*» ORATION ON EDUCATION, DELIVERED BEFORE THE SOCIETY FOR THE PROMOTION OP A RATIONAL SYSTEM OF EDUCATION, AND A NUMEROUS ASSEMBLY OF LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IN ST. JOHN'S CHURCH, NOVEMBER 7th 1811. B\ APPOINTMENT OF THE SOCIETY. WITH ANNOTATIONS. BY JAMES CUTBUSH, Vice Prendent of the Society, Lecturer on Chemistry, Member of tlit Philadelphia Linn<- ;.t and Agricultural Societies, Member of the Grand Lodge of fennsylvania, t[C. The senses arc the gifts of nature, and the primary regulators of our iictive powers. Prestos'. Our ideas are acquired through the medium of the senses L9CK0. PHILADELPHIA: PUBLISHED BY THE SOCIETY. Q, F. Goodman, Printer, 87, Callowhill street 1812, dt a meeting of the" Society for the promotion of a ra- tional system of Education," JVove jer Loth, 1811, the following resolution was adopted. "Resolved that the thanks of this society be pre- sented to Dr. James Cutbush for the excellent Oration on Education, delivered by him in St. John's Church, and that he be requested to favour the society with a copy for publication." Extract from the Minutes. John Bachman, Secretary. ORATION ON EDUCATION, GENTLEMEN OF THE SOCIETY FOR THE PROMOTION OF A RA- TIONAL SYSTEM OF EDUCATION. xjlGREEABLY to the duties of the appointment, I have had the honour to receive from you, permit me to call your attention to a subject, which has already awakened the liveliest feelings of the heart, namely, education. In order the better to illustrate this inquiry, in its most exten- sive sense, it may not be improper in the first place, to ex;mine the principles of associations in general; secondly, treat of education, from the elementary to the more refined branches of learning; and thirdly, conclude with some moral reflections, natu- rally resulting from so useful and comprehensive a theme. PirsJ. Of Man in society. At the summit of the scale of our globe is placed man, the master-piece of earthly creation. In modern times, it has be- come fashionable for philosophers, of a particular sect, to speak of mankind, as having originally been a race of savages, little re- moved from brutes, and wholly unconnected with one another m society. In such a state, which is.contrary to fact, every man must have been his own law giver, his own judge, his own protector, his own avenger. Although man may have so far degenerated as to have approximated to this state, yet, considering the constitution of human nature, he never could subsist. The social principle is as much interwoven with our nature, as the principle of self-pre- servation. No human creature could long continue in the exer cise of his rational faculties, without desiring society, and using means to obtain it, if such means were in his power. The law of nature, that was originally written on the he.rt of man, and still continues to be so, expressly requires social and relative duties; and expressly prohibits crimes against sociery. This necessarily presuppose a a social state. 4 If we have recourse to the holy writings, we find, that the mo4 rnent Eve was created, social and other duties were formed; con- sequently, society was constituted. The happiness of mankind, the means by which it is promoted, the physical constitution of human nature, the influence of education, and several other sub- jects will claim our attention in their proper places. There are two enquiries, however, which may be considered in this place, namely, man as a social being, and man in commu- nion with God by religion. In whateyer light we view associations, it may be Raid, that the principle on which they arc erected is implanted in our nature by the author and dispenser of all good; and is calculated to produce the same beneficial end in the moral, that the power of attraction does in the natural world.* This propensity to associate, may be observed in every stage of society; from the rude hunter of the forest, to the polished in- habitant of the city; from the first elements of simple societies, to the more complicated and expanded associations. Whether it is an instinct or a habit; whether it is the dictate of powerful unerring nature, operating for the benefit of the subject, or the the result of prudence and reason, consulting individual as well as. general good, it is not necessary to investigate. We feel and we know, that it predominates over our species; that it operates with the power of both these causes; and that, whether it exhibits itself in families, in literary or benevolent institutions, or in na- tions, its spirit is good and its object benificent. The absence of this principle in men, or in other creatures, is generally attended with ferocious and sanguinary propensities; and wherever it prevails, we find our nature improved, our feli- cities increased, and the general condition of society amelio- rated. The gloomy anchorite, the unfeeling fanatic, and the re- pulsive misanthropist, always inshroud themselves in solitude, and seek in vain for that happiness, which they failed of obtaining in the busy theatre of the world. Independent of these associations, which may be denominated natural, we observe voluntary societies springing up in a thou- sand shapes, for the improvement of our physical, mental, or moral faculties. In the whole order of beings, from the seraph down to the meanest insect, all, according to their rank in the scale of exis- tence, have, more or less implanted in them, the principle of as- sociation