas-relief on the temple at Sakkarah and in the various Greek busts of Homer. The Egyptian musicians are unmistakably blind. Thus, Paul Jamin's picture (School of Anthropology, Paris), of the prehistoric artist executing one of the mural paintings of bison in the Altamira caves, or the medal of the Royal College of Surgeons, showing Galen as he inspects the robbers' skeleton (the only human skeleton he ever saw), symbolize that power of natural observation, heightened by acute perception of values, which was the sole source of information 31 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION possessed by prehistoric and primitive man, or by the Greek physician, as to the external configuration of the human or animal body, its underlying framework, its physiology and even its pathology. The knowledge of the muscles and of the viscera gained by Egyptian embalmers was probably rudi- mentary and negligible. Galen's knowledge of the muscles and viscera was acquired by dissection of the lower animals, usually apes and swine, set off by such observation of the heart and other viscera as could be obtained from the sacrifice of horned cattle at the altars of the gods (Opferanatomie). The clay models of the sheep's liver used by the Assyro-Babylonians for purposes of divination, as also the bronze Etruscan livers (of sheep), were not didactic in inten- tion. Some general knowledge of human anatomy was, of course, gained by Greek and Roman army surgeons in the treatment of battle wounds and later through opera- tive surgery. In the Middle Ages, there was also a crude huntsman's and butcher's anatomy, the culinary anatomy of the 32 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION slaughter-pen and the kitchen, derived from the sacrificial anatomy of the Greeks and Romans, and comprising the topography of the edible portions of the bodies of animals. The Fluchanatomie, or anatomical blasphemies of the medieval Germans, consisted in taking in vain the names of different parts of God's body,1 as in the "'s blood" (God's blood) or "'s nails" (God's nails) of English sailors, a vernacular mode of anatomical nomenclature as crude and futile as Walt Whitman's catalogue of the parts of the human body in "Children of Adam." Up to the time of the great Florentine painters of the 14th century, early medieval human anatomy was based upon servile adherence to the traditional Galenic anat- omy of apes, swine, sheep and oxen, eked out by such knowledge of the human frame as could be gained from the few dissections permitted or permissible in the time. Ex 1SudhofF: Mittelalterliche deutsche Schwur- und Fluch- anatomie Gottes aus dem 14. Jahrhundert. Mitt. z. Gescb. d. Med., Leipz., 1913, xii, 265. 33 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION voto figures, representing the different parts of the body healed by divine intervention, continued to be made, even under the Christian dispensation and are still to be seen, in considerable number, in some parts of Germany, Austria and Italy. There is, however, a tradition, based upon the explicit statement of Aristotle himself, that ana- tomical "paradigms, schemata and dia- graphs"1 were used by him in teaching human anatomy and it is believed that these were subsequently employed in teach- ing by the great anatomists of the Alex- andrian school. Of these, Herophilus and Erasistratus not only dissected human subjects but described many new structures. The charts attributed to Aristotle and the Alexandrians were probably the origins of didactic, diagrammatic or traditional anatomic illustration, which, Sudhoff sur- mises, is traceable either to the Nile valley or the plains of Mesopotamia (Nil- Babel). Among the manuscript illustrations 1 irapaSelypara, axvPaTa> Stay pa<f>i. Aristotle: Degeneratione animalium, i, 7. Cited by Choulant. 34 FIVE PICTURE SERIES From a Medieval Persian MS. in the India Office, London. (Sudhoff.) ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION of the early Middle Ages, there is a series of five traditional schematic diagrams, called by Sudhoff the "Five Picture Series" (funfbilderserie), examples of which occur, with startling frequency and monotony of pattern, in China, Thibet, Japan, Persia, Yucatan and all over western Europe. These represent the bones, muscles, nerves, veins and arteries, to which a sixth figure, of the Gravida or pregnant woman, or a view of the male or female generative organs, was sometimes added. The attitude of these figures, in five-picture charts found all over Europe and Asia through several centuries, is invariably the squatting pos- ture familiar in the child's jumping-jack or the reflex frog of the laboratory. The stereotyped attitude, gazing rigidly forward, as in all Egyptian and early Greek sculpture, points, as Sudhoff surmises, to Hellenic, eventually Alexandrian provenance. Like the zodiac-manikins in the Purgation and Blood-letting Calendars of the Middle Ages, which they so much resemble in general attitude and rudimentary anatomy, these 35 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION figures of the Five Picture Series were obviously intended as mere memoranda or mnemonic schemata, to standardize what little was known, or otherwise to refresh the memory. As Sudhoff has shown, little in these pictures was based upon original observation or dissection. Most are merely servile copies derived from some remote tradition of the past, perhaps from the pseudo-Aristotelian "paradigms, schemata and diagraphs" of Hellenistic Alexandria. How servile and helpless this tradition, may be sensed from the fact that the schema of the nervous system in the Bodleian MS. of 1162, discovered by Sir Victor Horsley, is exactly like that in a 14th century MS. in the library of Prince von Lobkowicz (Raudnitz, Bohemia), exe- cuted two hundred years later. The many manuscript drawings of the schematic eye, described by Hirschfeld, Pansier, Sudhoff and others, are all monotonously alike, whether in Arabic or in medieval European manuscripts of successive centuries. The eye consists merely of a scheme of con- 36 FIVE PICTURE SERIES From MS. in Library at Stockholm. (By kind permission of Professor Karl Sudhoff.) ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION Schematic eye. (From Sloane MS. No. 981, British Museum). 14th Century. 37 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION centric circles, representing its tunics, al- though the crossing of the optic nerves is shown in MS. No. 924 in the New Mosque at Constantinople. The same crudity is apparent in the many abortive schemes of phrenology (localization of the functions of the brain) or the 13th century schema of the uterus and adnexa in the Bodleian Library (Ashmole MS. 399). All are equally crude, diagrammatic, rudimentary, and re- veal the almighty power of tradition in the Middle Ages.1 The barber shop skeleton of Richard Helain (1493), one of the many fugitive anatomic plates printed for the use of barber-surgeons and bath-keepers, is copied without change in the skeletons of Griininger (1493) and Johann Schott (1517). These skeletons are, however, an improvement on the dancing and tipsy skeletons figured by the Greeks on wine- cups and vases, in that some attempt is made to represent all the bones, with legends at 1 For specimen illustrations, apart from those given here- with, see the chapter on pre-Vesalian MS. illustrations by the late Dr. Mortimer Frank, in his translation of Choulant's History of Anatomic Illustration, Chicago, 1920, 49-87. 38 Rock-carving of Gautama Buddha from Gandhara (Lahore Museum). ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION the side, giving their names. The Greek skeletal figure was always a memento mori, of Epicurean intention. The skeletons and eviscerated corpses in the Books of Hours and Shepherd's Calendars of the Middle Ages are, like the omnipresent skeleton in Holbein's Dance of Death, symbols of the medieval concept of death as the King of Terrors. Some of the skeletons in these illuminated MSS. are spectral skin and bone figures (the Haut- skelett or Lemurengestalt of Sudhoff), with quaint little clowns or jesters between the legs, a kind of trade-mark of this family of pictures, which probably derive from the association of the medieval miniature paint- ers with the great artists who had begun to dissect the body.1 The eviscerated figures in 1 The same mummy-like appearance (Hautskelett) is charac- teristic of the skeletal figures of the seated Buddha found in Gandhara (Northwest India), in the rock-carving of the god- dess Kali in the temple at Elura (near Bombay) or in the mural paintings recently found by Griinwedel and LeCoq in temples of East Turkestan, all which are plainly of Hellenistic provenance. The spectral appearance (Lemur en- gestalt) of the Thibetan figures herewith presented suggests that all these figures had some common origin, and may have 39 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION the Books of Hours, curious illustrations, indeed, for a prayer-book, are plainly derived from this association of physician and artist in dissection. Our knowledge of this phase of the history of anatomy is due to the investigations of Streeter. Up to the beginning of the 13th century, anatomical teaching was based upon the dissection of animals, as set forth in the Galenic primer of porcine anatomy attrib- uted to the Salernitan Copho. During the 13th century, dissecting was mainly superseded by the Arabist tendency to teach anatomy entirely by the printed text. The famous bull De Sepulturis of Pope Boniface viii (1300) was, as Neuburger and Walsh have shown, directed against the boiling and dismembering of the bodies of the dead Cru- saders, as a preliminary to storing them in jars for transportation from the East. But the general popular feeling of the time was been brought into the plains of Mesopotamia and Turkestan by the expedition of Alexander the Great. The Greek word skeletos signifies, in fact, a mummified or dried-up human body. See R. Miiller: Die Umscbau, Frankfurt a.M., 1925, xxix, 154. 40 (i) Aztec and (2, 3) Thibetan figures, presumably from the Five Picture Scries. ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION against dissection of the human body, for the obvious reason that people feared the possible desecration of their own bodies or those of relatives. The earliest authorized dissections, such as those of Guglielmo da Varignana (1302) or of Mundinus (1315) at Bologna, were, in reality, post mortems. The thirteen miniature paintings in a surgi- cal manuscript of Henri de Mondeville (1314) and the eighteen colored figures in the MS. Anatomic of Guido de Vigevano (1345) are evidences of the newer tendency. These drawings are crude, diagrammatic, schematic, as in the Five Picture Series, but they go to show that 14th century physicians and surgeons were beginning again to dissect the human body. The Vigevano pictures, in particular, are actually designed to illustrate the technique of dissection. The Anatomy of Mundinus (1316) is also a primer or horn-book of dissecting. Dissection, however, remained, as Neuburger points out, a showy, occasional feature of medieval teaching, usually con- ducted with public pomp and ceremony. 41 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION The dissecting was commonly done by an assistant while the teacher expounded the structures by the book. There was little advance in knowledge of structure. The Vigevano pictures show visceral schemata like an inverted bag-pipe and spinal columns resembling a Malay kreese. The normal curvature of the spine was first delineated by Leonardo and was not even known to the young Vesalius. The skeletons, visceral schemata and reclining pregnant woman of the Five Picture Series continued to be stock figures even down to the period before the French Revolution, when Gautier d'Agoty executed them life-size in oil. The five-Iobed liver, seven-segmented sternum, horned uterus, bolt upright fetus, faulty tilt of the spine and pelvis and other errors of tradi- tional anatomy were not corrected in the manuscript hand drawings until the advent of Leonardo da Vinci. The printed woodcuts before Vesalius, such as those of Peyligk (1499), Hundt (1501) and Reisch (1503), are not much better in execution than a child's scratchings on slate or paper. It was 42 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION not until 1517 that Lorenz Fries, who made the first map containing the name "America," published fairly accurate pic- tures of the brain, the tongue and the vis- cera. Thus the Middle Ages were backward and non-progressive in descriptive or didactic anatomy, but, as we shall see, extremely forward in artistic or morphologic anatomy. The impulse to study human anatomy by frequent dissection and to make accurate drawings of the structures was to come, not from the physician-anatomists, but from an unexpected source, the great Florentine painters of the Quattrocento. As Streeter has shown,1 this advance was effected in a truly remarkable way. Early in the 14th century, the Florentine painters were in the habit of buying their pigments at the apothecary shops, where the physi- cians also foregathered. This association bred fraternal feeling, and as early as 1303, the artists applied for admission to the Florentine "Guild of Physicians andApothe- 1 Streeter, E. C.: The role of certain Florentines in the history of anatomy, artistic and practical. Johns Hopkins Hosp. Bull., Baltimore, 1916, xxvii, 113-118. 43 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION caries," which the great Masaccio himself joined, first as an apothecary (in 1421), later as a painter (1423). "This guild relation- ship," says Streeter, "endured for more than two and a half centuries, furnishing innumerable points of magnetic contact between science and art." Artist and physi- cian "were thrown together in all the multi- form guild-functions; they sat together in the same guild council, walked together under the same banner in pageants." Some apothecaries' apprentices, such as Masolino or Cosimo Roselli, eventually became, like Lucas Cranach in Germany, great painters. Giotto was a friend of the physicians Dino del Garbo and Torrigiani. Luca della Robbia and the pathologist Benivieni were friends, as were Francia and the anatomist Achillini, or Leonardo and Marc Antonio della Torre. Beginning with Giotto, it was the ambi- tion of all these artists to get away from the flat, two-dimensional, Byzantine mosaic manner of Giotto's teacher, Cimabue, into the great field of figure-painting in which depth and solidity (the third dimension) 44 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION are realized on canvas. Giotto did this, like Renoir long after him, through sheer force of genius. His assistant, Stefano, called "the ape of nature," became so skilful in depicting the branching veins that, as Streeter relates, barber-surgeons studied his pictures before opening a vein. The passion for realism expended itself, however, in elaborate studies of perspective and anthropometry. All the great treatises on human proportion, except Durer's, came out of Florence (Streeter). But