Avith others of the same species. Even the most incon- siderable animals are formed into different ranks and societies, for mutual benefit and protection. Need we name the careful ant> or the industrious bee; insects, which the wisest of men have re-. commended as patterns of unwearied industry and prudent fore- sight. But, does the innate principle of friendship, increase in * See the R. W. De Witt Clinton's Masonic Address, 1806 5 proportion to the exterision of our intellectual faculties? This rs a consideration of great magnitude. The cements of the rational world'are unbounded. When they cease, nature must be dis- solved, and man, the image of his Creator and the chief of lib voiks, be overwhelmed in the general chaos! Civilization undoubtedly depends upon an innate principle; and the social duties, which have existed from the days of Adam, ^re interwoven with our existence. The condition of society, how* ever, has been ameliorated from the knowledge of the arts and sciences. The learned Dr. Price is of opinion, that a time will come when mankind shall arrive at the summit of all possible perfection, from the extension of our intellectual faculties. He even goes so far as to add, that science will eventually "suppress vice and war, and even death itself 1 The pious Bishop of Lan* daff, however, is of opinion, that human nature can never arrive at this degree of perfection, nor do we think it possible, consider- ing the physical constitution of man. Though from our weak' ness we may gather strength, and from our wants gather plenty, yet we, worms of the dust! insects of an hour! can never penetrate the secret recesses of nature, and stop, the laws of creative power. While we look up to the cause of all causes....while we con- template creation, and observe her symmetry and beauty....while we raise ourselves up to eternal reason and study his laws.... while we have faith, hope, and charity to lead us in the paths of hap- piness.-.while we are animated with heartfelt gratitude for all the blessings, both spiritual and temporal, which we enjoy, we may erect our edifice, not on the sands, but on the rock of ages, which the mouldering hand of time can not destroy. In society, the principles of honesty, truth, benevolence, charity, and justice, should ever be practised and inculcated. No social compact can be honourable, happy and durable, without a com- pliance with these requisites. These principles should be im- pressed on the minds of youth. The many advantages resulting from friendship, whether we trace it through the circle of private connexions, to the grand system of universal benevolence, which no limits can circum- scribe, or consider it as a necessary duty, may be compared to a wheel of immense magnitude, whose revolutions mark the rise progress, and usefulness of a reciprocal intercourse of kind and generous actions. As the mercurial column shows the increase and decrease of temperature, so the social affections either rise or Jail in the ratio of mutual friendship. Where friendship is un- known, jealousy and suspicion prevail; but where that virtue is the cement, true happiness subsists. Patriotism, or love of country, is a species of friendship for the land in which we live, for the political and social compact, for the laws: in fine, for the country, its laws, its rulers. The warrior's glory may consist in murder, and the rude ravage of the desolating sword; but the blood of thousands will not stain the hands of his country's frierX £[is virtues are open^ and of the noblest kini c Tt is t: tie, that " the better men arc, the mere they love one-' fenother," of course, the more durable would be the friends ship, and of a purer kind; i. e. the mind would be divested of hy. poc'icy and deceit. " The skylle of becommynge gude and fiar- fygh.r," s-.vs king Henry, the sixth, in an original manuscript,* we may add is but little known; and if it is, it is but little practised. It m.,y be said, that the excellence of human reason shines with a new lustre, from the establishment of societies, or bodies fioli* fie. In them, virtue, honour, fear, and interest, variously em- ployed or combined, prove the source of peace, happiness and or* der. All the individuals, being mutually interwoven together, move in a regular and harmonious manner. Under the sanction of the iaws, the president, governor or magistrate, by exercising a lawful authority, promotes virtue, suppresses vice, and spreads around him the happiest instances and effects of his administration. In society, as in a pure and fertile climate, talents of different kinds spring up, and unfold themselves. From that the mecha- nical and liberal arts flourish. From thence are born poets, ora- tors, historians, physicians, divines, philosophers, lawyers. It is a truth, however, that in whatever state man is placed, provided his mind has been formed by a proper education, he feels a desire to acquire knowlege; and, very frequently, science may be seen enlightening and consoling him. Man, considered as an intelligent creature, is endowed with reason, judgment, volition, which constitutes him a being of the first order. He alone, of all other creatures, enjoys the gift of Speech. Sometimes with a strong and harmonious voice, he cele- brates, in a poem, the virtues of a hero. At other times, by the stroke of a pencil, he changes a dull and ungrateful canvass into 3 charming perspective. Here do we see him, with the chissel and graver in his hand, animating the marble, and giving life to brass. There, with the plummet and square, erecting a magni- ficent palace. Now do we behold him, by the assistance of a microscope of his own invention, discovering new worlds amid invisible atoms, or penetrating the secret exercise and motion of a particular organ. At other times, by changing this microscope a& it were into a telescope, he pierces into the heavens, and there contemplates saturn and his satellites. Returning home, he pre- scribes or rather determines the laws of the celestial bodies, de- scribes their orbits, measures the earth, and weighs the sun! Afterwards directing his flight towards the more exalted regions of metaphysics, he dives into the nature of beings, examines their relations, and the admirable harmony resulting from them.f Although amid these physical and metaphysical contempla- tions, man is a dependant being. To God, he owes his admir&». Me faculties; to God, he owes his existence, his every thing! • M. S. in the Bodlein library. f See note P. T ** Mil77 is sown corruptible; ke will rise incorruptible andglofi-* •oz/s"; these are the words of the apostlb and philosopher. The covering of the seed perishes; the germ subsists, and assures man of immortality. The last mark of the greatness of man, and of his high exalta- tion above other animals, is the commerce he has with his crea* tor, by religion. Wrapped in the thickest darkness, the rest of the animal crc« ation are ignorant of the hand that formed them. They enjoy an existence, but can not trace the author of life. Though the beaver may be considered an architect, and the bee a geometri- cian, yet, they possess only send;we and vegetative life. But man, a reflective being, is exalted above other animals. H13 rank is as far above the ape, as the ape transcends the smallest animalcuiae! The human mind combines and perfects without ceasing; that of other animals, neither perfects nor combines. Man alone soars to God the principle; and, prostrate at the footstool of his almighty throne, he adores with the proudest sen* timents of veneration, and "with the most lively gratitude, the In» effable goodness that created him. In consequence of those eminent faculties wherewith he is en- ro hed, God condescends to reveal himself to him, and to lead him as it were by the hand, in the paths of happiness. The various laws he has received from the Supreme wisdom, are so many great lights placed at proper distances on his road, to guide him from time to eternity. The sensorium of man may be considered as a wn'rrcr, in which different portions of the universe is painted in miniature, and which are reflected when the senses arc brought into action. If we compare the intellect of men, the mind will appear as diversi- fied as any other subject of nature. If we draw comparisons be- tween human beings, and infer that some are endowed with more powerful faculties than others; will not, I would ask, a perfect method of education so balance the scale, as to give industry and application the superiority over natural genius? If we go still further, and from analogy conclude, that some of these mirrors exhibit but a small number of objects, while others comprehend a more extensive field, are we to consider this difference as a di- versity in human genius, or the effect of education? What is the relation between the mirror of a mole, or that of a Newton, o Luther, or a Melancthon! What images were there in the brain of a Homer, a Virgil, or a Milton! That mind which could have read the brain of a Homer, would have there seen the Iliad represented by the various exercise of a million of fibres!* Secondly. Of Education. Having thus shown, that man alone is endowed with under* Standing, and that his usefulness and happiness depend on the • Bee note 17. 8 Joitivt.iicn of his rational faculties, wc now proceeed to consider education, or the means by which it is promoted. The state of society and of government with us, is admirably calculated to countenance and encourage learning in every shape. Education is the art of forming and managing the mind. If the ■benefits are so extensive and widely diffused, affecting the rich as *weli as the poor, surely it is a duty We owe society to perfect the art, and to establish a system on the immutable laws of na- ture. Of how much importance, therefore, are those institutions, which are formed to promote a rational method of education? As a preliminary step to any system, the principle of associa* tion should be forcibly impressed on the minds of youth. Sheri- don has expressly said, that in order to render education ade- quate to its purpose, it must be a fundamental maxim, that it should be particularly adapted to the nature of the government... and that the principles by which the community is supported, ahouldbe strongly inculcated on the minds of youth; for, says he, the best education can never produce citizens, who will adhere to the maxims of a free constitution, unless they are constantly re- minded of the origin of the social compact. Whether we contemplate education in this light, or whether we go into an abstruse or complicated analysis of the mind, or whether we trace the progress of the intellect expanding at every new sensation, our inference in this respect must be conclusive. The importance of education, and the establishment of this in- stitution, is thus portrayed in the preliminary to the constitution of the society: "The education of youth in useful knowledge, ought to be a primary object with parents and guardians. But more especially ought eveiy endeavour to be used in a religious corn* munity, to lay a sure and solid foundation for every moral and so* cial virtue. Impressed with a conviction of this important truth, a number of the members of St. John's congregation, willing to give every aid within their power, towards the establishment and support of a rational system of eduaction, have formed themselves into a society for that purpose." The institution is liberal, and calculated to produce considera- ble advantages.