through intimate contact with the physicians, the artists began to see the advantage of dissect- ing, which had been authorized and eluci- dated in the Florentine University Statutes of 1387. The painters at first assisted at the dissections conducted by their doctor friends and then began to dissect for themselves. The first artist to take up the scientific study of anatomy was apparently Donatello (1386-1466), whose interest in the subject is perpetuated in his bronze tablet, "The Anatomy of the Miser's Heart." Of Dona- tello's pupil, Pollajuolo, Vasari says: "He 45 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION dissected many bodies to study the anatomy, and was the first to investigate the actions of the muscles in this manner, that he might afterwards give them their due place and effects in his works."1 Myology and the physiological effect of muscular action on the outer contour of the body were, in fact, the only phases of anatomy studied by these artists in their dissections, but the outcome was wonderful. From Donatello to Veroc- chio, the teacher of Leonardo, there is an unbroken line of truly great artists, whose sculpture and figure-painting were based entirely upon dissection and natural obser- vation. From Pollajuolo's engraving of the "Battle of the Ten Nude Men" to Veroc- chio's myologic sketches and bronze flayed figures or Leonardo's cartoon of "The Battle of the Standard," and its rival, Michael Angelo's "Surprise, by the Pisans, of Floren- tine soldiers bathing in the Arno," there is everywhere evidence of solid competency in representing the nude male body in action. Dissecting the body had, in fact, 1 Cited by Streeter: Op. cit., 117. 46 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION become such commonplace procedure among the Florentine painters, that the jealous Vesalius exclaims: "As for those painters and sculptors who flocked around me at my dissections, I never allowed my- self to get worked up about them to the point of feeling that I was less favored than these men, for all their superior airs."1 Leonardo, himself, to forward his project of writing an anatomical treatise with Marc Antonio, did no less than fifty dissections in his lifetime, and made over 750 separate drawings from them. As Streeter says: "The influence of Leonardo upon practical anat- omy is decisive; he steps into a place of intolerant central glory." Leonardo da Vinci was the founder of artistic (morphological) and physiological anatomy. His hand drawings of human structure are beautiful, effective and several centuries in advance of his time. He was the greatest experimenter of the Renaissance. He had a wide-open interest in life, a genial personality, noble manners and the imper- 1 Streeter: Op. cit., 117. 47 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION sonal, disinterested spirit which makes for the active, receptive mind. He was not activated by gain but by a thirst for knowl- edge and remained poor throughout his life. As compared with Vesalius, Leonardo is the forerunner, pioneer and explorer, what Ostwald calls the Romanticist in science, who pushes into the unknown territory, takes all knowledge for his prov- ince, but of necessity, leaves much of his work inchoate or incomplete. Vesalius is the Classicist, who completes and rounds up a definite piece of work, leaving it in compact and well-ordered shape, as a practical guide and text for posterity. The Fabrica of Vesalius (1543) was described by Osler as "the greatest book ever printed, from which modern medicine dates." It disposed of the Galenic errors derived from dissection of the lower animals, systematized a vast amount of new knowledge, set a pace for all subse- quent textbooks of anatomy and its illus- trations were copied for centuries. Vesalius was withal a very able clinician, surgeon and pathologist, a pioneer in craniology and 48 Physiological anatomy of muscles of leg (Leonardo da Vinci). ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION comparative psychology, and with Leo- nardo, the only experimental physiologist of consequence between Galen and Harvey. Both Leonardo and Vesalius had the insati- able curiosity of the Renaissance people, and it is possible that Vesalius himself may have derived his plan for illustrating the Fabrica from seeing some of Leonardo's anatomical drawings. But, as compared with the superb draughtsmanship of the Leonardine Quaderni, the illustrations of the Vesalian Fabrica, done by the artist Calcar, are too conventional and sometimes too inaccurate to justify the charge of plagiarism sometimes raised. The drawings in the Fabrica are illustrations of the static, life- less, descriptive or didactic anatomy of which Vesalius was the true founder, and like the Five Picture Series, were copied and pilfered, as pattern-work, in after time. The drawings in the Quaderni are alive, dynamic, physiological, and are only coming to be generally known since their recent publica- tion. There is not a single drawing in the Quaderni which does not tell something new 49 