* Learning, in truth, is progressing with such rapid steps, in thia section of the northern hemisphere, which hut little more than a century back was a barren clime, that we behold universities, colleges, seminaries, springing up in every quarter of the United States, and diffusing their salutary influence on the genius and disposition of the people. Even in our city the number ot *ree schools, instituted by the benevolence and philanthropy shall I say of heaven-born characters, are numerous, and have al- leady ameliorated the condition of the poor. While a benevolent ■•■ See note 19, 9 Howard graces the page of English biography, may such be cji« rolled on the record of American worthies! Among the prominent characters who contributed to the sup- port of charity schools, I would do an injustice to my feelings were I to omit the name of Mr. Christopher Ludwick, an old and respectable German. He granted with a liberal hand, the sum often thousand dollars, for the purpose of teaching gratis, the poor of all denominations in the city of Philadelphia, the districts ofSouthwark and Northern Liberties, without respect to their country or religion.* It were to be wished, that our ideas on education were founded more on the nature of the mind, and the various relations which it maintains through the medium of the senses. Doubtless the rea- son of this lies not so much in the want of tenderness and affec- tion, as the Rev. Dr. ZoLUKOFFi.iif so justly observes, as in wrong and incompetent notions generally entertained of education. That is, this duty is but too often confided to the care of providing for the life and health of the children; of teaching them some me- chanical works and arts; loading their memory with a multitude of words which they do not understand; instructing them in. the rules of external propriety of behaviour and politeness; warning them of the grosser enormities, which are followed by punish- ment and disgrace; divesting them of their natural simplicity and openness of heart, and instilling into them the arts of reserve*, dis- simulation, and flattery. Such, indeed, are the ideas of education which many entertain; and such, in truth, has been the fatality of many systems of education, from incorrect opinions respecting the nature and properties of the sensorium. Education, instead of being what it should be, to form the understanding, or the minds of children, by producing certain impressions on the sensorium through the medium of the senses, from one degree of perfection to another; has generally been a system of erroneous notions, in- correct impulses, external show, and too often, of vanity and folly. How many instances, it may be asked, may we expect to find, in which a system has been carried into effect, so enlightened, unre- mitted, and ardent, as to produce the advantages of which we have spoken? Education, it is to be remembered, has the advantage of taking the mind in its original state; a soil prepared for culture and im- • provement, and as yet uninfested with weeds. The difficulties of a solid education may be compared to a kind of preliminary course, intended perhaps by providence as a gradual preparative for the subsequent difficulties in life. While reason exercises the intel- lect, and fortifies the understanding; the mind, however powerful, and however improved, must be so counterpoised, as to render mental discipline subservient to moral. "* Sfce note 14. f ZoLLiKOFBEa'5 S-rrmon' 10 In animate, temper governs all. In man, r. anon rr gulates thi? temper; and temper when under due regulations, facilitates, in its turn, the execrcise of reason. Learn then the temper; if it be vicious, you arc to correct it, by Skilfully diverting its course, and by carefully avoiding every thing that may contribute to add new strength to it, and swell the waters 6f such a dangerous torrent. How applicable are the words of Pope, " The proper study of tnankind is man." Numerous are the writings, and diversified arc the opinions, on the nature and physical constitution of man. In noticing this subject, it may not be improper to observe, that ^mankind are under a thousand obligations ta the. immortal Luther., That world would be unjust, were it to take from him a single laurel from the crown, which he gathered not for him- self indeed, but for the one family universal! He penetrated the arcana of nature! He, animated with benevolent and philanthro- pic fire, not only soared to the sublime truths of metaphysics and religion; but on more than one occasion portrayed in brilliant co- lours, the unbounded influence of mental and moral improvement! To him, the world is indebted for principles and precepts! To him, who drew with his pencil, the picture of his divine master, though in miniature, education alike owes its progressive im- provement! Perhaps I hear some one say, where is your