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION about a given anatomical structure; there is hardly one which does not attempt to elucidate the physiology of that structure. For the first time in the history of anatomy, Leonardo delineated the true curvature of the spine, the correct posture of the fetus in utero, and the bones, muscles, nerves, arteries, veins and viscera as they really are. The beautiful drawing of a dissection of the thigh, herewith presented, shows that he undoubtedly had at command some means of injecting the blood-vessels. This drawing also shows the first accurate representation of the femur ever made. The drawings show- ing the effect of muscular action upon the external configuration of the lower limb are as vital and dynamic as any of the spirited photographs of nude male and female fencers made in Munich. Alongside any of Leonardo's drawings of muscular action, those ofVerocchio, Raphael, Michael Angelo seem accurate and praiseworthy but other- wise static and insipid. To convey what Leonardo conveyed, we now resort to the camera and the movies. Leonardo studied 50 Drawing by Leonardo showing muscular exertion as anatomia animata. Dissection of thigh by Leonardo, showing injection of blood-vessels. ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION the dynamics of antagonistic muscles by means of tape-models, with schematic drawings, showing effects of flexion, exten- sion, pronation and supination. He made cross sections of the skull, showing the rela- tion of the pneumatic sinuses, and sections of the eyeball, hardened in coagulated white of egg. He made wonderful casts of the ventricles of the brain by injection of wax into the third ventricle. He observed the close relation of the branches of the pul- monary artery to those of the bronchial tree and noted dilatation of the terminal bronchi. Like Galen, he studied the heart in cattle, noted the muscular bands traversing the ventricle in bovine hearts, and the atrio- ventricular band in the human heart, which Sudhoff has named after Leonardo. In an entirely modern spirit, Leonardo unrolled the valves of the heart, and drew them as a "geography of the heart" in a kind of orthogonal or Mercator's projection. In this, he anticipated Peter Camper, while in his tendency to give only as much of a structure in his drawings as is necessary for 51 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION its comprehension, he anticipated Henle, who styled this method of anatomical delin- eation "architectural." In Leonardo's great drawing of the situs viscerum, we have already "transparent" or photographic anat- omy (one structure shown above another). In his serial cross-sections of the lower limb and the skull and in his Venus obversa, an attempt to show the relation of the parts in copulation by a vertical slice through the participants, Leonardo is already well into the frozen-section anatomy of Pirogoff. There is hardly any device in anatomical method which he did not employ to get at the physiological function of a structure or organ. As Klebs observes: "The way in which he draws the normal curvatures of the spine, adjusts his skulls with a definite intention in a definite horizontal plane, and fixes the pelvic inclination, would make one think that he adopted the standards decided upon in the latest anatomic and anthro- pological congresses."1 1 Klebs, A. C.: Leonardo da Vinci and his anatomical studies. Bull. Soc. Med. Hist., Chicago, 1916, iv, 76. For an 52 A drawing by Leonardo showing correct curvature of spine. ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION Leonardo's notes upon these drawings, made in mirror-writing, whether from con- genital left-handedness or from a natural desire to stave off persecution, plagiarism and vulgar obloquy, constitute the rough outline of the text of the great treatise on anatomy, which he designed to write, in collaboration with Marc Antonio della Torre. Had it been published, physiologi- cal anatomy would have been a going science long before Harvey. As it is, Leo- nardo's drawings were scattered and for- gotten, until William Hunter (in 1784) and Blumenbach (in 1788) called attention to the collections in the Royal Library at Windsor. They were first published in entirety by Vangensten, Hopstock and Fon- ahn, in 1911-1916. On the other hand, the skeletons, muscle-men and visceral sche- mata in the Fabrica of Vesalius were copied analysis of Leonardo's investigations on the anatomy and physiology of the circulatory system, see Klebs, A. C.: Leonardo da Vinci's scientific research, with particular refer- ence to his investigations of the vascular system. Bost. M. & S. J., 1916, clxxv, 1; 45. 53 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION and improved upon for two centuries, with such independent excursions into descriptive (static) anatomy as Varolio's view of the brain, Aselli's colored woodcuts of the lymphatics, Wirsung's copperplate of the pancreatic duct, the exquisitely drawn male and female skeletons of Albinus and Soemmerring, William Hunter's atlas of uterine and placental anatomy, Mascagni's album of the lymphatics and Scarpa's wonderful delineations of the nerves of the heart. The unconscious followers of Leon- ardo have been men like Harvey, Leeuwen- hoek, Swammerdam, Malpighi, Redi, John Hunter, Johannes Miiller, Henle, and Leidy, whose minds were open and active and who were constantly moving into new territory. It is a fact of the utmost significance that such remarkable medical men as Cheselden, Scarpa, William Clift, Alibert, Richard Bright, Thomas Hodgkin, John and Charles Bell, Sir Robert Carswell, Sir Richard Owen, Jakob Henle, Max Schultze, Carl Ludwig, Joseph Leidy and Lord Lister were all accomplished artists and made their own 54 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION drawings. The young Pasteur made unique pastels of his parents. Charcot, like Renoir, decorated porcelain and made clever crayon caricatures of his colleagues. The surgeon, Sir Seymour Hayden, became one of the most prized of modern etchers. The actual number of physicians, surgeons and biolo- gists who have been talented with pen, pencil, burin or brush would be legion. Since the days of the great Florentine painters, artists have done little dissecting, obtaining better results nowadays from selected living models of athletic physique, from the records of the camera or from the movies. Eugene Delacroix, the last of the great painters to dissect, studied the viscera in situ. Yet his painting of Prome- theus (1829) has the liver on the wrong side. Meanwhile the use of the camera for clinical purposes is common procedure, and many albums of disease, like the Nouvelle Incono- grapbie de la Salpetriere, will doubtless be made. The completion of the six published volumes of Leonardo's Quaderni during 55 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION the dreary war period, and the intense and widespread interest awakened in them, is one of the most encouraging signs of our time. It will be a sad day for medicine when dry book-lore and laboratory medicine displace this combination of the seeing eye and the executive hand in physicians. But it is not necessary for the doctor to be an actual draughtsman, painter or sculptor. Vision and visualization, the power to synthetize, are the highest mental qualifica- tions the physician may have; and even where he does not possess "The low-pulsed craftsman's forthright hand," the real physician, born to the purple, will always be something of an artist in his way of seeing things. The doctor at the bedside cannot afford to think in categories. In the mental operations he performs, through the gift of good seeing, he is rather like that great Englishman, who so much resembled Leonardo in power of perception and of whom Helmholtz said: "With wonderful sagacity and intellectual precision, Faraday 56 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION performed in his brain the work of a great mathematician without using a single mathematical formula." References for Collateral Reading Parkyn, E. A. An Introduction to the Study of Prehistoric Art. 8°. London, 1915. Fletcher, Robert. Anatomy and Art. Bull. Phil. Soc., Washington, 1895, xii. Choulant; Ludvig. History and Bibliography of Anatomic Illustration. Translated by Mortimer Frank. 40. Chicago, 1920. Charcot, J. M. & Richer, P. Les Difformes et Ies Malades dans I'Art. 8°. Paris, 1889. Richer, Paul. L'Art et la Medecine. 40. Paris, [1902]. Hollander, Eugen. Plastik und Medizin. 40. Stutt- gart, 1912. Furtwangler, A. & Ulrichs, H. L. Greek and Roman Sculpture. Translated by Horace Taylor. 8°. London, 1914. Hyde, W. W. Olympic Victor Monuments and Greek Athletic Art. 40. Washington, Carnegie Institution, 1921. Sudhoff, Karl. Tradition und Naturbeobachtung. 40. Leipzig, 1907. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Anatomie im Mittelalter. 40. Leipzig, 1908. 57 ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION Garrison, F. H. & Streeter, E. C. Sculpture and painting as modes of anatomical illustration. Ann. Med. Hist., N. Y., 1919. ii, 305-329. Klebs, A. C. Leonardo da Vinci. Bull. Med. Hist. Soc., Chicago, 1916, 66-83; Boston M. & S. J., 1916, clxxv, 1; 45. The many splendid albums of primitive sculpture (Plastify of China, Manchuria, India, Africa and Polynesia, published of late by the Germans, are easily obtainable from any importer or dealer in artistic books. I would strongly advise any physician or anatomist visiting the Far East, the South Seas or Africa to obtain specimens of primitive Plastik, which, as in the Philippines, are purchasable for a trifling sum. An album of primitive and classical sculpture for physicians giving selected illustrations of artistic anatomy, would do much to stimulate interest in our subject. 