proof? I answer with justice to my feelings, unfold his voluminons writ- ings, aud you will have incontrovertible testimony. He was, in- deed, an interpreter of Nature, and of nature's god! He was preeminent in every thing, which affected, in any manner, the hap- piness and well-being of fellow man. Incarnate word, first born of creatures, if it were possible to transfer this heavenly power, it was in the mind of Llthfr that it shone resplendent! Nor is the great Melancthon to escape our notice. lie was one of the wisest and best of men of his age, and an illustrious in- strument in bringing about the great work of reformation. He was learned in all the sciences; and his genius, which emanated at an early period of his life, displayed its power over every thing he undertook. He defended the works of Luther, with inde- fatigable industry; and gave lectures on theology and education, to crowded and popular assemblies, to the number it is said of three thousand persons. Erasmus, in noticing Melancthon, expresses himself in the following emphatic language: « But good God! what hopes may we not entertain of Philip Melanc- thon; who, though as yet very young and almost a boy, is equal- ly to be admired for his knowledge in both languages? What quickness of invention! What purity of diction! What powers of memory! What variety of reading! What modesty and grace- fulness of behaviour!" Such was Philip Melancthon in his juvenile days. The celebrated Emanuel, Baron, Count Swedenburg, had so exalted an*opinion of the divine philanthropy, which dwelt in thv> Ji i.osom of the amiable Melancthon, that while he co.pit ?,>..;:> 1.,. doubts of the felicity of a Calvin, he has assured us oi the cui- iial happiness of a Melancthon, to whom he has given the up? peilation of the guardian angel of Luther. Nor is it to such men alone as Luther ami Melancthon, that we arc indebted for information and improvement; we might name many, who distinguished themselves, though in a less-"/ dX give, in emancipating their fellow creatures from the shackles of prejudice, ignorance, and superstition, and to whom education also owes its improvement. The mind of man may be enriched with learning of a partiru- Lv kind, which may be useful or the contrary. He may lain, flu- ently of the sublimity of Milton, the majc., For any impulse upon the organs of sense to be effec- tual, it is further requisite, that it be seconded by attention of the mind. Without the mind is earnestly engaged, or volition em- ployed, no progress can be made; for us the will governs, however powerful the external impulse may be, it is as necessary for tho mind to be prepared, us it is for the senses to be brought into action.* Vifhl'!. The nature and strength of sensations depend upon thro'e circumstances; the original constitution, in which I include the present state of the whole frame, as well as that of particular 01 i'.nos; the force of the external impulse given to the senses; and l.stiy, the attention of the mind employed upon the subject. Consequently, a sensation of a determined force may be produced i y tm infinite number of different proportions,between the exter- nal ^gent, and the attention of the mind; as on the one hand, a strong perception may take place with little or no attention of muni, provided the impression from without be very powerful; so on the other, an equal perception may arise without any external impulse, by an uncom men exertion of mental attention. It often happens, however, that both the internal and external impulses a'v brought into action: certain faculties can not exist without t! is union. The surprising faculty of memory, is founded on this circum- stance. " Each passing form, the pausing1 heart delights, And young sensation every nerve excites. Oil front sensation', quick volition springs, When pleasure thrills us, or when anguish stings-, Hence J/ecollection calls with voice sublime Immersed ideas from the wrecks of Time, AVith potent charms in lucid trains displays, Eventual stories of forgotten days'. Hence Jleasnri's efforts good with ill contrast, Compare the prciiwiit, future and the past." IIarwin. We are fully convinced, that the principles of all knowlege are Pounded in mind; the mind of man either animated by desire, or pressed by necessity, puts in action its various energies, as we have just remarked. We reason correctly when we apply to any subject those ideas which are derived from its real nature; but, if prejudice or any other cause usurp the seat of truth, we fall into every kind of error. We conclude before we have reasoned, reason before we know, and presume we know before we have examined. » (See note 18. 15 In education, the more simple the object is in itself, the sooner the mind discovers its various relations, and is enabled to ria'. from one truth to another, till it reach those that are the most abstract. May we not compare mental improvement to the philosophy of motion? In the wheel and axle for instance, the velocity of the power is to the velocity of the weight, as the circumference of the wheel is to the circumference of the axle; so in education, the ve- locity of the mind is to the velocity of the senses, as the circum- ference of the mind, is to the circumference of the objects. In other words, the action of genius, or reflection, is dependent on the quickness of the sensations, and the sensations, if of a particu- lar kind, are dependent on external impulse, exactly in the sam