58 Paul B. Hoeber, Inc. 67-69 East 59th Street New York, N. Y. HOEBER'S MEDICO' HISTORICAL PUBLICATIONS THE GOLD-HEADED CANE By William Macmichael With Introduction by Sir William Osler and a Preface by Francis R. Packard, m.d. The Gold-Headed Cane, owned by successive physicians who lived in the eighteenth century, here tells its own experiences of the distinguished men with whom it was associated. Written in the form of fiction, it is none the less a truthful and intimate account of the lives and activities of the famous kings' physicians, Radcliffe, Mead, Askew, Pitcairn and Baillie, and supplies, at the same time, a fasci- nating picture of the English society of the time. The story thus amounts to a history of the development of medicine in England in the eighteenth century. It is told with such human inter- est and in such a charming style, that every reader will have a delightful time in the companionship of this cultured and humorous friend of the great medical gentlemen of the past. The book has earned for itself so wide a popularity, that laymen and medical men alike pronounce it a classic in medical literature, and a book to be enjoyed heartily by everybody. 12 mo. Cloth, 292 Pages, 25 IIIus $3-75 net 1 HOEBER'S MEDICO-HISTORICAL BOOKS THE LIFE AND TIMES OF AMBROISE PARE With a New Translation of his Apology and an Account of his Journeys in Divers Places By Francis R. Packard, m.d. The Life and Times of the great French surgeon of the sixteenth century should be in every surgeon's library, and also in every physician's study. "The revelations of Pare the man put this volume in the list of unquestioned classics. Through it we hold easy converse with one of the achieving minds of the race. A fine, dry and crackling wit serves as a universal leaven; here is nothing sour or philo- sophical; even in profoundest counsels cheerfulness is always breaking out."-New York Evening Post. Large 8vo. Cloth, 309 Pages, 27 Full Page Plates, 22 Illustrations in the Text, and Two Folding Maps of Paris in the 16th and 17th Centuries. 2nd. Ed. $7.50 net GUY PATIN AND THE MEDICAL PROFESSION IN PARIS IN THE XVIITH CENTURY By Francis R. Packard, m.d. Dr. Packard in his charming, lucid, delightful style has picked out the most salient features in the unique life of Patin and those which shed much interesting light on medicine in the seventeenth century. The story of the surgeons and the barber-surgeons, the hostility that existed between the physicians of Paris and Montpellier, details of the common prac- tice of bloodletting and abortion are a few of the medico-historical phases with which this study of Guy Patin deals. 8vo, Cloth, 332 Pages, 17 Illustrations. . $4.00 net [Edition limited to 1000 copies] 2 HOEBER'S MEDICO-HISTORICAL BOOKS THE SCHOOL OF SALERNUM The English Version by Sir John Harington and the Regimen Sanitatis Salernitanum with an interest- ing History of the School of Salernum by Francis R. Packard, m.d., and a Note on the Prehistory of the Regimen Sanitatis by Fielding H. Garrison, m.d. The "Regimen Sanitatis" of the great medical School of Salernum was the compendium of domestic medicine of the eleventh century. It has passed through over 300 editions since. It is of particular interest today, when hygiene and prophylactics take precedence over all the specialities of medicine. This new edition was made at the request of the late Sir William Osler. I2mo, Cloth, 215 Pages, 22 Illustrations. . $3.75 net THE PRINCIPLES OF ANATOMIC ILLUSTRATION BEFORE VESALIUS An Inquiry into the Rationale of Artistic Anatomy By Fielding H. Garrison, m.d. This book attempts to demonstrate that artistic anatomy is of considerable value to the practitioner because of its revelations in ethnic morphology, physiology and pathology. The author stresses the cultivation by the doctor of that vision and discrim- inating intelligence with which the artist is gifted. A most valuable and suggestive book for the medical man. I2mo, Cloth, With 26 Full Page Plates. . In Press 3 HOEBER'S MEDICO-HISTORICAL BOOKS PEDIATRICS OF THE PAST A HISTORY AND AN ANTHOLOGY By John Ruhrah, m.d. With a Foreword by Fielding H. Garrison, m.d. This book is a history of the medical treatment and care of children, from the earliest times. The History is told in the words of the various famous physicians of the past, who wrote on the subject. Their statements have been arranged chronologically, so that these make up a progressive story of a fascinating interest. The book is at once history, biography and science, and so filled with human as well as scientific interest that its appeal is to the parent as well as to the pedia- trist. Every book of every writer of any importance has been called from for its scientific and human values. The result is a book of rare enjoyment and instruction. 8vo, Cloth, xxxvi + 592 Pages, with 18 Full Page Plates and 54 Illustrations in the text. $10.00 net WILLIAM CADOGAN [his essay on gout] By John Ruhrah, m.d. Cadogan's famous essay was first published nearly a century and a half ago. It created a sensation at the time, and went through ten editions in two years. It told the fashionable London world what was the matter with it, and how it could regain its health. The advice then given is as applicable today, and it is given in language which all can understand. i2mo, Cloth, 122 Pages, Frontispiece. . $1.50 net 4 HOEBER'S MEDICO-HISTORICAL BOOKS THE PEAKS OF MEDICAL HISTORY An Outline of the Evolution of Medicine, for the Use of Students and Practitioners By Charles L. Dana, a.m., m.d. A rapid survey of the special movements which marked the progress of Medicine. The book presents, briefly and consecutively, the main facts of the his- tory from pre-Hippocratic times down to the middle of the nineteenth century. 8vo, Cloth, Illustrated with numerous Portraits and Plates of the Oath of Hippocrates and the Oath of the Hindu Physician In Press THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE CHARAKA CLUB Named after a Hindoo Sage, the Hippocrates of India, this Club was organized in 1898 by a group of New York Physicians seeking recreation and stimulation through excursions into literary, artistic and historical fields. Its "Proceedings," of which six volumes have appeared to date, comprise essays, delightful, scholarly, amusing, and informing, on subjects allied to the history of medicine. Vol. 1 Out of print Vol. 2 Out of print Vol. 3, 8vo, 173 Pages, 18 Illustrations (Limited to 370 copies) $4.00 net Vol. 4, 8vo, 143 Pages, 32 Illustrations (Limited to 385 copies) $4.00 net Vol. 5, 8vo, 101 Pages, 15 Illustrations (Limited to 500 copies) $4.00 net Vol. 6, 8vo, 168 Pages, 5 Illustrations (Limited to 500 copies) $4.00 net 6 HOEBER'S MEDICO-HISTORICAL BOOKS BY SIR WILLIAM OSLER TWO INSPIRING ADDRESSES BY THIS DISTINGUISHED PHYSICIAN AND SCHOLAR ON A SANE AND HAPPY LIVING (1) AWAY OF LIFE By Sir William Osler, m.d. i6mo. Boards, 62 Pages $0.75 net (2) MAN'S REDEMPTION OF MAN A LAY SERMON By Sir William Osler, m.d. i6mo. Boards, 63 Pages $0.75 net "The lessons of life, as taught by Sir William Osler, will make life finer and brighter for us all, and . . . any thoughtful reader will enjoy these lectures and be the better for having read them." -Johns Hopkins Hosp. Bulletin "Delightful for gifts . . . Both these booklets are splendid reading and again demonstrate the broad culture, refinement and philosophy of this truly wonderful man."-Northwestern Medicine " It is not only well worth the price to read once, but it is worth the price every time a man reads it afterward, and it will be many times read by the fortunate possessor."-Medical World 6 HOEBER'S MEDICO-HISTORICAL BOOKS MONTAIGNE AND MEDICINE Being the Essayist's Comments on Contemporary physic and physicians, his Thought's on many Material Matters relating to Life and Death, an Account of his bodily Ailments and Peculiarities and of his Travels in search of Health. By James S. Taylor, m.d., f.a.c.s. The story of Montaigne's personal ailments, and the relations these brought him into with the medical men of his day, form one of the most interesting chapters of the great Frenchman's life. Dr. Taylor has told it with a rare knowledge of Montaigne's writings, and in a style of great charm. A delightful book for the physician's leisure hours-full of the wisdom of Montaigne's profound insight into human nature. 8vo, Cloth, 263 Pages, 22 Full Page Illustrations and 10 Text Illustrations $3.75 net NOSOGRAPHY IN MODERN INTERNAL MEDICINE By Knud Faber, m.d. With an introductory note by Rufus Cole, m.d. An excellent presentation of the inevitability of the present status of medicine, made from an inten- sive study of the history of the healing art. 8 vo, Cloth, 235 Pages, 21 Full Page Portraits. $3.75 net 7 HOEBER'S MEDICO-HISTORICAL BOOKS ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY Quarterly Periodical devoted to the History & Literature oj Medicine Francis R. Packard, Editor Associate Editors: Horace Manchester Brown; Harvey Cushing; Charles L. Dana; George Dock; Fielding H. Garri- son; Henry Barton Jacobs; Howard A. Kelly; Thomas McCrae; Lewis Stephen Pilcher; Sir D'Arcy Power; David Riesman; Sir Humphry Rolleston; John Ruhrah; Charles Singer; Edward C. Streeter; Casey A. Wood. Subscription $8.00 a Year [Vol. 8, 1926] A Few Back Sets Available. 7 vols., 1917-1925. Art binding, with paper labels, $10.50 per vol. In parts as published, $8.00 per vol. This Quarterly Periodical is devoted to the history and literature of medicine and medical men. The purpose for which it was founded is to offer the members of the medical profession a medium through which they could view the practice of their science and art in their cultural and humanistic fields. As befitting so ambitious an enterprise, the Annals is noble in its appearance and authoritative in its contents. "Age cannot wither nor custom stale the infinite variety" of the doctor's profession. The past history is as full of human interest as is its present practice. In every way it has contributed to the progress of our civilization. The Annals resurrects the past in the brilliant colors of literature, so that it lives again in these pages for our enjoyment and higher education. It is both a refreshment and a stimulus to read. When Sir William Osler received the first num- ber, he wrote: "Congratulations on your courage! With the active support of all the workers it will be a great success. I will do all I can." 8